15 August 2006

RBC CM Preview of Scotiabank Q3 2006 Earnings

  
RBC Capital Markets, 15 August 2006

Q3/06 Preview - Expected In-Line, But with Improved Quality

Bank of Nova Scotia reports third quarter earnings on August 29. We are looking for cash EPS of $0.87, which is 1¢ above the Thomson First Call mean estimate of $0.86. This implies a growth rate of 13% year over year and 1% quarter over quarter.
We are factoring revenue growth at 8% year over year, indicated up 10% excluding securities gains. This is higher than last quarters 6% revenue growth, which was in line with the bank peer average. Last quarter, revenue quality was less than ideal as net interest income was lower than anticipated, driven in particular by weakness in Scotia’s domestic retail spreads. Exceptionally strong net interest income in the international division was not sufficient to offset.

Q2 ‘Underlying EPS’ Was Disappointing. We stripped down last quarter’s 89¢ in reported EPS to ~80¢ underlying EPS, indicating ~5% sustainable growth YoY, well below the 17% reported EPS gain. Above-normal securities gains and both a very low loan loss and tax rate added an estimated 14¢ to more than offset the 5¢ foreign exchange translation EPS drag. The International division’s loan loss was NIL last quarter, and that too is likely to normalize this quarter (Mexico looks light on an underlying basis this quarter). Also, the wholesale division not only profited from very strong trading and securities gains, but also from $54 million in loan loss recoveries last quarter. In our view, the Q2/06 reported GAAP result of 89¢ sets the bar too high, and investors should compare Q3/06 against an estimated 80¢ run rate.

Key Themes This Quarter:

1. Domestic Banking Outlook Brightened by Higher Rates (1/3 of Earnings). We are estimating divisional earnings could rebound to $345 million this quarter, from a $315 million average in H1/06. This quarter, we are banking on the higher short-term interest rates helping Scotia’s variable-rate loan book. In Q2/06, Scotia’s weak domestic banking loan spread mitigated otherwise excellent loan growth and market share gains: both revenue and operating leverage lagged its domestic peers. This may also be in part related to Scotia’s below-average leverage to wealth assets managed. This may prove to be a less-obvious hindrance this quarter, which we perceived as a tough environment for customer flows and portfolio returns. Last quarter, divisional loan losses were also up, and we think these too may stabilize or improve again.

• Maple Trust Acquisition – Integrating Independent Distribution. Scotiabank announced the acquisition of the mortgage business of Maple Financial Group for $233 million in February and closed the deal on April 3, 2006, so this will be the first full quarter of inclusion. The deal is expected to be accretive to earnings by the end of year two, however slightly, in our estimation, roughly break-even in the early going, and contributing on the order of 2-4¢ by and during 2008. This deal moves Scotia firmly into the high-growth mortgage broker channel, and may ease Scotia into non-conforming mortgages as well. Scotia was attracted to Maple’s existing and prospective customer base, betting it can cross-sell home equity lines of credit and deposit products. We believe Scotia is the only bank to have been bringing mortgage-broker originated borrowers to its branches to close the mortgage, perhaps giving Scotia an edge over peer banks that allow the mortgage brokers to ‘close’ the mortgage in the field on the banks’ behalf.

2. Wholesale Bank Profit to Level Off (1/3 of Scotia Earnings). We are estimating H2/06 earnings will revert to $260 million per quarter from ~$270 million on average in H1/06. Last quarter, wholesale generated 35% ROE (there was a time when management dreamt of 15% for this division) as Scotia’s commodity and derivatives business was outstanding, boosting trading revenue. This quarter we look to Scotia’s burgeoning M&A practice for strength instead. The aforementioned loan loss recoveries of $54 million helped in Q2/06 and are very unlikely to repeat.

• Scotia Waterous Seen Helping Out Already. Scotia’s M&A advisory activity is up by a factor of nearly six-fold YoY, more than 2 1/2 times last quarter’s total. This could boost Scotia from a distant 5th rank among the 5 majors to 2nd overall this quarter. We think this reflects the timely acquisition of ‘Energy-Patch’ advisor Scotia Waterous.

3. International Should Be Strong Again (1/3 of Earnings). We are estimating Scotia’s H2/06 earnings from International will revert to $240 million per quarter from >$250 million on average in H1/06, partly as the zero loan loss normalizes, but offset by incremental acquisition benefits expected to materialize. Scotia Mexico looks like it will add another $25 million in incremental earnings this quarter, although gains-assisted.

• Scotia Mexico’s Q2 ‘Beat’ Our Estimate. Grupo Scotiabank (Mexico) reported Q2/06 earnings of P$1,487 million or P$993 million excluding a VAT tax recovery of P$494 million. This translates into ~C$148 million or ~C$99 million (excluding one-time items) at the Scotiabank level. We were expecting a C$125 million contribution to earnings. Strong loan growth continued in calendar Q2, as mortgage balances increased 30% YoY, personal and commercial loans grew 38% YoY.

• Mexico Political Risk Muted. We discount the financial impact of recent election delays and expect Mexican banking fundamentals, including loan growth, will remain strong. Typically, political instability would pose a risk to local financial markets, though economic and political progress in Mexico in recent years has reduced the risk.

Mexico could be described as the regional leader on the path to sustainable democratic capitalism. Regardless of whether the Left- or Right-leaning Presidential candidate wins in Mexico, the positive economic path is set. We believe the RBC Emerging Markets Team’s words are instructive: “Mexico’s prudent fiscal and debt management policies and economic convergence with the U.S. means the country is significantly less vulnerable to internal or external financial market shocks than it was in the 1990s."

• Costa Rican Interfin Acquisition - Another Smart LATAM Deal. Early in the quarter (on June 14), Scotiabank entered an agreement to buy Corporacion Interfin for $330 million (US$294 million). Corporacion Interfin owns Costa Rica’s largest private bank (non-government) – Banco Interfin. The transaction is expected to close by August 2006. BNS is poised to be the #1 (private) bank in Costa Rica with this deal, and continues to be a leading player in Latin American bank consolidation. In our view, Scotiabank has taken another smart and decisive step in its international build-out. The deal is expected to be accretive by $0.03/share in year 1, without the benefit of synergies, and $0.04/share in year 3 assuming earnings growth above 10%. This is the bank’s fifth acquisition in the Latin American (LATAM) region in the past 2 years.

4. Foreign Exchange Translation Drag Continues. Last quarter, Scotia’s earnings were hit by 5¢ for by the depreciating U.S. and Mexican dollars; however, in Q3/06, we believe the bank earnings could be hit by another incremental 1¢. Of the Big Six banks, the F/X translation issue is most pronounced for Scotiabank as its larger international base of business derives much of the earnings from currencies that swing in concert with the U.S. dollar.

Capital & Dividends

No Dividend Hike. This quarter, we are not looking for a change to the quarterly dividend of $0.39/share, which was just hiked from $0.36 last quarter. We expect the next increase to be announced in December with Q4 results.

Tier 1 Ratio Now Peer-Like. We forecast a tier 1 capital ratio of 10.3% this quarter. BNS’ Tier 1 capital ratio declined to 10.2% last quarter from 10.8% in Q1/06, and now sits in line with the peer group average. The majority of the decrease was due to strong asset growth and the resulting impact on risk-weighted assets.

Valuation

Our price target of $49 is set at 13x our 2007 cash EPS estimate of $3.77. Our target P/E is set at sector neutral to our sector target P/E to balance Scotia’s strong long-term growth prospects and disciplined, focused management team, with its above-average credit exposure and earnings reliance on securities gains. Scotia’s international operations are clearly outgrowing North American bank norms, though the overall earnings level is supported by a below-average loan loss accrual and tax rate. We also estimate Scotia’s excess capital position at ~$2 billion at the end of Q2/06, down from a superior position within the peer group in prior periods. Our price target is also indicated at ~2.65x our projected book value of $18.52 (as at Jul 31/07).

Price Target Impediments

Risks to our call include: (i) prospects for higher loan loss accruals (largely reflecting Scotia’s higher corporate loan portfolio); (ii) below average wealth management leverage (at about half the group average); and/or (iii) another round of protracted U.S. dollar weakness. Also a potential concern would the possibility that BNS overpays in a foreign acquisition or a domestic merger (if permitted). BNS could do better than anticipated if the U.S. dollar weakness reverses.
;

Scotiabank Plans to Expand Latin America Transfer Business

  
Bloomberg, 15 August 2006

Bank of Nova Scotia, Canada's third-largest bank, may expand its wire transfer business in Latin America to compete with lenders such as Wells Fargo & Co., a bank executive said.

The Toronto-based bank, known as Scotiabank, is targeting countries including Mexico, Peru and the Dominican Republic, said Peter Cardinal, executive vice president for Latin America.

``We will grow in the remittances business, probably by opening more branches,'' Cardinal said in a television interview from Toronto.

In 2005, Mexico, Peru, Dominican Republic and El Salvador received $28 billion in remittances, mainly from immigrants in the U.S., according to the Inter-American Development Bank.

Scotiabank will compete with money-transfer companies such as Western Union, a unit of First Data Corp., or MoneyGram International Inc. Banks including Wells Fargo and Spain's Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA are also offering transfer services between the U.S. and Latin America.

Scotiabank owns Grupo Scotiabank, the sixth-largest bank in Mexico. The lender also completed the purchase of two banks in Peru in March to create the third-biggest bank in that country. Scotiabank expects to generate about 27 percent of its 2006 net income from operations outside Canada, Cardinal said.
;

14 August 2006

Hancock Seeks Clearance to Bid for Carter Holt Assets

  
Bloomberg, 14 August 2006

Hancock Timber Resource Group, the world's biggest forest investment fund, sought regulatory approval to bid for assets of Carter Holt Harvey Ltd., New Zealand's largest forestry company.

The Boston-based fund owns $5.2 billion of forests, including trees it bought in New Zealand from the former Fletcher Challenge estates in 2004. It asked New Zealand's Commerce Commission for approval to bid for shares in unspecified assets being sold by Auckland-based Carter Holt, according to a filing on the antitrust regulator's Web site.

``Hancock regularly investigates timberland investments that come on the market,'' said a New Zealand-based spokeswoman for Hancock who declined to be named. The company ``won't be commenting on any potential transactions.''

New Zealand billionaire Graeme Hart, who completed his NZ$3.3 billion ($2.1 billion) purchase of Carter Holt in March, is seeking buyers for the company's 275,000 hectares (680,000 acres) of land and trees. Hancock is one of six potential bidders the company invited to assess the assets, the New Zealand Herald reported last week.

Carter Holt's 220,000 hectares of trees are the largest estate in the country and were valued at NZ$1.57 billion a year ago. The trees account for about 12 percent of New Zealand's plantation forests and were forecast to produce about 4.8 million cubic meters of wood a year through 2008, according to Carter Holt's report for the six months ended June 30, 2005. Output would peak at 8.4 million cubic meters around 2021-to-2024, it said.

Hancock owns or manages about 107,000 hectares in New Zealand, making it the fourth-largest forest manager.

Carter Holt sold 94,600 hectares of trees, a third of its estate, last year for NZ$441 million. Most of the estate was bought by a venture between Jacksonville, Florida-based Rayonier Inc. and Deutsche Bank AG's RREEF Infrastructure unit.
;

11 August 2006

BMO CM on Sun Life Financial

  
BMO Capital Markets, 11 August 2006

Year to date, Sun Life shares generated the worst total returns among the large cap financial services companies, down 10.6%. The margin is quite wide as the closest comparisons are GWO, down 6.5%, and TD, down 3.9%. SLF currently trades at 1.6x bvps and 12.2x and 11.1x ‘06E and ‘07E EPS, respectively, cheaper than the lifeco and bank group averages. The yield is 2.9%, which we believe is an all-time high. Excluding MFS, SLF trades at 11.2x and 10.4x ‘06E and ‘07E EPS, respectively. Also excluding MFS, SLF trades at 1.6x bvps and the ROE would decline to 12.5% from 13.5% (MFS generates very high ROEs). The share price underperformance reflects a number of items including disappointing quarterly results, turnover in senior management, and frustration on the apparent unwillingness (or timing) to address structural opportunities (i.e., surfacing value at MFS). While we share these concerns, there are some positive developments. First, SLF has an opportunity to re-invigorate senior management ranks with two new key hires, particularly a new CFO and new COO. Second, while financial results were discouraging, new sales results and value of new business continued to show very positive trends. We also believe that SLF is more than willing to consider strategic alternatives for MFS. SLF is not considering any material acquisitions and excess capital is being used for buybacks and dividends. SLF is Outperform rated.
;

10 August 2006

BMO CM Preview of Cdn Banks Q3 2006 Earnings

  
BMO Capital Markets, 10 August 2006

Introduction

We expect Canadian banks to report one of their best operating results ever for the third quarter ending July 31, 2006. The story should be continued strength in the retail businesses, offsetting somewhat weaker market-related businesses.

Loan growth and stable spreads are the basis for our optimism in retail banking. Industrywide data suggests loan growth is over 10% year over year with the commercial loan book adding to the strength in consumer loans. On the spread front, we expect higher absolute levels of interest rates and more muted competition across a variety of products will offset the ongoing pressure on Prime-BA spreads and the need for additional wholesale funding. The net of these factors is that spreads should be stable.

In the wholesale operations results should, in aggregate, be down 10–15% from the first two quarters of the year. The obvious slowdown in issuance, a less robust trading environment and fewer loss recoveries will only partially be mitigated by stronger M&A activity. Outside of these fundamentals, this could be a noisy quarter. Tax rate changes (which could impact the valuation of deferred tax liabilities), unusual gains and ongoing accounting changes could make for a less than clean quarter for several banks. We expect the market to see through these items.

We expect two banks to increase their quarterly dividends – TD and RY, following on the heels of increases by the other four banks following last quarter.

Perhaps it is the market’s propensity towards mean-reversion, but we expect CIBC and TD’s results to look somewhat more positive. CIBC’s market share performance should look less ominous while TD’s pre-release of Banknorth and Ameritrade results takes some of the uncertainty out of its reporting. We continue to trumpet these two as our favourite bank stocks at current levels.

Loan Growth – The News Remains Very Positive

The third fiscal quarter of 2006 will again show faster than expected loan growth by Canadian Banks. The story continues to be ongoing strength in consumer loan demand, coupled with a resurgence of commercial and corporate (business) credit demand. In aggregate, bank loan books should grow by over 10% compared to year-ago levels, and over 2% on a linked quarter basis. We should note, however, that the “Big 6” are growing loans somewhat below this rate as they have not been as aggressive as some of the foreign lenders—particularly in sub-prime and asset-based lending.

We continue to expect slower consumer loan growth over the coming quarters as higher interest rates slow the demand for residential mortgage credit and HELOCs. The case is more sanguine for business credit. We have made a case in the past (last quarterly earnings preview, May 3, 2006) that the growth in business borrowings was due to a culmination of factors that is unlikely to reverse in the short-term. Specifically, these factors include pent-up demand after several disappointing years, more fixed asset investment (to combat the impact of the rising Canadian dollar), better agricultural lending and less pre-selling of new homes by developers.

Whatever the cause, as we show in Chart 1, the growth in business credit remains very robust in the short term. In fact, in June 2006, business credit by chartered banks grew at the fastest rate in the past two decades. It is also worth noting that even if business loan growth was 4–5% in the medium term (in line with nominal GDP growth), this would likely support solid overall loan growth into 2007.

Spreads – Stable, Again

Trying to predict reported spreads for Canadian banks on a quarterly basis is a thankless exercise. You can be completely accurate, but still arrive at the wrong conclusion on earnings, and vice versa. Suffice it to say that we believe that the majority of the spread compression witnessed over the past four years is behind us (Chart 2 shows our specific forecast for this metric).

It is probably more useful to consider the mix of variables that structurally impact spread, as these items point to what is driving overall profitability. Below, we detail the four major factors arguing for tighter spreads:

• Rapid loan growth. This is a vivid example of exactly why nominal spreads (net interest income divided by average earnings assets) can be so misleading. When loan growth exceeds retail deposit growth, this causes some structural pressure on spreads. The incremental loans need to be funded in the (more expensive) wholesale market. It should be noted that while lower nominal spreads are a side effect, the overall impact of loan growth on bank profits is positive.

• Term extension in the mortgage book. Recent meetings with senior retail bankers suggest that the consumer has been more aggressive in terming out the retail mortgage book. Over the past two decades, consumers have generally been winners by opting for the shortest duration mortgage (i.e., variable rates). However, with more first time buyers in the market (buyers who are typically more concerned about the visibility of payments over some period of time) and increased concerns following multiple increases in short term interest rates, there has been an anecdotal shift to longer-term mortgage duration. This has had a negative impact on spreads.

• New mortgages continue to be originated at tighter margins than a year earlier. There is little doubt that the residential mortgage business has been commoditized even further over the past year. Banks view this product simply as a way to get into the consumer pocketbook and to anchor the relationship.

• Tighter Prime BA spreads. Even outside of the discrepancy between loan and deposit growth rates, banks use the BA market to fund some of their Prime-priced loans. With relatively clear signs of ongoing Bank of Canada tightening in the past year (seven increases in the Bank Rate since late 2005), the wholesale market has consistently anticipated increases in short-rates. This has put pressure on Prime-BA spreads since the fourth quarter of 2005 (Table 1). The good news here is that this phenomenon has largely run its course (i.e., rate increases will be less regular, if at all) and we believe that the outlook is more positive over the next 12 months.

However, there are several factors that are working in support of margins:

• Faster commercial loan growth. With the commercial book growth beginning to outpace the growth in the residential mortgage book for the first time in over five years, banks appear to be growing higher-spread loans faster than lower-spread loans. The differential is meaningful: spreads on commercial loans are several times that of secured residential mortgages. As we have indicated before, we expect business loan growth to continue to eclipse residential mortgage growth in the medium term.

• Less competitive posted pricing in residential mortgages. Bank of Montreal has been the most aggressive bank in discounting posted pricing on 3- and 5-year residential mortgages over the past 12 months. With the disappointing performance on spreads in the first half of 2006, the bank moved away from this strategy (Chart 3). In addition, anecdotal evidence suggests that discounting by BMO off of these higher posted rates has also been reduced.

• Less competition from ING in high-interest savings accounts. We believe that declining profitability at ING Bank (not the Property and Casualty insurer) has caused a more cautious stance on pricing of high-interest savings accounts. While we are not suggesting that competition has disappeared (we note the pricing moves by Altamira over the past few quarter), we believe that it is, at worst, a stable environment for pricing of this product.

• Higher overall interest rates. We have long highlighted that when interest rates moved to unusually low levels, banks were faced with increased pressure on spreads—declining yields on loan books combined with effective “floors” on deposit rates (particularly in checking or basic savings accounts). The reality is that the value of the “free float” in these accounts diminished as rates declined. With the rise in rates, we believe the pressure on spreads in the deposit books is abating somewhat.

With regard to spreads, there are certainly specific factors that impact various banks. For instance, it appears as if BMO and BNS are more impacted by the Prime-BA spreads and CIBC benefits less than its peers from rising rates due to its large credit card book. But overall, we believe that spreads for Canadian banks should be stable compared to the second quarter.

While this doesn’t sound impressive on the surface, it is a solid achievement and is all that is needed in an environment of rapid loan growth.

Loan Losses – Somewhat Higher Levels but Still No Signs of Concern

We expect loan losses of roughly $625 million across the six big banks this quarter (Table 2). This is somewhat higher than in the past several quarters and is simply a reflection of fewer reversals in the investment banks as gross impaired corporate loan books have continued to decline.

Over the past year, loan loss surprises have consistently been on the downside and though we are comfortable with our forecasts at this stage, this trend may again be repeated. We note that were loan losses to remain in the $450–500 million range, overall bank earnings this quarter would be 2–3% higher than we are forecasting.

Trading Revenues – Less Robust Than in the Past Two Quarters

After two outstanding quarters, we believe that trading revenues will be more moderate in the third. We forecast trading revenues of $1.45 billion across the big six banks (Table 3). Indeed, our expectations of moderation in trading revenues which we detailed in our second quarter preview (May 3, 2006) was essentially “on-the-money” except for Royal Bank which had a blockbuster quarter. Royal surprised us in the last quarter with trading revenues that were almost as much as that of BMO, TD and CIBC combined.

Predicting trading revenues is fraught with risk. Our basic premise is that the reversal of several consistent trends (caused by oil and gold price weakness, stable Canadian-U.S. dollar exchange rates, etc.) as well as a less clear stance by the Fed argue for more difficult liability trading conditions. On the other hand, the client demand for hedging in interest rates, currencies and commodities remains robust.

Capital Markets – The Market Giveth, and the Market Taketh Away

Because of timing issues and the breadth of revenue sources, it is difficult to generalize about quarter-to-quarter variation in performance in the Wholesale (capital markets and investment banking) operations of Canadian banks. Having said that, it does appear as if the third quarter will see Canadian Banks report somewhat lower fee revenues. Issuance appears to be down 40% versus the second quarter and the same quarter of last year. M&A, on the other hand, has returned with a vengeance—meaning fees in this business should be essentially flat with the second quarter and up about 10% from yearago levels. In aggregate, ie. inclusive of issue and M&A fees, we expect fee revenues to be down 25% from the second quarter.

Picking the relative winners and losers is even more difficult than summarizing how the industry performs on a short-term basis. Royal’s wholesale operations had an excellent second quarter, so did BMO’s with its skew towards the resource sector. TD, BNS and CM were somewhat weaker, while NA had reasonable performance. We hold little optimism for TD, BNS, NA or BMO this quarter, but believe that CM will rebound (largely for the timing reasons detailed by management during the second quarter conference call) and that RY, while down, will still be quite strong.

Of course, the actual “bottom line” contribution of the Investment Banks (i.e. RBC Capital Markets, ScotiaCapital, etc) is a function of these fees but also of the scale of loan loss recoveries and the trading success factors discussed previously. This being the case, we believe that Royal will continue to be Canada’s most profitable investment bank, but that it will be most affected by the confluence of the factors mentioned. We expect a contribution of closer to $300 million than the $433 million reported in the second quarter by Royal.

Writedown of Tax Assets – Expect Modest Charges

We expect some banks to take one-time charges for a reduction in the carrying value of deferred taxes. With the reductions in Canadian Federal Tax rates now clearly in place, banks which have built up deferred tax assets and liabilities (as a result of timing differences in the recognition of income for tax purposes) will need to account for the reduced value of the future net asset. We do not expect any of these charges to exceed $100 million for any bank, but we do note that the impact is very difficult to quantify. We expect any banks impacted to report and disclose clearly the one-time charges associated with these changes.

The irony of these charges is that reduction of tax rates are actually a positive for long term earnings power. This is a useful cautionary example of the limitations of “GAAP” earnings as a yardstick to value an enterprise.

Dividend Increases and Indications of Buybacks

We expect two banks to increase their dividends this quarter – TD and Royal. In the case of the former, it is clear that management is intent on building balance sheet strength in the face of developing opportunities in the U.S. Furthermore, it appears as if the final structuring of the Basel II rules will have the most impact on TD given its large investment in associated businesses. As a result, the bank has been the most tentative on returning money to shareholders. In fact, TD has been consistently increasing its share count through its dividend reinvestment program and through issuance related to acquisitions. While we remain supportive of the growth plans, we believe that a somewhat less lethargic stance on returning money to shareholders is warranted. We are forecasting that TD’s quarterly dividend will be increased from $0.44 to $0.46, and we believe that some buyback is possible over the next few quarters.

In the case of Royal, which in many ways has been following a polar opposite strategy to TD (i.e., significant buybacks and more aggressive increase of the dividend), we are also expecting an increase from $0.36 to $0.38.

With CM, BMO, NA and CIBC having increased quarterly dividends last quarter, none are likely to move again. We do not assume that any other banks will follow BMO’s aggressive change in payout ratio.

We have not yet seen share buyback levels for the month of July, but we believe that BMO and BNS have been quite active in repurchasing shares over the past quarter.

Individual Company Comments

• Bank of Montreal – All Eyes on Spread

Bank of Montreal leads off the reporting cycle on Tuesday, August 22. We are calling for cash EPS of $1.27, marginally ahead of the seasonally weak second quarter and up strongly from the weak third quarter of 2005. We expect relatively steady (but strong) capital ratios. We would not be surprised to see the bank become more aggressive on U.S. expansion within the next 12 months, particularly if the performance of the domestic P&C bank stabilizes.

The real focus for investors (as it has been for the past few quarters) will be the Personal and Commercial Banks (P&C) – both in Canada and the U.S. The former has produced somewhat worrying trends in margins – partially driven by overly aggressive pricing of residential mortgages. As we have noted previously, the bank has clearly back-tracked on this strategy, but given the seasonal bias towards heavy Spring origination volumes, we don’t believe that margins can turn dramatically until the fourth quarter. Having said that, any stability on this front would be welcomed. Another issue is how well volumes (and market shares) hold up given the pricing changes. Harris continues to limp along with ongoing reinvestment offsetting volume growth.

Recent management changes are on-balance slightly positive. The return of Frank Techar to Canada is a welcome development. He certainly had success in building the Bank’s commercial book in Canada before moving to Chicago, and we believe he is well liked and knows the business well. The job for Ellen Costello in Chicago is more daunting. She has limited retail banking experience and will need to depend on her direct reports in the early stages.

The Wholesale Bank, after a very strong second quarter, should be less robust, though still well ahead of the third quarter of last year when the bank was dealing with the flattening yield curve but without the benefit of higher commodity trading. In addition, expense accruals in the third quarter of 2005 appeared to be somewhat elevated. The Corporate segment should see more moderate contribution; the second quarter was inflated by somewhat lower tax rates. The modest MasterCard gain should also help this segment this quarter.

• TD Bank – Improved Visibility

TD’s quarterly results, to be released on August 24, should be far less exciting given the bank’s pre-release of the contributions from Ameritrade and Banknorth. The market will certainly concern itself with the ongoing repositioning of TD Securities. Indeed, the truism, “the only constant is change” appears to carry tremendous weight in the case of TD’s wholesale banking business.

The good news on TD Securities is that despite all the changes, it seems able to report solid, consistent earnings regardless of the environment. The strong second quarter environment didn’t do much for earnings in this segment, and we don’t expect the weaker underwriting in the third quarter to impact much either. As such, we forecast another quarter of earnings between $125 million and $175 million, with trading revenues back to more normal levels. In the event of merchant banking gains (which are certainly possible this quarter), we would not be surprised to see more aggressive exiting of some of the structured product businesses. In aggregate, the market may try to micro-analyze TD Securities. As we have said in the past, we broadly view this entity as a trading book, with a small investment bank strapped onto the side. It is unclear whether additional investment of capital, or of people, would change this reality.

TD Canada Trust should continue to show very strong trends. One variable that is difficult to gauge is the impact of the seasonally weaker trading volumes on the contribution from the domestic Wealth Management business. On this front, we have assumed that TD Waterhouse Canada (which we believe to be disproportionately important to overall profits) will negatively impact earnings this quarter.

It will also be interesting to see what the bank does with its ongoing build of excess capital. Tier 1 should punch well into the mid-12s, yet the bank has continued to issue stock to its dividend reinvestment program and has been somewhat stingy on its dividend increases. We are expecting a dividend increase this quarter of $0.02 – from $0.44 to $0.46 quarterly.

• Royal Bank – Ongoing Strength

As always, Royal Bank, with its earnings release on August 25, will set the tone for how the street considers quarterly performance within the bank group. We expect another excellent quarter. The Canadian Personal and Business unit (which includes the retail bank and the wealth management businesses) should have a record quarter. Strong volume growth, ongoing stable spreads and excellent flows in wealth management all argue for a record quarterly profit.

The U.S. and International Personal and Business Operations (which include the large global private banking unit) should again have a reasonable quarter. Some currency headwinds are likely to be offset by good growth in private banking. We believe that the contributions of Centura and Dain should be relatively stable.

The swing factor this quarter for Royal will be RBC Capital Markets. The second quarter showed how materially this unit has separated itself from the other Canadian investment banks. Having said that, the less robust underwriting environment should take some toll and we expect to see earnings closer to $300 million rather than $400 million. A large factor for this unit will be bonus accruals, which were very high in the second quarter. In the end, weaker revenues could be largely offset by lower expenses.

We are also expecting a dividend increase at Royal Bank, from $0.36 to $0.38. The bank’s Tier 1 is not as good as its peers, but as a result of the strength and diversity of Royal’s franchises, the market (and the rating agencies) does not penalize the bank. With the recent decision to acquire Flag Financial, and relatively consistent increases in risk-weighted assets within RBC Capital Markets, we don’t expect to see much higher Tier 1s during the rest of 2006.

• Scotiabank – Building the International Footprint

Scotiabank’s earnings, to be released on August 29, are generally predictable and strong, and the results this quarter should be no different. Like other banks, the domestic retail business should be up from last year. We expect to see earnings rise by 6% year over year, not as strong as TD or RY, but still solid.

On the other hand, Scotia Capital benefited in the second quarter from unusually high loan loss recoveries. While we don’t see any specific problems on this front (and gross impaired loans haven’t declined much over the past year), we still believe that the third quarter will have de minimus recoveries, and overall earnings that are somewhat lower than in the second quarter. One variable that is difficult to quantify is the impact of the deal with GMAC, which could contribute more than we are expecting.

One area that always creates some confusion for the market is the International Banking business, because of the multitude of countries that contribute to overall profits. This quarter, Scotiabank Mexico reported a solid operating result, and was also able to book an unusually large tax gain (equal to about $0.04 per Scotiabank share). Given this strength and the tremendous performance of the non-Mexican businesses in the second quarter, one could speculate a “blow out” result for Scotiabank. If history is any guide, the bank will use the opportunity created by one-time gains to heavy up on marketing and integration costs in Central America and the Caribbean. Whatever the decision, we remain confident that Scotia has a powerful franchise in these regions.

After leading the industry on capital ratios for some period, Scotiabank’s capital strength appears to be more in line with the group as it has built risk-weighted assets from the GMAC deal and from acquisitions. We believe, however, that the bank still has significant capacity to add leverage in Tier 1 and has been virtually inactive in securitization. We continue to see share buybacks, but given the move on dividend last quarter we don’t expect any change here.

• CIBC – Losing Its Reputation for Excitement

We expect another “workmanlike” quarter from CIBC on August 31. The story continues to unfold with ongoing cost reductions, reduced risk and less capital markets volatility. We believe that the market will come to value this consistency over time.

In the short term, the market is too focused on market share losses. This isn’t to say that we are indifferent to share: We have seen Canadian banks embark on transitions in the past and none have permanently hurt the franchises. We believe that this situation is the same and believe that share will stabilize. It is, however, tough to predict when this occurs. We think that CIBC’s card business has turned the corner, but the ongoing repositioning of the consumer loan book will continue to have a negative impact on share in some products. With BMO’s residential mortgage share under some pressure, CIBC could well benefit. Like with BNS, the bottom line contribution in Retail Markets (which includes banking and Wealth Management) should continue to produce solid year-over-year fundamental growth.

We also note that there is concern that CIBC World Markets, on the heels of cost cutting and on departures to Genuity, has lost some of its franchise value. This concern was exacerbated by a weak revenue performance in the second quarter despite a solid operating environment. We will chalk some of this up to timing of deal closing, and remain confident that this entity can produce $100–125 million in quarterly earnings. This assumes higher loan losses offset by better revenues. We don’t expect much in the way of merchant banking gains this quarter.

CIBC continues to rebuild its balance sheet in advance of the FCIB deal at year-end. Buybacks are on hold and, to our surprise, the dividend was increased last quarter. We believe that CIBC is most likely to provide an earnings upside surprise this quarter.

• National Bank – Nothing too Fancy

As with CIBC, we believe that National Bank will report a solid quarter on August 31. Mid-single-digit gains in retail banking and ongoing strength in Wealth management should allow the bank to exceed what was an excellent quarter last year.

The retail operations continue to perform well. In addition, we look for leverage from the partnership relationships with the Power Group and the benefits of the deposit gathering capabilities of Altamira. Both have been successful in building the balance sheet, but so far the bottom line benefits are not apparent. We believe that both offer good medium term growth potential.

NB Financial, run by Louis Vachon who was recently appointed COO of the bank, has put together an impressive track record of stable earnings. Whether it be trading, securities gains, investment banking or yield curve management, the bank has consistently produced earnings in the $50–70 million range, and we expect more of the same this quarter. We forecast somewhat weaker underwriting and trading, but assume that the Mastercard gain ($5–7 million after tax) will be included in this segment. Trading after a blowout result in the third quarter of 2005 should be more modest.
;

Scotia Capital Preview of Cdn Banks Q3 2006 Earnings

  
Scotia Capital, 10 August 2006

Banks Begin Reporting August 22

• Banks begin reporting third quarter earnings with Bank of Montreal (BMO) on August 22, followed by Toronto-Dominion Bank (TD) on August 24, Royal Bank (RY) on August 25, Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS) on August 29, National Bank (NA) and Canadian Imperial Bank (CM) on August 31, Laurentian Bank (LB) on September 6, and Canadian Western closing out reporting on September 7.

Earnings Growth 10% YOY – Led by BNS and RY

• Our third quarter earnings estimates are highlighted in Exhibit 1. Third quarter bank earnings are expected to be up 9.7% year over year but down 1.3% sequentially. BNS and RY are expected to lead in earnings growth at 12% and 11%, respectively. RY earnings growth is expected to be driven by the strength of retail and wealth management platforms and continued strong performance from Global Capital Markets. BNS earnings are expected to be driven by International operations although the Peso weakened significantly in the quarter.

• Profitability is expected to continue to run at historical highs on very large capital positions. Return on equity is expected to be 19.8%.

• Retail banking earnings are expected to be solid, although we expect some slowing in earnings growth as loan growth slows over the next year driven by weaker real estate markets, and margin expansion is delayed until interest rate levels stabilize. Short term interest rates have now risen 175 basis points or 42% in the past year. The increase in prime rate has relieved margin pressure created by the prime rate deposit cost (floor) squeeze however the rate of the increases as well as competition has delayed actual margin expansion.

• Wealth management earnings are also expected to continue to be buoyant although only three banks disclose these earnings on a separate basis. Bank average mutual fund assets are up 15% year over year and flat QOQ.

• Wholesale banking earnings are expected to weaken modestly from the extremely high levels of the first half of the year. Trading is expected to be solid although weaker than first half and equity underwriting is also expected to be very weak with M&A mixed. Equity trading volumes declined 18% QOQ but are up 33% YOY. New equity issues declined both 34% YOY and QOQ with secondary financing also declining sharply at 40% QOQ and 19% YOY. In terms of M&A, Closed/Pending Value is up substantially both YOY and QOQ. CDN M&A Closed Deals Value is up 21% QOQ but down 49% YOY.

Interest Rates and Retail Net Interest Margin

• The prime rate increased 25 basis points (bp) in fiscal Q3/06 following a 50 bp increase in each of the previous three quarters. Short-term interest rates have now increased 175 bp or 42% in twelve months. The Bank of Canada left the overnight rate unchanged at its last announcement date, July 11. The increases in short-term rates we believe are positive for compression reversal, stabilizing the margin descent. However, the retail net interest margin (NIM) has yet to show any real improvement from these rate hikes due in part to interest rate guarantees on mortgages, lag impact, and competition.

• We expect retail net interest margin to remain stable in Q3/06, with margin expansion being pushed out until rates stabilize, which is expected over the next six to 12 months.

Dividend Increase Candidates RY and TD

• The likely candidates for dividend increases this quarter are RY and TD, with dividend increases in the 7% to 8% range expected. This follows dividend increases announced in the previous quarter Q2/06 by BMO, BNS, NA, and CM of 17%, 8.3%, 4.2%, and 2.9%, respectively. The bank group's dividend payout ratio on our 2006 earnings estimates is 43% with BMO a high of 51% with TD, NA and RY the low at 39%, 40% and 42% respectively.

Strong Fundamentals – Remain Overweight

• We believe bank fundamentals remain strong, with low balance sheet risk, high capital levels, strong asset quality, record profitability, and historically low earnings volatility.

• Bank stocks are underperforming the Resource led TSX year to date with a flat bank index versus a 7% gain for the overall market. The bank group betas have declined to 0.39 versus a 5 year beta of 0.8.

• Banks are trading at a low 11.9x our 2007 earnings estimates, with bank dividend yields relative to bonds, equity markets, income trusts, and pipelines and utilities all in the Strong Buy range.

• Canadian Banks' P/E premium to the major U.S. banks has declined from the 10% - 15% range to nominal. Canadian banks are at a 15% P/E multiple discount to U.S. Regional Banks. U.S. yield curve is now inverted.

• Solid earnings growth outlook and double-digit dividend growth expected for the next three to five years bodes well for resumption of bank share price appreciation.

• We reiterate our Overweight Banks recommendation, based on attractive valuation, strong fundamentals, and low relative risk.

• We maintain 1-Sector Outperform ratings on RY and BNS, 2-Sector Perform ratings on NA, CWB, LB and TD with 3-Sector Underperform ratings on BMO and CM.

Recent Events

BMO – Frank Techar Appointed Head of Canadian Retail Banking

• On June 6, BMO announced the appointment of Frank Techar as President and CEO, Personal and Commercial Banking Canada, effective July 1, 2006. This position was formerly held by Rob Pearce. Mr Techar had headed BMO's P&C Banking in the U.S. since 2002 as President and CEO of Harris Bankcorp.

• On July 19, BMO announced the appointment of Ellen Costello as CEO of Harris Bankcorp. She replaces Frank Techar who was recently made President and CEO, Personal and Commercial Banking in Canada. Ms Costello had previously held the position of Vice-Chair and Head, BMO Capital Markets, New York.

• On August 3, BMO announced its intention to acquire bcpbank Canada, a full-service chartered bank owned by Millennium bcp of Lisbon, Portugal for $41 million. Bcpbank Canada has a network of eight retail bank branches, seven of which are located in the Greater Toronto Area.

BNS – Costa Rican Acquisition

• On June 13, BNS announced that it would acquire Corporacion Interfin, parent of Banco Interfin, the largest private bank in Costa Rica, for Cdn $330 million. BNS intends to merge its existing operations with Interfin. The transaction is expected to close in August 2006.

CM – Global Crossing Lawsuit

• There was an action filed in New York on June 20 to add additional CIBC affiliates and other third party defendants to the claims originally filed in 2004 seeking $2 billion in profits from alleged insider trading with respect to Global Crossing. CIBC has said that the action contains no new claims against CIBC. CIBC filed to dismiss these claims in January of 2006 which is still pending.

NA – Louis Vachon Appointed COO

• On July 27, NA announced the appointment of Louis Vachon as COO of the company. Prior to this appointment, Louis Vachon was Senior Vice-President, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of National Bank Financial Group.

TD – TD Banknorth and TD Ameritrade Earnings

• TD Banknorth (BNK) reported Q2/06 cash operating earnings of US$0.56 per share, versus US$0.55 per share in the previous quarter and US$0.63 per share a year earlier. Consensus was US$0.55 per share for the quarter. The operating contribution of BNK to TD Bank (TD) is estimated at C$0.09 per share versus C$0.08 per share last quarter and C$0.10 per share a year earlier

• TD Ameritrade (AMTD-NASDAQ) reported Q3/06 earnings of US$0.23 per share, versus IBES estimate of US$0.22 per share. At its current ownership level of 39.8%, the contribution to TD Bank (TD-T) is estimated at C$0.08 per share.

• On August 3, TD Ameritrade announced a share repurchase program of up to 12 million shares, or 2 percent of its shares outstanding.
;

Enron Investors' Fraud Trial Postponed to 2007

  
Bloomberg, 1 August 2006

Enron Corp. investors seeking to recover $40 billion in losses tied to the energy trader's collapse won a delay in the trial of their fraud claims against the company's former bankers until April 2007.

William Lerach, the lead investor lawyer, had urged U.S. District Judge Melinda Harmon to postpone the Oct. 16 trial to allow investors time to combine claims against investment firms and lenders, including Merrill Lynch & Co. and Toronto-Dominion Bank. Harmon granted the request Aug. 8 after a telephone conference with investor and bank lawyers, according to a note on the court docket of the case. The new trial date is April 9.

The request for a delay came two weeks after Harmon threw out investor fraud claims against Barclays Plc, Britain's third- largest bank, over its role in Enron's 2001 collapse. Merrill Lynch and Toronto-Dominion are seeking to have the judge dismiss the claims against them on similar grounds.

``Given that our motion to dismiss has not yet been heard, it would not be appropriate to comment at this time,'' said Simon Townsend, a spokesman for Toronto-Dominion. Mark Herr, a Merrill Lynch spokesman, had no comment.

Enron, once the world's largest energy-trading firm, had more than $68 billion in market value before its December 2001 bankruptcy filing wiped out thousands of jobs and at least $1 billion in retirement funds virtually overnight.

Investors contend the banks helped former Enron Chairman Kenneth Lay and Chief Executive Officer Jeffrey Skilling use off- the-book partnerships to manipulate the company's finances. Both men were convicted of fraud and conspiracy charges in May.

Skilling, 52, faces at least 25 years in prison when he is sentenced in October. Lay died of a heart attack on July 5 at the age of 64.

Both men were named as defendants in the investors' class action, which seeks to recoup losses from the collapse in the value of Enron's shares. Shareholders' lawyers already have recovered $7.3 billion from settlements with lenders such as Citigroup Inc., JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce.

Lerach, a partner in the San Diego-based law firm Lerach Coughlin Stoia Geller Rudman & Robbins, said procedural snags in the case would have forced investors' lawyers to try claims against some defendants in October and then hold another trial for remaining banks. Lerach didn't immediately return a call seeking comment placed today before regular business hours.

Investors contend the banks and investment firms actively participated in Enron's fraud by providing funding for off-the- books partnerships used to inflate the energy trader's earnings, and engaging in sham asset purchases and other questionable deals. Harmon found Barclays adviser role was insufficient to trigger liability under U.S. securities laws.

Merrill is a passive, minority investor in Bloomberg LP, the parent of Bloomberg News.

The case is Newby v. Enron Corp., No. 01-cv-3624, U.S. District Court, Southern District of Texas (Houston).
;

Manulife Sells Canaccord Shares

  
Investment Executive, 10 August 2006

Canaccord Capital Inc. says The Manufacturers Life Insurance Co., a significant shareholder of the company, yesterday sold 2 million Canaccord common shares through the facilities of the Toronto Stock Exchange.

The share block was crossed at a price of $18.10 per share. As a result, Manulife now holds 2,943,369 common shares in the company, representing 6.15% of the issued common shares.

William Eeuwes, vp of Manulife Capital and a director of Canaccord Capital Inc. commented, “We are delighted by the shareholder value Peter Brown and his management team has created, since our investment in 2002. Manulife Capital’s decision to sell two million shares today was driven by a need to rebalance its portfolio.”
;

Price Targets for Life Insurance Companies

  
Great West Lifeco Inc.
• BMO Capital Markets maintains "market perform," 12-month target price is $32.00
• Desjardins Securities upgrades to "buy,"
• GMP Securities maintains "buy," 12-month target price is $34.50
• National Bank Financial maintains "sector perform," 12-month target price is $31.50
• RBC Capital Markets maintains "sector perform," 12-month target price is $32.00
• Scotia Capital maintains "sector outperform," 12-month target price is $33.00
• TD Newcrest maintains "hold," 12-month target price is $31.00

Industrial Alliance Insurance & Financial Services
• BMO Capital Markets maintains "outperform," 12-month target price is raised to $38.00 from $37.00
• Desjardins Securities maintains "buy," 12-month target price is $36.50
• RBC Capital Markets maintains "outperform," 12-month target price is $40.00
• Scotia Capital maintains "sector underperform," 12-month target price is $35.00
• TD Newcrest downgrades to "hold," 12-month target price is $35.00

Manulife Financial Corp.
• BMO Capital Markets maintains "outperform," 12-month target price is $40.00
• Desjardins Securities maintains "top pick," 12-month target price is raised to $41.00 from $39.50
• GMP Securities maintains "buy," 12-month target price is $38.50
• RBC Capital Markets maintains "top pick," 12-month target price is $43.00
• Scotia Capital downgrades to "sector perform," 12-month target price is reduced to $38.00 from $38.50
• TD Newcrest maintains "action list buy," 12-month target price is $42.00
• UBS upgrades to "buy," 12-month target price is $42.00

Sun Life Financial Inc.
• BMO Capital Markets maintains "outperform," 12-month target price is reduced to $51.00 from $54.00
• Desjardins Securities downgrades to "hold," 12-month target price is reduced to $47.50
• RBC Capital Markets maintains "sector perform," 12-month target price is $52.00
• Scotia Capital maintains "sector perform," 12-month target price is reduced to $50.00 from $52.00
• TD Newcrest downgrades to "hold," 12-month target price is reduced to $47.00 from $52.00
;

RBC Buys Flag Financial Corp

  
Financial Post, Duncan Mavin, 10 August 2006

Royal Bank of Canada jumped back into growth mode in the United States yesterday with its purchase of Atlanta-based Flag Financial Corp. for US$456-million.

The deal is the first acquisition since 2003 by RBC's U.S. retail banking subsidiary, North Carolina-based RBC Centura. The deal appears to mark the end of a couple of years of stalemate at RBC Centura, which has suffered disappointing results since recording a loss in 2004.

"This acquisition supports RBC Centura's overall strategy of disciplined, affordable, add-on investments to expand our distribution network," said RBC Centura chief executive Scott Custer.

The deal also signals RBC Centura is following the lead of bigger players in the U.S. banking sector that are targeting branch-network growth by gobbling up smaller regional banks.

Already this year, U.S. giants Capital One Bank, JP Morgan & Co. and Wachovia Corp. have added hundreds of new branches through acquisitions.

Toronto-Dominion Bank, through its TD Banknorth subsidiary in the U.S. northeast, has also increased its branch network significantly, while Bank of Montreal's Chicago-based Harrisbank is reported to be on the prowl for acquisitions too.

RBC's acquisition is not on the same scale as the expansion of some of the largest U.S. banks -- the deal adds just 17 full service branches and five mortgage offices in Atlanta to the bank's existing network of 30 branches in Georgia.

"[But] it makes absolutely perfect sense for [RBC's] U.S. franchise," said Kevin Reynolds an analyst at Stanford Financial Group who covers Flag Financial.

By acquiring a small number of branches in a strong Atlanta banking market, RBC is "dipping its toe in the water and finding a quality franchise that seems to fit with its way of doing business," he said.

The deal means RBC Centura increases its deposit balance by approximately US$1.35-billion, or 12%, and its loans will grow by US$1.25-billion, or 10%.

RBC Centura also gets 370 new employees and customer relationships with about 22,000 households, as well as a beefed-up presence in the region.

"This transaction can be viewed as a bolt-on to Centura's market position in Georgia," said Desjardins Securities analyst Michael Goldberg in a note. "Most importantly, it gives Centura a stronger footprint to further grow in Atlanta," he said.

Some observers believe the U.S. banking industry is ripe for further consolidation because smaller banks are facing a challenging environment.

Intense competition coupled with rising interest rates have reduced the spread between the rates charged on loans and what banks have to give to lure deposits, known as the net interest margin.

That has left bigger players chomping at the bit as they wait for smaller targets to put themselves up for sale.

"Like most U.S. regionals, Flag has struggled with [net interest margin] compression," said Genuity Capital Markets analyst Mario Mendonca.

RBC's purchase of Flag Financial may signal that smaller players are beginning to feel the pinch and further deals could be possible, he said.

However, there was no sign of that trend in the price RBC has agreed to pay for Flag, said Tom Kersting, an analyst at Edward Jones.

"The price seems reasonable," said Mr. Kersting. "Even though the industry conditions are becoming increasingly difficult, it doesn't seem to have really impacted the price."

Nevertheless, at about eighteen times estimated earnings for 2007, most analysts agreed the price for Flag is comparable to recent deals for banks of a similar size.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Sinclair Stewart, 10 August 2006

Royal Bank of Canada is spending more than half a billion dollars to acquire an Atlanta-based retail banking group, kick-starting a U.S. expansion drive that has been largely idle for the past few years.

The country's largest bank is paying $456-million (U.S.), or $510-million (Canadian), for 17 branches operated by Flag Financial Corp.

While not a huge deal, it does represent RBC's first retail acquisition south of the border since the summer of 2003, and suggests the bank has not wavered on its strategy despite some well-publicized struggles in that market.

"This seems to be an attempt to move forward, slowly," said one analyst who follows the bank. "It's a sign that RBC is definitely not retreating from the U.S."

RBC has been a reluctant deal maker in the United States of late, preferring instead to address some performance issues at RBC Centura, its North Carolina-based retail bank, and rid itself of a problematic mortgage division.

Even though much of that work has been done, and the U.S. operations have demonstrated improvement, RBC chief executive officer Gordon Nixon has continued to preach patience on expansion, saying that regional banks are too expensive.

The Flag acquisition was certainly not viewed as a bargain on Bay Street, given that RBC is paying roughly 20 times the company's projected profit for 2006.

Strangely, however, it isn't paying much of a premium on Flag's share price. That's because Flag's stock has been on a tear, climbing roughly 23 per cent in the past month and suggesting to some observers that word of the deal had leaked into the marketplace.

Scott Custer, CEO of RBC Centura, said all regional banks have enjoyed a lift in valuation in recent weeks, and chalked up some of the stock movement to better-than-expected quarterly results reported by Flag.

He also insisted that the price of the deal was in line with what other banks in the area have fetched from suitors.

"It is expensive," he acknowledged of the current market. "That's why you don't try to buy everything that's got a 'For Sale' sign in front of it."

Mr. Custer, who took over the role two years ago, said RBC Centura has made good progress on addressing some of the issues that hurt its profitability, and is now at a point where it can make acquisitions, rather than just grow through new branch openings.

Flag has 370 employees and deposits of $1.35-billion (U.S.) drawn from across Georgia, where RBC has 30 banking centres. Flag will help boost RBC's presence in the southeastern region, but it still remains a small player there.

The last time RBC bought a U.S. retail bank was in the summer of 2003, when it paid $75-million for a group of Florida branches owned by Provident Financial Group Inc. However, the bank hasn't made a U.S. deal of this size since it acquired brokerage Tucker Anthony Sutro in 2001 for almost $600-million.

Mr. Custer said he hopes he doesn't have to wait another two or three years before making another acquisition, but he conceded the bank has to demonstrate it can digest U.S. purchases -- one of the key knocks against it and the Canadian banking industry in general -- before it begins hunting for another deal.

"The easy part is figuring out how to buy something," he said.

"The hard part is figuring out how to run it once you've bought it.
__________________________________________________________
Canadian Press, Rita Trichur

Royal Bank of Canada, the country's biggest bank, is ramping up its presence in the southeastern United States by paying $456 million US through a U.S. subsidiary for Flag Financial Corp. and Flag Bank in Georgia.

The deal marks RBC Centura Banks Inc.'s first U.S. acquisition since late 2003, in a lucrative market that has proved challenging in the past.

"We've got a good presence here in Atlanta but ... this essentially more than doubles our business base here," said Scott Custer, CEO of RBC Centura, in an interview from Atlanta.

"Flag Bank's presence in Georgia, combined with its distinct business banking capability, are ideally aligned with RBC Centura's strategic focus to become the bank for business, business owners and professionals."

The acquisition - which is expected to close by the end of the year, subject to regulatory and shareholder approvals - amounts to $25.50 per Flag share.

Flag Financial owns and operates Flag Bank, which has 17 branches and 370 employees serving about 22,000 households in metropolitan Atlanta and the central and western areas of Georgia.

Flag Bank has a deposit balance of about $1.35 billion US and loans totalling $1.25 billion.

Its branch offices will join a network of 30 RBC Centura banking centres already in Georgia, primarily in the Atlanta area.

After the transaction closes, Centura will merge Flag Bank into RBC Centura. Flag Bank's branch network will operate under the RBC Centura brand name, with current Flag Bank CEO Thomas Wiley as the Georgia state president of RBC Centura.

But the American market has proved tricky for Canada's largest bank. In 2005, it exited its U.S. mortgage business after suffering operational challenges in that division.

"After taking their lumps, they appeared to get it (their U.S. operations) turned around - much to a lot analysts' surprise," said John Kinsey, a portfolio manager with Caldwell Securities.

During its last quarter, RBC's U.S. and international banking arm pulled in $106 million versus $82 million a year earlier, although the strength of the loonie held down U.S.-dollar-denominated earnings by $35 million. The bank is scheduled to report its third-quarter earnings Aug. 25.

"We're just a different company than we were two years ago. And we're much more able, I believe, to execute on an acquisition of this size and ultimately any other acquisition that we might do," Custer said.

The bank, he added, is continuing with its U.S. branch-build strategy and will open four new Atlanta locations in the next 45 to 60 days.

Atlanta, a metropolis of more than five million people, is considered the No. 1 growth market in the U.S. southeast.

"It's a market that a lot of banks have focused on, so it is a little more competitive with newer entrants," said Tom Kersting, a financial services analyst with brokerage Edward Jones.

"But it does appear to be sort of an under-banked market compared to some of the other markets, especially for a large metropolitan area."

In addition to RBC Centura, Royal Bank's U.S. operations include RBC Dain Rauscher, a full-service securities firm based in Minneapolis; RBC Insurance, a national provider of insurance protection and asset accumulation solutions based in Greenville, S.C. and RBC Capital Markets, with corporate and investment banking operations in New York, Minneapolis and Greenwich.
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, 9 August 2006

Royal Bank of Canada, the country's biggest bank, agreed to buy Flag Financial Corp. for about $456 million, making its first purchase of a U.S. bank in almost three years as it moves to expand in Georgia.

Shareholders of Atlanta-based Flag Financial will receive $25.50 a share, Toronto-based Royal Bank said today. The bid was 17 cents higher than yesterday's closing price for Flag shares.

Royal Bank has scaled back acquisitions at its RBC Centura unit, based in Rocky Mount, North Carolina, after a 2004 slowdown in the U.S. led to the company's first annual profit decline in four years. RBC Centura bought the Florida branch network of Provident Financial Group Inc. in November 2003 for about $80 million.

``We've been very focused on turning our performance around and earning the credibility that we needed to be able to be back in the acquisition business,'' RBC Centura Chief Executive Officer Scott Custer said today in a telephone interview.

Flag Bank has 17 branches in Atlanta and other parts of Georgia, the banks said in a statement. It has about $1.35 billion in deposits and 370 employees. Royal Bank's RBC Centura unit has 30 branches in Georgia, mostly around Atlanta.

``Atlanta's got some of the best growth demographics, not only in the U.S. Southeast, but in the whole country,'' said Custer, 49.

The Flag branches will be operated under the RBC Centura name. The transaction is expected to close this year.

RBC Centura plans to add 20 new branches by the end of 2007 to its network of about 270. Custer said the bank will continue to consider acquisitions in Georgia, Florida and the Carolinas, although he declined to say how much the bank will spend.

``There's no shortage of smaller community banks that continue to open and probably put themselves out there to be acquired or merged,'' Custer said.

Shares of Royal Bank fell 10 cents to C$46.66 at 4:10 p.m. in trading on the Toronto Stock Exchange. Flag shares fell 66 cents, or 2.6 percent, to $24.67 in Nasdaq trading.
__________________________________________________________
RBC Capital Markets, 9 August 2006

• No Change to Estimates. This deal is not material to overall EPS. Accordingly, we are making no estimate changes and reiterate our Outperform rating.

• Deposits Up 12%, Loans Up 10%. Flag Bank adds 17 branches, (8 in Atlanta), US$1.35B in deposits and US$1.25B in loans. RBC Centura has 274 branches (30 in Atlanta), and ~US$11B in deposits. RBC Centura’s pro forma deposit base increases by 12%, loans by 10% and branch count by 6%. According to SNL Financial data, this should move RBC Centura into 8th place in Georgia and 7th in Atlanta (by deposits).

• Flag is a Commercial Real Estate Lender. Flag’s loan portfolio is 91% in real-estate loans. Construction and land development accounts for 39% of total loans, while another 51% is secured mortgage loans.

• Valuation. Our $55 price target is set at 14x our 2007 cash EPS estimate of $3.94. Our premium target P/E is based on high-quality EPS revisions potential, best-in-class ROE and excellent credit performance. RBC has an excellent business mix with high-quotient of retail business, augmented by leading positions in both wealth and insurance. Our price target is indicated at ~3.1x our projected book value of $17.51 (as at April 30/07).
__________________________________________________________
BMO Capital Markets, 9 August 2006

Royal Bank announced this morning that it has signed a definitive agreement to acquire Flag, a 17-branch bank in Georgia for US$456 million. RBC Centura already operates 30 branches in Georgia, principally Atlanta. The acquisition price is high (20.2x forecast 2006 earnings, 4.7x tangible book value) but this reflects good growth opportunities in the U.S. South and Flag’s high average deposits per branch. The pro forma market share of Royal Bank in Atlanta will be 1.9% and the combined entity will be the 7th largest bank in that market. Despite the price, and the checkered track record of Royal in U.S. retail banking, we believe this is a slightly positive deal. Royal’s franchise in Canada is in great shape, its ROE is impressive and the bank’s stock has performed well. Having said that, we believe the bank needs to improve the scale, competitive position and profitability of its U.S. franchises if it is to have good long-term growth potential. This is a small step in the process for Royal Bank.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Richard Blackwell, 9 August 2006

A U.S. subsidiary of Royal Bank of Canada has signed a deal to buy Georgia-based Flag Financial Corp. for U$456-million.

RBC Centura Banks Inc., Royal's U.S. arm that is based in North Carolina, will pay Flag Financial shareholders $25.50 per share for the retail banking operation.

Flag Financial has 17 Flag Bank branches and five mortgage offices in Atlanta and central and western regions of Georgia. It has 370 employees, deposits of about $1.35-billion and loans of about $1.25-billion.

Flag Financial also operates a payroll service businesses for clients across the United States.

Flag Bank will be merged into the RBC Centura operations, and take the RBC Centura name. RBC Centura already has 30 banking centres in Georgia, mostly in the Altanta area.

The deal need approval by regulators in Canada and the United States, and by Flag Financial shareholders. RBC said it hopes to close the deal by the end of 2006.
;

BMO Sued Over Currency Conversion in Retirement Plans

  
Financial Post, Duncan Mavin, 10 August 2006

Bank of Montreal is at the centre of a multi-million-dollar class-action lawsuit alleging the bank charged unfair and undisclosed fees to customers with retirement savings plan accounts, it was revealed yesterday.

In a statement of claim filed with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, it is alleged that BMO charges the fees for transactions that are not approved, and earned profits inappropriately at the expense of customers, depleting the funds in the customers' retirement or education funds.

It is not yet known how many BMO customers might be affected, and it is possible other Canadian banks could face similar legal challenges if they have not amended their systems since the tax act changes five years ago.

"It is our understanding that this issue may well go beyond BMO," said Odette Soriano, a lawyer with Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP, the firm that filed the claim on behalf of James MacDonald, a BMO customer.

The issue has arisen since revisions to the Income Tax Act which came into effect on June 14, 2001.

The changes permitted Canadians to hold foreign currency investments in their registered retirement savings plans, registered retirement income funds and registered education savings plans.

Ms. Soriano said the claim alleges BMO did not change its systems to allow for the fact customers could hold foreign currency investments in those savings plans. As a result, everything bought or sold in the account always goes through a foreign exchange conversion, making it very difficult for customers to make a profit while trading foreign securities in their savings plans. Customers are likely aware that they pay a fee for the initial conversion of their savings into foreign currency to invest in foreign securities, said Ms. Soriano. "But, if they are like Mr. McDonald, they aren't aware of the additional charges," she said.

The claim seeks damages of up to $100-million for "all the fees charged on unauthorized conversion of foreign currency to Canadian funds since the change to the Income Tax Act became effective."

Meanwhile, a spokesman for BMO said the bank does not comment on matters before the courts and has not yet filed documents in response to the claim. However, he said the bank does intend to file a statement of defence.
__________________________________________________________
Canadian Press, Rita Trichur, 9 August 2006

Bank of Montreal along with its BMO Nesbitt Burns and BMO Trust divisions are named as defendants in a $100-million, class-action lawsuit over disputed foreign currency costs charged to certain registered accounts.

The proposed action was launched by Ontario retirement plan investor James MacDonald on behalf of all former and current BMO clients who held Registered Retirement Savings Plans, Registered Retirement Income Funds or Registered Education Savings Plans, and incurred foreign currency conversion charges on those accounts since mid-June 2001.

The statement of claim alleges the bank needlessly converted foreign currency to Canadian dollars in those accounts, despite changes to the Income Tax Act that came into effect June 14, 2001 allowing RRSPs, RRIFs and RESPs to hold foreign currency as an investment.

"Mr. MacDonald saw some fees that were being charged to him for foreign-exchange conversions and he was concerned that what was happening was not required," said lawyer Margaret Waddell of Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP in an interview.

"And when he asked BMO about it, the answer he got was you have to change it, which he then found out was not in fact the case."

The claim alleges that in effecting those currency conversions, BMO levied "an undisclosed conversion fee" in addition to what they actually paid to buy or sell currency.

It further alleges "the reason for the defendants' failure to effect a change was so that they could continue to earn profits from the foreign exchange fees, at the expense of the class members," his lawyers said.

The allegations have not been proven in court and the class-action has yet to be certified.

MacDonald, who lives in Stouffville, Ont., north of Toronto, filed his complaint in Ontario Superior Court on Aug. 2, but BMO was officially served Wednesday.

"We've not filed any documents in response yet, but we intend to defend the action," said bank spokeswoman JoAnne Hayes.

According to the filing, the bank has 20 days to respond.

The claim seeks damages for all the fees charged in association with the unauthorized conversion and the repayment of all the hidden foreign-exchange fees on transactions where the customer did authorize a conversion of funds but did not agree to pay the hidden fee.

BMO's shares lost two cents to $63.43 on the Toronto stock market.
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, 9 August 2006

Bank of Montreal, Canada's fourth- biggest bank by assets, was sued by a retirement plan investor claiming he was charged fees on unnecessary currency conversions.

The proposed class action, filed by Ontario resident James MacDonald in Ontario Superior Court, seeks at least C$110 million ($98 million) for all investors in Registered Retirement Savings Accounts, the Canadian version of 401k accounts, the Toronto law firm Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein said today in a statement. The plaintiff also wants to bar the bank from charging undisclosed fees on any foreign exchange transactions.

The complaint, filed Aug. 2, challenged the bank's practice of charging foreign exchange fees on stock trades in the accounts. MacDonald claimed he was charged a fee when he bought Tyco International Ltd. shares in U.S. currency in 2003. He was billed a second time when he sold the shares two months later after the proceeds were converted back to Canadian dollars, the complaint said.

``The foreign exchange fee is not and has never been disclosed to MacDonald and the other class members,'' his lawyers said in the complaint. ``The foreign exchange fee is and was intentionally hidden and kept secret from the class members, in breach of the defendants' contractual and fiduciary duties.''

Spokeswoman Joanne Hayes said in an e-mailed statement that Bank of Montreal will defend the suit. It has 20 days to file a statement of defense.

Visa, MasterCard Claims

Last month, Visa International Inc., MasterCard Inc. and banks including Citigroup Inc. said they agreed to pay $336 million to their customers to settle antitrust lawsuits over currency conversion fees charged on foreign transactions.

MasterCard said it will pay $72.5 million as its share of the settlement. Bank of America Corp., JPMorgan Chase & Co's Bank One Corp. and Chase Manhattan Bank and Washington Mutual Inc. are also defendants in the case.

The suits involved claims the credit card companies failed to disclose fees of up to three percent on purchases made in foreign currencies, said Merrill Davidoff, a lawyer for the consumers.

The case is Between James Richard MacDonald and BMO Trust Co., Ontario Superior Court of Justice (Toronto), Case No.: 06- CV-316213CF.
;

Sun Life's Prieur Resigns

  
Scotia Capital, 10 August 2006

• A neutral event our opinion. A relatively "non-external face" at Sun Life, Prieur, who is 55, had spent the last twelve months in Hong Kong, assuming leadership of the company's Asian unit (in what was believed to be a "stop-gap" role) following the August 10, 2005 retirement of Doug Henck, who previously was President of Sun Life Financial, Asia. We believe the company is very close to announcing its Asian leadership position.

• While in Hong Kong, Prieur's President and COO duties we believe were assumed to some extent by CEO Don Stewart, who is 59 and is expected to continue on at Sun Life for a number of years.

• We expect the company will announce a replacement for Paul Dersksen, CFO, within the next 3 months, who just over 3 months ago announced he will be retiring, effective February, 2006.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Sinclair Stewart, 10 August 2006

Sun Life Financial Inc. has lost a second key member of its executive team after Jim Prieur resigned as president to become chief executive officer of Conseco Inc., a rival U.S. insurer with a checkered past.

The 55-year-old insurance veteran will be the fourth CEO Conseco has appointed since 2003, when it emerged from one of the largest bankruptcy proceedings in U.S. history.

Mr. Prieur will replace interim CEO Jim Hohmann, who is remaining with Conseco as president and chief operating officer.

"It's a company that's been through a lot, and it's sort of on the verge of success," said Mr. Prieur, who will relocate to Conseco's Chicago offices next month.

"I think it's a real interesting opportunity."

Mr. Prieur, who has spent the past year in Hong Kong overseeing Sun Life's Asian expansion, was viewed by some as a possible successor to current Sun Life CEO Donald Stewart. His departure follows that of chief financial officer Paul Derksen, who recently announced his plans to retire at the beginning of next year.

Mr. Stewart admitted he was surprised when Mr. Prieur told him he was leaving after 27 years with the company. But he played down suggestions that Mr. Prieur was poised to replace him.

"It's a little hard for someone pretty close in age to me to be a logical successor," said Mr. Stewart, 59.

He said Sun Life is close to naming a new head for its Asian business, and is hoping to make an announcement on a new CFO by the end of next month. He is not replacing Mr. Prieur's role of president and chief operating officer.

"Life moves on, and we'll have new people in place, and the company will move forward," he said.

Mr. Prieur has focused much of his time recently on bolstering Sun Life's international presence, particularly in India, Hong Kong and mainland China. Under his watch, the Asian unit has increased profit by 63 per cent over the past four quarters.

He is also no stranger to the U.S. market, having lived there for several years to oversee one of Sun Life's insurance units. Conseco, however, which focuses on middle America, poses a different set of challenges.

While Sun Life is a conservative-minded company with more than 140 years of history, Conseco is a relative upstart that has been racked by regulatory probes, dire financial problems, an accounting scandal, and bad publicity.

Several times, it has faced criticism for generous executive pay packages, and was buffeted by controversy a few years ago after guaranteeing loans to some of its top executives. Some of these officials were unable to repay the money after the company's shares plummeted, leaving the company in the lurch.

One of Conseco's previous CEOs was ousted in 2000, and the company faced federal accounting probes in 2002, shortly before it tipped into bankruptcy protection. Since then, the CEO office has resembled a turnstile.

However, the company appears to be turning the corner. Early this month, it announced it would take a $100.3-million (U.S.) charge to settle a class-action lawsuit alleging some of its subsidiaries forced customers to pay higher premiums on some insurance products or surrender them for cash in order to bolster the parent company's finances.

Mr. Prieur described this as a significant step in aiding the company's turnaround, and allowing it to secure a better credit rating. That would help Conseco expand its sales reach and enter new markets.

;

09 August 2006

NYSE Fines RBC for Proxy Handling

  
Bloomberg, 9 August 2006

Royal Bank of Canada agreed to pay $80,000 to the New York Stock Exchange to settle allegations that it mishandled proxies, making it the fifth brokerage faulted this year for breaking rules governing votes on corporate actions.

RBC Capital Markets, a unit of Canada's biggest bank, agreed to the fine without admitting or denying wrongdoing, the NYSE said in a statement today. Deutsche Bank AG has drawn the largest fine, paying $1 million in February, followed by UBS AG's $600,000 in June. The fines stem from a 2004 investigation into whether shareholders may be disenfranchised by brokerages that cast too many, or too few, votes on corporate actions.

``We want to give the firm message that this is an area where they need to have tighter controls,'' Linda Riefberg, a vice president at NYSE Regulation's enforcement division, said in an interview. ``NYSE Regulation will continue to review firms for compliance with the proxy rules and see if the firms are getting their reconciliation responsibilities right.''

The fine against Toronto-based Royal Bank was announced by the exchange today among 51 disciplinary actions that netted a total of $1.47 million. In 2004, the firm instituted written polices and procedures to correctly tabulate its proxy votes, according to an NYSE disciplinary panel.

``We respect the decision of the NYSE hearing board and are pleased that this is now resolved,'' said Katherine Gay, a spokeswoman for the bank.

Daiwa Securities America Inc., the U.S. unit of Japan's second-largest brokerage, drew the largest fine announced today, agreeing to pay $250,000 for failing to retain some e-mails and business records.

``We are satisfied that this settlement recognizes our improvements in our record keeping and internal review procedures and resolves our open issues with the exchange,'' a Daiwa spokeswoman said.

In addition to Deutsche Bank, Germany's biggest bank, and UBS, Europe's largest, Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and Credit Suisse Group have also been fined by the exchange for mishandling proxies. All the firms agreed to pay the fines without admitting or denying wrongdoing.

None of the violations cited by the NYSE in its investigation affected the outcome of votes on corporate actions, the exchange said.
;

08 August 2006

NatWest 3 May Testify Against RBC

  
The Toronto Star, Tara Perkins, 8 August 2006

Three British bankers who are in Houston awaiting trial on criminal charges related to the Enron Corp. scandal have been subpoenaed to give depositions in a separate, class-action civil suit against the Royal Bank of Canada.

The so called NatWest Three have been ordered to appear at the Houston Deposition Centre on Sept. 28 in connection with a suit against the Royal Bank that was launched two years ago by the regents of the University of California in Houston district court.

The suit was filed on behalf of people who bought Enron stock and bonds between Jan. 9, 1999, and Nov. 27, 2001. The university's board of regents, which oversees an investment portfolio of more than $54 billion (U.S.), lost more than $144 million on Enron shares.

The suit alleges that the Royal Bank "engaged in or participated in the implementation of manipulative or deceptive devices to inflate Enron's reported profits and financial condition. ...

"By this fraudulent scheme and course of business, (Royal) pocketed millions of dollars in fees, interest and credit facility payments," the suit states.

The claim alleges that Royal knew Enron considered it to be a second tier bank and that it wanted to become one of Enron's top 10 banks.

The lawsuit alleges the bank hired the NatWest Three to help boost its relationship with Enron — and subsequently helped Enron hide debt on its balance sheet.

The Royal Bank, which lost a battle to have the case dismissed last December, denies the allegations in the civil suit. Royal is in no way implicated in the criminal case against the NatWest Three.

The U.S. government had the three men — Gary Mulgrew, Giles Darby and David Bermingham — extradited July 13 on criminal wire fraud charges for allegedly bilking their former employer, National Westminster Bank, out of $7.3 million (U.S.) in a scheme engineered by former Enron finance chief Andrew Fastow.

The three, who wear electronic monitoring devices around their ankles and are not allowed to leave southern Texas, have all pleaded innocent. They came to the U.S. after losing all appeals in a two-year extradition battle.

In Britain, human rights advocates, lawyers and opposition politicians argue that the case should be tried in England because the three stand accused of defrauding a British bank.

They also say a fast track extradition system enacted in 2003 to fight terrorists allows the U.S. to demand a Briton's extradition without providing evidence.

The case received even more attention last month after a banker who was a witness for the FBI was found dead in a London park.

The three former bankers left Greenwich NatWest in 2000 and went to work for the Royal Bank, Canada's biggest bank where, the lawsuit alleges, they helped Enron hide debt on its balance sheet in order to raise the bank's stature with the Houston-based energy trader.

"We consider the allegations to be false, and we intend to aggressively defend against them," said Royal Bank spokeswoman Beja Rodeck.

A few weeks ago, the men were served subpoenas that will require them to give depositions next month for the plaintiffs in the Royal suit.

The subpoenas were served as they sat in a Houston courtroom moments before a bail hearing was to begin for their criminal charges, Bermingham said in a telephone interview Thursday from his lawyer's office.

"We were just looking at it, thinking, `As if we thought things couldn't get any worse,' they just keep piling shit on us," he said. "We had been in the country less than 24 hours when lawyers for whoever, the ambulance chasing lawyers, came out with their subpoenas," Bermingham said from Houston.

The criminal trial against the three was scheduled to start in September, but Bermingham said it now looks like it will begin early next year, largely because Mulgrew and Darby haven't scraped together the funds for lawyers.


"The terms of the bail package that were set were so financially constraining, they required so much cash to be put out front, that Gary and Giles were not able to maintain the retainers that were necessary to instruct their counsel," Bermingham said. "So they're trying to raise the funds elsewhere by selling other assets in order to retain counsel."

In the meantime, "we have curfews, we have electronic monitoring, we have non-association clauses," said Bermingham, whose wife and three children remain in England.

The criminal charges relate to activities that took place when the men worked for Greenwich NatWest, which has since been bought by the Royal Bank of Scotland.

Bermingham said that in 2000, NatWest was the subject of a hostile takeover bid from two Scottish banks. Part of NatWest's defence strategy was to sell its branch network business, he said.

"And RBC happened to be one of the banks that was actively interested in buying the Greenwich NatWest business. RBC made it very clear that they were very interested in setting up a structured finance group," he said.

"And so, around the time we were leaving, (NatWest) they put an advertisement in the paper saying they would like to set up a structured finance group. I had actually resigned in March of 2000 (from NatWest). And so I was the first to make contact for them."

Soon after, Bermingham helped establish a structured finance group for the Royal Bank of Canada in London of about 50 people, some from NatWest, some from elsewhere, he said.

"RBC moved towards accomplishing this by hiring approximately 25 bankers in August 2000 from the NatWest structured finance group," the civil suit states.

"The NatWest bankers included Gary Mulgrew, who led NatWest's structured finance group and then Royal Bank's global structured finance group; Giles Darby, a managing director in NatWest's structured finance group and the Enron `relationship manager'; and David Bermingham, a director in NatWest's structured finance group," the suit states.

Once at the Royal, the NatWest bankers sought to raise the bank's profile within Enron and thereby increase its fees, the suit adds.

As an example, it claims that the Royal's first Enron transaction after hiring the NatWest bankers was the so-called Alberta prepay.

In August 2000, the province of Alberta auctioned a number of 20-year power purchase agreements. Enron Canada was one of the successful bidders.

While Enron had no interest in purchasing gas, RBC helped to finance a transaction that allowed Enron to treat the financing as a sales contract rather than debt on its balance sheet, the suit alleges.

In a response to the civil suit, filed this March, the Royal acknowledged it hired the NatWest Three and that it entered into a $147.5 million (Canadian) prepaid gas contract in September 2000 in connection with Enron's financing of its power purchase deal with Alberta.

But it outlines 37 defences, arguing that the claims are barred by the statutes of limitations or repose, and that the "plaintiff's claims, at most, allege aiding and abetting the principal conduct of third parties" and are barred by case law.

The Royal argues that it was engaged solely in private transactions with Enron and engaged in no conduct in connection with the purchase or sale of any security, and that the Royal had no "... duty to review, supervise, approve or correct Enron's public financial disclosures, nor were the RBC defendants under any duty to make public disclosure of Enron's financial condition."

The Royal also argues that it proceeded in good faith in relying on disclosures from Enron and that it was ultimately deceived by the company.

The University of California also has class-action claims against Toronto Dominion Bank, Crédit Suisse First Boston, Arthur Anderson LLP, Goldman Sachs, Merrill Lynch, the Royal Bank of Scotland and others related to Enron.

Last August, CIBC settled a class-action suit for $2.4 billion (U.S.). Others have also settled in amounts ranging from $32 million to $2.2 billion, the second largest settlement, which was paid by JPMorganChase in June.
;

Scotiabank, the World's Oldest Gold Dealer

  
Financial Post, Boyd Erman, 8 August 2006

At the top of Bank of Nova Scotia's red skyscraper in Toronto, a group of salespeople and traders from the bank's ScotiaMocatta precious-metals unit sit in front of blinking terminals buying and selling gold, silver, platinum and palladium all around the world.

Seventy floors below, an underground vault holds stacks of bullion in safekeeping for clients.

Despite its home in the New World, ScotiaMocatta is the world's oldest gold dealer. The firm traces its history back to 17th-century London, where the Mocatta family set up as a bullion dealer to the Bank of England. The Canadian bank bought the business from a British bank in 1997 and has since steadily expanded its precious-metals operations.

"If we are not the largest in the world in the business of physical gold, we are one of the largest," says Barry Wainstein, who runs ScotiaMocatta as well as currency trading operations for Bank of Nova Scotia's securities unit.

ScotiaMocatta is still one of the biggest players in its ancestral home of London, where the majority of the Western world's gold changes hands. The company is one of the select clearing houses that move an average of US$15.4-billion of gold to settle each day's trades. In addition, the company has branches in New York, Dubai, Hong Kong, and India, and just hired its first representative in Shanghai to take advantage of the liberalizing Chinese economy.

So how much gold and silver exactly is ScotiaMocatta responsible for at any one time? "I know that and I can't tell you that because of insurance issues," says Mr. Wainstein with a laugh.

Instead, he sketches out a few figures that illustrate just how big the operation is: it's the conduit for 30% of the gold that comes into India, the largest market for physical gold in the world; it has a similar market share in Italy, the leading jewellery design and manufacturing centre in Europe; and it's one of the largest buyers of metal from South Africa, the world's number one gold producing country.

If you are about to visit the vault of one of the world's dominant gold dealers, you might expect to see a vast steel room stacked with gleaming bars.

Instead, ScotiaMacotta's room has a suspended-tile ceiling, flourescent lighting and walls lined with safes painted a hospital green, giving the place the look of a high-school football team's locker room.

It's not unlike a working warehouse. In the middle, there are pallets of silver bars marked with marker-scrawled tags bearing the names of their owners. Scattered about are packing materials, scales and other instruments, all part of the business of shuffling millions of dollars of gold around the world each day, much of it by armored car and by airplane. There are similar rooms in Scotia facilities around the world.

"[ScotiaMacotta connects] the industrial users and the big investors and the producers of precious metals," Nick Barisheff, president of Bullion Management Services, which runs the $80-million Millenium Bullion Fund. Among the bars stacked in the centre of the Toronto vault are dozens of silver ones belonging to the Millenium fund, which uses ScotiaMocatta as its bullion dealer.

"Because of its size and contacts throughout the world, if we have an order for several hundred million dollars of metal, ScotiaMocatta can deal with it," Mr. Barisheff says.

Even as one of the biggest dealers in the world, precious metals are a niche business for Bank of Nova Scotia. Trading and lending in gold makes money for Scotiabank, but like much in the world of precious metals, figures are hard to come by. The bank does not break out results for ScotiaMocatta, though Mr. Wainstein will allow that the precious metals business has generated record profits four years in a row.

The bank's commitment to the business is increasingly rare, as other banks steadily pull out of precious metals, deeming the business too small or too unrelated to the real money makers of retail or investment banking. N.M. Rothschild and Credit Suisse are among the rivals that have left the business altogether or scaled back.

That's provided an opportunity for ScotiaMocatta, which has been an active shopper as other banks shed assets. Mr. Wainstein is currently looking at a proposal from another competitor that wants out. He's considering expanding into base metals, whose prices have been soaring in recent years.

The outlook for gold is still bullish after its rise beyond US$650 an ounce, Mr. Wainstein says, as there are concerns about a weakening U.S. dollar and rising inflation. A higher price, however, is not necessarily good for business. More expensive gold can suppress demand, as Asian consumers buy less jewellery as investments, and demand for fashion jewellery in the Western world fades. On the other side, a higher gold price increases the value of gold ScotiaMocatta has lent out, adding to interest income.

"We want profitability to be sustained throughout the cycle," Mr. Wainstein says. "Though we do probably make more money when gold goes up than when it goes down."
;

07 August 2006

Is HSBC the Go-To Bank for Global Investors?

  
By Stephen D. Simpson, CFA (TMFWildWeasel), 7 August 2006

You want a big bank? Very few are bigger than London's HSBC. You want diversified? This bank's profits come pretty equally from Europe, North America, and Asia, and there is growing balance in its split between personal, commercial, and investment banking. You want a good dividend? This bank has that, too.

This has been a decent year for larger banks, and the first-half results HSBC reported last week were no exception. The company offers more than a few different iterations on "profit," but let's just go with pre-tax profits, which were up about 18%. Net income attributable to shareholders was also up about 15% to $8.7 billion.

Growth was well-balanced throughout the world, as pre-tax profits grew about 25% in Europe, 15% in North America, and about 17% for all of Asia (10% in Hong Kong and 29% in the rest of Asia). Moreover, HSBC management talked about investing more resources into the fast-growing Chinese market and the now-recovering Japanese market.

Growth was also balanced along business lines. Personal finance was something of a laggard, with 10% profit growth, and it still constitutes about 50% of total profits. But deposit-gathering looked OK, and credit trends have thus far not been a problem. Profits in investment banking were much stronger (up about 37%), and the company continues to try to close the gap between itself and other large bank/investment bank hybrids like Citigroup, Bank of America, and JPMorgan Chase.

HSBC definitely makes an appealing investment. It's no longer unique in terms of its emerging-market exposure, but it's still seeing good growth in places like the Middle East and China, and it has a longer history in many of these markets than its rivals. And while HSBC's returns aren't the best, you could make the bullish argument that this simply provides room for improvement.

The roadblock for me on this stock is fairly simple. Why buy HSBC when Citigroup, JPMorgan Chase, and Bank of America all seem cheaper? Moreover, going with less-global banks in countries like Korea, Brazil, India, and Australia will get you better growth and better valuations. I'd be more than happy to own these shares at a better price, but not until then.
;