13 September 2007

Review of Banks' Q3 2007 Earnings + Outlook

  
National Bank Financial new analyst's ratings and target prices:

• BMO is rated "underperform," 12 month target price is $67.00

• CIBC is rated "outperform," 12-month target price is $105.00

• RBC is rated "sector perform," 12-month target price is $58.00

• Scotiabank is rated "sector perform," 12-month target price is $57.00

• TD Bank is rated "outperform," 12 month target price is $80.00
__________________________________________________________
• Credit Suisse upgraded BMO from "underperform" to "neutral." The target price is set to C$73.

Credit Suisse mentioned that revenues and profits at the BMO's core retail banking activities seem to be improving. BMO's Canadian retail and wealth operations posted robust bottom-line Q3 2007 results due to impressive revenue growth and efficient cost management; BMO continues to face difficulty in improving its share in the personal deposit market, Credit Suisse added.

• Dundee Securities cuts CIBC to 'neutral' from 'outperform'

• Dundee Securities cuts RBC to 'under perform' from 'neutral'

• Dundee Securities cuts Scotiabank to 'neutral' from 'outperform'
__________________________________________________________
BMO Capital Markets, 11 September 2007

Sector Downgraded to Market Perform: The Cumulative Weight of Events
Industry Rating: Market Perform

We are downgrading Canadian banks to Market Perform from Outperform. We moved to an Outperform rating in early 2005, driven by our confidence in the domestic banking business and our view that the appreciation in other yield vehicles highlighted the attractive valuation of bank shares. Since then, banks have produced over a 50% return over the 30-month period and have matched the returns from the TSX overall. This was achieved in an environment when both oil and gold prices moved meaningfully; not bad relative performance for a defensive group like the Canadian banks.

Our downgrade to Market Perform is based on three basic tenants:

1. We are witnessing a significant re-pricing of risk across several credit and cash markets. To date, this has been occurring in a less-than-orderly fashion, which creates some short-term risks to earnings.

2. The domestic environment in Canada has been incredibly strong. It is likely that we will witness slower loan growth and higher loan losses as we move forward. In addition, with the volatility in wholesale funding rates (and some short-term pricing moves by competitors), there could be some short-term pressure on core spreads.

3. The decline in the valuation of global financials is likely to continue to weigh on Canadian bank stocks. Canadian banks are now at 140% relative P/BV when compared to their U.S. peer group. We don't know how much wider this spread can get.

We aren't crying fire in a crowded movie house. Banks are off about 8% from their all-time highs, and though they have lagged the resource-heavy TSX over the past 12 months, they are still up 9% and have provided a rewarding 3-4% yield. We are very comfortable that banks have the liquidity and capital to deal with the current challenges.

Indeed, Canadian banks will likely benefit from the current volatility. Other financial intermediaries, finance companies, etc., will likely have less availability to funding than banks in this environment. The issue for us is timing, and the volatility in the short term is somewhat concerning. As such, we are moving to a Market Perform rating, and have reduced our bank share price targets.

The Past 30 Months Have Produced Solid Returns

Canadian Banks have produced excellent returns over the past 30 months (see table below). Indeed, Royal, TD, CIBC and BNS have been great performers with BMO and NA having lagged. The ability of the Canadian bank stocks to match the market (essentially) is impressive in the context of massive upward moves in commodity prices. In early 2005, crude oil was about US$40 a barrel and gold was just over US$400 an ounce.

A Disorderly Re-pricing of Risk

We have been struck by the significant volatility in what have traditionally been stable cash markets. We show the yield on U.S. 3-month T-bills in the chart below. This volatility has been driven by a flight to quality, as investors have shied away from various vehicles where there is limited visibility. Examples of this have included the asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) market here in Canada, the structured investment vehicle (SIV) market in the U.K. and the collateralized debt obligation (CDO) market in the U.S. ABCP, SIV and CDO have all become worrisome acronyms, at least for equity investors.

We believe that the root cause of the problem is the lack of confidence of buyers in ratings and rating agencies; ratings that were formerly trusted no longer seem to cut the mustard and buyers are becoming more (read very) selective. We aren't pointing the finger at rating agencies here; the reality is that many of these structures are still performing well on the asset front.

The issue seems to be that buyers have lost confidence in the ratings process. It is clear that the demand for credit analysis (and hopefully credit analysts) in North America is rising. However, this process will take time and we would be surprised to see it occur in a smooth fashion.

The Domestic Environment Remains Strong, but for how Long?

We are confident that the Canadian economy will remain strong. Canada is an 'oasis of stability' in an uncertain world. The fact that Canada is a resource economy, that the fiscal situation at most levels of government is good and the strength of the Canadian dollar all support this view.

However, the reality is that the environment is likely to be less robust over the coming quarters. As we show in the chart above, loan growth over the past three years has been spectacular and in July was over 12%. Over the past two decades, loan growth has occasionally exceeded 10%, but normally only for short periods. The fact that loan growth has exceeded 10% for close to three years surely suggests that slower growth is ahead. We don't anticipate loan growth falling off a cliff, but if bank stocks can't perform when the environment is this strong, one wonders what happens when loan growth slows to more normal levels (say in line with nominal GDP growth).

So far, mainline banks have been quite disciplined on pricing so that spreads have stabilized after experiencing declines from late 2001 until the start of 2006. One element that has helped has been stability in the Prime-BA spread and relatively easy access to wholesale funding. This appears to be changing (see chart below) with little sign that the Prime Rate (which prices most of the banks' loan books) is moving higher. National Bank's recent decision to significantly increase posted rates across GICs is, in our opinion, not a positive development and adds to the uncertainty in an already unclear environment.

Canadian Bank Valuations Have Already Widened Dramatically Versus Global Peers

In terms of stock price performance, Canadian banks have handily beat their global peers (see table below) over time. Since the start of the current decade, Canadian banks have more than doubled the performance of U.S. and U.K. banks. This outperformance has continued year to date and is a testament to the better banking model in Canada (heavy retail emphasis, consolidated banking system, etc), and to the strength of the Canadian economy.

Having said that, we believe that it will be difficult to have much more multiple expansion when global financials are in turmoil. As we show in the chart below, Canadian banks now trade at a 40% premium to U.S. bank stocks on a P/BV basis. We believe that Canadian ROEs are sustainably better than their U.S. peers; we just aren't sure if they are sustainably 40% better. Remember that U.S. banks have some potential for consolidation whereas Canadian banks have lived in a world of 'no mergers' for several years.

Conclusion

Essentially, we are saying that Canadian banks will probably continue to beat their global peers, but are unlikely to beat the TSX overall, particularly if we get the performance we expect from the oil and gold sectors.

None of the issues listed in this report are brand new, although the first two have only surfaced in the past couple of months. We remain confident that banks can deal with them. The issue is that, taken together, they put additional pressure on bank balance sheets. We are downgrading the bank sector to Market Perform and have reduced our share price targets across the board

Canadian banks still derive 60% of earnings from domestic banking and wealth, and have excellent balance sheets and solid dividends. Individual investors should be aware of tax implications of selling bank shares, particularly if the shares have been held for an extended period and the cost base is low.

New target prices:
• BMO $67.00
• CIBC $106.00
• National Bank $56.00
• RBC $58.00
• Scotiabank $53.00
• TD Bank $75.00
__________________________________________________________
Investment Executive, James Langton, 7 September 2007

Canadian financial stocks could be the place to wait out the market’s current turmoil, suggests a new report from UBS Securities Canada Inc.

UBS says that, “the abstruse nature” of the credit crunch issue “means that a definitive all-clear signal is unlikely”. Rather, markets are likely to regain their footing gradually, it says. “What are investors to do in the interim? Our answer is Canadian financials.”

The report says that while Canadian financials have not been immune to the market turmoil, “they still have a very attractive reward/risk profile relative to both the TSX and the S&P 500 financials.”

“Essentially, the credit crunch is a deflationary shock which tends to hurt resources and cyclicals more than financials,” it says. “And importantly, since confidence looks likely to be only gradually restored, the financials should also lead in the early recovery.”

Back in 1998, when markets stumbled in August and floundered throughout much of the fall, resources trailed to the end of the year, UBS recalls. “The 1998 pattern has already been borne out since the July 19 peak, and we expect the recovery phase is a good Plan A until the dimensions of the credit crunch become clearer,” it advises.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, 6 September 2007

In a vote of confidence for profits in the battered financial sector, Desjardins Securities has upgraded Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce to “strong long-term buy” from “buy,” matching the ratings on Royal Bank of Canada, Toronto-Dominion Bank and Bank of Montreal.

The one problem child is National Bank of Canada, which was cut to a “long-term hold.”

Desjardins strategists also say Canada’s major insurers are showing accelerating profitability, prompting upgrades of Manulife Financial Inc. and Great-West Lifeco Inc. to “strong long-term buys” from “long-term buys.”

Power Corp. of Canada and Power Financial Corp. were raised to “long-term holds,” as profitability is now stabilizing, Desjardins predicts.
__________________________________________________________
RBC Capital Markets, 4 September 2007

All six banks reported Q3/07 EPS that were higher than expectations, driven by better than expected wholesale banking earnings and continued strong retail earnings growth.

• It appears that bank trading rooms, broadly speaking, were well positioned to (1) avoid large negative marks to markets that could have occurred on inventory holdings and proprietary trading positions as debt and equity markets weakened in the latter part of July (the banks' quarter end), and (2) many were actually positioned to take advantage of widening credit spreads and interest rate volatility, as evidenced by surprisingly strong fixed income trading revenues for the group.

We expect total returns of 15% from holding bank stocks in the next 12 months, but believe that the price appreciation is likely to come in the latter half of those 12 months.

• We remain concerned that Canadian banks could trade sideways or down in the near term on negative news flow out of world financials, as well as potential earnings disappointments in Q4/07.

• Bank valuations have declined from 13.2x to 11.6x on a NTM P/E basis since the year began. We believe that bank valuations could trade back up to their 5-year average forward multiple of 12.2x if credit conditions remain benign, capital markets stabilize and interest rates do not rise meaningfully.

• If capital markets remain weak and capital market issues become economic issues, we believe there would be further pressure on valuation multiples (and earnings).

TD is our favourite bank stock

• We have an Outperform rating on TD. Domestic retail momentum and higher earnings from the U.S. should drive above-average retail earnings growth for TD. We also believe that there is less downside risk to our earnings forecasts for TD than for the industry as the bank is less exposed to wholesale earnings, and appears to have a more conservative mix of businesses within its wholesale division.

Positive on 12-month outlook for bank stocks; still cautious near term

All six Canadian banks reported Q3/07 EPS that were higher than our expectations (and consensus), driven by better than expected wholesale banking earnings and continued strong retail earnings growth. The release of the banks’ Q3/07 results showed that their trading rooms, broadly speaking, were well positioned to (1) avoid large negative marks to markets that could have occurred on inventory holdings and proprietary trading positions as debt and equity markets weakened in the latter part of July (the banks’ quarter end), and (2) many were actually positioned to take advantage of widening credit spreads and interest rate volatility, as evidenced by surprisingly strong fixed income trading revenues for the group. We were comforted that the banks did not take major hits (two exceptions: the trading revenues of both Bank of Montreal and CIBC were affected by large losses in commodities and U.S. sub-prime securities respectively), although surprises may still spring up as the month of August proved to be even more volatile in equities and interest rates.

We expect total returns of 15% from holding bank stocks in the next 12 months, but believe that the price appreciation is likely to come in the latter half of those 12 months. We remain concerned that Canadian banks could trade sideways or down in the near term on negative news flow out of world financials, as well as potential earnings disappointments in Q4/07. The increased risk aversion seen in capital markets and tightening of liquidity, if it continues, could have a much larger impact on wholesale revenues in Q4/07 than it did Q3/07, in our view. Our positive 12-month outlook is predicated on continued strong growth in retail earnings and a benign credit environment. The biggest risk to our positive outlook is that capital market issues become economic issues; a scenario that our economists do not envision at this time.

Bank valuations have declined from 13.2x to 11.6x on a NTM P/E basis since the year began. We believe that the banks could trade back up to their 5-year average forward multiple of 12.2x if credit conditions remain benign, capital markets stabilize over the next 12 months and interest rates do not rise meaningfully. The 5% increase we expect in valuation multiples, combined with 9% expected earnings growth in 2009, would provide attractive returns for banks’ shareholders over the next 12 months.

If capital markets remain weak and capital market issues become economic issues, we believe there would be pressure on valuation multiples (and earnings). In such an environment, we believe that the 5-year valuation trough of 10.3x is indicative of where banks may trade – an 11% drop in valuation multiples.

Things we like about the Canadian bank stocks:

There are many things that we like about Canadian bank stocks, in spite of our concerns about potential negative surprises and disappointing capital markets revenues in the near term:

• Retail and wealth management businesses are strong;
• Direct exposure to most troubled parts of capital markets appears limited;
• Capital ratios are high;
• Widening credit spreads should eventually create opportunities;
• The interest rate environment is better for bank stocks than it was a few months ago;
• An economic cycle is needed to see trough ROEs; and
• Prior periods of fear for the financial system in the last decade were unfounded.

Retail and wealth management businesses are strong

Retail banking and wealth management businesses continue to perform well, and those generate about 70% of Canadian banks’ earnings. Canadian loan growth remains very strong, and the conditions that have driven the strong loan growth remain in place: employment growth, rising incomes, low interest rates and a solid housing market. The outlook for wealth management growth is heavily influenced by equity markets (the majority of revenues are asset management and brokerage) and, although choppy this summer, Canadian equity markets are up 4.5% year to date.

The negative news flow surrounding financial institutions is mainly centered around capital markets issues, which generates about 30% of earnings for Canadian banks. A spillover of the credit-related issues into equity markets has negative implications for retail wealth management businesses, but the revenue sensitivity of asset management and retail brokerage businesses is lower than capital markets revenues in our view, particularly as banks have all strived to increase the proportion of retail brokerage revenues that are fee-based versus commission-based.

Direct exposure to most troubled parts of capital markets appears limited

The Canadian banks appear to have manageable exposure to the most troublesome areas of capital markets, including U.S. sub-prime mortgages the Canadian third-party asset backed commercial paper market, and LBO underwriting commitments. There are exceptions, which we highlight later in this report, but we think it is still fair to say that the Canadian banks are less exposed to these three areas than many U.S. and European banks, and the Canadian banks’ exposures come in the context of an earnings mix that is dominated by retail banking and wealth management.

Capital ratios are high

Canadian banks have high capital ratios compared to banks in other developed markets, with Tier 1 ratios ranging from 9.3% to 10.2%. Their ability to grow their capital is also quite high, as approximately 70% of their income comes from retail banking and wealth management, two sources of revenues that are not overly capital intensive. We also believe that the banks’ reputation as conservative institutions allows them easier access to liquidity and capital than some other financial institutions.

Widening credit spreads should eventually create opportunities

The repricing of credit risk is likely to create money-making opportunities for well capitalized financial institutions, including the Canadian banks. The current capital markets turbulence and expansion in credit risk spreads will likely create opportunities for trading businesses, it should be a positive for margins in commercial and corporate lending, it should help well-capitalized organizations get higher returns on capital as competition for investments becomes scarcer, and acquisition opportunities may arise. This period of opportunity does, however, typically come after a period of pain in which assets get marked to market, and banks generally are conservative in deploying capital until market conditions show signs of stabilizing. We do not believe that this adjustment period is over.

The interest rate environment is better for bank stocks than it was a few months ago

The interest rate environment has improved for bank stocks in three different ways:

• 10-year Government bond yields have dropped 31 basis points in Canada from their peak of 4.73% on June 12th. There is a very strong inverse correlation between bank P/E ratios and long-term interest rates given their high dividend yields and the beneficial impact of lower interest rates on loan growth and credit quality. RBC Economics expects 10-year Government of Canada bond yields to rise with a target of 5.45% by the end of 2008 so there may be pressure on bank valuations if those estimates prove correct.

• The outlook for short-term rates in Canada has also changed, with the Bank of Canada no longer expected to raise rates in the near term given the volatile capital markets conditions. Rising Bank of Canada rates have historically been negative for bank stocks more often than not so a probable delay in rate hikes is a positive. RBC Economics believes that worries about the spillover from the financial markets into the economy will likely keep the Bank of Canada on the sidelines and have shifted the timing of the next rate hike to the first quarter of 2008 (a change from their previous view of a rate hike by 25 basis points on September 5th) and forecast the overnight rate to rise 75 basis points over the first half of 2008 to 5.25%.

• The steepening yield curve, which resulted from short-term Government securities rallying on a flight to quality, has made the carry trade a possibility again.

An economic cycle is needed to see material reductions in ROE

We are forecasting a median ROE of 21.0% in 2007 for the Canadian banks. Capital markets profitability is clearly at risk of dropping in the near term, but even a drastic decline in wholesale net income – let’s use 50% to illustrate our point – would leave ROEs high. Given that wholesale income accounts for approximately 30% of earnings for the system, a 50% drop in profitability would knock ROEs off by about 3%, leaving them a still high 18%. In order to see ROEs head toward the low teens, we believe that we need to see an economic cycle, which would have negative implications for loan losses and retail loan growth.

Prior periods of fear for the financial system in the last decade were unfounded

The financial system has skated through many incidents that raised concerns over widespread financial market health in the last decade. Examples include the Asian crisis, the Long-Term Capital bailout, a corporate credit loss cycle, Amaranth, 2 major hurricanes in one year, and Argentina’s economic crisis. Those events caused material losses to individual financial market participants but ultimately did not impair the health of the financial services industry.

Risks for Canadian bank stocks have risen

We have a positive view on bank stocks over the next 12 months, but risks to continued strong stock price appreciation are higher than in recent years in our view. We highlight five concerns:

• Illiquidity and rising risk aversion is not an ideal environment for capital markets revenues;
• A lasting credit crunch could lead to economic issues;
• News flow is likely to continue to be negative, with the potential for surprises not over;
• Key earnings drivers of last five years at risk of weakening; and
• Capital ratios could decline, albeit from high levels.

Illiquidity and rising risk aversion is not an ideal environment for capital markets revenues

We believe that Q3/07 wholesale banking results were not indicative of the deterioration in revenues that could occur in the next few quarters. The Canadian banks reported strong wholesale earnings in Q3/07, continuing on a trend that has seen those divisions exceed expectations. The Canadian banks appear to have manageable exposure to the most troublesome areas of capital markets but, we still feel that their wholesale income is likely to decline in the next two quarters and, if liquidity problems become economic problems, possibly longer.

• Trading revenues were strong in Q3/07 but the quarter ended in July, and August saw more volatility and credit spread widening. Liquidity also became scarcer in August.

• Q3/07 benefited from strong M&A and underwriting revenues but the outlook for new assignments is on hold in our view. The closing of previously announced deal may mask underlying weakness in new originations in the near term.

• Liquidity should improve but it may not be as high as it was before the summer. Following sharp increases in credit spreads, liquidity typically returns as spreads stabilize; buyers emerge as that they stop believing price will get better and sellers get over sticker shock. The concern we have, however, is that a good portion of the liquidity of recent years came from highly levered strategies and is unlikely to come back in the near term. This includes “short low risk, buy high risk” and “fund short, invest long” strategies, that led to the development of Structured Investment Vehicles and risky ABCP structures, highly levered hedge funds, rapidly growing private equity funds and, most likely, more levered proprietary trading desks looking to replicate strategies that were successful for clients.

A lasting credit crunch could lead to economic issues

The most negative environment for bank stocks would be continued weakness in capital markets, and a weaker economic environment. Our outlook for the banks does not assume a recession, which is in line with our economists' outlook, which believe that the impact of rising defaults in the U.S. sub-prime mortgage market will not have a crippling impact on the broader economy. Our concern is that if liquidity continues to be a concern and credit availability is restrained for an extended period as a result of financial institutions’ concerns over their and others’ exposure to U.S. sub-prime real estate and/or levered credit investing strategies, it would have a negative impact on the economy. If the economy turned sour, it would accelerate the long-expected normalization of credit losses and the argument that the current risks facing banks are isolated to capital markets businesses would be out the window. We believe that such a scenario would have negative implications for both bank profitability and valuation multiples.

Capital ratios could decline, albeit from high levels

We believe that there is a risk that the Canadian banks’ Tier 1 ratios could decline from their high levels as:

• Banks could potentially bring on balance sheet some of their asset backed commercial paper conduits. They may do so by choice in Canada as the spreads over bankers acceptances are high enough that it does not make sense, in our view, for the banks to fund themselves in that market while spreads remain this high. If the commercial paper market remains tight, it is also possible that some of the conduits to which that the banks provide liquidity backstops would tap these lines.

• If credit spreads widen further, corporations may hold off on issuing debt and tap existing credit lines for funding needs.

It is important to point out that banks would generate additional net interest income as a result of adding assets to their balance sheets, and they would have adequate capital to fund those assets. The impact on ROE would depend on the mix of assets – banks putting retail mortgages on their balance sheets would not see their capital usage go up as much as if business lending suddenly soared. Even if all bank backstop liquidity facilities (i.e. including U.S. Commercial Paper programs) were fully drawn, the banks would have enough capital to handle those assets coming on their balance sheets, although funding those assets may be challenging.

News flow is likely to continue to be negative, with the potential for surprises not over

We are concerned about news flow out of financials because:

• There is still no or very little liquidity for many structured finance assets, most of which have not been marked to market and many of the esoteric structures have not traded, U.S. subprime mortgage delinquency rates are likely to increase as interest rate resets take effect, and there are still many LBO loans that are waiting to be distributed. The risk of downgrades in certain CDO tranches also introduces the risk of selling by investors with strict requirements on the types of risk they may own. If those investors drive down the price of certain assets, it may force others to mark their portfolios lower, which can cause major issues with levered investors.

• We realize that those issues are less material for Canadian banks than many U.S. and European ones, but we doubt Canadian bank stocks will perform well if negative news flow leads to weaker share prices for financial institutions worldwide.

• It is not inconceivable that there could be more large funds or institutions that run into financial difficulties, in which case markets are likely to push down valuations of worldwide financials.

• Equity markets (and Canadian banks) have also rebounded solidly since mid-August, partly on the expectation that the Fed is likely to cut rates in September. No action by the Fed would be negative for equity markets, in our view, while the expected action probably would not drive much more upside.

The Canadian banks appear to have manageable exposure to the most troublesome areas of capital markets, although that is not to say they are not exposed at all:

• National Bank is most exposed to the challenged third party ABCP market in Canada. In our view the risks are as follows:

o The bank will be exposed to credit risk as it is well on its way to repurchasing approximately $2.0 billion in ABCP from its mutual funds and retail customers. The bank is relying on DBRS in its assessment of the credit quality of the underlying assets at this point, and had the following to add in its Q3/07 press release: "At this time, the Bank can not quantify the financial impact, if any, of these initiatives mainly for two reasons. First, most of such ABCP has been issued by non-bank sponsored conduits which are subject to a restructuring proposal, which is at a very formative stage and the outcome of which could have a material effect on the value of such ABCP. Second, there is insufficient information available about the current value of the assets which underlie the ABCP being purchased and about any other contingent liabilities which may exist. The magnitude of the sums involved and the uncertainties referred to above could give rise to a material charge to the Bank's earnings. The Bank will address this issue when it publishes the fourth quarter results for fiscal 2007."

o Quantifying the damage to the bank's reputation is near impossible, but the impact is nonetheless meaningful in our view. Commercial and corporate clients that bought ABCP via National Bank face an extension of term and/or losses given that the purchase of ABCP by National Bank covers only holdings of under $2.0 million. This will undoubtedly disappoint some of the bank's clients, and may lead to lost business.

o The bank may provide credit lines to commercial and corporate customers whose cash balances were negatively impacted by the developments in the ABCP world. This may also add to the bank's credit risk, depending on the creditworthiness of the customers. The bank cited on its Q3/07 call that the liquidity advances have been done on normal banking terms and that it has not changed its underwriting criteria.

o Legal risk also arises, as some clients may seek recourse in the courts over their holdings in ABCP.

o Capital flexibility will likely be reduced. The bank's capital position is strong, with a Tier 1 ratio of 9.4%. The purchase of $2.0 billion in ABCP will lower the Tier 1 ratio by 0.35%, but the potential capital drag from providing liquidity lines is unknown.

• CIBC appears most directly exposed to weakness in the U.S. residential mortgage market.

o The bank incurred a loss of $290 million in Q3/07 due to the impact of mark-to-market write-downs, net of gains on related hedges, on collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) and residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) related to the U.S. residential mortgage market.

o The bank also estimates approximately $90 million in further CDO and RMBS markdowns in August.

o CIBC's exposure to the U.S. residential mortgage market before write-downs is approximately US$1.7 billion, invested in 5 or 6 structures, and is entirely held in a mark-to-market book. The bank has sub-prime index hedges of approximately US$300 million.

• TD has underwritten $3.3 billion of a $34.3 billion credit facility and provided a $500 million equity bridge facility to a group of institutional investors led by Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan Board in support of their bid to acquire BCE. The banks have mostly adopted “underwrite and distribute” philosophies in the last five years. In a rising credit spread environment, the risk of taking losses after having committed financing but before distributing the loan/debt rises. Banks can avoid near-term losses by holding onto loans, but at a cost of increased concentration risk. The bank’s $3.8 billion in commitments represent only 0.9% of assets but 34% of net tangible common equity.

• Royal Bank is exposed to headline risk as it is a more active participant in the U.S. than its peers. The bank has $1.1 billion in U.S. subprime RMBS and CDOs, a manageable amount relative to the bank’s asset base but nonetheless a sign of potential negative headlines if that market witnesses further deterioration.

• BMO manages two Structured Investment Vehicles in the UK, with assets totaling about $30 billion. Leverage in those conduits is about 10 to 1 (low by industry standards), there is essentially no exposure to U.S. subprime securities, and underlying assets are 100% investment grade, 88% of which are AA or better. Both conduits are self-funding at this time, and the bank's financial exposure appears limited to a $76 million equity interest and letters of credit and commitments to extend credit of $184 million (as at October 31, 2006). Unlike the asset backed commercial paper market, liquidity backstop lines are limited in the SIV market. The bank's risk is therefore more reputational if the SIVs face funding (or credit) issues, although the structure of the assets in the two SIVs (no U.S. sub prime) and use of leverage (which can be as high as 70 times) appears conservative compared to more aggressive structures.

Key earnings drivers of last five years likely to weaken

We believe that banks’ EPS growth is set to slow. The Canadian banks have had an excellent track record of earnings growth since the credit cycle of the early part of this decade, growing EPS at double-digit rates as a group since then. The major drivers have been: strong retail loan growth, declining provisions for credit losses, the positive impact of very strong equity markets on wealth management businesses and capital markets revenues that were fueled by high liquidity (some of which came from added leverage).

As we look out over the next two years, it is difficult to anticipate those earnings growth contributors being as strong

TD is our favourite bank stock

Our investment ratings are unchanged from our view going into the quarter:

• We have an Outperform rating on TD. Domestic retail momentum and higher earnings from the U.S. (driven by cost synergies at TD Ameritrade, and by higher ownership of TD Banknorth) should drive above-average retail earnings growth for TD. We also believe that there is less downside risk to our earnings forecasts for TD than for the industry as the bank is less exposed to wholesale earnings, and appears to have a more conservative mix of businesses within its wholesale division. TD trades at 11.8x 2008E EPS, compared to a group median of 11.5x.

• We have an Outperform rating on CIBC shares because of (1) the potential for further material increases in dividends; (2) lower exposure to wholesale income and deteriorating business credit quality; (3) tight expense management, which leaves room for upside earnings surprises in our view; and (4) our expectations for improved retail revenue growth. Exposure to U.S. sub-prime securities is a risk if there is further deterioration in that market. CIBC trades at 10.9x 2008E EPS, compared to a group median of 11.5x.

• We believe that Royal Bank’s stock is attractive given: (1) leading, and rapidly growing retail banking and wealth management franchises; (2) a more diversified capital markets business, which should lead to lower volatility in revenue and earnings than some of the other Canadian banks' investment dealers; and (3) A superior outlook for near-term revenue growth, driven by a 15% increase in risk weighted assets in the last twelve months, a result of organic growth and acquisitions. Royal Bank trades at 11.8x 2008E EPS, compared to a group median of 11.5x.

• We have a Sector Perform rating on Scotiabank. We believe that the bank has above-average medium- and long-term growth prospects compared to its peers due to its presence in Latin America and the Caribbean. Near-term revenue growth should also benefit from a 16% increase in risk weighted assets in the last 12 months. We are concerned, however, that bank's 0.5x P/E premium could narrow because (1) the high Canadian dollar hurts the bank more than its peers; (2) rising risk aversion could affect the multiple paid on earnings from emerging markets; and (3) we believe that net income for Scotiabank's key Mexican division may disappoint in the near term. Scotiabank trades at 12.0x 2008E EPS, compared to a group median of 11.5x.

• We continue to believe that Bank of Montreal's stock is likely to underperform those of Canadian peers. (1) We believe that BMO will struggle to bring its domestic retail revenue growth up to the industry's leading banks at the same time as it embarks on cost cutting initiatives; (2) We expect slower dividend and earnings growth; and (3) The bank derives a higher proportion of earnings from wholesale banking. To be clear, our Underperform argument is relative; our 12-month target price of $69 is 6% higher than the current stock price, and the stock's dividend yield is 4.3%. Bank of Montreal trades at 11.2x 2008E EPS, compared to a group median of 11.5x.

• We rate National Bank’s shares as Underperform. The bank trades at the lowest multiple of the 6 Canadian banks but (1) we expect slower retail earnings growth; (2) there is significant uncertainty related to the ultimate outcome of the bank's ABCP-related challenges; and (3) the bank is has greater reliance on wholesale markets as a percentage of total income. The two major risks to our rating would be (1) a rapid and favourable resolution to ABCP challenges; and/or (2) improving relative retail revenue and earnings growth. In both cases, a clarity is unlikely in the near term. National Bank trades at 9.7x 2008E EPS, compared to a group median of 11.5x.
__________________________________________________________
;

11 September 2007

Scotia Capital’s Financials Summit

  
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins, 11 September 2007

The chief executive officers of Canada's big banks weighed in on the rocky state of financial markets Tuesday, with the heads of two of the top banks suggesting the turmoil is far from over.

The financial system is going through a necessary cleansing because people did some “stupid things,” and it could be spring before the markets complete the adjustment, said Toronto-Dominion Bank chief executive officer Ed Clark.

“You've just got to fasten your seatbelts, we're going for a ride here for the next three or four months,” he told banking analysts and investors at a conference in Toronto Tuesday, where all of the big bank CEOs spoke.

There are more shoes to drop because the market has not been transparent, Mr. Clark said.

“The reality is, I think it's going to be quite ugly in the next few months,” and the market will reel back, he said.

But that's a good thing, “because if people do stupid things and don't pay a price for it, you don't run a good market system, and you've got to cleanse this out.”

Mr. Clark's hoping that most of the repricing that must take place in securities that are related to U.S. mortgages will be done with by March.

“I think people haven't gone to confession yet,” Mr. Clark said. “Your gut is telling you there's a lot of stuff to come out in the marketplace.”

Gordon Nixon, chief executive officer of Royal Bank of Canada, also said he expects it will take some time before market conditions return to normal.

And he warned that, when it comes to the Canadian asset-backed commercial paper market, “it may get worse before it gets better.”

Bank of Nova Scotia chief executive officer Rick Waugh injected a positive note into the conference by saying he does not believe there will be a recession either globally or in the United States, and “certainly not in Canada.”

“Liquidity has to be repriced and has to be reallocated, and this will require some adjustment and in some cases some significant adjustment. But I believe these can be made successfully by the global markets and by most financial institutions,” Mr. Waugh said.

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce chief executive officer Gerald McCaughey noted that the problems have been widespread and said the markets are now at a turning point because policy decisions are being made, which is when they tend to work themselves out, he said.

The main financial headache in the Canadian system has been the problems in the $35-billion market for asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) that is not sponsored by the big banks.

That market is now essentially frozen as a number of its major participants attempt to hammer out a plan to restructure it.

The larger market for bank-sponsored ABCP – which is roughly three times the size of the non-bank market – is still functioning, but not as smoothly as it did prior to the chaos that erupted in August.

Bank of Montreal chief executive officer Bill Downe said he's seen an improvement in the tone of the ABCP market in the last week.

In a separate conference call Tuesday, Peter Routledge, a senior credit officer at Moody's Investors Service Inc., said spreads for Canadian ABCP appear to have widened to 50 to 60 basis points above the banker's acceptance rate. Before all of this market turmoil began, the normal spreads were below 10 basis points.

ABCP is commercial paper that's backed by big packages of loans, ranging from credit card debts to mortgages.

Those loans are pooled together and bought by trusts that fund them by issuing short-term commercial paper.

Because the vast majority of the loan pools, or assets, underlying the bank-sponsored ABCP remain relatively healthy, there's limited risk that their value will take any sizable hit, Moody's said.

Tuesday, the group of financial institutions that are working to come up with a restructuring plan for the non-bank ABCP market said a data room containing information about many of the trusts will be open to ABCP investors beginning today.

Parties who signed the proposal, which was released in mid-August, agreed that investors would not try to take their money out of ABCP trusts and that the trusts would not ask their banks for emergency loans for a 60-day period. After that, the plan calls for the commercial paper to be turned into longer-term debt instruments called floating-rate notes.
__________________________________________________________
Investment Executive , 11 September 2007

BMO Financial Group is focusing more sharply on customer service and growth in its core businesses, said president and CEO Bill Downe at Scotia Capital’s Financials Summit 2007 conference on Tuesday.

BMO’s Canadian personal and commercial banking business posted record earnings of $350 million in the third quarter, up 14% over a year ago, excluding the IPO gain related to MasterCard International and tax recoveries. Cash productivity was 53.3% — also a record. Year-over-year, revenue in commercial banking grew almost 7%, loans grew 7.7%, and deposits grew 9.6% as share increased strongly for the second quarter in a row, rising 56 basis points year-over-year.

Downe noted that BMO’s emphasis on branch-originated sales is paying-off in its cards business, where core revenues grew 13% year-over-year. Year to date, BMO has seen new cardholders rise by 40% and the number of applications coming from the branches has increased by 118%. Downe said BMO is looking for the best way to distribute other products through its branches. “In our mortgage business, we exited the broker channel, which has low spread and fewer cross-sell opportunities. We are hiring more mortgage specialists. We expect to increase volumes and regain lost share - but with a much higher margin.”

Commenting on the major management renewal of BMO’s Canadian retail banking arm, Downe said: “The new executive team has considerable line experience, and throughout the organization, managers are closer to the customers, and decision-making is closer to the front line. More than a third of the 28 district heads are new appointments.”

As for the performance of the Private Client Group, Downe stated, “The Private Client Group is delivering outstanding results. PCG’s efficiency is top decile, with a cash productivity ratio of 68.4%.”

BMO Capital Markets reported net income of $196 million in the third quarter. “Excluding the impact of the commodities losses, these are exceptional results,” Downe said. Adjusted for those losses, earnings grew 45% from a year ago to $293 million.

BMO’s U.S. personal and commercial arm, Chicago-based Harris Bank, has averaging acquisition integration expenses of between $4 million and $6 million for the past three quarters; but without those expenses, Q1, Q2, and Q3 of this year generated consecutive growth in earnings — up 19% from Q4, 2006.

“We have a very strong franchise here with an enviable network of high quality locations, strong customer satisfaction and loyalty scores, and a breadth of service beyond the reach of smaller competitors. We see real opportunity in business banking. We can gain real leverage as we add more branches to our network,” Downe noted.

In referring to comments by U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, who stated in a recent speech that delinquency rates for sub-prime mortgages with adjustable rates rose to about 13.5% in June, Downe stressed, “Harris does not originate sub-prime and has very little direct retail exposure with sub-prime characteristics. Harris’s overall delinquency rate was 0.4% in June.”
__________________________________________________________
Canadian Press, 11 September 2007

The current turmoil in credit markets is “a very good thing,” Toronto-Dominion Bank's Ed Clark declared Tuesday — a position endorsed less floridly by other big-bank chief executive officers who also see opportunity in volatility.

“Time will cure this problem,” Mr. Clark told a financial services industry conference.

“In fact, there were excesses going on. The market was taking risks that I think were not adequately being rewarded.”

He said Canadian banks are “in very good shape” as the U.S. subprime mortgage market crisis plays out.

However, in the wider world “it's going to be quite ugly in the next few months,” Mr. Clark said.

He noted that the housing slump concentrated in seven U.S. states has already hit banks as far afield as Australia and Germany, and “I think people haven't gone to confession yet.”

Meanwhile, investors “are dumping quality assets because they have to” in order to cover losses on low-quality debt.

Still, “This is good, because if people do stupid things and don't pay a price for it, you don't run a good market system — and you've got to cleanse this out.”

Asked how long the cleanout will take, Mr. Clark replied: “I'm sort of hoping that by next March, we're through this.”

In the meantime, banks can expect “some headwinds,” Bank of Montreal CEO Bill Downe told the conference.

However, “market volatility and wider credit spreads may ultimately benefit both our trading business and the corporate loan book,” he added.

“This market presents opportunities for large, well capitalized, well diversified financial institutions,” said Royal Bank of Canada CEO Gordon Nixon.

“Risk is being more appropriately priced, which will positively impact our return on assets in the long term.”

Rick Waugh, CEO of conference organizer Bank of Nova Scotia, advanced a similar sentiment: “We are now starting to get paid appropriately for our credit risk, for our credit risk analysis and for our liquidity.”

TD's Mr. Clark said “I've not seen a situation in the financial services industry quite like this,” as market players struggle to price risk because nobody knows how big the losses will be from the collapse of the U.S. subprime mortgage market, and where the pain will occur.

“Many institutions have exposures here that they haven't really come to grips with,” he said, but the sooner they make their accounts conservative, the sooner the world will be reassured “that the financial institutions are actually quite strong.”

He stressed the solidity of the Canadian commercial paper market, despite last month's seize-up in non-bank asset-backed commercial paper — short-term notes that package mortgages, credit cards and other debts.

Mr. Clark said banks originate $80-billion of the $120-billion Canadian asset-backed commercial paper market, and “the six banks will not let that market go down.”

Although fearful investors now are clinging to government notes and accepting lower returns than they could get from commercial paper, “eventually greed will triumph.”

BMO's Mr. Downe said “the liquidity of the banks has been quite good,” with the vast majority of commercial paper rolling over uneventfully, adding: “We've seen an improvement in the tone of the market in the last week.”

Asked how the banks might profit from the so-called Montreal accord — under which tens of billions of dollars worth of troubled non-bank asset-backed securities are to be converted into floating-rate longer-term notes that normal commercial paper investors won't want — Mr. Nixon said RBC is not involved in this market and “I just don't know the answer to that question.”

The U.S. asset-backed commercial paper market is improving, while in Canada “paper is rolling, but it's tougher,” he said.

“Over time, markets will become rational” and buyers will return to high-quality commercial paper, the RBC chief added. “Now, whether that takes two or three months to work itself out remains to be seen.”

Going forward, “Market and industry conditions are not as favourable as they were,” said Gerry McCaughey, CEO of Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, citing “a shifting of gears going on from a period of very mild pricing of risk, and we're now moving to a more traditional level of the pricing of risk.”

However, “I would expect that the issues will subside,” he said.

As for acquisitions, TD's Mr. Clark said the asking prices for financial services companies “haven't really moved down significantly; we've passed on a number of opportunities recently,” and TD is focused on organic growth.

On the other hand, Mr. Downe said BMO is on the watch for acquisitions in the U.S. Midwest, where its Chicago-based Harris Bankcorp subsidiary is already a significant force.

RBC Centura, based in the southeastern U.S., last week undertook a $1.6-billion (U.S.) takeover of Alabama National BanCorporation, which owns 11 small banks in the region.

However, Mr. Nixon said “there are not a significant number of obvious opportunities” that match Centura's philosophy and geographical focus.

Mr. McCaughey said CIBC's dividend is “still at the lower end of our range” and its share buyback is likely to continue, as “in terms of major acquisitions I don't at the moment see any on the horizon.”

Mr. Waugh stressed Scotiabank's strong capital and liquidity position, saying it remains set to grow after $2.5-billion (Canadian) worth of acquisitions in Latin America and the Caribbean in the last two years, while also picking up Canadian businesses in mortgage brokerage and auto finance, along with the Canadian operations of the National Bank of Greece.

Scotiabank intends to add to its “multiple distribution channels” through wealth management acquisitions in Canada, Mr. Waugh added.

Mr. Downe stressed that Harris Bankcorp “draws its customer base from some of the most desirable segments in the Midwest” and is insulated from the housing-market woes racking U.S. coastal states.

TD, meanwhile, is “transforming the business model” of its Maine-headquartered TD Banknorth subsidiary to reflect the bank's Canadian stress on branch convenience and small-investor wealth management.

At home, “our domestic retail growth prospects are faster than the wholesale prospects,” Mr. Clark said, and all the bank bosses emphasized a commitment to retail customer service, with each striving to, as RBC's Mr. Nixon put it, “differentiate ourself in this area.”
;

BMO Represents ~42% of Guardian Capital's NAV

  
The Globe and Mail, Shirley Won, 11 September 2007

Whither Bank of Montreal stock, so goes shares of Guardian Capital Group Ltd.

Shares of the money manager have been tracking the bank's stock because it has close to five million BMO shares on its books - a holding that represents nearly half of its net asset value (NAV).

And some investment industry folks suggest it could be a less pricey way to play BMO, whose shares yesterday closed at $62.34 on the Toronto Stock Exchange.

Guardian non-voting A shares, which are off its 52-week high of $13.50 in May and have taken a hit recently like other financial service stocks, ended the day $10.82.

"It's a good proxy for BMO," says Jeannine LiChong, a portfolio manager with Gluskin Sheff + Associates Inc.

But Gluskin Sheff - the largest institutional shareholder of Guardian's A shares - owns the stock because it is trading at a substantial discount to an estimated net asset value of about $15 a share, Ms. LiChong said.

Guardian runs institutional money, and also owns a mutual fund dealer.

"If you look at the market value of what they hold in investments, including BMO, that is where the stock is trading at," she said. "Basically, you are getting the investment management and financial advisory business for free."

Toronto-based Guardian acquired its BMO shares in a $180-million stock deal ($36.29 a share) from selling its mutual fund business known as Guardian Group of Funds to the bank.

"Obviously, there would be a tax liability if they were to sell [the shares] so you would have to give some kind of estimate for that as well," Ms. LiChong said in an interview.

Guardian is controlled by its chief executive officer John Christodoulou, who is in his mid-70s. In 2001, BMO began negotiating a deal to buy all of Guardian, but only ended up buying the mutual fund arm. Guardian, however, negotiated a contract to continue running certain funds.

While Guardian has earned a strong reputation for investing in the income trust sector, that avenue of growth has looked less robust after Ottawa announced plans last fall to tax these investments in 2011.

But Ms. LiChong is not concerned, saying the trust sector has been rebounding, and Guardian has been able to manage its way through this unexpected turn of events.

Scotia Capital Inc. analyst Kevin Choquette has a "sector perform" rating on Guardian stock with a one-year target of $14.

BMO represents about 42 per cent of Guardian's net asset value, while its institutional asset business is about 33 per cent, Mr. Choquette wrote in a recent report.

"We view Guardian Capital as a high-quality small-cap financial with steady earnings improvement and relatively high discount to NAV" of about $16, the analyst said.

Guardian's NAV and profit should get a lift from "the bank's expected share price appreciation and dividend increases," Mr. Choquette added.

Both BMO and Guardian's shares prices have "moved hand-in-hand" since Guardian sold its fund arm to the bank, and "a 10 per cent increase in BMO's share price increases Guardian's NAV by approximately 5 per cent," he said

Robert Tattersall, executive vice-president of Howson Tattersall Investment Counsel Ltd., said he has owned Guardian stock for a number of years, and paid an average of $7.50 a share.

"It's one of those stocks that you can think of as having a hidden asset in plain view," said Mr. Tattersall, referring to the BMO holding.

Subtracting the value for BMO, "we are buying an institutional or money management firm with a diverse book of business for a modest valuation," said Mr. Tattersall, a value investor who holds Guardian in Saxon Small Cap and other funds.

Speculation as to whether Guardian will one day transfer BMO stock to its shareholders, and any takeover potential for the company is dependent on Mr. Christodoulou, who controls about half the voting shares. There has long been speculation that he could sell for succession reasons.

But Mr. Tattersall suggested that Mr. Christodoulou is well paid, and appears to be "in no hurry to move on." Last year, the CEO received 85 per cent of the stock options granted by Guardian - that is, 400,000 class A shares - in addition to his pay package of $1.3-million, including a bonus of $700,000.

"We don't control the agenda, and that is one reason why it [Guardian stock] is moderately undervalued," Mr. Tattersall said. "I cannot say it is a screaming buy because the [non-voting A] shareholders are not driving the bus."

By the numbers

Assets under management

at June 30: $17.8-billion.

Major shareholders: John Christodoulou with 49 per cent of voting shares; Joseph Rotman, founder of Clairvest Inc., with 16 per cent; and Rosemary Short, wife of Guardian's founder Norman Short, with 12 per cent.

Largest shareholder of non-voting A shares: Gluskin Sheff + Associates with 10 per cent.

Advisers at Guardian unit, Worldsource Wealth Management: 600

Market value: $431-million
;

07 September 2007

Banks' Commercial Paper Premiums Hit Record

  
Bloomberg, Doug Alexander, 7 September 2007

Bank of Montreal, Royal Bank of Canada and other Canadian banks are paying record interest-rate premiums to get investors to buy their asset-backed commercial paper amid a meltdown in U.S. subprime mortgages.

The rates for the banks' 90-day commercial paper are as much as 5.6 percent, or 60 basis points higher than benchmark rates, said traders and investors including Edward Devlin at Pacific Investment Management Co. The difference, or spread, was about 2 basis points a month ago. A basis point is 0.01 percentage point.

``Markets are simply about greed and fear, and right now they're about fear over greed,'' said Devlin, a portfolio manager at Newport Beach, California-based Pimco, which manages the world's largest bond fund.

The soaring spreads show how the commercial paper crisis has shifted to Canada's banks from non-bank issuers such as Coventree Inc., even though the bank-sponsored funds have almost no investments in U.S. subprime mortgages. The rising rates may erode bank earnings if they're sustained, said Devlin, who helps manage $692.7 billion at Pimco.

``The banks are going to suffer from higher funding costs,'' he said.

Commercial paper spreads widened after Toronto-based Coventree and other non-bank funds, or conduits, failed to roll over most maturing commercial paper in mid-August because investors were concerned about possible links to mortgages made to people with poor credit.

Unlike commercial paper issuers in the U.S. and elsewhere, Canada's non-bank funds were unable to turn to banks for emergency funds to refinance maturing debt. That's because the banks that committed to back these trusts only have to do so in the case of a ``market disruption,'' according to criteria used by rating company DBRS Ltd.

The C$35 billion ($33 billion) market for non-bank paper froze as a result, prompting 10 banks and money managers, including Deutsche Bank AG and Barclays Bank Plc, to convert the paper into longer-term debt.

Canadian banks have said the market for their own paper, which accounts for about two-thirds of the C$120 billion asset- backed market, hasn't stalled, and they've been able to roll over the debt when it comes due.

The banks said their paper is largely backed by investments such as credit-card bills and car loans, instead of subprime loans. The soaring interest rates suggest investors aren't listening, steering clear of all commercial paper, regardless of what assets are backing them.

``No one likes ABCP anywhere right now,'' said Huston Loke, an analyst at DBRS in Toronto. DBRS is the main rating company for asset-backed commercial paper in Canada.

Toronto-Dominion Bank has no subprime investments in its asset-backed commercial paper conduits, said spokesman Simon Townsend. Nor does Royal Bank, spokeswoman Katherine Gay said. Bank of Montreal has no U.S. subprime investments in its Canadian bank-sponsored commercial paper, spokesman Ralph Marranca said. CIBC declined to comment as did Bank of Nova Scotia spokesman Frank Switzer. The five banks are based in Toronto.

``The market has yet to clearly draw distinctions between bank-sponsored and non-bank sponsored programs in Canada,'' Gay said. ``The former does not have the fundamental problems that are causing a drop in market confidence, but can't help but be affected by the general spread widening.''

Bank of Montreal had the biggest market share among Canadian banks in the asset-backed commercial paper market as of June, followed by CIBC, Toronto-Dominion, Royal Bank and Bank of Nova Scotia, according to DBRS.

``Even though the yields are pretty juicy, nobody wants to be left holding the bag even if you've got a very rock-solid program,'' Pimco's Devlin said. Pimco is a unit of Munich-based Allianz SE.

The banking industry ``is not sustainable'' if they're funding at yield spreads 50 basis points above the bankers' acceptance rate, Devlin said. The bankers' acceptance rate is the benchmark for the commercial paper market.

``Banks right now are still caught in the same situation that everyone is, globally, where there's a crunch and anything with any risk on it is looked at with disdain,'' Loke said. ``This has been unprecedented in terms of not only the spread at which things are trading, but also the credit environment.''

Banks ``may be experiencing some losses if they are having to roll over paper and pay rates'' that are unprofitable, Dundee Securities analyst John Aiken said in an interview from Toronto. ``But this is something that is hopefully transitory.''

The 90-day bankers' acceptance rate, which banks charge each other for short-term loans, has also risen to 4.96 percent in Canada, from 4.63 percent on July 3.

Banks that continue issuing asset-backed commercial paper may simply pass on the higher costs by charging more for loans, Aiken said.

``A month from now it may cost you a lot more to get an auto loan, even if there's no change in interest rates,'' he said.

Pimco hasn't been a buyer of bank-sponsored asset-backed commercial paper in Canada, Devlin said.

``Obviously at these levels, they're starting to look more interesting,'' he said.
;

RBC to Buy Alabama National BanCorp

  
BMO Capital Markets, 7 September 2007

Royal Bank announced on September 6 an agreement to purchase Alabama National BanCorporation (ANB), a bank headquartered in Birmingham, Alabama, for US$1.6 billion. Under the terms of the agreement, ANB shareholders will receive US$80 per share of either cash, RBC shares, or a combination of the two. The total consideration will consist of roughly half cash and half stock. The deal is expected to close in early 2008.

The purchase price represents 20x 2007E earnings and 3.1x tangible book value. We expect Royal's Tier 1 ratio to decline by about 30bps. Management anticipates the deal to be accretive to RBC earnings in 2009. We would view this as a reasonable price for a reasonable franchise. According to all reports, the management team is strong.

ANB is the parent company of 11 subsidiary banks. It has 103 branches throughout the U.S. Southeast - 45 in Alabama, 45 in Florida and 13 in Georgia. The bank has assets of US$7.9 billion, and core deposits of US$4.5 billion. Its largest presence is in Alabama, where it has roughly 3.5% deposit market share.

Bit by bit, Royal is cobbling together a medium-sized banking footprint in the Southern U.S. After this acquisition is integrated, RBC Centura will have a branch count to 440 branches and US$33 billion of assets. The pro forma deposit market share positions will be #4 in Alabama (7% share), #6 in North Carolina (4%) and #8 in Georgia (2%). It is clear that Royal still has some distance to cover if it plans to build a leadership position in any of these states.

After a difficult start, the earnings contribution of RBC Centura has been showing solid improvements. Net earnings in the first half of 2007 are about 5% higher than in the same period of 2006, and up 26% from the same period of 2005. Needless to say, the environment in 2007 has been very challenging so this is a very respectable result.

We continue to recommend RY shares. The bank's success in the U.S. has been limited, but it is clear that given the strength of the Canadian dollar and the valuation premium that is currently afforded to Canadian bank shares, RY is far better positioned to build now than it has been in the past. The U.S. operation still only produces 6% of overall earnings, and can best be described as a 'free option' in RY shares. The attractiveness of the stock is principally driven by the strength of the domestic retail and wealth management franchises.
__________________________________________________________
Scotia Capital, 7 September 2007

RBC Centura to Acquire Alabama National BanCorp for US$1.6 Billion

• RY announced that it intends to acquire Alabama National BanCorporation (ANB) through RBC Centura (RBCC) for US$1.6 billion or US$80 per ANB share with consideration expected to be 50% cash and 50% RY shares. The transaction is expected to close in early 2008 and be accretive to RY's earnings in fiscal 2009.

• ANB has 45 locations in Alabama including locations in the attractive market of Birmingham, 45 locations in Florida, the majority along the Gulf and 13 in Georgia. As of June 30, 2007, ANB had loans of US$5.7 billion, deposits of US$5.8 billion (core deposits of US$4.5 billion) and assets of US$7.9 billion.

ANB Acquisition - Positive Strategic Fit

• RBCC's acquisition of Alabama National Bancorporation (ANB) is positive strategically as it expands the banks' distribution platform by 30% which is critical to generating higher returns from RY's U.S. retail platform. This acquisition doubles the banks' branch network in Florida and Alabama and increases its presence in Georgia by 24%.

• The addition of 103 branches and 124 ATMs from ANB brings RBCC's network up to 440 locations with 85 locations in Alabama, 89 locations in Florida and 68 in Georgia. This acquisition brings RBCC deposit market share in Alabama to 4th, Georgia 8th (Atlanta 6th) and 17th in Florida. Total RBCC assets would be approximately US$33 billion.

• RBCC hopes this acquisition will allow it to leverage its infrastructure, new front-end technologies and product and service capabilities. RBCC also plans to maintain local market expertise and customer service models and the appropriate local autonomy with centralized processing capabilities.

Cost Savings

• We guesstimate the cost synergies to be approximately 20% on ANB's cost base or US$37 million.

Valuation

• The purchase price of US$80 per ANB share was a hefty 50% premium to the closing price of US$53 on September 5, 2007 but a more modest 8% premium to its year high of US$74.15 on February 21, 2007.

• We believe the bank paid a relatively high price in the context of the current environment with the purchase price at 19.8x 2007 consensus estimate of US$4.04 per share, 3.0x price to tangible book value and a 25% core deposit premium.

• If we made the presumption that US$60 or 15.0x EPS would have been a very attractive price, representing a 13% premium, the bank would have overpaid by US$400 million or $0.33 per RY share.

• The bank paid up based on scarcity value and strategic fit and if properly executed we expect that the deal will enhance shareholder value.

Deal Size

• RY acquisition of ANB at US$1.6 billion represents 2.4% of RY's market capitalization similar to BNS's recent acquisition of Banco del Desarollo in Chile for US$1.03 billion (including minority) at 2.1% of market capitalization.

Recommendation

• We view this acquisition as positive and believe it should enhance shareholder return from RY's U.S. business longer term. Maintain 1-Sector Outperform.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Tavia Grant, 7 September 2007

Royal Bank of Canada has pulled off its second-largest acquisition in the U.S., bolstering its presence in the Southeast just as parts of the region's real estate woes are deepening.

Canada's biggest bank is paying $1.6-billion (U.S.) in cash and stock for Alabama National Bancorporation, a 51-per-cent premium over Wednesday's closing share price. The move will double RBC Centura's locations in Alabama, triple its business in Florida and add to its presence in Georgia, boosting RBC's total U.S. banking centres by a third.

RBC and other Canadian banks, prevented from domestic mergers, have been aggressively expanding their footprint abroad. RBC's plan to boost its exposure in the Southeast, however, means increased exposure to areas facing rising foreclosures and falling house prices, especially in Florida.

"It's definitely an area that's under stress in the short term but over the long term it's probably likely that [Alabama National] is able to weather it without real significant losses," said Kevin Fitzsimmons, managing director of New York-based Sandler O'Neill & Partners, who covers the U.S. bank.

He figures about 35 per cent of Alabama National's loans are construction-related and another 25 per cent are in commercial real estate in Florida or Alabama, areas that have seen loan growth slow and credit quality deteriorate. The rate of U.S. home loans in foreclosure hit a record in the second quarter, with Florida one of the hardest hit states, a Mortgage Bankers' Association survey showed yesterday.

That's not deterring RBC, which is betting that attractive demographics and sound economies in the region will outweigh shorter-term market troubles.

"I think the portfolios will stand the test of a little bit of a market downturn," said Scott Custer, chairman and chief executive officer of Raleigh, N.C.-based RBC Centura, in an interview.

"This company has demonstrated over the past years that they have got a great credit culture and a very sound and solid loan portfolio," Mr. Custer said.

"And they have shied away from the high-risk type lending that some others have gotten in trouble with there."

Birmingham-based Alabama National is the parent of 11 banks and has assets of about $8-billion.

The bank's net loan losses crept above its historical average in the first half of this year, prompting it to take a $2.48-million charge in the second quarter.

Mr. Custer said he got acquainted with Alabama National's management earlier this year while finalizing a separate deal to buy 39 branches from AmSouth Bancorp. in Alabama. He expects to keep Alabama National's management team in place and maintain its customer base.

RBC Centura expects the move will boost revenue growth in the near term and add to RBC earnings in 2009.

This is RBC's largest acquisition in six years and one of its biggest ever after it bought Centura Banks for $2.2-billion in 2001.

And while a 51-per-cent premium seems hefty, it's in line with similar deals of that size, said a U.S. analyst, who believes a competing bid is unlikely to emerge.

Fears of exposure to residential real estate construction in the Florida and metropolitan Atlanta markets mean "that could potentially dissuade some other potential buyers from making a bid run," said Adam Barkstrom, an analyst at Sterne Agee who last month cut his estimates for the company.

RBC isn't the only Canadian bank on the prowl, given the strength of the Canadian dollar. Rival Bank of Nova Scotia last week boosted its South American presence through the $1.03-billion purchase of Banco del Desarrollo in Chile. And Toronto-Dominion Bank has been expanding in the U.S. Northeast.

Yesterday's deal, which will see RBC Centura swell to about 440 locations in the region, is expected to close early next year if no hiccups arise. Half of the purchase will be financed through cash and the other half through RBC shares.

There won't likely be "significant branch consolidation" though some jobs may be affected, Alabama National said in a Securities and Exchange Commission filing yesterday.
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, Duncan Mavin, 6 September 2007

While other banks are running for cover from the U.S. mortgage maelstrom, Royal Bank of Canada is jumping into the eye of the storm, announcing yesterday it is spending US$1.6-billion to boost its banking operations in the Deep South.

Canada's biggest bank said it has netted Alabama National Bancorporation (ANB), doubling the presence of its U.S. re-tail-banking subsidiary, RBC Centura, in Florida and Alabama, and adding about 25% to its branch network in Georgia.

RBC is paying US$80 a share for the bank, which has assets of US$7.9-billion and will bring Raleigh, N.C.-based Centura's total assets to more than US$33-billion.

At first blush, the price paid by RBC looks high. ANB's stock was trading at US$53.12 before the deal was announced and RBC's offer represents a premium of more than 50% at a time when the U.S. banking sector is in trouble.

ANB's US$5.7-billion loan book is heavily weighted toward residential mortgages and construction. About 46% of its loans are in Florida, one of the states worst-hit by a steep decline in the housing market that has sparked widespread mortgage-related panic.

However, Scott Custer, RBC Centura chief executive, said the price is fair and ANB represents good long-term potential despite the current market turmoil.

Adam Barkstrom, an analyst at Sterne, Agee and Leach Co. in Birmingham, Ala., says the transaction is a positive one for RBC.

ANB is "very, very conservative on the credit side," and its stock has been overly punished by investors spooked by the wider mortgage crisis, Mr. Barkstrom said.

Also, the deal values ANB at a lower price compared to its earnings than the average price other banks have paid for similar acquisitions in the region in the past two years, he added.

Another positive is that RBC will acquire a "very, very strong" management team, Mr. Barkstrom said.

"RBC has been fairly aggressively expanding in the South East and they've got this stuff all over this place but no management. To a large degree, with ANB they are buying management," he said.

RBC has bolstered the RBC Centura franchise with a number of smaller acquisitions over the past 12 months.

In a deal announced last November, the bank bought 39 branches with about US$1.5-billion in loans formerly belonging to AmSouth Bancorporation in Alabama.

In August, 2006, RBC Centura also bought Flag Financial Corp. -- a 17-branch operation located in metropolitan Atlanta, and central and western areas of Georgia.

The ANB deal marks a much bigger step and is one of the largest acquisitions in RBC's history.

The purchase of Centura in 2001 was the bank's largest at US$2.2-billion. RBC also paid US$1.2-billion for Dain Rauscher in 2000.

The purchase of ANB will add 103 branches to the RBC Centura network, bringing its total presence to more than 440 branches.

It will likely take 12 to 24 months to integrate ANB into the Centura network, Mr. Custer said. RBC Centura will keep the ANB management team in place after the transaction closes in early 2008, he added.

The Centura chief said it is tough to forecast whether the mortgage crisis will slash the valuations of regional U.S. banks leading to further acquisition opportunities.

"It's hard for me to know if things are ever going to get cheaper," he said. "You just have to be opportunistic."
RBC Centura Expansion:

    2001 Acquired by RBC; banking subsidiary renamed RBC Centura.
    2002 Acquires Eagle Bancshares
    2003 Acquires Provident Financial Group
    2003 Acquires Admiralty Bancorp
    2004 Closed 38 branches, opened 21
    2005 Closed 19 branches, opened 8
    2006 Acquires Flag Financial
    2007 Acquires 39 AmSouth branches
    2007 Acquires Alabama National Bank
    Total 440 branches
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, Doug Alexander and Sean B. Pasternak, 6 September 2007

Royal Bank of Canada, the country's largest lender, agreed to buy Alabama National BanCorp. for $1.6 billion in cash and stock in its biggest acquisition since expanding into U.S. consumer banking six years ago.

Royal Bank offered $80 a share, or 51 percent more than Alabama National's share price yesterday. The Birmingham-based bank has 103 branches in Alabama, Florida and Georgia, and would increase Royal Bank's U.S. outlets by about a third, the banks said today in a statement.

Canadian banks, barred from merging at home, are taking advantage of a stronger dollar to step up acquisitions abroad. Royal Bank bought Atlanta-based Flag Financial Corp. in December for $433.5 million, and added 39 branches in Alabama from AmSouth Bancorp. Bank of Nova Scotia, the second-biggest bank, agreed last week to buy Chile's Banco del Desarrollo for about $1.03 billion.

``The money's there, the acquisition opportunities are potentially there,'' said Jacob Jegher, an analyst at Boston- based research firm Celent. ``It would not surprise me to see other large acquisitions by these banks.''

Royal Bank shares fell 4 cents to C$53.96 at 4:10 p.m. on the Toronto Stock Exchange. Alabama National rose $23.98, or 45 percent, to $77.10 on the Nasdaq Stock Market.

Royal Bank offered cash, stock or a combination of both, the Toronto-based bank said. The transaction, scheduled to close early next year, will make a ``significant'' contribution to revenue growth at RBC Centura, as the Raleigh-based U.S. consumer bank is called, and add to earnings in 2009, the bank said.

``They're basically going to go full-force ahead with the Southeast,'' CIBC World Markets analyst Darko Mihelic said today in an interview. ``There's probably more to come, especially if the weakness in the markets continues and the Canadian dollar stays where it is.''

Royal Bank is paying about 1.9 times the net assets, or book value, of Alabama National, in line with recent U.S. bank purchases, said John Aiken, an analyst at Dundee Securities Corp. in Toronto. It will be the bank's largest purchase since the $2.16 billion takeover of Centura Banks Inc. in 2001.

``This is another step along the path of progress that we're trying to make in building a southeastern regional bank,'' said Scott Custer, chief executive officer of RBC Centura, in an interview.

Royal Bank has increased the pace of acquisitions after slowing purchases in 2004 when losses in the U.S. led to the company's first annual profit decline in four years. The Canadian dollar has gained 23 percent against the U.S. currency the past three years, making foreign purchases cheaper.

In response to the profit slump, the lender cut about 500 U.S. jobs and sold a money-losing mortgage business. Earnings from U.S. and international banking climbed 6.1 percent to C$87 million ($83 million) in the third-quarter this year, the highest in at least nine quarters.

Alabama National has 11 bank units with 103 banking centers, eight mortgage and loan offices and 124 automated teller machines. The bank has $7.9 billion in assets, deposit balances of $5.8 billion and loans of $5.7 billion, Royal Bank said. Profit rose 20 percent last year to $79.8 million.

Alabama National was approached by Royal Bank, and said there won't be ``significant branch consolidation'' as a result of the takeover, according to a filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.

The Alabama bank declined to say how many jobs will be affected. Alabama National has 1,900 full-time employees and about 200,000 customers, according to Royal Bank's Web site. With the purchase, Royal Bank will rank fourth in Alabama for deposits, eighth in Georgia and 17th in Florida.
__________________________________________________________
Reuters, Lynne Olver,6 September 2007

"If you look at our franchise, we're in six states in the Southeast and this company was in three of those states," RBC Centura's chief executive and chairman, Scott Custer, said in an interview. "It significantly expands us and gives us management depth."

Amid concerns about the U.S. housing market, Custer told Reuters that the credit quality of Alabama National's real estate portfolio is "excellent," and he said neither Centura nor Alabama National had any exposure to subprime mortgages.

"We're very comfortable with the current state and the future prospects for the loan portfolio," he said.

There will be some efficiencies through branch consolidations and head-office cost savings, Custer said.

With the purchase, RBC Centura will nearly double its branch locations in Alabama and Florida, and will be a bigger player in Atlanta, Georgia.

RBC Centura will become the fourth-largest bank by market share in Alabama, with a 6.4 percent chunk of the market, after Regions Financial Corp , Wachovia Corp and Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA, according to research firm SNL Financial.

The research firm noted that RBC Centura will also rise to eighth-largest in the Georgia market, and becomes the 16th largest bank by market share in Florida, where many retired Canadians spend their winters.
__________________________________________________________
Reuters, Lynne Olver,6 September 2007

Royal Bank of Canada subsidiary RBC Centura Inc said on Thursday it has agreed to acquire Alabama National BanCorporation in a $1.6 billion deal that will add to the Canadian bank's presence in the U.S. Southeast.

Royal Bank, which expects the deal to close in early 2008, said Alabama National shareholders may choose to receive $80 per share in cash, Royal Bank shares, or a combination of the two.

The offer price is a 50.6 percent premium to Alabama National's closing share price of $53.12 on Wednesday. Alabama National's stock has traded in a wide range of $49.31 to $74.15 over the past year.

According to Royal Bank, or RBC, the acquisition will add to its earnings in 2009.

Canada's largest bank has been gradually expanding its U.S. assets after it bought Raleigh, North Carolina-based Centura Banks in 2001 for $2.3 billion. Last summer, RBC Centura bought Atlanta, Georgia-based Flag Financial for nearly $456 million, and in March this year it closed the acquisition of 39 Alabama branches from AmSouth Bancorp.

Since Canadian banks are not permitted to do domestic mergers, they have sought to grow by moving into new geographic regions and broadening their range of financial services at home.

Alabama National, based in Birmingham, is the parent of 11 subsidiary banks and affiliated businesses in Alabama, Florida and Georgia.

They offer banking services to individuals and businesses, commercial mortgage services through a division of First American Bank in north-central Alabama, and brokerage services through another First American subsidiary, NBC Securities Inc.

Shares of Alabama National soared 45 percent to $77.01 on Nasdaq by early Thursday afternoon, after rising as high as $77.80. Royal Bank shares slipped 26 Canadian cents, or 0.5 percent, to C$53.74 on the Toronto Stock Exchange.

While the premium may appear high, RBC is offering to pay 1.9 times Alabama National's book value, and a multiple of almost 20 times its 2007 forecast earnings, Dundee Securities analyst John Aiken said in a research note. Those valuations "are essentially in line with other recent acquisitions," he said.

Al Savastano, an analyst at Fox-Pitt Kelton in New York, said that RBC is picking up additional branches in a high-growth area.

"If you're going to pick anywhere in the U.S. to grow, it would be the Southeast, because it's showing the most growth in terms of population," Savastano said.

But Alabama National is not without problems. About two-thirds of its assets are in construction and commercial real estate, including loans to home builders, who have broadly suffered amid the U.S. housing market slump.

"We expect credit quality at Alabama National to perform better than peers, but the company is not immune to the environment," Savastano wrote in a note last week. In the same note, he lowered his 2007 and 2008 earnings estimates for the bank because of expected credit difficulties and lower fee income.

Alabama National's exposure to "a very frothy real estate market in Florida" highlights the risk associated with the transaction, but this is partly mitigated by the U.S. bank's "conservative lending practices," said Genuity Capital Markets analyst Mario Mendonca in a research note.
__________________________________________________________
Canadian Press. Laura Bobak, 6 September 2007

A U.S. subsidiary of Royal Bank of Canada is paying $1.6 billion (U.S.) in cash and stock for Alabama National BanCorporation, the parent of 11 small banks in the southern United States.

The acquisition by RBC Centura Banks of Raleigh, N.C., adds 45 branches in Alabama, 45 in Florida and 13 in Georgia, extending Centura's reach in the fiercely competitive U.S. Southeast.

Under the takeover deal announced Thursday, shareholders of Birmingham, Ala.-based ANB will receive $80 (U.S.) per share in cash or RBC shares, with the total transaction consisting of half cash and half stock.

ANB's 11 subsidiaries have 103 branches, eight loan offices and 124 bank machines.

As of June 30, ANB had assets of $7.9 billion (U.S.). The acquisition will expand RBC Centura to over $33 billion (U.S.) in assets.

The takeover by RBC, Canada's largest bank with assets of $604.6 billion, follows the acquisition of 39 branches from AmSouth Bank in March, which sparked a down-home reaction from a rival bank.

Superior Bancorp erected a billboard in April near an RBC branch in Decatur, Ala., which read "Sweet Home Canada." On the sign, "Canada" was crossed out, replaced by "Alabama," with the annotation: "It didn't sound right to us either."

Although American banks may be taking the Canadian interloper as a serious threat, Mario Mendonca, an analyst with Genuity Capital Markets in Toronto, said the ANB deal is small in the scope of the overall operations of Toronto-based Royal Bank, which earned $1.4 billion in its latest quarter.

"A deal like this, for $1.6 billion, is hardly a replacement for a merger with the Bank of Montreal, for example," Mendonca said in an interview. "It's better than nothing, let's be clear, but it's hardly a replacement for a merger in Canada."

The purchase is reasonably priced at about 20 times earnings, he said.

"There's nothing really outrageously high about that," Mendonca said.

Asked if it's a good time to expand in the U.S., given the turmoil of swelling mortgage defaults, Mendonca said: "As long as you know what you're buying and you're paying an appropriate price, it might be a great time, especially if things are actually getting better from here, but we don't know."

Royal is facing a "super-competitive" American market for deposits and loans, while the real estate market continues softening, he noted.

Another major issue is whether to centralize major credit decisions or give local managers wide discretion, he said. In Canada, most big loan approvals are made in Toronto.

"You lose a little bit of control over your overall portfolio if you give just a bit too much discretion at the branch level," Mendonca said. "So you can do that, but you have to monitor it pretty closely."

The acquisition, slated to close in early 2008 subject to shareholder and regulatory approval, "is expected to make a significant contribution to RBC Centura's revenue growth in the near term and be accretive to RBC earnings in 2009," the Royal stated.

Scott Custer, chairman and CEO of RBC Centura, said the deal "strengthens our ability to reach more customers in the region by expanding our branch network to more than 440 locations, solidifying our market position in Alabama and opening new and important markets in Florida, and increasing our presence in Atlanta."

The ANB bank units are First American Bank, Alabama Exchange Bank and Bank of Dadeville in Alabama; Indian River National Bank, First Gulf Bank, Florida Choice Bank, Community Bank of Naples, Cypress Coquina Bank and Millennium Bank in Florida; and Georgia State Bank and The Peachtree Bank, both in Atlanta, Ga.
__________________________________________________________
Dow Jones Newswires, 6 September 2007

Royal Bank of Canada's paying a full price for a valuable franchise, Fox-Pitt Kelton says of its $80/share deal for Alabama National (ALAB), one ALAB couldn't refuse. "Given the challenging credit environment that lies ahead, we believe this was an offer that could not be refused," firm says. "Clearly, (ALAB) management recognized the challenges ahead and took advantage of a very attractive offer to maximize value for shareholders."
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, 6 September 2007

Royal Bank of Canada’s acquisition of Alabama National Bancorp is “consistent with long-term strategy but, at this point, is not material to its bottom line,” says Blackmont Capital analyst Brad Smith, adding that the deal will be accretive to earnings by fiscal 2009.

He figures Royal’s deposit market share will rise in Alabama to 6.5 per cent from 3.5 per cent; in Georgia, to 1.9 per cent from 1.4 per cent; and in Florida, to 0.9 per cent from 0.3 per cent.

He kept Royal at a “buy,” with a $65 price target. The stock has been in negative territory all day Thursday and is now down 14 cents at $53.86.
Alabama National has been steady from its opening vault and is quoted at $77.01 (U.S.), up $23.89 or 45 per cent, on the Nasdaq.
;

06 September 2007

Societe Generale Loses Bid to Block RBC Suit

  
Bloomberg, Joe Schneider, 6 September 2007

Societe Generale and Citigroup Inc.'s CitiCapital unit lost a bid to block Royal Bank of Canada's suit to recover C$100 million ($95 million) lost to fraud at a Toronto medical clinic.

The Supreme Court of Canada today denied, without comment, Societe Generale and CitiCapital's requests for a hearing. The banks sought to overturn an Ontario Court of Appeal ruling allowing the suit to go ahead.

The Supreme Court's denial means the case will go to trial Feb. 25, Royal Bank's lawyer, Robert Morris, said in a phone interview. The trial in the Ontario Superior Court is scheduled to take eight weeks, Morris said. ``And the judge said we'd better be finished in those eight weeks,'' Morris said.

Royal Bank, based in Toronto, is attempting to recover money from bank drafts and checks issued to Loren and Roman Koval, former owners of the Kings Health Center, by Societe Generale and CitiCapital from 1994 to 2000. The Kovals had devised a fraud scheme to finance a lavish lifestyle with phony equipment lease contracts.

The proceeds of the equipment-lease fraud at the clinic were deposited at Royal Bank in the form of checks and drafts honored by Societe Generale and CitiCapital. When the fraud was uncovered and the two banks reversed payment, Royal Bank said Societe Generale and CitiCapital were negligent in their dealings with the clinic and didn't have the right to recover the money.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario last year overturned two lower-court rulings dismissing Royal Bank's claims, saying the lower court erred by placing the onus on Royal Bank to prove there was a need for a trial on the issues.

``The onus is always on the moving party to satisfy the court that there is no genuine issue for trial with respect to a claim,'' Judge Stephen Borins wrote for the three-member appeal panel. ``To not interfere with the decision of the motions judge would result in a substantial risk of inconsistent findings.''

Societe Generale issued 49 bank drafts from 1994 to 2000 to finance the clinic's bogus medical equipment. CitiCapital issued five checks to Loren Koval for similar financings. Royal Bank accepted the bank drafts and checks for deposit, and Societe Generale and CitiCapital cleared the transactions, the appeal court said.

CitiCapital and Societe Generale sought to recover the money in 2000, after the fraud came to light and the Kovals fled Canada. Captured in 2001 and sentenced to seven years in prison, they were paroled in 2003. Only $1.29 million of the money they took was recovered.

Royal Bank sued Paris-based Societe Generale and CitiCapital, along with Bank of Montreal, which ``reverse cleared'' CitiCapital's checks. Royal Bank alleged the banks acted improperly in reversing payment. The defendant banks relied on a rule that gives a person on whose behalf a bill is paid the right to recover the amount if the bill contains a forged endorsement.

``SoGen was unaware that it was the victim of Ms. Koval's fraud because, throughout the six years, it never made any inquiries of any `supplier,''' the appeal court said.

Royal Bank is seeking C$80.7 million from Societe Generale and C$8.7 million from CitiCapital and Bank of Montreal, plus damages.

The case is Between Royal Bank of Canada and Societe Generale (Canada), 31880, Supreme Court of Canada (Ottawa).
;

04 September 2007

Power Financial & GDF-Suez

  
The Globe and Mail, Eric Reguly, 4 September 2007

The blockbuster merger of Suez SA and Gaz de France SA, formally announced yesterday, has put Montreal's billionaire Desmarais family at the centre of the world's third-largest power utility.

The family's impeccable investment and political connections paid off: The Desmarais got there with a little help from their friends - Albert Frère, their European partner and agent, and none other than Nicolas Sarkozy, the new President of France.

GDF-Suez, as the new company is to be called, will have a market value of €90-billion - the equivalent of $130-billion - and will count Groupe Bruxelles Lambert (GBL) among its top shareholders. GBL is the Brussels investment company ultimately controlled by the Desmarais family, through their Power Corp. of Canada empire, and Groupe Frère Bourgeois, where Mr. Frère and son Gérald reign supreme.

At last count, GBL held a 9.5-per-cent equity stake, and 13.2 per cent of the votes, in Suez. Those stakes will be diluted by half in the roughly one-for-one share swap merger with Gaz de France. But the enlarged company, which will be 35 per-cent owned by the French state, will have the market and industrial presence to qualify as a "global energy leader," the companies said in a press release.

Suez is one of Europe's biggest sellers and traders of natural gas and electricity. Gaz de France, owned 80 per cent by the French state, is Europe's biggest gas network operator. Together they will have annual revenue of €72-billion. GDF-Suez will rank as Europe's top buyer and seller of gas and will own the continent's biggest gas transmission and distribution businesses. It will be the global leader in liquefied natural gas (LNG), the fastest-growing energy sector.

In the power industry, only OAO Gazprom, the Russian gas producer, and Electricité de France, the state-run operator of 58 nuclear reactors, will be bigger.

Mr. Frère, who is chairman of GBL and vice-chairman of Suez, has been one of the biggest advocates of the Suez-Gaz de France merger. The deal was announced 18 months ago as a defensive measure; the Italian utility Enel had made a hostile offer for Suez (though Suez and Gaz de France had secretly contemplated a union for years). It immediately ran into political and valuation problems and was declared moribund several times.

Politically savvy French investors knew no progress would be made until the May French election was out of the way.

Over the summer, negotiations reopened among Suez, Gaz de France and the Mr. Sarkozy's government. The President reportedly was in favour of the merger but only if Suez were to spin off its hefty environmental arm, whose businesses operate water treatment plants and waste services. The spinoff, resisted by Suez, would reduce Suez's valuation. This would put it roughly on par with Gaz de France's, allowing a true merger of equals.

The Financial Times reported yesterday that a phone call to Mr. Sarkozy from Mr. Frère in the past few days helped to break the impasse. The exact nature of the discussion is not known. But the timing of the merger announcement suggests the phone call and meetings with other key Suez shareholders, including Areva, the French nuclear reactor builder, built momentum for the deal. In the end, Suez, as Mr. Sarkozy wanted, agreed to spin off 65 per cent of the environmental business to Suez shareholders.

Power Corp. was not available for comment on the Labour Day holiday. It is not known whether the Desmarais family got involved in the discussions with the government. Paul Desmarais Sr., the chairman of Power Corp.'s executive committee, and sons Paul Jr. and André know Mr. Sarkozy. The President reportedly has gone to the Desmarais' Charlevoix estate in Quebec for private holidays.

As the family's point man in Europe, it is more likely the Desmarais family let Mr. Frère handle the merger negotiations. Mr. Frère is one of the most powerful businessmen in Europe and has had a close relationship with Paul Sr. since the late 1970s, when the two men each had minority investments in Paribas, a French investment bank. Since then, they have created one of Europe's top industrial holding companies.

GBL has investments valued in the billions of dollars. As of the end of July, they included 3.9 per cent of Total, the French energy giant, 26.3 per cent of Imerys, a minerals processing company, 17.3 per cent of Lafarge, the world's biggest cement and building materials company, and 6.2 per cent of Pernod, the second-biggest wine and spirits business. Last year, GBL had adjusted net assets of €16.7-billion.

The Desmarais and Frère families have ambitious goals as investors and being passive isn't one of them. The stated goal of Pargesa, the holding company directly atop GBL, is the creation of long-term value and "to exercise control, or major influence, over the companies in which the Group holds interests."

Already, there is speculation that GDF-Suez, backed by the French government, GBL and the other powerful shareholders, will embark on an acquisition spree after the merger closes next year. Analysts think takeovers are inevitable, if only because the new company will have relatively little debt.
;

01 September 2007

Scotiabank to Buy Chile's Banco del Desarrollo

  
Business News Americas, 4 September 2007

Scotiabank sees Latin America as a key growth area where the group will continue expanding operations organically and through acquisitions, executive VP for Latin America Peter Cardinal told BNamericas.

While Mexico remains Scotiabank's largest Latin American earnings contributor, accounting for 15% of total net income for the 2006 fiscal year, the Toronto-based bank has been trying to increase revenue contribution from other countries in the region by purchases in Peru, Costa Rica, the Dominican Republic and an upcoming US$1bn takeover in Chile.

In the meantime, the Canadian firm is focusing on organic growth in Mexico, where its biggest Latin American banking unit Scotiabank Inverlat ranks sixth. BBVA and Citi hold the two top spots.

Retail-oriented Scotiabank Inverlat is adding 85 branches this year to end 2007 with some 590 in attempt to increase its 1.4mn client base.

Mortgage financing is one of the bank's key businesses in retail lending as it takes advantage of Mexico's young demographic profile.

"We are the leading bank in the mortgage market [as measured by new mortgage loans granted]," said Cardinal, who also heads Scotiabank's Mexican unit.

The bank granted 8,058 mortgages last year, increasing its mortgage loan book 33% to 23.3bn pesos (US$2.16bn).

The executive is positive about medium-term economic prospects for Central America, where Scotiabank ranks fourth in El Salvador, runs a medium-sized bank in Panama and is merging two banks in Costa Rica.

"[Central American] markets are undergoing a transformation and want to become part of the global economy... we think it's very positive," Cardinal said.

The Canadian bank is facing increasing competition from rivals like Citi and HSBC, which bought some of Central America's largest banking groups last year.

In Costa Rica, Scotiabank paid US$300mn for local financial group Interfin, which combined with its existing unit will take it to fourth spot from today's eighth.

"[The merger process] will be completed in early October," said Cardinal, who thinks Scotiabank's international presence gives the bank an advantage over the country's top players, state-run Banco Nacional and Banco de Costa Rica.

Scotiabank's international banking operations accounted for 29% of the group's total net income for the nine-month period ended July 31, when the overseas operations had Cd$65bn (US$61.0bn) in assets.
__________________________________________________________
RBC Capital Markets, 31 August 2007

Scotiabank announced it has signed agreements to purchase 79% of Banco del Desarrollo, Chile's seventh largest bank for US$810 million. These agreements are the first stage in a plan to purchase up to 100 per cent of the bank for US$1.03 billion.

The transaction is consistent with the bank's strategy to expand in markets it already has a presence in, and should allow Scotiabank to achieve greater critical mass in a country where its market presence was small and its profitability below the leading banks.'

The 2.8x book value and 15x 2007 earnings multiples, based on the bank's 2007 expectations, are not particularly cheap for a Latin American acquisition, which reflects Chile's stability (investment grade status since 1992) and fast growing banking markets (20% CAGR in loans and deposits in the last 5 years), in spite of the banking market having fairly mature characteristics.

The bank believes that the transaction will add $0.05 to Year 1 EPS and $0.10 to Year 3 EPS, providing the bank with an expected return on invested capital of 13% by Year 3. Synergy assumptions appear conservative and the bank has a track record of delivering on acquisition promises in Latin America.

Cost synergies should come from traditional infrastructure and central function areas, but Scotiabank should also help lower wholesale funding costs due to its high rating. Revenue synergies are also possible from a cross-selling standpoint, but those are not included in management's estimates.

Scotiabank had only 2.5% market share in loans and deposits in Chile, but following the close of the deal (expected in November 2007) it should reach 6.4% and 5.2%, respectively.

Scotiabank will remain well capitalized, in our view. This transaction is expected to lead to a 45 basis point decline in its tangible common equity ratio (currently a healthy 7.6%).

We believe further acquisitions are likely, particularly in Latin America and Asia. Investments in Asia would likely be smaller than in Latin America as the bank is still building its presence in that area, and the bank has historically initially entered new countries via small deals.
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, Grant Surridge, 1 September 2007

After weeks of speculation, the Bank of Nova Scotia finally lodged a US$810-million bid yesterday to purchase 79% of Banco del Desarrollo, the seventh-largest bank in Chile.

Rumours of the deal surfaced at the beginning of August, when local newspapers reported the Canadian banking giant was on the verge of making a US$450-million offer for about 40% of the Chilean bank.

"Where there's multiple share-holdings, you've got to figure out how to get them all on line," said Scotia's executive vice-president of international banking, Rob Pitfield.

He said Scotia originally held talks with Sociedad de Inversiones Norte Sur SA, a Chilean investment firm that holds 39% of Banco del Desarrollo, but secured a 24% stake from France's Credit Agricole SA and a 16% stake from the Italian bank Intesa Sanpaolo SPA before yesterday's announcement.

It was always Scotia's intention to purchase the entire bank, he said, a deal worth just over US$1-billion the bank hopes to complete by the end of the year.

If the deal goes through, it would catapult Scotia to sixth position in the Chilean bank pecking order.

With total assets of more than US$5.1-billion, Banco del Desarrollo has 74 branches in Chile, while Scotia's Chilean subsidiary, Scotiabank Sud Americano, has assets of US$3.5-billion and 57 branches. Scotia intends to maintain the two separate brands, because they target different market segments.

"I'm glad to see they are using capital to grow along the lines they promised shareholders they would," said Juliette John, who manages the $980-million Bissett Dividend Income Fund and holds Scotia shares. She said Canada is a low-growth market, and that Scotia's strategy of diversifying to regions with lower banking penetration should pay off in the long term.

Scotia's overseas operations accounted for about 27% of its overall earnings in third-quarter results reported this week.

Scotia has expanded more aggressively in Latin and South America than its Canadian peers, with operations in Peru, Mexico and Costa Rica, among others.

Other Canadian banks have focused on "low-hanging fruit" in the United States rather than look for more challenging opportunities abroad, said Jacob Jegher, an analyst with the research and consulting firm Celent, which does work for Canadian banks.

He said a mature market at home and the fact domestic banks are prevented from merging leaves no choice now but to look abroad.

"You have to seek opportunities elsewhere to grow your business," he said.

In 2002, the bank wrote off a US$500-million investment and retreated from Argentina when that country's economy collapsed.

But Scotia is confident that Latin America is an increasingly stable and affluent market, and that past problems served as a learning experience.

"Argentina also showed us the dangers of being too small," Mr. Pitfield said. "If we were a bigger and more powerful bank, it's harder to suffer as much as we did.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins, 1 September 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia plans to keep two separate brands in Chile, after it pulls off its $1.03-billion (U.S.) acquisition of Banco del Desarrollo.

Scotiabank's current venture in Chile, Scotiabank Sud Americano, has 57 branches that deal in everything from consumer banking to wealth management, corporate and investment banking, commercial lending and insurance.

Banco del Desarrollo, on the other hand, was founded with a mission to support the community and social development, and its key strengths include small business and micro lending, and consumer finance.

The addition of these 74 branches and 24 business centres to Scotiabank's current Chilean operations will vault Canada's most international bank into the big leagues of Chilean banking, making it the sixth-biggest bank in the country.

But Scotiabank executives expect to maintain two distinct brands to maintain their ability to deal with different ends of the population.

Banco del Desarrollo's branches are more relaxed, smaller, more like outlets than branches, said Rob Pitfield, Scotiabank's executive vice-president of international banking.

It focuses on the segment of the market that generally has between $5,000 and $12,000 of household income a year. That represents about 55 per cent of the market, Scotiabank said.

"You know, you don't want to be presenting yourself to a number of these customers in shirts and ties and suits and things like that," Mr. Pitfield said in an interview yesterday. "You want to have more of a relaxed look, like casual golf shirts, slacks ... Lots of external sales force type things, with people who just work the neighbourhood."

Then the question is, "if you've got that kind of different look and feel, do you need then a different brand to go along with that, or a subbrand to go along with that? So, we're working our way through that now, not only in Chile, but in all the other places. And usually, it's a combination. Sometimes it's a subbrand of a main brand, sometimes it's a different brand altogether."

Scotiabank said yesterday that it has reached agreements with three major institutions that own shares of Banco del Desarrollo to buy a 79-per-cent stake in the bank for $810-million.

Scotiabank hopes to buy the remaining stake through a public share acquisition, bringing the total price tag to about $1.03-billion.

But Scotiabank has 20 days to do its due diligence, and has struck a deal that leaves it some room to lower the price if it doesn't like what it sees. The final deal also requires regulatory approval, and is not expected to be complete for a number of months.

The negotiations for this deal began before Christmas, Mr. Pitfield said.

International deals often take time. After months of rumours in the press, Scotiabank disclosed in March that it was in talks to buy a minority stake in Bank of Dalian Co. Ltd., China's seventh-largest city commercial bank.

Yesterday, Mr. Pitfield said "we're continuing to see if there's an opportunity to work with Dalian."

"In China, it works the way China wants it to work, and along the timelines that China wants it to work," he added. "These are very new deals for China, and all of these city banks do their own deal. And so, they have to become familiar with the way the documentation and the structures [work], all these things. They have nothing really to relate [it] to, so it takes time."
__________________________________________________________
Business News Americas, 31 August 2007

Scotiabank has agreed to buy Chile's seventh largest bank Banco del Desarrollo for some US$1.03bn in a deal that will take Scotiabank to sixth spot from today's 11th.

The Toronto-based group said on Friday it agreed to pay US$810mn for 79% of Banco del Desarrollo, a stake that will be bought from Chilean investment firm Sociedad de Inversiones Norte Sur (39%), France's Credit Agricole (24%) and Italian bank Intesa Sanpaolo (16%).

After conducting due diligence, which will start next week, Scotiabank will be launching a tender offer for all the bank's shares, executives from local unit Scotiabank Sudamericano and Banco del Desarrollo told reporters in Santiago.

The agreements include provisions to adjust the price based on due diligence.

"This [the sale of the bank] was not an easy decision," said Inversiones Norte Sur chairman Vicente Caruz, adding Scotiabank's commitment to maintain Banco del Desarrollo's mission was key in the decision making process.

The Chilean bank was founded to promote social development by providing banking services to SMEs and low-income earners.

Scotiabank's purchase comes 17 years after it first entered Chile, where it now controls a 2.5% loan market share, and at a time when the Canadian bank has been expanding in the region through acquisitions.

"This enables us to increase our presence in Chile, one of Latin America's most developed markets... the highest rated country in the region," said Peter Cardinal, head of Scotiabank's Latin American operations.

Given the complementary nature of the two operations, most of the staff are expected to keep their jobs, said Scotiabank Sudamericano CEO James Callahan, who did not rule out layoffs.

Cardinal said no decision has been made whether to merge and rebrand Banco del Desarrollo under the Scotiabank name.

In Peru and Costa Rica, where Scotiabank bought local banks last year, the group rebranded its acquisitions under the Scotiabank name.

Banco del Desarrollo has assets of US$5.1bn and a network of 74 branches, while Scotiabank Sudamericano has US$3.5bn in assets and 57 branches.

The purchase is expected to close before the end of this year.
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, Jonathan Ratner, 31 August 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia’s move to buy a 79% stake in Chile’s Banco del Desarrollo for US$810-million, signals its continued interest in bulking up both in Chile and throughout Latin America.

The bank has US$5.1-billion in assets and 74 branches, which will boost Scotiabank’s international segment by between 6% to 8%, Dundee Securities analyst John Aiken told clients in a note.

He views the acquisition and BNS’s international expansion “very positively,” saying with $1.5-billion to $2.7-billion in excess capital estimated at the end of the third quarter, Scotiabank should be able to absorb the purchase easily.

However, he pointed to two items in the bank’s press release that raised concerns.

"What synergies are available to BNS, if there does not appear to be significant overlap in the businesses?"

"Who buys a bank on the Friday before a long weekend?"
__________________________________________________________
Dow Jones Newswires, David Pearson, 31 August 2007

Credit Agricole SA one of France's leading financial institutions, said Friday it is tendering its 23.7% stake in Chilean bank Banco del Desarrollo to Nova Scotia, a Canadian concern that has launched a bid to acquire full control of the Chilean bank.

Credit Agricole said the decision to tender its shares to Nova Scotia is contingent on no more favorable counteroffers being made by another buyer.
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, Sean B. Pasternak & Edgar Ortega, 31 August 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia, Canada's second- largest bank, plans to acquire Chile's Banco del Desarrollo for about $1.03 billion to more than double its business in the South American nation.

Scotiabank agreed to buy 79 percent of the Chilean lender from three investors for $810 million, and plans to make a public offer for the rest of the shares on similar terms, the Toronto- based bank said in a statement today. It will be the biggest takeover in Scotiabank's 175-year history.

The acquisition of Chile's seventh-largest lender will more than double Scotiabank's branches in the country, boosting assets by almost 150 percent. Chief Executive Officer Richard Waugh has spent about $1 billion over the past 17 months on purchases in countries including Puerto Rico, Thailand and Jamaica.

``We have a small franchise down there, but it needed to be bigger,'' Rob Pitfield, the bank's executive vice-president of international banking, said today in an interview. Chile is ``still a population that has plenty of banking requirements and needs.''

The transaction will make Scotiabank Chile's sixth-largest bank, with 131 branches and a total of $8.6 billion in assets. Scotiabank first entered the country in 1990, when it bought a stake in Banco Sud Americano.

The bank is buying 39 percent of Banco del Desarrollo from Chilean investment firm Sociedad de Inversiones Norte Sur SA, 24 percent from Credit Agricole SA, Europe's largest mutual-fund manager, and 16 percent from Intesa Sanpaolo SpA. The transaction is expected to close in November.

Chief Financial Officer Luc Vanneste told investors on a conference call that the purchase will add about C$47 million ($44 million) to earnings in the first year, and C$100 million by the third year. Scotiabank will have about 6.9 percent of Chile's $20 billion mortgage market after the transaction and 11 percent of the $9 billion small business market.

``We view the acquisition and Bank of Nova Scotia's overall expansion in its international segment very positively,'' said John Aiken, an analyst at Dundee Securities Corp. in Toronto. The bank has up to C$2.7 billion in excess cash, the analyst said today in a note.

Scotiabank has been making acquisitions to reduce its reliance on Mexico in its foreign earnings. Mexico accounted for 41 percent of international profit in the first half of 2007, down from 52 percent a year earlier, Merrill Lynch & Co. analyst Sumit Malhotra wrote in a note.

Scotiabank reported Aug. 28 that international bank profit fell for the first time in more two years, declining 3.4 percent to C$276 million. International banking accounted for about a quarter of the bank's C$1.03 billion profit for the three months ended July 31.

Pitfield said today the bank would look at acquisitions in other areas where it doesn't have a large presence, including Panama.

Scotiabank shares rose C$1.07, or 2.1 percent, to C$52.24 at 4:10 p.m. in trading on the Toronto Stock Exchange. The stock has climbed less than one percent this year, compared with a 1.6 percent decline among the nine-member Standard & Poor's/Toronto Stock Exchange Banks Index.
__________________________________________________________
Dow Jones Newswires, Monica Gutschi, 29 August 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia says Chile's Banco del Desarrollo would give it the scale it needs to acquire critical mass in that country.

As reported, the Canadian bank has entered an exclusivity agreement with Chilean firm Inversiones Norte Sur related to discussions on its shareholding in Banco del Desarrollo.

Bank of Nova Scotia's head of International Banking, Robert Pitfield, said Tuesday that Banco del Desarollo was strong in commercial and near-prime lending, two areas the Canadian bank needs to beef up.

He also said the bank would add the scale and return on equity that Bank of Nova Scotia looks for in an acquisition. He also noted that Chile is an investment-grade country.

Pitfield said talks are continuing.

Banco del Desarrollo is controlled by Inversiones Norte Sur, in which the Catholic Church has a stake. Other minority shareholders include France's Credit Agricole, Italy's San Paolo IMI and the Dutch Oikocredit EDCS.
__________________________________________________________
• 10 August 2007 Scotiabank to Negotiate Exclusively with Banco del Desarrollo

• 9 August 2007 Scotiabank's Rumoured Interest in Chile's Banco del Desarrollo;