07 April 2006

Banking on Citigroup's Shares

  
As Stock Price Trails Indexes, Some Investors See Value and Bet On Firm's Long-Term Outlook

The Wall Street Journal, Ian McDonald and Clint Riley, 7 April 2006

When it comes to its share price, Citi is looking decidedly small town these days.

After sliding about 7% over the past two years -- compared with a 15% gain for the Standard & Poor's 500-stock index and 7% for the Dow Jones Industrial Average -- shares of Citigroup Inc. are cheaper, meaning they trade at a lower multiple of their expected per-share earnings, than the stocks of smaller peers in banking, capital markets and consumer lending, which are the company's biggest businesses globally.

By that same measure, the financial-services company's stock also is more than a third less expensive than its average price over the past decade, according to researcher Capital IQ.

In 4 p.m. composite trading yesterday on the New York Stock Exchange, Citigroup's shares were down 41 cents, or 0.85%, to $47.85, giving the company a market value of $241 billion. It has $1.5 trillion in assets.

The rough patch for the stock, once a favorite among growth and value investors alike, is partly driven by the general concerns affecting all banks: that rising rates and a slowing economy will pinch profits. More specifically, some investors worry that Citigroup is too big to expand meaningfully, especially since Chief Executive Charles Prince has become more selective about making acquisitions.

While Mr. Prince has talked of eschewing big deals, he received such flexibility this week when the Federal Reserve lifted its roughly yearlong ban on "significant" acquisitions, which was slapped on Citigroup after a string of dust-ups with regulators.

Its shares are trading at just 11 times this year's expected per-share earnings, about the same as Bank of America Corp.'s per-share multiple, and slightly cheaper than J.P. Morgan Chase & Co.'s 12.5, according to Thomson Financial. So, it is getting tough for Wall Street and big investors to ignore the opportunity, especially since Citigroup raked in profits of more than $5 billion each quarter for the past year and a half. "It's tantalizing," says Michael Holton, manager of the $400.6 million T. Rowe Price Financial Services Fund, which holds Citigroup shares.

Others agree. "Really and truly, it's hard to see what the big downside could be for Citi at this point," says Craig Woker, an analyst who covers the company at Chicago researcher Morningstar Inc. and estimates that Citigroup's shares are worth $54 each.

There are three ways an investor makes money from owning a stock: rising earnings that boost the share price, dividends that the shareholder can pocket or use to buy more shares and a rising price-to-earnings multiple. Fans of Citigroup say there is a good argument that the bank can deliver on all three fronts.

Morningstar's Mr. Woker projects mid- to high-single-digit earnings growth for the company in coming years. Overall, analysts project 10% earnings growth over the next five years, according to Thomson Financial.

Mr. Prince has changed the company's strategy since taking the CEO reins from his mentor and departing Chairman Sanford I. Weill in the fall of 2003. His aim: To reinvest in existing units rather than buy up competitors, focusing on being a global distributor of financial services.

In the U.S., the company just launched an Internet bank aimed at luring customers with high-yielding savings accounts to battle similar offerings from competitors like ING Groep NV and HSBC Holdings PLC. And it is expanding its retail-branch network. At the same time, several analysts have said they expect Citigroup's corporate and investment bank to show strong profits in the first quarter from its trading operations and fees from equity and debt underwriting.

Despite its size, it can be argued that Citigroup has room to grow, particularly overseas. The company currently has a little more than 2% of the international market for financial services. Citigroup's bid for Turkey's Finansbank fell through this month, but it has also made a $3 billion bid to take majority control of struggling Guangdong Bank in China.

"If I didn't think the company's fundamentals would begin to improve over the next two years it would be easy not to own it," says T. Rowe Price's Mr. Holton. "At the same time, you're getting paid pretty well to wait."

The company's dividend yield is more than 4%, higher than the 10-year Treasury bond's yield after taxes for many investors. Citigroup also spent nearly $13 billion on share repurchases last year, dropping its share count, but failing to boost its share price.

Given those ample payouts to shareholders, even modest earnings growth would likely relax critics and bring the stock's P/E multiple back up to its historical range -- and raise the stock's valuation closer to historical levels.

"Chuck Prince hasn't totally won the Street over," but skepticism, which might be overblown, is reflected in the current price, says James Schmidt, manager of the $938.6 million John Hancock Financial Industries Fund, in which Citigroup was the fund's second-largest holding at the start of this year.

Others are banking on a rise for Citigroup's shares, too. Los Angeles-based Capital Research & Management Co., manager of American Funds, bought more than 29 million shares in the fourth-quarter, according to regulatory filings. The firm is Citigroup's second-biggest shareholder, behind Barclays Global Investors.

What could chill investors' affection for Citigroup further?

A serious dip in global economic growth or a big bump in consumer bankruptcies would hurt. As would a scandal akin to those involving allegations of illegal bond trading in Europe and the irregularities that led to the shuttering of Citigroup's private-banking operations in Japan. Last week, Australian authorities accused the firm of insider trading, charges that Citigroup says it will "vigorously defend."

But most analysts see such prospects as remote. Fourteen of the 20 buy-side analysts who currently follow Citigroup rate the company as either a "buy" or a "strong buy." The remaining analysts rate the company a "hold."
;

BMO NB Report is Food for Thought on Banks' Futures

  
The Globe and Mail, Andrew Willis, 7 April 2006

Ed Clark, one of the more free-thinking bank CEOs, can look forward to some interesting weekend reading courtesy of the bank analyst at BMO Nesbitt Burns.

In a report that speaks to the way smart analysts are plying their craft these days, Nesbitt's Ian de Verteuil made a strong case this week for one of the Canadian banks to retreat from investment banking by selling out to one of those big, dumb American investment banks. To illustrate his point, Mr. de Verteuil modelled the sale of TD Securities, and the resulting benefits for Mr. Clark's employer, TD Bank.

Before diving into the argument for this radical move, a caveat is needed. Mr. de Verteuil opened his report by explaining that his thesis is pure speculation. No one at TD Bank has given him the slightest indication that the bank is considering selling its so-called wholesale operations. The Nesbitt report is a piece of original thinking, meant to give investors a fresh perspective on the structure and valuation of the Canadian banks. On this front, it is a fabulous piece of work.

It must also be noted that Mr. de Verteuil's report kicked off a hilarious whirlwind of rumours. By co-incidence, the report emerged on Wednesday at the same time TD Securities senior executives were asked to set aside time the following day for an "urgent conference call" on "good news for our domestic growth strategy." Speculation swirled late Wednesday that the call would unveil the sale of TD Securities to Lehman Brothers. In fact, it was to announce that the bank had snagged the eminently connected Frank McKenna as a deputy chairman.

At the heart of Mr. de Verteuil's report is the question of just where a bank's shareholders get the best bang for their capital buck. The Nesbitt analyst argues, quite persuasively, that these are the best of times for the investment dealers. He shows that capital markets are notoriously fickle, and there's a good chance that the credit cycle, underwriting revenues and takeover fees are all heading down from where we are today.

"We are witnessing a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for the Canadian banks to sell their wholesale business, the whole kit and caboodle, at premiums to book value," wrote Mr. de Verteuil, and he named houses such as Lehman, Bear Stearns or Goldman Sachs as likely buyers. The huge sums raised in these sales could be used to fund share buybacks and expansion of the shareholder-friendly retail banking network, which generate far more dependable profits.

Breaking down the numbers at TD Securities, the analyst said the business is less integrated with the bank parent than other Canadian dealers. Mr. de Verteuil put a price tag of up to $7-billion on the business, and explained that exiting the business would bring strategic benefits, along with an upward move in the price-to-earnings ratio that TD Bank commands.

Will it happen? I'd argue that the banks will avoid radical domestic moves for at least another 24 months, as they test the waters on mergers. But no bank CEO can be permanently wedded to the wholesale business. There's always room to rethink business lines . . . Mr. de Verteuil's bit of original thinking is going to make for interesting conversation in the bank boardrooms.
;

TD Hires Frank McKenna

  
Duncan Mavin, CanWest News Service; Financial Post, 7 April 2006

Former Canadian ambassador to the United States Frank McKenna resurfaced at Toronto-Dominion Bank Thursday, where it's hoped he will lend some star quality to TD's pursuit of growth in Canada and the U.S. as the bank's new deputy chair.

TD's chief executive officer Ed Clark said he had been pursuing the former New Brunswick premier and one-time favourite for the Liberal leadership to join him at TD for two years before they finally settled on a deal.

``If you try to recruit Wayne Gretzky, you don't do it in one shot,'' said Clark.

A key reason for hiring McKenna is to help beef up TD Securities as it strives to become one of the top three investment banks in Canada, said Clark.

There had been speculation on Bay Street recently that the bank might be willing to sell TD Securities to a number of acquisition-hungry Wall Street investment banks. TD is in the best position of any of the Canadian banks to cash in on a ``once-in-a-lifetime'' opportunity to sell their wholesale business at a premium to bloated Wall Street firms, said Bank of Montreal analyst Ian de Verteuil in a note to clients.

TD Securities has historically struggled to match some of its rivals, especially because of a weaker retail-brokerage network and because the business has not made adequate inroads with Canadian chief executives.

However, Clark trumpeted McKenna's arrival as a sign of the bank's growth plans for TD Securities. Those plans could include a hiring spree. Also, McKenna will bring strong relationships with ``virtually every CEO in Canada,'' said Clark. ``We have lots of capable investment bankers, but we don't have the historical relationships that other banks have and we think Frank can be the gap-filler,'' he said.

BMO's de Verteuil said there is no sign of any ``imminent'' sale of TD Securities.

McKenna could also provide a higher profile for TD's ambitions in the U.S. He was Ottawa's man in Washington for a year until the election of the Conservative government in January.

TD could be on the cusp of making significant growth plays in the U.S., including potential acquisitions, say some analysts. The bank's shares closed at $64.20 Thursday, down 30 cents on the Toronto Stock Exchange.

The bank has a stated five-year plan to grow TD Banknorth's market capitalization to between $10 billion US and $12 billion US. The U.S. bank has a current market cap of about $6.7 billion US.

High prices on potential acquisitions in the U.S. are currently considered a significant barrier to deals featuring Canadian banks. But U.S. banks could be more accessible later this year if tougher conditions prevail in the sector. Capital-heavy Canadian banks with U.S. ambitions such as TD could benefit from a downturn in the U.S. economy, and the continued flattening of the yield curve in the States, as well as the strength of the Canadian dollar relative to its U.S. counterpart.

``We know the banking environment is tough in the U.S.; that's the bad thing,'' Clark told the Financial Post last month. ``The thing is it's going to cause some acquirees to put up their hands,'' he said.

``You have to be prudent but if you say 'this is ugly, I'm out of here,' you run the risk of missing an opportunity.''

McKenna said his role will also relieve some of the ``ceremonial duties'' from other TD executives, especially Clark.

McKenna, a lawyer, was a member of the New Brunswick legislature for 15 years, including 10 as premier. He was also a member of the board at several companies, including the Bank of Montreal.

He is understood to have received various offers from Canadian businesses after resigning as Canada's ambassador to the U.S. and before agreeing to join TD's board starting May 1.

``I've resolved that I want a full-time job, with a full-time focus, and to be part of a really exciting growth story,'' said McKenna, who is 58. ``I'm really committing the next tranche of my life to helping this institution on its growth trajectory,'' he said.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Sinclair Stewart, 7 April 2006

Ed Clark didn't wait to see whether Frank McKenna planned to run in the Liberal leadership race before he began recruiting him to join Toronto-Dominion Bank. Just hours after Mr. McKenna revealed he was quitting his post as Canada's ambassador to the United States, the chief executive officer called him and urged him to return to the private sector as a rainmaker for TD.

"The day I made the announcement that I was resigning, Ed Clark was on the phone with me, and quite frankly, aggressively thereafter, in a way that I found very flattering," the former New Brunswick premier said in an interview yesterday, when TD announced his appointment as a deputy chairman.

"I liked the idea of getting back to a single obsession in my life, rather than doing a hundred different things. I didn't really become persuaded that I wanted to leave the large buffet that I was at and go to kind of a single course, but then I went to Washington on behalf of the prime minister and I came to realize just how much satisfaction there was in having a single-minded focus."

He was appointed by Liberal Leader Paul Martin and quit when Conservative Leader Stephen Harper formed the government earlier this year.

Mr. McKenna, who had his fingers in several corporate pies before becoming a diplomat early last year, and who served as a director of TD rival Bank of Montreal, insisted he was not weighing Mr. Clark's offer against the chance to take the helm of the Liberal Party. He said he was not interested in becoming a leadership candidate a few days after he resigned as ambassador in late January, but said he had pretty much decided several months before that he wasn't going to re-enter politics.

Mr. McKenna will essentially have an ambassador-like role at TD, using his connections to help the bank land new corporate customers in Canada and the United States. He will report directly to Mr. Clark.

"We haven't had the historical relationships, we don't have enough people in the bank who have the knowledge and the relationships with the key CEOs, and that's what made Frank so attractive," Mr. Clark said. "He has all that."

Mr. Clark is trying to reinvigorate TD Securities Inc., the investment banking arm, and transform it into one of the top three dealers in the country. Many analysts and bankers are skeptical that he can do it: TD Securities has an enviable trading operation, but it has a smaller market share than its peers in underwriting and mergers. That's partly because TD chose to build its own dealer largely from scratch, rather than buy a major independent firm like the other banks did.

The hope is that Mr. McKenna will be able to convert his myriad relationships into new business for the firm. He has served on several boards, including BMO, Air Canada, CanWest Global Communications Corp. and General Motors of Canada Ltd., while acting as counsel to a pair of law firms, doing much the same kind of work he will be doing at TD.

He bought a kitchen cabinet company in 2002, which is run by one of his sons, and has been active with private equity groups.

In addition to his Ottawa ties, which can help the bank with domestic lobbying, Mr. McKenna has strong political links with the northeastern U.S. states, where TD is anchoring its expansion strategy through TD Banknorth, based in Portland, Me. When he was in office, Mr. McKenna was very active with the Conference of New England Governors and Eastern Canadian Premiers, an affiliation that could prove helpful to Mr. Clark and TD.

The two long-time Liberals met each other in the early 1990s, when Mr. Clark, a former high-ranking civil servant, was running Canada Trust and Mr. McKenna was acting as New Brunswick's premier, and trying to entice companies to set up call centres in the province. They stayed in touch sporadically, and two years ago Mr. Clark first approached him about taking a job at the bank.

Despite his designation as deputy chairman, Mr. McKenna has an executive role, and will not be named to TD's board of directors.
__________________________________________________________
Dow Jones, Monica Gutschi, 6 April 2006

Toronto-Dominion Bank has hired former U.S. Ambassador Frank McKenna as a rainmaker to help it open doors as it works to boost its profile in wholesale and commercial banking.

"We think that we have less than our natural market share in certain key markets," Chief Executive Ed Clark said in an interview. "We think that Frank can help us there."

The bank named McKenna, 58, to the newly created role of deputy chairman Thursday. In the position, which he will assume May 1, he'll report to Clark and be a member of the bank's executive team.

McKenna, who most recently served as Canada's ambassador to the U.S., first entered public life as a member of the New Brunswick legislative assembly in 1982. He became Premier in 1987 and served in that position for 10 years.

McKenna's relationships in New York and Washington will be useful in helping Toronto-Dominion strengthen its U.S. growth strategy, Clark said.

Toronto-Dominion has moved aggressively into the U.S. in recent years, buying Boston-based retail bank Banknorth Group in 2004, and joining with discount brokerage Ameritrade Holding Corp. to form TD Ameritrade last year.

Clark said that, as Bill Ryan of Banknorth and Joe Moglia of Ameritrade make more acquisitions in the U.S., McKenna's contacts in the "upper echelons" of U.S. society will come in handy.

McKenna said he sees his role as a facilitator of "business-development opportunities and retention of business." He said he will work to connect the bank's leaders with customers, in order to "leverage to the maximum the strength of the team."

As well, Clark said that, in the Canadian market, Toronto-Dominion lags in equity underwriting, despite having the capacity to do more deals.

"We're the Number One personal bank, but not the Number One commercial bank," Clark said.

He noted his Canadian banking peers purchased investment dealers and thus obtained "historical relationships." In the absense of that at Toronto-Dominion, "we're convinced that Frank can build those relationships."
;

06 April 2006

Problems Loom for China's Newly Refurbished Banks

  
The Economist, 6 April 2006

The mainland's banks have never looked in better shape. On April 6th China Construction Bank, the country's third-largest lender, reported its results for 2005. Although net income dipped a bit, operating profit (a better reflection of its underlying business) rose by 17%, boosted by robust loan growth in a booming economy. The bank's shares have risen in price by more than half since it listed in Hong Kong last October, the first of the “Big Four” state banks to do so. Meanwhile, the share price of the smaller Bank of Communications (BoCom) has doubled since listing last year. No wonder that Industrial and Commercial Bank of China and Bank of China (BoC), another two of the Big Four, are as eager to sell shares this year as foreign investors are to buy them.

Reality, though, is less rosy than it appears. The banks look healthy largely because of repeated capital infusions, initially from the Chinese government but latterly also from foreign strategic partners and the capital markets. Moreover, the bad loans sluiced overboard in past bail-outs look as if they are being replaced by a new wave. China's rapid growth may be producing good-looking profits today, but it is storing up problems for tomorrow.

The biggest threat is overcapacity in almost every industry. Take steel, a big client of the state banks. China's rapacious demand drove steelmakers' profits from 5 billion yuan ($600m) in 1999 to more than 125 billion yuan last year. This triggered a surge of investment in new plants—worth 650 billion yuan in the past five years, two-thirds of it financed by the state banks. Today China has excess steelmaking capacity of 120m tonnes, or a third of its output. “No other country even produces 100m tonnes of steel—and that's China's excess,” marvels Nicholas Lardy, a senior fellow at the Institute for International Economics in Washington, who put the numbers together. The result is plunging returns. In the first two months of 2006, the steel industry's profits were 75% lower than a year before. On March 30th Baosteel, China's biggest producer, reported its first quarterly drop in net profits in more than three years. Stocks of steel are expanding and cashflow is drying up. Despite signs that global steel prices may be picking up, many steelmakers will find it hard to pay back the loans they took out to finance their expansion.

This overcapacity—and declining profits—is repeated in many industries, from power generation to cement, coke, aluminium, car parts and luxury property. All told, the banks face a fresh burst of bad loans, says Mr Lardy: “This could erase some of the very hard-won progress in bank reform in the last eight years.” The concerns go right to the top. At the annual meeting of China's parliament in March, Wen Jiabao, China's prime minister, pointed to a growing risk to the banks from a build-up of inventories.

Yet while the government has tried to curb investment in some industries, in others its foot remains firmly on the accelerator. It plans to splurge 2 trillion yuan on railways, including several new subway lines in Shanghai, in the next five years; to build 24,000 km (15,000 miles) of expressways by 2010; and to have 30 nuclear power stations by 2020, against nine now. Much of this will be financed by the banks, and not all with state guarantees. Dong Tao, chief Asia economist at Credit Suisse, thinks a lot of it will not be commercially viable: “The returns will not be high. There will be a lot of new pressure on the banks.”

Nor can the banks rely on new consumer spending to bail them out. Although pundits have been hailing the emergence of the Chinese consumer for years, net new household borrowing declined in 2005, estimates Mr Lardy, and accounted for less than 15% of net bank lending. Last year, for the first time in nine years, the share of bank loans to households failed to grow.

These threats would be worrying enough if the banks had learnt how to lend properly. But they haven't. A new working paper by economists at the IMF finds that the big state banks still do not price their loans according to either the riskiness or the profitability of the borrower. An embarrassing tale last month of five officials at a remote branch of BoC, who embezzled 430m yuan, is further evidence that old, bad habits remain. Behind their newly burnished facades, China's banks still carry rot within.
;

05 April 2006

BMO NB Speculating on TD Securities' Sale

  
BMO Nesbitt Burns, 5 April 2006

The Sun Is Shining on Canada

Canada as an investment market is 'hot' currently. The TSX has outperformed most other developed country markets (see Chart 1) over the past several years. Strong commodity stocks (and bank stocks) coupled with a strengthening Canadian dollar deserve most of the credit for the outperformance. Several strategists (including our own Don Coxe) believe that Canada will continue to outperform on the back of increased demand for commodities, largely due to strong growth in China.

The strong market performance, coupled with the refining of the Income Trusts as an asset class, the strength of resource underwritings and low interest rates (which have buoyed M&A activity), has allowed the Canadian investment dealing industry to achieve, in 2005, another year of record profitability. The chart below speaks to the current strength of the investment banking business. We aren't bold enough to say what happens next other than to note that profits have historically been volatile.

The Valuation of Wall Street Firms is at a Record

Shares of Wall Street firms have performed well over the past several years. As we show in Table 1, the average P/Tangible Book value for these firms is currently 2.7x, with Bear Stearns with its smaller market cap trading at the bottom end of the range at 2.0x. P/Es range from 10.4x to 13.2x.

Of the five companies we reviewed, only three are overwhelmingly 'wholesale' franchises: Lehman, Bear Stearns and Goldman (i.e., most comparable to TD Securities). Looking back over time, it is interesting that the stocks of all three are generally trading at decade-high P/BV multiples.

It is noteworthy that these franchises have been very successful in the U.S. and several other markets, but to date none have achieved a meaningful and sustainable share of the Canadian capital markets. Goldman and Merrill (the latter having bought into Canada through the Midland purchase) have made the most progress, but with most of their success in M&A more often than not showing up in the top five.

TD is Best Positioned to Make Such a Move

We describe TD Bank as the 'un-universal' bank. Unlike its peers that have leveraged in-house credit capability, and have extensively used their retail broker platforms to sell new issues, TDSI has remained relatively true to the culture of Newcrest, as a niche player in capital markets. TD Securities' loan book is only $6 billion and its full-service brokerage network is relatively small (Table 2).

The more the investment bank interacts (or co-depends) on other parts of the organization, the more likely there will be negative side-effects from exiting the wholesale business. For example, RBC Capital Markets and CIBC World Markets have benefited from their large broker networks to lead the income trust market place. Without such an extensive distribution network, the odds are that underwriting would suffer. On the other hand, having an extensive full service brokerage sales force without access to a steady flow of underwritings could negatively affect contribution from the entire network. In the case of Scotiabank, the strong credit culture has ensured that corporate lending at the bank has remained a core business.

Without the investment dealer, Scotiabank would have less ability to extract ancillary fees from corporate relationships and would be more dependent on earning spreads. It is worth noting that BNS has a corporate loan book of $30 billion- five times that of TD Bank's.

Unlike BMO and Royal Bank, TD Securities is a relatively pure Canadian investment banker. The BMO includes the Harris midmarket loan book in with BMO Nesbitt Burns, while RBC Capital has the U.S. wholesale platforms acquired through Dain and Tucker. The RBC U.S. operations also have tie-ins with their U.S. brokerage platform because of the firm's strong position in municipal bond underwriting in the U.S.

National Bank also has very close ties between its brokers and its investment dealer subsidiary. Like the RY, BMO, CM and BNS, it would be difficult to truly isolate the wholesale operations from the retail without negatively impacting value.

What is TD Securities?

TD Securities is quite different from many of its bank peers. We have often described TDSI as a trading book- with an investment bank strapped onto the side. This acknowledges the fact that TDSI is more dependent on trading than its bank peers. On average, 50% of TDSI revenues come from trading (and probably a similar proportion of the earnings). We note that, contrary to the beliefs of many, this difference actually existed before the Newcrest purchase, and dated back to Don Wright, who fundamentally believed in a trading operation that continued to evolve over time, with new businesses (i.e., entered in the past two years) as a meaningful part of overall revenues. Newcrest, with its boutique focus, and the scaling back of corporate lending simply augmented many of the differences.

Today, we would summarize TDSI as being a top five (but not top three) player in underwriting and capital markets businesses, and a top 10 player in M&A in Canada. We believe that this partially reflects three factors: the lack of U.S. presence, a reluctance to use its loan book aggressively and TD's below-leverage scale in full service brokerage.

Overall, TDSI employs $33 billion of risk-weighted assets. We show our estimates of the make-up of these assets in Table 3, below. The majority of the RWAs arise from loans and commitments to lend in the future, with about $10 billion from the derivative and market risk associated with the trading operations.

As we look at the historical profitability of TDSI (see Table 4), one is struck by the volatility of the business as new management has grappled with restructurings. Results in 2002 included the sectoral charges taken to address the investment bank's heavy emphasis on telecommunications and power companies. 2003 included the writeoff associated with the equity option business in New York. Further charges were incurred in 2005. What is interesting is that even if we consider the average ROE excluding 'unusual items' (which is generous because profits in 2000 and 2001 included contribution from several businesses exited), we still get an ROE of only 13.5% over the period 2000-2006.

Interestingly, ROEs in 2004, 2005 and 2006 are more stable and impressive. The question that TD's management needs to answer is how much of this improvement reflects a 'new and improved' business model, and how much simply reflects a 'bull market' for all Canadian investment dealers, as evidenced by performance of the IDA members.

What Could It Be Worth?

We estimate that TD Bank could sell TD Securities for $5-6 billion to various Wall Street banks that may be interested in developing a large, sustainable wholesale presence in Canada. This would translate into a multiple of 10x forecast operating results this year, and 1.8x tangible book value. We note that such a price would be lower than the trading valuations of U.S. potential acquirers. One would assume that the U.S. investor base of these firms would embrace such a transaction- as long as the deal is not perceived as hurting the fundamental value of TDSI.

In reality, one could make the case that the opposite would be true: TDSI would likely be a more powerful competitor were it owned, and integrated into a Wall Street dealer. We note that in its annual report, TD included a brief description of the Canadian Securities Industry. In it, it described the business as facing intense competition from the Canadian banks, the large global investment banks, and to an extent- small niche investment banks and dealers. 'TD also indicated that it 'is necessary to offer international expertise in order to service the Canadian based international corporate client base' and that TDSI needs to 'offer innovative solutions and ideas which span across products and regions.'

We wholeheartedly agree with these comments and not surprisingly we believe that TDSI as part of, say, Lehman would be a far more effective competitor for all Canadian bank-owned investment dealers.

To highlight the economics to Lehman of a TDSI purchase, we have put together an acquisition model, assuming a $5 billion price which would be funded 80% with debt and 20% with equity issuance. We note that such a deal would likely be accretive to Cash EPS immediately, would position Lehman to capitalize on the opportunities in Canada and would involve the issuance of only 6 million shares (less than 3% dilution of its existing share count).

We are assuming that TDSI's estimated earnings decline in 2007 to $540 million from $616 million in 2006. This is clearly more conservative than assumptions for Wall Street firms, where the 'Street' numbers are broadly calling for 5% higher profits in 2007.

One issue for any potential buyer is the lending book. While TDSI has significantly reduced its loans, it still has $6 billion outstanding and commitments to lend of $57 billion. Firms such as Lehman, Goldman and Bear Stearns are not opposed to lending, but have generally subscribed to a securities model (package and distribute) rather than a commercial bank model (make and retain loans) in support of their investment banking operations. Having said that, it is noteworthy that Lehman and Goldman typically rank in the top 10 as lead arrangers in the U.S. syndicated loan market.

It is possible to model other potential buyers such as Goldman or Citigroup but Lehman is a simpler, more transparent scenario.

Would TD Bank Be Better or Worse off Without TDSI?

Selling a business at 10x earnings is certainly dilutive to Cash EPS- even if one assumes that some of the proceeds are used to repurchase your own shares. In aggregate (and consistent with our assumptions for an LEH-TDSI tie-up scenario), we have assumed that TD sells TDSI for $5 billion, books a gain of $1.5 billion (after $500 million of taxes) and then uses $3 billion to repurchase its own shares at $65. In this scenario shown in Table 6, it is clear that there would still be dilution to TD's EPS.

On the other hand, there is one very tangible financial benefit: Tier 1 (largely because of TD having jettisoned TDSI's $33 billion in RWA) would sky-rocket to over 14%- even after a $3 billion share buyback. This would allow further expansion in the U.S. to be funded with additional debt.

The reality, however, is that the rationale for the transaction would have to be very strategic. Clearly, the downside is very tangible: lower earnings in the short-term.

It is interesting to note that if the price was $7 billion, the dilution could fall to 3.5%. The benefit would have to accrue from having created a retail-only entity with strong positions in Canada in retail banking and wealth management, and credible niche businesses in the U.S. The question is whether such an entity would be a 'better' entity in which to invest. As we look at it, there would be two very large positives to a TD Bank without TDSI.

First, the bank would have eliminated many of the risks that came with being in the investment banking business. Specifically, TD would not be exposed to deterioration in the corporate credit markets or a possible slowdown in activity in Canadian capital markets. History has shown that both of these businesses do exhibit volatility- and over the past three years, the trends have only gone in one direction.

The second benefit relates to the fact that TD would have eliminated a secular challenge: that Canadian capital markets are becoming more global, and that Canadian bank-owned parochial dealers will become less competitive over time as big Canadian issuers seek out global firms for advisory and underwriting expertise. This threat is certainly open to debate and the past three years suggest that this can be managed. Having been in the business for over 18 years, the author of this report can clearly state that this is a real long-term challenge.

Most importantly, the question is whether the market would revalue TD shares- ex TD Securities. The answer, in our opinion, would be a categorical yes. Indeed, for TD shareholders to benefit from a possible sale of TDSI, we would only need one additional multiple point on P/E. Given the more stable earnings base, the better balance sheet and the elimination of a strategically challenged business, this looks very achievable.

In the end, this analysis is quite speculative and TD Bank executives have not provided any reasons to believe this option is being considered. As we have said before, we don't believe anything is imminent, but this analysis does show that it is a valid option.
;

RBC CM's Highlights on Cdn Banks' Valuation Premium

  
RBC Capital Markets, 5 April 2006

Valuation and Recommendation

In this report, we take a closer look at the Canadian banks remarkable price run over the past five years relative to U.S. banks. We focus on what we believe is a reasonable basis for the current valuation premium as well as risks to our call. Our Market Weight recommendation for Canadian banks reflects a view that sector valuation is now full by conventional measures. We are also now selectively wary of negative EPS revisions.

Since May 2005, the bank sector is up 23% largely on a 12% revaluation to 13.7x from 12.2x forward consensus earnings. Our target valuation outlook at 13.1x 2007 estimated factors a 4.25% bond yield estimate in the coming year. For every 50 basis point increase in the 10-year bond yield, our model predicts a 1 multiple reduction in the target P/E.

Highlights

• Exceptional Price Performance. Canadian bank stocks are among the top price performers globally over the one and five year time frames. Canadian banks are now up 79% in the past three years relative to the U.S. banks’ 36% rise. The Canadians’ +43% relative price performance versus U.S. banks has been driven by 22% higher EPS growth with the balance driven by incremental re-valuation.

• P/E Premium Reflects Higher EPS Growth. The Canadian bank one-year forward relative price-earnings multiple has expanded from the perennial 10% discount versus US banks to now command a 22% P/E premium. Still, the 2006 consensus EPS growth estimates indicate Canadian banks look more attractive at a P/E-togrowth (PEG) ratio of 1.5x compared to U.S. banks at 1.65x. In 2005, Canadian banks recorded recurring EPS growth of 14% versus 6% for U.S. banks.

• Price/Book Premium Reflects Higher ROE. The Canadian banks’ relative price/book valuator has expanded from a long-term average at 84% of the U.S. banks to 148% of U.S. banks. During this transition, Canadian bank ROE has held at 20%, well in excess of U.S. banks at 15%. In addition, from deficits only a couple of years ago: (i) Canadian bank Tier 1 capital has jumped out to a 10% higher level than for U.S. banks and (ii) credit reserve coverage is 33% higher.

• Non-Fundamental Factors. Recurring speculation that intra-market consolidation may be allowed could be cited as partly responsible for the creeping Canadian premium. Another corollary factor would be the prospect for break-up and related NAV analysis if the latter does not materialize. The unique-to-Canada income trust market indicates higher-than-normal potential spin-off valuations than found in other countries.

• Valuation Risks. Versus history, Canadian bank valuations are through the range indicated appropriate for current bond yields and relative to the market multiple, for the first time since late 2003. Second, the Canadian banks’ ROE is not as high as the current price/book ratios are suggesting appropriate per our ‘value map’ against U.S. banks. Third, we would be concerned that current EPS estimates are now fully reflecting the good news on credit, and that the next series of surprises may start to prove disappointing as opposed to positive.
;

03 April 2006

How RBC Asset Management Got to the Top of the Industry

  
Almost one-quarter of net mutual fund sales in Canada last year were generated by RBCAM, and it is far from resting on its laurels

Investment Executive, James Langton, 3 April 2006

RBC Asset Management Inc. is the Toyota Motor Corp. of the Canadian mutual fund industry, vanquishing traditional industry leaders in an ultra-competitive business with top-notch products, solid strategy and superior execution. Now, like fast-rising Toyota, RBCAM’s greatest challenge will be sustaining its advantage.

A quick glance at recent mutual fund sales figures reveals the breadth of RBCAM’s sales dominance.

Last year, the best year for the fund industry since 2001, saw $23.4 billion in net sales generated. RBCAM accounted for almost a quarter of the total, punching well above its weight class, with its market share of assets at slightly less than 10%. RBCAM boasts that it has led the net sales parade for nine consecutive quarters. That isn’t simply the result of a hot sector or two; RBCAM was ranked among the top three sellers in every long-term asset category in 2005.

Dominating fund sales so thoroughly is no small feat. The industry is already mature, saturated with products and filled with aggressive competitors. There are few easy sales, and no real secrets to success, as every firm knows it needs eye-catching investment performance and effective distribution. In such an environment, execution is the key differentiator.

Relative to the rest of the industry, RBCAM has executed exceptionally well. It has done perhaps the best job among the banks in capitalizing on their natural competitive advantage: large, built-in distribution networks. At the same time, it has skilfully expanded its distribution into independent channels, where it was once thought that bank-managed funds could never hope to compete. RBC has also exploited its scale to keep costs low, product development active and to improve governance, which can have its own salutary effect on returns.

The convergence of near-perfect conditions is no accident. George Lewis, chairman and CEO of RBC Asset Management and executive vice president of RBC Wealth Management, says the march forward is the result of excellent execution by his team in all key functions: distribution, investment performance and product development.

Most important is distribution. “We decided that to be a top one or two player in this business, we had to operate in more channels. So, five years ago, we began to market our funds to brokers and financial planners,” says Lewis.

Back then, RBC Asset Management ranked fourth in mutual fund assets, and just seventh in long-term assets, data from Toronto-based Investor Economics Inc. show. Since then, RBC’s share of long-term assets has grown to almost 9% from less than 6%, a gain that came primarily at the expense of the large, independent fund manufacturers.

In pursuing the independent channel, Lewis says, the firm first focused on its full-service investment dealer sister, RBC Dominion Securities Inc. , taking the approach that it had to earn the business one advisor at a time. The challenge was tackled with dedicated external wholesalers, product development that focused on stockbrokers’ needs and changes on the investment-management team, including bringing Dan Chornous over from RBC DS, where he was chief strategist, to serve as chief investment officer at RBC Asset Management in 2002.

After earning its stripes with the DS sales force, Lewis says, RBC is now doing a fair amount of business in the independent channel, principally with the other bank-owned investment dealers and some of the larger fund dealers. Indeed, he notes, the brokerage/ planner channel represented about 25% of RBC’s net sales in 2005, and the dollar value of sales in the channel increased 300% last year to about $1.2 billion. “I’d be disappointed if we didn’t double that in 2007,” he says.

The fact that RBC funds tend to be cheaper doesn’t hurt, either. Lewis says RBC has tried to align itself with dealers that want to use no-load funds or unbundle client costs by charging a fee for advice and using F-class units. He says the firm will continue to attract clients as regulators and investors demand greater fee transparency.

In the past, the dig at bank-owned fund firms was “no-load means no performance,” but RBCAM is proving that is not the case. “You can have the benefits of low management expense ratios, advisor-friendly trailer compensation and good performance,” says Lewis.

Although external dealers are a significant and fast-growing source of sales, the bulk of RBC sales comes through the parent bank’s traditional distributors: 7,500 branch-based reps and 1,500 branch advisors, known as investment specialists.

Of the 1,500 branch advisors, about two-thirds serve the retail bank’s bigger clients that already have investments with Royal Bank of Canada. The other third are so-called “mobile” advisors — an asset-acquisition force that aims to bring in clients that are either new to the banks or existing clients that don’t do any investment business. The 500 mobile advisors focus on making the initial sale and then hand off the client to one of the 1,000 planners to manage the ongoing relationship.

The different objectives of the two parts of the branch advice sales forces is reflected in their compensation. The mobile advisors are commission-based, whereas the others are paid salaries and bonuses based on the size and growth of their books.

The branch advisors are distinct from the larger sales force in that they provide financial planning, aren’t locked into proprietary products and can also offer third-party funds. Lewis says RBC was so confident in its ability to compete as a manufacturer that it funded half the cost of equipping its parent’s sales force to sell third-party products.

Why fund your rivals’ distribution? Allowing branch advisors some flexibility to offer third-party funds gives them the ability to establish credibility with clients by demonstrating independence, and possibly improving returns, even if it means using a competitor’s product. The sales force accounts for 30%-35% of RBC’s assets under management, Lewis says, and third-party funds represent about 5% of that amount.

RBC finds the use of multiple channels reinforces its competitive advantages. “We’re in a situation in which we’re in a virtuous circle,” says Lewis. “We have very strong relationships with our distribution partners, both internally and externally. Because of that, we have good product development to meet the needs of those distributors.”

The success in winning independent distribution, in turn, validates the quality of its products to the bank’s internal sales forces, he adds, because having independent advisors selling a bank fund is a benefit.

Apart from distribution, Lewis says, the bank also has advantages as an investment manager because it has a large team of portfolio managers in Toronto as well as offices in Montreal, London and Hong Kong. Although it uses a variety of sub-advisors, having a large group of managers who are focused globally gives it a different perspective on the markets.

That perspective has helped RBC make some solid asset-mix calls, and to bump up investment performance in recent years. As a result, Lewis says, RBCAM ranks among the top three firms with the proportion of funds in the top two quartiles over six-month, and one-, three- and five-year periods.

Good investment performance makes life easier for distributors, and it has also changed the reputation banks had of being second-rate asset managers. Lewis says RBCAM’s success shows “banks can operate an asset-management business well, and that was not the perception seven or eight years ago.”

The solid performance has helped push RBC’s AUM to $61.5 billion at the end of the recent RRSP season. It is also powering the parent bank’s growth. In the first quarter ended Jan. 31, 2006, the bank reported that wealth-management revenue increased 17% compared with the same quarter in 2005, a time when overall revenue rose 10%. It attributes the gains primarily to robust fund sales and greater fees resulting from higher AUM, along with higher volumes in full-service brokerage and improved spreads.

The AUM total has the firm at the top of the industry rankings, but it wants more. Lewis says RBCAM aims to surpass the $100-billion mark by 2010. The goal is well within reach if RBCAM can sustain its momentum. Maintaining current sales levels over the next five years would mean total sales of about $30 billion through 2010. Throw in a modest lift from the markets in that time, and that goal is easily attained.

Moreover, industry trends appear to be tilting in RBCAM’s favour. Investor Economics projects the overall wealth market will grow by 8% annually in the next decade, with branch advice running at 12% and full-service brokerage at almost 11%.

Domestic acquisitions don’t figure prominently in the plan. Lewis indicates RBC’s acquisition ambitions are global and not local; it is more likely to do deals that would open asset-management businesses in other markets, and not bulk up in the domestic market. He says that is RBC’s philosophical position, not an active ambition, although the parent bank has been rumoured to be pursuing a fund-management venture in China.

As there are no domestic acquisitions in the cards and the markets are an inherent unknown, the big challenge at RBCAM is to maintain its sales record. Given its current performance and momentum, however, it looks like the Toyota of the fund business is only getting stronger.
;

GMP Targeted, as Investment Banks Eye Mergers

  
Focus on small- to mid-cap sector deemed a winner as dealers strive to build strength

The Globe and Mail, Andrew Willis, 3 April 2006

The deal makers may be lining up deals of their own, as Canadian investment banks eye takeovers of rivals to better take advantage of red-hot markets.

There have been informal merger talks between several brokerage houses in recent months, as investment banks strive to build strength in every line of business. The focus is on acquiring expertise in energy, mining, trusts and mergers and acquisitions. Dealers with a proven strength in these sectors are hearing approaches from rivals that want to bulk up.

The most coveted platform is GMP Capital Trust, the parent of institutional boutique GMP Securities LP and retail brokerage GMP Private Client LP. Its focus on small- to mid-capitalization resource companies is a winner in this market. There is ongoing speculation that Goldman Sachs Group Inc. or another U.S. dealer lacking an equity operation in Canada may buy the publicly traded firm.

GMP senior managers recently had get-to-know-you chats with Goldman's new Canadian executive team, according to sources at GMP. Units in the GMP Trust hit an all-time high of $24.95 last week and closed Friday at $24.90.

There are three major global brokerage houses with Canadian-based equity operations: UBS Securities, Merrill Lynch and Credit Suisse First Boston. Dealers such as Goldman and JP Morgan Canada have fixed income and corporate finance departments, but no domestic equity desks.

Dealers such as GMP are in the market's sweet spot right now, compared with the international firms, according to statistics prepared by the Investment Dealers Association of Canada. In a report last week the IDA said: "Although cross-border financings were up last year, the bulk of the takeover landscape was in the domestic, small- to mid-market. This backdrop favoured the domestic institutional players over the foreign firms"

Other brokerage houses trying to muscle up through takeovers include publicly traded Jovian Capital Corp. and Dundee Wealth Management Inc. Jovian owns a brokerage house called MGI Securities and made overtures to institutional boutique Westwind Partners Inc., according to sources close to both firms. Westwind was not interested in a merger, these sources said.

Dundee is controlled by financier Ned Goodman and recently drafted Kym Anthony as its chief executive officer. As CEO of National Bank Financial Inc., Mr. Anthony oversaw the integration of two large dealers. Dundee is said to have looked at a takeover of employee-owned Sprott Securities, which rebuffed overtures.

A number of other dealers, including Blackmont Capital Inc. and Wellington West Capital Inc., have already done small acquisitions and made no secret of their interest in larger dealers. The problem right now is the market features more buyers than sellers. Investment banking takeovers also have an extra degree of difficulty compared with deals in industrial companies because they have to be employee-friendly, as a dealer's only real asset is human talent.

The urge to merge comes as dealers strive for share of a record-setting market. Industry wide, 2005 was a record-setting year for Bay Street, and the torrid pace of financings and takeovers has continued through the first three months of 2006.

IDA statistics show the investment banks posted a record $4.3-billion of operating profit in 2005, shattering the previous all-time high of $3.6-billion in 2004.

In the past, investment banks have staged takeovers when markets are soaring. Most of the Canadian banks acquired brokerage houses in the runup to the 1987 market crash, while Merrill Lynch bought Toronto-based Midland Walwyn Ltd. just before the dot-com bubble burst in 2001.
;

01 April 2006

Cdn Banks and $20 Billion Excess Capital

  
Financial Post, Duncan Mavin ,1 April 2006

Canada's big banks have a ton of cash. So much so that their investors and the analysts who cover the industry want the banks to do something with all that liquid wealth. Merge with someone. Buy something else. Just don't let all that cash sit there.

It's a hell of a problem to have.

Mergers have been top of the must-do list for bank executives for much of the past decade. And casual observers could be forgiven for thinking that the mighty banking sector would crumble without a merger or two. How many times were we told that bulk was the only thing that mattered? As for the near future, no minority government is going to open up the politically contentious issue of bank mergers.

Yet here we are in 2006 and the banks look stronger than ever, delivering record earnings and enlarging returns with the help of a runaway Canadian economy and favourable demographics -- ageing Baby Boomers and a lot of enthusiastic immigrants.

"There's a good steady wind in the sails of the industry," says Robert Pearce, president and chief executive of personal and commercial clients at Bank of Montreal. That steady wind will only get stronger with favourable demographics, he adds.

The market capitalization of the six biggest banks is $200-billion, up from $167-billion at the end of 2004. The entire Canadian income trust sector, 235 trusts in all, has a market cap of $199-billion.

In 2005, the big banks earned a combined net income of more than $16-billion, finding 18.5% growth in what is supposed to be a mature market. In the first quarter of 2006, the banks continued to break earnings records, with an aggregate performance 11.6% better than the previous year. Even after such a stellar performance, analysts estimate the banks will increase earnings between 8% and 10% for the rest of 2006.

And it's all been achieved without much dipping into the banks' swollen war chests.

The banks have stashed away excess capital of more than $20-billion, according to a recent report from financial services firm PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP.

The funds available for acquisitions could more than double in the next three or four years thanks to continued earnings growth and a new set of global banking regulations that should shrink the amount the banks are required to set aside for a rainy day.

Certainly, the big banks aren't afraid to share the joy -- their shareholders received aggregate dividends of more than $6-billion last year, up 151% since 2000.

"They are becoming dividend rich -- which is not horrible," said Basil Kalymon, an expert on the financial services industry at Ivey Business School's executive MBA program. "They are part of the more stable side of the economy, so paying out dividends is not inappropriate."

They've enjoyed an outstanding run, admits Diana Chant, head of PricewaterhouseCoopers financial services group in Canada. But she asks one burning question: "Where do they go from here?"

The answer may be the banks don't have to go anywhere.

There's plenty of growth at home simply because the domestic economy is so strong, says HSBC Canada chief executive officer Lindsay Gordon. "At the end of the day, how a bank does is a reflection of how the economy does."

Mr. Gordon says Canada represents only 2% of the global economy yet it accounts for 4% of HSBC's international profits.

Indeed, HSBC Canada has delivered growth of about 15% a year on average over the past few years. And Mr. Gordon remains bullish about the future of the Canadian banking sector.

The numbers support his optimism. The country's record-low unemployment is putting cash in consumer's pockets, while 14 years without a recession ensures businesses can repay their loans. Even the much-feared downturn in the credit cycle is looking less fearsome and less likely than it did a few months ago. The banks almost unanimously left untouched their provisions for bad debts in the first quarter of 2006.

"These aren't boom times, but they are damn good," said the Bank of Montreal's Mr. Pearce. The consumer mortgage market is "huge and growing" -- by as much as 10% a year -- while car loans and personal debt are projected to grow by 8% to 9% a year.

The ageing of Canada's population is well documented, and in the banking sector, the trend is driving growth in wealth management as Canadians plan for retirement. In the first quarter of 2006, wealth-management earnings at Toronto-Dominion Bank grew 35% compared to the previous year, and at Bank of Montreal it was 27%.

Meanwhile, hundreds of thousands of immigrants are expected to arrive in Canada in the next few years -- about 250,000 in 2006 alone -- contributing to "amazing retail growth" beyond expectations, said Harry Ort, head of financial services at accountants KPMG LLP in Toronto.

Although performance varies from bank to bank, year-over-year retail and wealth-management growth at the big banks in the first quarter of 2006 was about 13% on aggregate -- it was more like 16% to 22% at the best performers, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, TD and RBC.

While retail growth is expected to stay as high as 10% for the rest of this year, there's even more impressive growth available in niche markets, such as the sub- or near-prime lending business. Canada's banks have usually steered clear of the segment, which is riskier than traditional consumer lending because it involves providing loans to customers whose credit history would otherwise prevent them from obtaining funding.

But following the lead of global giants Citibank and HSBC, a couple of the Canadians have dipped their toes in the market -- notably, TD recently bought sub-prime auto-lender VFC Inc., while Scotiabank acquired near-prime home-loans business Maple Mortgage. The sub-prime vehicle loans market is expected to grow at about 35% a year, and the growth in non-traditional mortgages is estimated to be as high as 30% a year.

But there's also a spin-off benefit because banks that acquire sub-prime lenders get access to thousands of new customers.

Scotiabank's Maple Mortgage acquisition brought 40,000 new customers into the fold, says Barb Mason, executive vice-president of marketing and sales and services at Scotiabank.

For each one of those new relationships, the bank estimates it can "cross-sell" two new products, such as credit cards or a bank account. Despite the sub-prime tag, many of the new customers will be responsible borrowers with legitimate reasons for weak Canadian credit ratings.

And then there's the whole insurance market. Banks are not currently allowed to sell or market insurance from their bank branches. But RBC and TD are leading the charge for changes to the Bank Act -- up for review in the fall -- to open up the insurance business.

"We see it as a growth business for us," said Jim Westlake, head of personal and business clients for RBC in Canada. "In every market around the world where banks have been allowed to sell insurance, the market has grown." Mr. Westlake also says having insurance customers walk into RBC branches will provide more of those potentially lucrative cross-selling opportunities.

Nevertheless, in Mr. Kalymon's view, the banks will still have to look abroad for the sort of growth that can fundamentally change the bottom line.

"Canada is a relatively small market when it comes to financial products compared to the global market," he said. "The banks certainly have the potential to expand."

Canadian banks may be successful at home, but they are dwarfed by such global giants as HSBC, Citigroup or UBS, for instance. Citigroup alone has a market capitalization more than US$30-billion bigger than the combined Canadian figure.

Yet although domestic performance is still the main driver for the Canadian banks, they are already doing better than you might think in foreign markets and they are trying to do even more.

The Bank of Nova Scotia, which rightly claims to be Canada's most international bank, with particularly strong operations in Central and Latin America, has seen earnings growth from its foreign subsidiaries of between 15% and 20% a year recently. Now Scotiabank is making announcements about growing its consumer lending and credit business in Mexico, probably through an acquisition.

At TD, more than 50% of net income originated from the bank's expanded U.S. and international operations last year, up from less than 40% the year before, for example. Earlier this week, TD's chief executive, Ed Clark, said the bank would look to get on the acquisition trail in the United States this year.

RBC's U.S. and international operations produced net income of $101-million in the first quarter of 2006, an increase of 3% from the prior year, despite the rising strength of the Canadian dollar. The bank has also announced plans to expand the branch network of its RBC Centura subsidiary in the United States by 10% a year from 2008 -- RBC Centura already provides 9% of the bank's profit

As well, net income at BMO's Chicagoland operations grew by 13% in 2005 to $125-million. And in mid-March, CIBC announced it will pay US$1.1-billion to double its existing stake in FirstCaribbean International Bank this year.

In fact, while traditional domestic banking is providing steady growth even in a mature market, it's clear analysts want more and bank executives are open to further deals. Indeed, the surplus cash must be burning a hole in their pockets.

There's persistent speculation about one or more of the banks hooking up with a fund manager, and the Bay Street rumour mill suggests the big banks are already wrestling to pin down the best corporate lawyers in town in anticipation of a potential surge of spending activity.

"In today's dynamic environment, if you stay nailed to the spot, you are in trouble," Mr. Kalymon said. "Yes, maybe the banks are doing very well focused on mortgages and retail, but I don't think that's a way to succeed into the future. They have to maintain creativity. Obviously they shouldn't commit funds just to commit funds. But staying put is a dangerous position."
;

Manulife's Dividend Reinvestment Plan

  
The Globe and Mail, Rob Carrick, 1 April 2006

Manulife Financial has just handed small investors a gift with an unpleasant surprise inside.

Manulife introduced a dividend reinvestment plan, or DRIP, last month that will give shareholders the option of having their dividends used to buy new shares instead of paid in cash. Manulife also created a share purchase plan, whereby shareholders can buy additional stock directly through the company.

Companies as big and successful as Manulife don't introduce DRIPs very often these days, so this is big news for investors who appreciate the slow, steady wealth-building potential of reinvesting dividends without paying brokerage costs. Unfortunately, in a move that could be a trendsetter for other big companies, Manulife decided to depart from the custom in Canada and charge investors fees and brokerage commissions to use its DRIP and SPP.

The two Manulife plans still have some appeal to the investor who wants to build a position gradually in a Canadian blue-chip company with a global reach (full disclosure: I'm a Manulife shareholder). But it also serves as a reminder that there are other DRIPs and SPPs that not only forego fees, but also let you buy shares at a discount.

Manulife's fee schedule is as follows: for the DRIP you pay 5 per cent of the reinvested dividends up to $6 per quarter (plus GST), as well as a nominal brokerage commission of 4 cents a share purchased with those dividends; for the SPP, the cost is $15 per purchase plus the same brokerage commission. Selling DRIP or SPP shares costs $20 plus commissions and an additional charge of 6 cents a share.

"That seems very stiff to me, to be honest," said Norman Rothery, a financial consultant who has for years maintained a DRIP database on his very useful website, Stingy Investor (ndir.com). "Fees are pretty common in the U.S., but they're unusual in Canada. Most of the time, it's a no-fee situation."

Manulife's explanation is that it's in a unique position with respect to its new DRIP because of its vast base of almost 900,000 shareholders in Canada and the United States. Terri Neville, the insurer's assistant vice-president of shareholder services, said that if the percentage of shareholders using the DRIP is in line with other established companies, then the cost of administering the plan would represent a considerable expense to be borne by all the company's shareholders, regardless of whether they used the DRIP.

"We thought, do we want everybody to pay the cost of something maybe 30 per cent of the people will use?" Ms. Neville said. "We decided, no, we don't. We thought it was more equitable for people who want it to pay for it, and people who don't want it don't have to pay."

Fees like those charged by Manulife are fairly common among big U.S. blue chips, although the amounts are sometimes lower. For example, Verizon Communications Inc. charges $2.50 (U.S.) for cash purchases of shares, $1 to $2 for reinvested dividends and $10 to sell shares, while IBM charges up to $3 for reinvested dividends, $5 for optional cash purchases and $15 to sell shares.

Ms. Neville suggested that charges like this will be increasingly common among big Canadian companies that want to introduce DRIPs but also control administrative costs. "I know there have been very few issuer-paid plans started up in the past few years for the reason that it's really starting to hit the bottom line," she said.

Fortunately, many blue-chip Canadian companies still have no-cost DRIPs, including each of the Big Six banks, BCE Inc., Fortis Inc., Imperial Oil Ltd., Magna International Inc., Suncor Energy Inc. and TransCanada Corp. Many income trusts offer free DRIPs as well, as do a few closed-end funds such as Canadian General Investments. (Closed-end funds are basically mutual funds that trade like a stock).

Companies offer DRIPs to help raise capital and broaden their shareholder base. Some companies are eager enough to pursue these goals that they build a discount into the price of shares that investors buy through dividend reinvestment or SPPs, or they provide a small bonus of extra units.

Discounts run from 2 to 6 per cent of the market price at the time the shares are purchased, while the bonuses are usually in the 3-per-cent range and apply to the amount being reinvested. "It's a pretty sweet deal and well worth using," Mr. Rothery said.

Not surprisingly, the highest-profile companies don't offer discounts on their DRIPs. But you will find discounts available from companies and trusts such as the following.

ARC Energy Trust (AET.UN). Widely considered to be one of the more stable oil and gas energy trusts, ARC offers a 5-per-cent discount on reinvested dividends and cash payments used to buy more units.

H&R REIT (HR.UN). Canada's second-largest real estate investment trust offers a 3-per-cent discount on its DRIP, but not its SPP.

MDS Inc. (MDS). This health care company offers a 5-per-cent discount on its DRIP, but not on its SPP.

Nexen Inc. (NXY). One of the largest oil and gas producers listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange, Nexen offers a 5-per-cent discount on its DRIP.

RioCan REIT (REI.UN). RioCan is the largest REIT in the land and it offers a discount of 3.1 per cent on its DRIP, but not its SPP.

There are actually two kinds of DRIPs, the traditional offered by companies and an alternative run by many full-service and discount brokers. If Manulife's new DRIP proves to be a trendsetter, those brokerage DRIPs are going to be an increasingly attractive option.

With a company-offered DRIP, you have to buy a share or shares of a company through a broker and request that the share be registered in your name and sent to you. Next, you complete a DRIP enrolment form (they're available from corporate investor relations departments) and send it to your company's plan administrator, known as a transfer agent. Many DRIP companies allow you to reinvest dividends into fractional shares, which means you can put every penny of your quarterly dividend payments to work in buying new shares.

With a broker DRIP, your broker collects the dividends and reinvests them in new shares. Many brokers do this without fees or commissions, but be sure to enquire about any costs.

Broker DRIPs offer a few conveniences over company plans, one being that you can keep your DRIP stocks under the same roof as your regular investments. Another is that you don't have to pay the fees associated with buying a share, having it registered in your name and then sent to you so you can enroll in a company plan.

The drawbacks of brokerage DRIPs are that you probably won't be able to buy fractional shares with your dividends, and you won't be able to buy extra shares at no cost using a share purchase plan.

A good alternative to both types of DRIPs is to use the services of Canadian ShareOwner Investments (investments.shareowner.com), a brokerage that has commissions as low as $9 and free reinvestment of dividends. ShareOwner Investments is an offshoot of the Canadian ShareOwner Association, which promotes sound investing by small investors through the bimonthly ShareOwner magazine.

Hard-core Canadian DRIP enthusiasts will be interested to know that Manulife now offers a direct purchase plan for its U.S. shareholders, whereby they can buy their first shares directly through the company rather than a broker. DPPs are common in the U.S. market, but regulators haven't showed much enthusiasm about allowing them to be introduced here.

"We can't do it in Canada because the regulations won't allow it," Manulife's Ms. Neville said. "We really wish they would."

Many publicly traded companies allow shareholders to use their dividends to buy more shares at no cost through a dividend reinvestment plan, or DRIP. Manulife Financial has a new DRIP that breaks this custom by charging fees, but there are several TSX-listed companies and income trusts that both offer no-cost DRIPs and either allow investors to buy new shares at a discounted price, or provide a small bonus on the dividends reinvested. These companies and trusts include those below.

Agnico-Eagle MinesAEM 5%
Allied Properties REIT AP.UN 5%
ARC Energy Trust AET.UN 5%
Calloway REIT CWT.UN 3%
Canadian REITREF.UN 3%
Contrans Income Fund CSS.UN5%
Enerplus Resources FundERF.UN 5%
First Capital Realty FCR 2%
Fort Chicago Energy Partners FCE.UN 5%
Inter Pipeline FundIPL.UN 5%
MDS Inc. MDS 5%
Nexen Inc. NXY 5%
Paramount Energy Trust PMT.UN 6%
Pengrowth Energy Trust PGF.B 5%
Penn West Energy Trust PWT.UN 5%
Plazacorp Retail PropertiesPLZ 3%
Primewest Energy PWI.UN 2%
Pulse DataPSD 5%
Retirement Residences REITRRR.UN 3%
RioCan REITREI.UN3.10%
Summit REITSMU.UN 5%
TransAlta Corp.TA 5%
TransAlta Power LPTPW.UN 5%
Vermilion Energy TrustVET.UN 5%

Source: The Stingy Investor Website, Computershare Ltd., CIBC Mellon, Company Websites

;

30 March 2006

TD to Stay Focused on US Despite Headwinds

  
Bloomberg, 30 March 2006

Toronto-Dominion Bank, Canada's No. 2 lender, will focus this year on making at least one acquisition in the U.S. and bolstering its investment-banking unit, Chief Executive Officer Edmund Clark said.

TD Banknorth, Toronto-Dominion's U.S. lender, will have ``opportunities'' to make purchases, Clark said in an interview today following the annual meeting in Vancouver.

``I think we will get some opportunities over the next year because the environment is tough'' for smaller banks, Clark said. ``I think we'll have some real choices.''

Toronto-Dominion bought control of TD Banknorth last year for about $3.5 billion, its first consumer-banking presence in the U.S. TD Banknorth has since purchased Mahwah, New Jersey- based Hudson United Bancorp for about $1.9 billion, and has said it plans to make one or two purchases a year.

Toronto-Dominion also wants to expand its TD Securities investment bank, which ranked fifth in Canada for equity and equity-linked deals last year, and was 10th in mergers advice, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

``How do we get more people on the front line in investment banking who know more CEOs and have better relationships in order to build that part of the franchise?'' Clark said. ``That will be our next big focus.''

Clark also said the bank will expand its asset-management business on its own rather than make acquisitions. Canadian lenders such as Bank of Nova Scotia have been looking at ways to expand their fund businesses to take market share from mutual fund companies.

Goodwill Costs

``The value added we're getting through organic growth is pretty phenomenal,'' Clark said. ``When you compare that with the economics of acquiring someone and paying a bunch of goodwill, it's not obvious the economics work for us.''

The banks increased their share of the country's C$570 billion ($491.2 billion) fund market to about 35 percent last year from 25 percent in 2000, according to the Investment Funds Institute of Canada.

Toronto-Dominion owns the fifth-largest fund company in Canada and has been No. 2 in net sales of long-term mutual funds for three years, Clark said at the meeting. Profit from asset management climbed 41 percent to C$138 million in the fiscal first quarter.

CI Financial Inc. Chief Executive Officer William Holland said in January he expects Canada's five main banks to buy fund companies to continue their expansion.

Two years ago at the bank's annual meeting in Edmonton, Alberta, wealth management head William Hatanaka said Toronto- Dominion would consider buying fund companies.

Clark, 58, also today urged the federal government to relax a ban prohibiting banks from selling insurance in their branches so that consumers can get more information.

Insurance Competition

Canadian banks are pushing for insurance rules changes to compete with insurers such as Manulife Financial Corp. and ING Canada Inc. Banks can sell insurance over the Internet and through brokers, but can't sell in branches.

Clark said the Toronto-based lender isn't seeking the right to sell insurance in branches, but wants to be able to provide information to clients about its insurance products.

``We're the only country in the world that has these rules,'' Clark said. ``Everyone knows we should (be able to) do this. The question is, is there any political will to do these minor sort of changes?''

Clark said he doesn't expect the government to remove its ban on bank mergers among the five largest lenders anytime soon. He said Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who was elected in January, has outlined his five policy priorities.

``Bank mergers is not one of them,'' Clark said.
__________________________________________________________
Canadian Press, Craig Wong, 30 March 2006

Troubles in the American banking industry could open up acquisition opportunities south of the border for Toronto-Dominion Bank's business in the northeastern United States, chief executive Ed Clark said Thursday.

Banking in the United States is having a rough ride is recent months with rising short-term interest rates being a negative for growth at TD Banknorth, Clark said.

But the TD CEO said that same bad environment is creating opportunities for acquisitions by the regional bank.

“Organizations that are operating in there that are small, and in the long run, don't think that they are going to be survivors are saying, ‘Am I going to hang around and survive for the next two years when it is ugly or should I maybe get out now,”' Clark said after the bank's annual meeting.

“Canadian banks have sat back and not built sustainable franchises in the United States and I think if you want to be a North American bank that's what you have to do. So, I think if we find the right strategic fit, we'll take advantage of it.”

TD Bank acquired a 51 per cent stake in TD Banknorth last year for $3.8 billion (U.S.) as a vehicle for its expansion in the United States. Since then, TD Banknorth bought Hudson United Bancorp of New Jersey for $1.9 billion in cash and shares in a deal backed by its parent company.

Expansion into the United States has proven troublesome for some Canadian banks in the past.

Royal Bank's subsidiary RBC Centura has had disappointing results since Canada's largest bank bought the small North Carolina-based retail network for about $3.3 billion in 2001 Meanwhile, CIBC has rid itself of much of its U.S. operations in recent years including the sale of its Oppenheimer wealth management business and the closure of its Amicus U.S. electronic banking operation, which entailed half a billion dollars' worth of restructuring charges.

But Clark remains convinced his bank's strategy with TD Banknorth and stake in TD Ameritrade is the right one.

“We've focused in on the northeastern United States and we've focused in on the online brokerage business,” he said.

RBC Capital Markets analyst Jamie Keating has suggested the Hudson United acquisition will add about one third to TD Banknorth's revenue and earnings, however work still needs to be done.

“The U.S. bank, while profitable on a run-rate basis, is still costing the bank in terms of restructuring charges and economic profit,” Keating wrote in a research note to clients.

Clark's attention to growth in the U.S. follows signals from Ottawa that new rules on mergers between Canada's banks are not one of the five main priorities for the minority Conservative government.

But he said changes still could and should be made that would allow Canada's banks to give out information about insurance products in branches, refer customers and market insurance products to customers who need it.

“The insurance industry would be better off and the consumer would be better off,” Clark said.

“This is a regulatory change. It is not a big thing. There's no public policy dispute on this. You bring in any expert and they'll all say, this is a no-brainer.”

TD Bank reported last month a first-quarter profit of $2.3 billion or $3.20 a diluted share, thanks to a huge gain from selling control of its U.S. retail brokerage. The profit compared with $630 million or 95 cents a year ago.

The bank's decision to sell TD Waterhouse Group Inc.'s U.S. retail brokerage business to on-line broker Ameritrade Holding Corp. resulted in a $1.67-billion after-tax gain.

__________________________________________________________
Reuters, Cameron French, 30 March 2006

Toronto-Dominion Bank said on Thursday it plans to stick with building its U.S. Northeast retail bank franchise despite a difficult profit environment in the sector.

"We're going to be prudent, we're not going to go do something stupid," chief executive Ed Clark told Reuters after the bank's annual meeting in Vancouver. "On the other hand, you have to sit there and say you do actually think there's a limited window of time here that you can go into the United States

"So we're hoping ... this tough environment will throw up things that are perfect for us strategically, at reasonable prices."

With domestic bank mergers currently not allowed, TD, Canada's No. 2 bank by assets, has focused its growth aspirations on the United States. It acquired a majority stake in Maine-based Banknorth last year and sold its Waterhouse USA discount broker to Ameritrade Holdings Inc. in exchange for an about one-third stake in the combined company.

Banknorth has since acquired New-Jersey-based Hudson United Bancorp, and Clark said he expects the U.S. retail franchise to have a market capitalization of $10 billion to $15 billion within five years.

Profits from Banknorth, however, have lagged expectations, prompting some analysts to question whether TD might alter its strategy.

Speaking to Reuters after the meeting, TD Banknorth chief executive William Ryan said he didn't expect much improvement in the U.S. business until 2007. The segment has suffered from the declining gap between -- and recent inversion of -- short- and long-term U.S. interest rates.

But he said the integration of Hudson United was going better than expected, and that Banknorth was already capable of going after other acquisition targets.

TD has been making money hand-over-fist from its domestic branch-banking business, and has also seen improved profit from its mutual fund business. While the bank has plenty of excess capital to handle acquisitions, Clark said he prefers to grow the fund business organically and use the capital to expand the bank's U.S. presence.

Speaking at the meeting, Clark also called for reforms in Canadian rules that prevent banks from selling most kinds of insurance through their branches.

The bank has had success in the sector with its profitable property and casualty insurer, Meloche Monnex.

Public bank policy discussions in Canada have largely focused on whether to allow mergers of big banks or "cross-pillar" mergers of banks and insurers.

But Clarke said that he doesn't expect much immediate progress on those fronts, and that rule-makers should focus on smaller changes, such as allowing banks to give information about insurance products through their branches, which they are currently not allowed to do.

"We're getting a clear message from the government that (mergers) are just not a priority," he said.

"The way we look at it is: can we tweak the rules?"
__________________________________________________________
Reuters, 30 March 2006

TD Banknorth's integration of recently acquired Hudson United Bancorp is going better than expected, and the bank is capable of handling more acquisitions immediately, its chief executive said on Thursday.

"I feel very comfortable with where we are with the Hudson United conversion that we could look at banks right now," TD Banknorth chief executive William Ryan told Reuters after the Toronto-Dominion Bank annual meeting.
;

29 March 2006

National Bank & CIBC at NBF Financial Services Conference

  
Canadian Press, Allan Swift, 29 March 2006

The CEO of National Bank of Canada says the Montreal-based bank is not overly exposed to Canada's flagging pulp and paper industry, which is concentrated in the province of Quebec.

Real Raymond told a banking conference Wednesday that most of the debt for that industry is held by secondary markets in the United States.

"Our exposure is very much under control," Raymond told analysts after giving a speech.

In any case, Raymond said, National Bank's overall corporate loan portfolio of all industries combined has shrunk to about $2.7 billion from $6 billion to $7 billion about five years ago.

Analysts say National Bank is vulnerable by having all its branches and most of its activities within Quebec, with the province's dependence on export-related manufacturing hurt by the rising Canada dollar.

But Raymond said the province's economy has done relatively well and is more stable even than Ontario, which is overly dependent on the volatile automotive sector.

Raymond said that in any case, his Quebec-based bank now gets 65 per cent of its revenue from business not related to lending. The growth has come in the growing areas of wealth-management products like mutual funds and insurance.

With the aging Canadian population, "revenue in wealth management will continue to grow at a fast pace," Raymond said.

The CEO said the bank sees a huge opportunity in selling its products through the financial advisers of its partners, called white label products because the consumer does not know the loan or other product comes from the bank.

National Bank has access to 8,000 third-party representatives, and Raymond said only 30 per cent of them have so far sold at least one of the bank's products.

"There's a huge opportunity there, we touch maybe five or six per cent of that client base overall," he said. "There is a lot more we can do with our partnerships."

Earlier, CIBC's chief executive Gerry McCaughey said the Toronto-based bank is ahead of its target to reduce its annual non-interest expenses by $250 million by the end of this fiscal year.

While CIBC's cost cutting in the first quarter put it on the road to passing the goal, McCaughey said the target is in the context of other banks also reducing their non-interest expenses, so the target may have to be raised.

He said CIBC wants to reach the median non-interest expense ratio of the other banks, or exceed it.

The $250-million target "should get us to the median; if not, that would mean our competitors have also improved their operations," he said.
;

Manulife Would Rather Acquire Than Increase Dividend Payouts

  
Bloomberg, 29 March 2006

Manulife Financial Corp. would rather spend excess cash on acquisitions than pay out more of its earnings in dividends, chief financial officer Peter Rubenovitch said. The company has "the flexibility to pursue any kind of options we would consider to be attractive to shareholders," he told investors yesterday at Montreal conference sponsored by National Bank Financial. Manulife raised the proportion of earnings paid to shareholders to as much as 35 per cent last year, from up to 30 per cent. Mr. Rubenovitch didn't name acquisition targets.
;

RBC to 'Reaccelerate' US Footprint in 2007

  
Canadian Press, 29 March 2006

RBC Financial Group plans to ramp up its presence in the United States - a market that has proved challenging in the past - with 15 to 20 new branches per year starting in 2007, says the head of its American operations.

Scott Custer, CEO of RBC Centura Banks Inc., made the remarks Wednesday during a presentation to a Canadian financial services conference in Montreal.

He said that planned reacceleration, primarily in the Atlanta and Florida markets, would follow "slowed expansion" in 2006 as the bank focuses "on key business development and operational initiatives."

Canada's largest bank, also known as Royal Bank of Canada, had already outlined those expansion plans after opening 10 U.S. branches in 2005 and 18 in 2004.

Royal Bank, however, has previously coped with operational challenges in the United States, with RBC Centura posting "disappointing" earnings in 2004.

That led the bank to exit its U.S. mortgage business - RBC Mortgage Co. - to focus on "high-growth client segments" such as businesses, business owners, professionals and commercial clients.

In 2005, it sold its U.S.-based RBC Mortgage and its 135 branches for an undisclosed price to a subsidiary of real estate trust New Century Financial Corp. of Irvine, Calif., marking its farewell from the cut-throat American national market for mortgage services.

Earlier this month, RBC president and CEO Gordon Nixon acknowledged those challenges when addressing shareholders at the bank's annual meeting, but said that shifted focus has resulted in strong growth of both consumer and commercial loans and deposits, while contributing to a "significant improvement" in RBC Centura's financial performance.
;

Cdn Banks Will Have to Deal with Significant Challenges in 2006

  
The Globe and Mail, Paul Waldie, 29 March 2006

Canada's big banks enjoyed stellar financial results in 2005, but they face several challenges in 2006 that could hurt profits, according to a report released yesterday by PricewaterhouseCoopers.

The big six banks chalked up more than $12-billion in combined profit last year, thanks largely to a strong Canadian economy, high commodity prices and low interest rates. Excluding one-time charges related to litigation costs at a couple of banks, the results were up 18.5 per cent from 2004, the report said.

However, rising interest rates, slower growth in lending and problems in the automobile industry are a few of the issues that could affect earnings this year, said the report entitled "Canadian Banks 2006."

"What we're saying is, we expect 2006 to be challenging for the banks," said Diana Chant, a partner in the consulting firm's Canadian financial services practice. "Lending absolutely does go in cycles, and things are not going to stay high forever."

The report noted that interest rates have been creeping up in Canada and the United States. Rising rates are usually not beneficial to banks because their interest-earning assets are long term and are typically funded by short-term liabilities. "Most economists are calling for continued increases in Canadian and U.S. interest rates throughout 2006 and sustained pressure on interest rate margins [at the banks] is anticipated by most, if not all, analysts," the report said.

The report also said household debt is at unprecedented highs, leaving little room for more consumer borrowing.

Canada's banks have enjoyed a stable credit environment in recent years but there are concerns about rising loan defaults, the report said. Problems at General Motors Corp. and Ford Motor Co., and the fallout to their suppliers, is already being felt in parts of Central Canada.

Soaring pension costs is another major issue for corporations and ultimately banks, Ms. Chant said.

"Some people have said that that is one of the biggest looming problems that we have in the business environment that will kind of hamper corporations," she said. "And when corporations are hampered, then lending and banks get implicated."

On the plus side, Canada's banks are seen likely to continue to benefit from strong commodity prices, which are expected to remain high this year.

As for possible bank mergers, the report said there were signs in 2005 that political opposition to mergers has softened. The election of a Conservative minority government could also hasten the release of merger guidelines, which have been delayed for months. The report noted that the largest Canadian bank, Royal Bank of Canada, ranked 32nd in the world in terms of market capitalization.

Ms. Chant said the merger issues have gone on for so long that most banks have reconciled themselves to looking elsewhere for growth.

"I think the banks themselves are coming out and getting beyond the question of mergers. They are sort of saying, 'Well, you know if it happens it happens, if it doesn't it doesn't. We've got our strategies we've got to keep going.' "

Savings plan

Canada's big banks have enjoyed a stable credit environment in recent years, but concerns about loan defaults are rising. As a result, many banks set aside more money last year to cover problem loans.
Total provisions (millions)Provisions as a % of loans
200320042005200320042005
BMO$455-$103$1790.31%-0.07%0.10%
Scotiabank 8933902300.490.210.11
CIBC1,1436287060.710.390.42
National 17786330.380.170.06
RBC7213464550.340.150.19
TD186-386550.13-0.250.03
Combined 3,5759611,6580.400.100.16

Source: PricewaterhouseCoopers

__________________________________________________________
Investment Executive, 28 March 2006

Although Canada’s top six banks enjoyed another record-breaking year in 2005, they will need to embrace change more than ever to meet the challenges of the coming year, according to the Canadian Banks 2006, PricewaterhouseCoopers’ (PwC) annual survey of the banking industry.

“The banks are certain to find 2006 challenging. The year likely holds continued margin pressure, slower growth in lending volumes and increases in credit provisions.” says Diana Chant, partner and leader of the PwC financial services practice in Canada. “It will be a challenge for banks to continue the record-breaking profits of the past few years.”

The Big Six earned a combined net income of over $12 billion and thrived in the strong Canadian economy. If not for litigation losses, aggregate results would have been over $16 billion, an increase of 18.5% over 2004.

“2005 was a banner year for Canadian banks. The economy provided a solid foundation for generating strong profits and the banks responded, delivering another year of outstanding results,” says Chant. “But behind this performance are governance, risk and compliance projects impacting the operations of all banks.”

These projects include the implementation of Sarbanes-Oxley 404 in 2006 for all but one of the Big Six. All banks are leading up to the implementation of the Basel Capital Accord and are also developing systems to manage the new accounting requirements for financial instruments. Added to this is the challenge of an uncertain U.S. economy and the negative consequences a slowdown south of the border would bring.

“Canadian banks and the rest of the world need a robust and growing U.S. economy,” says Chant. “Spending is already trending down in the U.S. With high consumer debt, large fiscal deficits and a weak North American auto industry, it is likely there will be a slowdown south of the border in 2006. 2005 was a great year for Canadian banks. The question now is: Where do they go from here?”

Change is the focus of Canadian Banks 2006, and the survey addressed several emerging trends and hot topics in the banking industry, including:

- sharpening client focus and progressive practices in segmentation;
- aligning governance, risk and compliance with the business agenda;
- operational tax risk;
- re-engineering processes;
- the outlook for economic capital in financial services;
- the new Canadian Financial Instruments Standards;
- 2005 accounting and reporting developments.
;