24 May 2006

Judge Approves Enron Bank's Settlement

  
Reuters, Matt Daily, 24 May 2006

A U.S. judge on Wednesday approved a $6.6 billion civil settlement by three banks accused by Enron Corp. shareholders of helping the company hide financial misdeeds that led to its collapse.

The settlements to be paid to former Enron shareholders include $2.4 billion from Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce , $2.2 billion from JP Morgan Chase and $2 billion from Citigroup. .

U.S. District Judge Melinda Harmon gave preliminary approval to the settlement with the three banks in February.

Including earlier settlements with firms such as Lehman Brothers and Bank of America , shareholders are now due to receive more than $7.2 billion of the $40 billion plaintiffs in the cases have claimed they lost in Enron's collapse.

The civil suit filed by shareholders against Enron, its banks and several former top executives including Ken Lay, Jeffrey Skilling and Andrew Fastow, is scheduled to start in October, according to lead shareholder attorney William Lerach.

Lay and Skilling are awaiting a verdict in their criminal trials on charges they lied to investors to hide financial chaos at the once-heralded energy company.

Lerach told reporters after the hearing that there was still no indication of whether several other banks included in the lawsuit would settle claims against them before the trial.

"It's radio silence at the moment," he said.

Lerach could not say when the payouts from the bank would reach shareholders, who watched their stock drop from a peak near $90 per share to zero with Enron's bankruptcy, but said the money would be paid "as soon as possible."

Interest of about $550,000 on the settlements was accruing on a daily basis, he said.

Those banks include Merrill Lynch , Barclays Plc., Credit Suisse First Boston, Toronto Dominion Bank, Royal Bank of Canada and Royal Bank of Scotland.

Numerous shareholder lawsuits were filed, with the University of California being named lead plaintiff.
;

Banks Set to Raise Dividends

  
Financial Post, Duncan Mavin, 24 May 2006

The banks are at the starting line for another earnings season, and analysts are predicting further dividend hikes -- at least in some cases.

Bank of Nova Scotia, National Bank and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce are all set to increase their quarterly payouts, said RBC Capital Markets analyst Jamie Keating in a note to clients.

CIBC, he noted, could push its quarterly dividend up 2 cents a share to 78 cents, the first increase "since the Enron capital-rebuild began," a reference to the bank's efforts to slash costs to cope with a big legal bill from 2005.

Mr. Keating also forecast National Bank could hike its quarterly dividend 2 cents, to 50 cents. "This may look conservative given the bank's relatively low payout," said Mr. Keating, "though we do anticipate potential for an earnings per share slowdown may rein in board enthusiasm for a higher increase."

Both Mr. Keating and Genuity Capital Markets analyst Mario Mendonca foresee a dividend increase at Bank of Nova Scotia. The bank has "materially slowed" the level of share repurchasing to 1.9 million shares in the second quarter of 2006, compared to an average of 5 million shares since fiscal 2005. That introduces "the possibility of a slightly larger dividend increase," Mr. Mendonca said in a note. Mr. Mendonca is forecasting Scotiabank will increase its quarterly dividend by 15% to 39 cents from 36 cents in the first quarter of 2006.

Meanwhile, Bank of Montreal, which reports its results today, Royal Bank of Canada, and Toronto-Dominion Bank "are 'off-cycle' having just hiked last quarter," when it comes to dividends, said Mr. Keating.
;

23 May 2006

Banks Face Margin Pressure

  
Lenders compete for deposits; Short-term interest rate rising

Canadian Press, Tara Perkins, 23 May 2006

As the big banks begin releasing their second-quarter earnings this week, one key factor to keep an eye on is high-interest rate savings accounts.

In the first quarter, Scotiabank, the Bank of Montreal and National Bank saw the margins on their Canadian retail loans squeezed.

"The common characteristic between these three banks is that they all offer a `no-strings attached' premium rate savings account," Genuity Capital Markets analyst Mario Mendonca wrote in a note to clients.

Banks make money on the margin between the interest they pay on deposits and the interest they receive on loans.

Looking to the second quarter, Mendonca said access to low-cost deposits will be increasingly important.

"With the majority of banks competing aggressively for retail loans (CIBC and Canadian Western Bank are the exceptions), the ability to effectively manage the deposit side of the net interest margin equation has become a key differentiator, particularly since the Bank of Canada started raising short-term rates in September," Mendonca wrote.

While he rates CIBC a sell, he noted that its push on variable-rate mortgages, combined with its "less aggressive" premium-rate savings account, should help its margins during the quarter.

The banks won't reveal how successful high-rate accounts have been in capturing new customers.

Last week, HSBC Bank Canada, which is not considered one of the big banks, launched a high-rate savings account.

Customer reaction has been "very positive," chief executive Lindsay Gordon said.

"All banks are looking for ways to grow their deposits," he said. "The deposits are the raw material with which we make loans. We want to raise more deposits, and secondly we believe there is a strong and growing demand from Canadians for what we call high-interest savings."

Gordon said HSBC is "certainly prepared to be pretty aggressive in this space," adding that he expects to raise attention from the big banks.

"I think you've got to be competitive, and how high a rate you're willing to pay over the competition will obviously influence how much market share you gain," he said.

Scotiabank managing director of term deposits and day-to-day banking, Gillian Riley, said "we feel that this product enhances relationships with our customers, encourages growth, banking deposits and customer retention."

The market will be watching the banks' second-quarter earnings closely.

Bank stocks have become cheaper lately.

"Over the last three months, the banks were the worst performing sub-group on the S&P/TSX, down 6.5 per cent and even underperforming the technology sector," Mendonca said in his note last week.

Much of the stock losses can be attributed to the amount of investor funds flowing into the resource sector, and to speculation that the Federal Reserve and Bank of Canada will continue to raise rates, Mendonca said.
;

22 May 2006

Eyes on Bank Earnings

  
Canadian Press, Rita Trichur, 22 May 2006

Canada's six biggest banks are poised to deliver low double-digit earnings growth on a year-over-year basis when they report their second-quarter earnings over the next two weeks.

And while it is shaping up to be another quarter of solid results, analysts will be watching closely for any deterioration in credit quality and the performance of their capital markets divisions.

“We are looking for median core earnings-per-share growth of 12 per cent year-over-year, with Royal Bank of Canada at the head of the pack and Scotiabank at the end,” said Andre-Philippe Hardy of Merrill Lynch, noting stronger-than-expected capital markets activity is expected bolster profits.

“Sequentially, we expect a three per cent median core EPS (earnings per share) decline, with only Bank of Montreal's three per cent increase being positive.”

The second-quarter earnings season runs between May 24 and June 1, with Bank of Montreal kicking off the financial reports.

It will be followed by a double-header May 25, featuring TD Bank and National Bank of Canada.

Royal Bank will report May 26, with Scotiabank disclosing May 29, leaving CIBC to cap off the season on June 1.

Consensus analyst estimates for second-quarter earnings per share, according to Thomson Financial:

— BMO: $1.21, up 11 per cent from a year ago.
— TD: $1.13, up 13 per cent.
— National Bank: $1.20, up 11 per cent.
— Royal Bank: 82 cents, up 18 per cent.
— Scotiabank: 84 cents, up 10 per cent.
— CIBC: $1.56, up 10 per cent.

But the headline earnings tell just part of the story. Analysts say they will also be monitoring the financial results for higher provisions for credit losses, or PCLs, on residential mortgages, unsecured loans and credit cards in the banks' mainstay retail operations.

“Although interest rates are moving higher, employment in the Canadian economy remains so strong that it would be unreasonable to expect retail PCLs to have increased,” said Mario Mendonca, an analyst with Genuity Capital Markets.

There are two banks in particular that he'll be monitoring with respect to consumer credit quality — CIBC and Royal Bank.

CIBC is the country's largest credit-card operator and has a higher PCL ratio than its peers. Last quarter, its retail loan losses were “surprisingly low” and analysts are hopeful that trend will continue in the February-to-April period.

Royal Bank, meanwhile, has shown strong growth in both credit-card loans and unsecured lending.

“And if there are two areas where you might see a bit of a crack early on — if and when the credit environment softens — it would be in those two loan categories,” Mr. Mendonca said.

Tom Kersting, a financial services analyst with brokerage Edward Jones, said that while credit losses remain low, ultimately that trend will turn as credit quality returns to more normalized levels.

“I think it will probably happen sometime this year, likely in the second half,” he said.

Analysts are also forecasting healthy growth in trading revenues from capital markets activity.

“The year-over-year improvement in trading volumes was about 40 per cent on the TSX,” Mr. Mendonca said.

“All of the banks have good exposure to equity market trading revenues, so I would suspect that we're going to see equity market trading revenues look pretty good across the group.”
;

19 May 2006

Why Bank Stocks are Cash Machines

  
With their high yields and low P/Es, they offer the potential for solid long-term gains with little risk.

Fortune, Shawn Tully, 19 May 2006

In a world that's buzzing over the Internet's raging return and the dollar play in Asian equities, it's hard to believe that the best place to invest may well be bank stocks.

Try not to yawn. Bank stocks aren't boring, they just look that way. You might say they're so colorless they're colorful. Why? Because what they lack in glamour they more than make up in compelling numbers.

The story comes in two parts. First, the biggest banks, from Citigroup to Wachovia, are paying rich dividends and are likely to increase them steadily, practically guaranteeing double-digit returns far into the future. Second, regional banks and thrifts are prime takeover candidates as the giants rush to expand - witness Wachovia's $26 billion deal for Golden West Financial.

Says Goldman Sachs analyst Lori Appelbaum: "Bank stocks don't look sexy until you look at the potential returns."

For investors, the big diversified banks offer a rare combination: juicy yields plus significant earnings growth. And even though big-bank stocks are up 7 percent this year, they still sell at bargain prices.

It's a neat package. The five largest U.S. banks are Citi, Bank of America, J.P. Morgan Chase, Wachovia, and Wells Fargo. For the moment we'll set J.P. Morgan aside, because it's the one huge bank that's not yet highly profitable (though it's getting there). The four remaining players boast an average dividend yield of 3.6 percent. That's twice the yield of the S&P and not too far behind the three-year Treasury yield of 4.9 percent.

And while interest rates are just as likely to fall as to rise, the beauty of dividends is that they tend to keep growing. Since dividends are paid from earnings, they typically increase in step with profits. Over the past four years the big banks (again, excluding J.P. Morgan) have raised earnings at double-digit rates.

Result: BofA's dividend has jumped 14 percent a year since 2001, while Wells' has posted annual increases of 19 percent.

But wait - there's more! Let's take a cautious stance. We'll project that the big banks' earnings growth averages to 8 percent over the next seven years, far below the recent level. So dividends should also grow at 8 percent.

The banks, though, offer an added treat. While paying out around 46 percent of their annual profits in dividends, they're typically using another 20 percent or so of their earnings to buy back stock. It's a safe bet that they'll keep buying back about 1.5 percent of their shares annually. Since both earnings and dividends will be spread across fewer shares each year, the dividends per share will rise not by 8 percent a year, but by more like 9.5 percent.

By the way, these numbers tell a powerful story about banking. The banks are using two-thirds of their profits to pay dividends and buy back stock, which means they're retaining only one-third to invest in growing their business. But that's all they need, because banks generate huge returns, both on the capital they already have and on the new money flowing in as retained earnings.

The proof: On average, the four most profitable big banks boast a sumptuous return on equity of 16.5 percent over the past five years, vs. an average of 12 percent for stocks in the S&P 500.

The payoff

Now let's get back to the payoff for investors. You're starting with a 3.6 percent dividend. It's rising at almost 10 percent a year. Those increases should far outstrip inflation. So in 2012, you'll be receiving 6.8 percent, not 3.6 percent, on your original investment, and the payouts will ratchet upward from there.

But wait - there's even more! The dividend payments are just part of your return. If earnings per share keep rising at 9.5 percent annually, the banks' stock prices will increase at the same rate (assuming the relatively low price/earnings multiples remain constant). Your returns should start in the 13 percent range - the 3.5 percent current dividend plus a 9.5 percent capital gain. But in seven years, thanks to the ever-growing dividend, that number should surpass 15 percent.

J.P. Morgan has the potential to deliver even greater returns. To buy the stock now, you have to believe that new CEO Jamie Dimon will be able to turn the bank around (and we do - see "The Contender"). If that comeback happens, the dividend - and the stock price - could soar.

Unlike its big rivals, J.P. Morgan hasn't increased its dividend in five years, chiefly because it's been saddled with weak earnings. Dimon has been expanding in lucrative areas like credit cards and energy and mortgage-backed security trading to increase profitability. If those moves manage to raise J.P. Morgan's ROE from 8 percent to its peers' 16.5 percent average, the dividend will double along with earnings, giving investors who got in early an enormous yield of around 6 percent as well as a big capital gain.

The risks

Is there any risk in these equations? Of course. J.P. Morgan's comeback could stall, and the other banks' share prices could flatten or drop, saddling investors with little more than the single-digit returns provided by dividends. That's possible, but unlikely.

The reason: Bank stocks still look cheap. On average, Citi, BofA, Wells, and Wachovia have P/Es of just 12.4. That's far lower than the multiples in the other big-dividend-paying sectors - pharmaceuticals, utilities, and telecom - even though the banks' earnings are growing just as fast as profits in those three industries. In fact, it's more probable that banking multiples will rise to the 15 or so that prevails in the other big-dividend sectors, adding a big kicker for shareholders.

Investors can play the banking market a second way, by predicting which regional and smaller banks and thrifts the big boys are likely to buy. Today retail banking is highly fragmented: The big five control just 28 percent of nationwide deposits.

"We'll see tremendous consolidation in the industry in the next few years," says Meredith Whitney, an analyst with CIBC World Markets.

The key is geography. Several of the giants have gaps in their footprints. J.P. Morgan and Citi, for example, need to establish big footholds in Florida and California, while Wachovia covets more branches in the West.

Among the best candidates: SunTrust, which is a powerhouse in Florida and Georgia, where Citi and J.P. Morgan need to grow. PNC is a major player in Pennsylvania and New Jersey, which are among the nation's wealthiest markets. U.S. Bancorp boasts a solid franchise in the Pacific Northwest, California, and Colorado. Washington Mutual would hand a buyer 2,200 branches across the country, including a strong presence in California.

Watch the banks. As a famous bank robber put it, that's where the money is.
;

Q2 2006 Earnings Reports Start Next Week

  
The Globe and Mail, Allan Robinson, 19 May 2006

Investors in Canada's Big Five chartered banks will be poring over second-quarter results during the next two weeks after seeing share prices drop from record levels since March.

The drop in those prices has created a buying opportunity because the banks are expected to report strong profit growth, analysts say.

The largest Canadian banks alone account for more than 16 per cent of the S&P/TSX by market capitalization and if the two largest life insurers (Manulife Financial Corp. and Sun Life Financial Inc.) are included, the seven financial giants account for almost 23 per cent of the index.

On a year-to-date basis, the financial sector is up only 0.05 per cent, after ringing up a gain of 16.7 per cent during the past 12 months.

The 6-per-cent drop in bank shares during the past two months reflects a weak stock market and interest rate worries, said Jason Bilodeau, an analyst with UBS Securities Canada Inc. "Heading into what should be a generally positive second-quarter news flow, we see room for upside," he said.

Profit-reporting season gets under way on Wednesday with Bank of Montreal scheduled to report, followed by Toronto-Dominion Bank and National Bank of Canada on Thursday and the Royal Bank of Canada on Friday. Bank of Nova Scotia is scheduled to report its results on May 29 and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce on June 1.

According to Thomson First Call, analysts forecast second-quarter 2006 earnings for BMO of $1.21, compared with $1.09 a year earlier; $1.13 for TD Bank, compared with $1; $1.20 for National Bank, compared with $1.08; 82 cents for RBC, compared with 70 cents; 84 cents for Scotiabank, compared with 76 cents; and $1.56 for CIBC, compared with $1.41.

This week UBS Securities increased its ratings on RBC, Scotiabank and TD to "buys" from the "neutral" ratings.

"Canadian bank valuations compared to their international peers have not been compelling in recent quarters," according to a report by Susan Cohen, an analyst with Dundee Securities Corp. "However, this valuation gap narrowed materially in early May, owing to a correction in Canadian bank stocks and a rally in U.S. bank stocks," she said.

The share price decline provides investors with a chance to buy banks in advance of what is expected to be a reasonably good second-quarter profit reporting season, Ms. Cohen said.

The recent decline in bank shares has shaved a full multiple point off of their forward price-to-earnings multiples to 11.7 from 12.8, according to CIBC World Markets Inc.

However, some analysts are expecting a slowdown in profit and dividend growth in the second half of fiscal 2006 and into 2007 as loan growth slows and credit costs increase.
;

BMO Looks to Leverage China IPO Win

  
The Globe and Mail, Sinclair Stewart, 19 May 2006

Bank of Montreal, flush with the success of landing a piece of China's largest initial public offering so far, is opening an investment banking office in Beijing next month to compete for more underwriting assignments.

Last Friday, BMO learned it was one of six global firms awarded a mandate to lead a $10-billion (U.S.) IPO for Bank of China, the country's second-biggest financial institution. BMO is the only Canadian investment bank participating in the IPO, although sources confirmed that it was not the only domestic bank that pitched for an underwriting assignment.

And with good reason. The fees on the deal are expected to reach $250-million, and will be largely divvied up by Goldman Sachs and UBS AG, which are leading the offering. Even so, a smaller slice is expected to be very lucrative for BMO, which has been building up goodwill in China for decades now, and has developed deep relationships with both government and banking officials.

Now that it has been stamped with the imprimatur of the Bank of China, BMO is hoping to parlay its IPO assignment into new business from other Chinese companies looking to test the public markets.

"Once you have this kind of assignment from a prestigious institution like Bank of China, there's no question in our minds that it's a very strong signal that we are recognized as a firm that can deliver globally and can help Chinese institutions," said Yvan Bourdeau, chief executive officer of investment banking arm BMO Nesbitt Burns Inc. "I would think when additional IPOs are coming to the market, when we make our pitch to them we will certainly stress to what extent we were involved with this transaction."

The real question, though, is how investors will fare. Two other Chinese state-owned banks, China Construction Bank Corp. and Bank of Communications Ltd., have gone public recently and both have enjoyed considerable success. Shares of China Construction, the industry's No. 3 player, are up approximately 50 per cent since the company filed a $9.2-billion IPO last year. Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, meanwhile, the No. 1 bank, is expected to unveil a $12-billion offering this fall.

The fascination with Chinese bank stocks is driven by the assumption that they present a simple way to cash in on the country's thriving economy. Yet the banking industry remains dogged by questions surrounding its financial health and transparency.

For decades, Chinese banks were viewed as lumbering, inefficient cash registers for the government, and their heavy lending to state-run enterprises left them with a crushing burden of bad loans.

The Chinese government has injected tens of billions of dollars into its major banks to help fix their balance sheets and prepare them for competition with their Western counterparts. It has also eased ownership restrictions and allowed foreign entrants to take minority ownership stakes in Chinese banks.

The government says the underperforming loans have been whittled down to $137-billion, a figure some critics argue is too low.

Mr. Bourdeau conceded that these banks are still working through their loan book issues, but said he is confident the country has put in place the right programs to address the problem. In addition to government aid, he said the banks are benefiting from a new generation of managers, many of whom did their formal training in the United States and other Western countries.

BMO will be selling its portion of the Bank of China IPO to Canadian investors, most of which will be institutional. Mr. Bourdeau noted that Canada has a large Chinese population that is familiar with the bank, and said this could provide a retail opportunity for BMO.

Its fledgling investment banking operation will have a staff of three people who will look for financing or underwriting opportunities with Chinese companies. When they compete for business, the bank will fly in a group of international bankers to meet with clients and assist with the pitch.

BMO already has a wealth management operation in China through its minority stake in Fullgoal Fund Management Co., and was the first Canadian bank to be granted a licence to accept deposits in local currency at one of its Chinese branches. It expects to receive a second licence by the end of 2006.
;

18 May 2006

Money in the Banks: Time to Buy the Big 5?

  
Canadian Press, Gary Norris, 18 May 2006

Diversification is the mantra of the prudent investor, but if you were hypothetically limited to just one stock-market holding, what would it be?

You'd hope for a solid if not spectacular long-term return, probably with a reliable income component on top of share-price gains. You'd also want as little risk as possible.

If you think nothing like this exists outside the Twilight Zone, then submitted for your consideration are ... Canadian bank stocks.

With a single investment, thousands of highly trained people work to maximize your return on equity, in a vast enterprise ranging from credit cards and car loans to industrial finance, investment dealing and the far frontiers of trading in commodities, currencies and derivatives.

And while equity mutual funds typically charge at least two per cent a year to manage your money, the banks - which incidentally operate many of the country's largest funds - pay dividends worth three per cent or more, and have a long record of increasing those payouts.

For investors who like to sleep soundly at night, all the big Canadian banks are solidly capitalized and use sophisticated risk-management techniques.

They also tend to recover adroitly from miscues: CIBC shares, for instance, tumbled from over $80 to under $70 last August after $2.8 billion in Enron-related charges, but revived to hit $86 in March and currently trade in the $82 range.

For the record, this is up from $23 a decade ago, representing a compound annual return of 13.6 per cent, not counting dividends.

The biggest bank, the Royal boasts a 10-year compound annual stock-price gain of 19 per cent, compared with 18 per cent for Scotiabank, 17 per cent for Toronto-Dominion and 14 per cent for Bank of Montreal.

"They're not going to run up $4 or $5 a share in a day . . . it's a more subdued sector," observes Fred Ketchen, director of equity trading at Scotiabank's Scotia Capital division.

However, "If I was going to buy one stock, it would be a major bank," Ketchen says.

"The reason for that would be their record of growth, and their record of dividends. I think that over the last 10 years every bank, except TD which just missed one year, has increased its dividend at least once every year."

That's not to say bank shares are bulletproof.

"If you go back to the first part of 1998, the bank index in general was down 47 per cent over a six-month period," says Tom Kersting, a financial services analyst at Edward Jones in St. Louis.

"They can go down, they do go down, and they don't always snap right back - when they went down the 47 per cent in 1998 it took 18 months just to get back to break-even."

John Kinsey of Caldwell Securities notes that the past three or four years have been a golden age for the banks, thanks to low interest rates, solid economic growth and small loan losses.

Now their profit growth is slowing, Kinsey says, and he expects annual percentage price gains for bank stocks to decline from the high double digits to the high single digits, which including dividends would be "a little over 10 per cent or so - and that's not too bad, considering the (low) risk."

In fact, it doubles your money in seven years or less.

As for the risks, "clearly the economy and interest rates are the short-term variables that tend to impact the bank stocks as much or more than any other sector," says Kersting.

He recently removed "buy" ratings from the five biggest Canadian banks, rating them all "hold."

"We still think they're fabulous companies; however, we think that the stocks got a little ahead of themselves and were pretty pricey."

Since Edward Jones shifted its sectoral call to "neutral" in March, the sector has pulled back, with Scotiabank and BMO down by as much as 10 per cent.

"I still think the stocks are toward the upper end of their historical valuation levels," Kersting said.

But for Scotia's Ketchen, the recent decline suggests "this would probably be a good time to pick your favourite bank" ahead of their quarterly earnings reports, which begin May 24.

Merrill Lynch analyst Andre-Philippe Hardy recently raised his estimates for the quarter. But Hardy also warned that historically high price multiples, now about 12 times expected annual earnings, are "unlikely to expand," and he rates all five big banks "neutral."

Regardless of near-term fluctuations, Ketchen declares: "I'm going to live with the banks because they have treated me well for 25 years and I don't know what's going to make them stop."

As Kersting observes: "They're very well run companies. They're large, they're well capitalized, diversified for the most part. Long term, for the financial services industry there are some favourable drivers," including the needs of aging baby boomers and new opportunities in a globalizing economy.

And whatever happens, bank shares pay an unquantifiable psychological benefit: the more you detest getting nickel-dimed by account fees, the happier you'll be as a part-owner of the bank.
;

World's Top 10 Banks, by Assets (2004)

  
The Economist, Robert Cottrell, 18 May 2006

Borrowing and lending has become a fairly well-understood line of business, and a fairly well-managed one most of the time in most of the world. It is the banks themselves that are volatile, shifting shapes and strategies as furiously as their regulators will allow them in their efforts to win markets and market share. In China they are escaping state captivity by selling shares to foreigners and stockmarket investors. In Russia they are running wild, with balance sheets growing by 30-40% a year. In Japan three new “megabanks” have eaten 11 old banks and are now digesting them. In central Europe foreigners have bought or built 80% of the top local banks since the fall of communism.

In America the ten biggest commercial banks control 49% of the country's banking assets, up from 29% a decade ago. They are pausing for breath now, after a long merger binge encouraged by the deregulation of interstate banking and the removal of barriers between banks, insurance companies and securities firms. Non-financial companies are not meant to own banks, but even that is now being tested by America's biggest retailer, Wal-Mart, which wants a restricted banking licence.

This survey of commercial banking around the world is much preoccupied by questions of size and of ownership. Almost everywhere, big banks have been getting bigger through mergers and acquisitions as well as through organic growth. Is there a natural limit to this process of bank-eat-bank? Could the biggest bank of tomorrow be two or three or even ten times the size of a Citibank or an HSBC today, and if not, why not? And who benefits? It is not always the surviving bank's shareholders. One-half of recent bank mergers around the world have destroyed shareholder value, says Philippe De Backer, a partner in Bain & Co, a consulting firm. In America it is medium-sized banks that are prized most highly by the stockmarkets, partly because investors expect them to be bought dearly by the big banks.

One argument commonly used in favour of mergers, in banking as in many other industries, is the pursuit of economies of scale in areas such as procurement, systems, operations, research and marketing. But the gains from that in the mass production of financial services, though not necessarily illusory, can be elusive. There is a sizeable literature of academic papers claiming that economies of scale can be exhausted by the time a bank reaches a relatively modest size. A study of European banks in the 1990s, published by the European Investment Bank, put the figure for savings banks as low as €600m ($760m) in assets. More recent studies suggest far higher thresholds, up to $25 billion.

Big banks might even dispute that there is a limit at all. But at some point diseconomies of scale will also start creeping in. Management will find it harder and harder to aggregate and summarise everything that is going on in the bank, opening the way to the duplication of expense, the neglect of concealed risks and the failure of internal controls. Something of that last problem afflicted the world's biggest bank holding company, Citigroup, in 2002-05, when it was rocked by a string of compliance problems. America's Federal Reserve reacted by telling Citigroup to suspend large acquisitions, but lifted the order in April this year when it judged that the company had got better controls in place.

Another argument commonly made for mergers is based on economies of scope, the proposition that related lines of business under the same ownership or management can share resources and create opportunities for one another. The basic economy of scope common to almost all banks is the taking of deposits on one hand and the making of loans on the other. The bank gets to re-use its depositors' money profitably. The skills and information useful on one side of the business tend to be useful on the other side too.

But does the same hold good when a retail bank is paired with, say, a corporate bank, an investment-banking division, a credit-card processor, an asset-management operation, private banking (for rich people), an insurance business or a foreign branch network? These businesses all overlap with one another to some degree, but so do lots of other businesses. The fashion for industrial conglomerates came and went 30 years ago. Will financial conglomerates be any more enduring? The bank holding companies that are building them clearly believe so.

A third reason for banks to pursue growth through mergers and acquisitions is one that is never used as an argument at the time, but is universally recognised as a factor. It is managerial ambition (which includes managerial error). Chief executives want the gratification of running a bigger company, or they fear that their own company will be taken over unless they grab another one first.

Managers can argue that the business environment is changing rapidly and that banks must seize the new market opportunities created by new technology or national deregulation or economic globalisation. Thus there is much talk in Europe now of a fresh wave of cross-border mergers and acquisitions within the 25 countries of the European Union, encouraged by the single European currency, the deepening Single European Market and the enlargement of the EU into central and eastern Europe. Shareholders may be the more easily persuaded because a takeover tends to look good at the time. The buyer books the new revenues immediately and cuts some overlapping costs. The acquisition premium goes straight to goodwill. It is only later that you find out whether the businesses are a good long-term fit.

And perhaps growth-hungry CEOs are wiser than their students and their critics know. The very big banks created in America over the past ten years have not been stellar stockmarket performers recently, but they may just be taking time to bed down and knit their management and computer systems more closely together. Their future results may transform the current wisdom about economies of scale.

Bigness may also have benefits not easily captured in studies of financial performance. One is the ability to place strategic bets on future markets, such as China, without putting the whole bank at risk. Another is regulatory capture, or the ability of the regulatee to influence the regulator. The bigger the bank, the more likely its home-country regulators and legislators will be to take its interests into account when drafting new rules, and the more likely they will be to judge it “too big to fail” in the event of a crisis.

Not, of course, that banks these days fold as often as they used to, which is another reason why strong banks go shopping. Weak banks no longer fall into their laps, at least in Europe and America. Banks fail less often, partly because external conditions have been kinder. Developed economies around the world have become more stable over the past 20-30 years, save for Japan in the 1990s. Big shocks in the financial markets have become rarer and better managed. Recent medium-sized shocks, such as the downgrading of General Motors' credit rating last year, have been relatively easily absorbed. The financial markets have moved, you might say, from being a source of shocks to being shock absorbers too.

Such stability may engender its own instability if it encourages everyone to take on more risk in the belief that disasters are less likely to happen. But give credit, until then, where credit is due. Benign economic conditions have encouraged stable banks, and vice versa. Bankers and regulators in much of the world have arrived together at a pretty good model of how commercial banks ought to be run. Pressured by the demands of the capital markets for efficiency and predictability, they have also been pretty good about sticking to the rules and so avoiding catastrophic mistakes.

A version of that modern banking model is enshrined in a new set of rules, running to about 700 pages, that tell banks how they should weigh their risks, and how much capital they should keep on hand in case things go wrong. Big banks in most developed banking markets will be adopting the new rules, known as Basel 2, starting with the European Union next year. But America is hesitating. Some critics there think that the Basel 2 rules are at once too lax and too complicated; others think they discriminate too much between big and small banks.

One safe prediction is that Basel 2 and its risk-modelling methods will make banks even harder to understand than they are already. Ask a banker to explain risk management or credit derivatives or capital allocation to you, and the algebra will soon be spilling off the blackboard. The opacity of banks may count against them with investors. Mercer Oliver Wyman, a strategic and risk-management consultancy, says that publicly listed financial-services companies around the world were valued last year at an average of 14 times their profits, against a multiple of 18 for non-financial companies. But the discount has been shrinking, suggesting both that investors have got more optimistic about relative growth prospects for financial services, and that they think bankers have got better at banking, turning it into a generally less risky business.

This survey broadly agrees on both points. It considers the state of competition and consolidation in the developed markets of America, Europe and Japan. It looks at the big emerging markets of China, India and Russia, where the global winners and losers of the future may be decided. (China alone may account for over 25% of new global demand for financial services in the coming five years, says Alain LeCouedic, a partner at Boston Consulting Group.) It pauses to consider the intricacies of Basel 2, the virtues of pure investment banks and the cost of a Brazilian overdraft before drawing a conclusion which can be briefly summarised here: better banks tend to get bigger, but bigger banks are not necessarily better.

;

Scotia Capital Preview of Cdn Banks Q2 2006 Earnings

  
Scotia Capital, 18 May 2006

Earnings Growth 11% YOY - Led by RY and TD

• Our second quarter earnings estimates are highlighted in Exhibit 1. Second quarter bank earnings are expected to be up 11% year over year but down 5.4% sequentially from a very strong first quarter. RY and TD are expected to lead in earnings growth at 15% and 13%, respectively, driven by the strength of their retail and wealth management platforms as well as their insurance businesses.

• Profitability is expected to continue to run at historical highs on very large capital positions. Return on equity is expected to remain high at 19.5%.

• Retail banking earnings are expected to be solid with continued strong volume growth, cost control and a stable net interest margin although the second quarter has fewer days which trims earnings 1% - 2% versus the first quarter.

• Wealth management earnings are also expected to be strong although only three banks disclose these earnings on a separate basis. Bank mutual assets grew 20% year over year and banks captured 51% of total industry net sales during the fiscal second quarter. RY, TD and BMO have been the dominate players in mutual funds.

• Wholesale banking earnings are expected to be supported by strong capital markets revenue given the sequential increase in the number and size of equity underwritings. Fees from new equity issues are estimated to have increased 70% sequentially in the second quarter with RY and BMO experiencing the largest increases. Trading revenue is expected to be strong with S&P/TSX average daily trading volumes up 13% and trading values up 10% quarter over quarter. However, trading revenues are expected to be weaker than the record first quarter levels.

• Consensus earnings estimates and share price targets are highlighted in Exhibit 3.

Interest Rates and Retail Net Interest Margin

• The prime rate increased 50 basis points (bp) in fiscal Q2/06 following a 50 bp increase in fiscal Q1/06. (Exhibit 12) Short term interest rates have now increased 150 bp or 35% in 9 months. While these increases in short term rates are positive for compression reversal , the retail net interest margin, which was stable in Q1 (Exhibit 9), has yet to show any real improvement on the back of these rate hikes due in part to the 120 day rate guarantees on mortgages, lag impact, and competition.

• We expect retail net interest margin to remain stable in Q2/06 with margin expansion being pushed out until rates stabilize which is expected over the next six to twelve months.

Appreciation of CAD Reduces Bank Book Values by 7% - Fiscal 2003-2005

• The appreciation of the CAD against the USD has been a drag on the banks' foreign currency earnings which are mainly in U.S. dollars, with the exception of BNS (which has material earnings in Pesos and Caribbean currencies).

• In addition, the bank group's book value has been reduced as the banks have incurred foreign exchange translation losses on their net foreign currency investments. Translation losses for the banks from fiscal 2003 to 2005 totalled $18.2 billion. However, the banks hedge their foreign currency investments to varying degrees with the book value impact reduced to $6.3 billion through hedging, net of taxes. Thus, the appreciation of the CAD in fiscal 2003 through fiscal 2005 reduced banks' common shareholders equity or book value by $6.3 billion or 7%, with BNS absorbing the largest impact with a 13% reduction in book value (Exhibit 17).

• National Bank has 95% of its businesses and activities in CAD thus foreign exchange translation losses are not material. The most aggressive bank in hedging its foreign currency investments appears to be CIBC with hedges offsetting more than 90% of its translation losses.

• BMO, RY, and TD's hedging activities have offset approximately 65% of translation losses with BNS at the lower end at 45%. Hedging activity at BNS is less due to the difficulty and impracticality of hedging some Caribbean (soft) currencies as opposed to the USD.

• In the first quarter of 2006 foreign exchange translation losses net of hedging and taxes were $670 million, a further 0.8% reduction in book value based on 3.8% appreciation (spot) in the CAD. The CAD has appreciated a further 1.9% in Q2/06 with a guesstimate of a further $300 million reduction in book value CAD Appreciation Strongest in Fiscal 2003

• The major CAD appreciation (spot) actually occurred in fiscal 2003 with an 18% increase, with fiscal 2004 at 8%, and fiscal 2005 a modest 3%. However the CAD has increased momentum versus the USD appreciating 7% in the first six months of fiscal 2006 as at April 30, 2006.

• If the CAD was to appreciate to par with the USD this would represent a further 10% appreciation from the current exchange rate. Thus, it would appear that the major appreciation of the CAD has already occurred.

Earnings Sensitivity to Appreciation in CAD

• In fiscal Q2/06, the CAD appreciated 1.5% (based on average exchange rates, which are used to translate net income). Assuming no hedging, the impact on second quarter earnings is estimated from a negative 0.07% for National Bank to a negative 0.6% for Scotia (Exhibit 20)

• The negative impact in fiscal Q3/06 is expected to be greater as the CAD has already appreciated $0.03 to $0.04 or 3.5% - 4.0% from the Q2/06 average exchange rate.

• On an annual basis, the negative impact on earnings of a $0.05 appreciation in the CAD, assuming no hedging, is estimated at 2.3% for BNS, 1.8% for CM, 1.6% for BMO, 1.4% for RY, 1.3% for TD, and 0.3% at NA (Exhibit 21). The actual impact is expected to be less as some banks do hedge their foreign currency earnings.

Dividend Increases Expected from BNS and NA

• We expect BNS and NA to announce dividend increases in the 5% to 7% range (Exhibit 5). This follows on dividend increases by RY, BMO, and TD of 12.5%, 8.2%, and 4.8%, respectively, in the first quarter.

• Bank of Montreal is expected to report $1.20 per share, an 11% YOY increase. We expect the bank will be challenged to repeat the record level of trading revenue it recorded in the first quarter. BMO's retail NIM declined 12 bp in Q1/06 and we expect continued weakness relative to the bank group. BMO appears to be positioned for declining as opposed to increasing interest rates which could have a negative impact on its NIM in the quarter. BMO appears to be the only bank with this interest rate positioning. We expect stronger equity underwriting revenues while Harris earnings growth is expected to remain sluggish and further hampered by the strong CAD.

• Bank of Nova Scotia is expected to report $0.80 per share, a 5% increase YOY. A strong Canadian dollar will continue to mute the bank's earnings growth from Mexico and the Caribbean. Retail NIM at BNS declined 11 bp in the first quarter although the overall net interest margin was stable. The bank cited transfer pricing as the reason for the weak retail NIM performance. The sharp rise in interest rates magnified the impact of the banks' transfer pricing mechanism. The banks' smaller wealth management platform will hurt its relative earnings momentum versus RY and TD. A large unrealized security surplus provides for sustainable security gains. A dividend increase of 5.6% to $1.52 per share is expected.

• Canadian Imperial Bank is expected to report $1.55 per share, a 10% increase from a year earlier. The bank was well positioned for rising interest rates in Q1 and benefited probably the most of any bank. The bank is also well positioned going into Q2. CIBC enjoyed accelerated cost saves in Q1 that are unlikely to be fully available in Q2 and loan loss provisions may rise again. CIBC's equity underwriting was strong in the quarter.

• National Bank is expected to report earnings of $1.17 per share, an 8% increase from a year earlier. The bank needs to continue to generate strong trading and capital markets revenue. The bank was reliant on high security gain levels in Q1. Retail bank performance was disappointing in Q1 due to higher costs. Wealth management earnings should remain very strong. A dividend increase of 6.3% to $2.04 per share is expected.

• Royal Bank is expected to report $0.80 per share, a 15% YOY increase. Retail and wealth management earnings are expected to remain solid, supported by strong insurance earnings and equity underwriting revenue.

• Toronto Dominion Bank is expected to report $1.13 per share, a 13% YOY increase. Retail and wealth management earnings at TD are expected to remain the earnings drivers, supported by strong insurance earnings. TD Ameritrade (strong) and TD Banknorth (weak) contributed approximately $0.06 per share and $0.09 per share, respectively to TD's Q2/06 earnings.

Recent Events

BMO - Robert Pearce Resigns

• On May 8th, BMO announced the resignation of Robert Pearce, head of Canadian Personal and Commercial Banking. Bill Downe, COO of BMO, will lead the group until a replacement is found.

BNS - Investments in Latin America and Acquisition of Maple Trust

• On March 9th, BNS completed the purchase of two Peruvian banks - Banco Wiese Sudameris (BWS) and Banco Sudamericano (BSA) - for a total investment of C$390
million. BNS intends to merge the two to form the third largest bank in Peru.

• On April 3rd, BNS closed the deal to buy Maple Trust Company, the mortgage lending business of Maple Financial Group.

• On April 18th, BNS announced the acquisition of Citibank's retail banking operations in the Dominican Republic.

• It was reported on May 10th that BNS was in discussions to buy a stake in Shenzhen Commerical Bank of China.

CM - Acquires Majority Stake in FirstCaribbean International Bank

• On March 13th, CM announced that it intends to acquire an additional 43.7% ownership stake in FirstCaribbean International Bank (FCIB) from Barclays Bank PLC for a total ownership stake of 87.4%. FCIB has branches and banking centres in 17 countries across the Caribbean with its strongest presence in Bahamas, Barbados, and Cayman Islands. The transaction is valued at US$1.08 billion or US$1.62 per share.

TD - Increases Ownership of TD Ameritrade to 37.5% from 32.5% at Deal Close - Retains Board Seat

• TD Bank continued to invest in its two main U.S. businesses TD Ameritrade (AMTD) and TD Banknorth (BNK) in the second quarter.

• TD invested a further US$263 million in AMTD, purchasing 12.9 million shares at an average price of US$20.42 per share and increasing its ownership to 34.6% from 33.4%. Subsequent to the second quarter (ending April 30th) TD invested a further US$326 million (as at May 15) purchasing 17.4 million shares at an average share price of US$18.70 per share, increasing its ownership to 37.5%.

• TD Bank announced February 22, 2006 that it intends to purchase up to 15 million or 2.5% of AMTD stock by August 15, 2006 and that it aims to own 37.5% of AMTD by January 2007. TD has already purchased, as at May 15, 2006, 30.3 million shares since closing for US$589 million or US$19.43 per share. This brings its ownership up to 37.5%, well ahead of January 2007, which allows it to keep the one board seat.

• TD's cost base for AMTD is estimated at US$15.42 per share with the current AMTD share price of US$16.57 or 7.5% higher than TD's cost base.

TD - Modest Additional Investment in TD Banknorth

• TD's additional investment in BNK was modest in the second quarter at US$23.3 million or 762 thousand shares at an average price of US$30.58 per share increasing its ownership in BNK to 55.8% from 53.5%, aided by BNK net repurchases of 8.2 million shares of its own stock.

• On April 13th, BNK announced the acquisition of Interchange Financial Services Corp of New Jersey for US$480.6 million cash. The deal is to be financed mainly through the sale of 13 million BNK common shares to TD Bank.

• As at May 15th, TD had acquired 99.99% of the outstanding common shares of non-prime automotive financing company, VFC Inc.

Strong Fundamentals - Remain Overweight

• We believe bank fundamentals remain strong with low balance sheet risk, high capital levels, strong asset quality, record profitability, and historically low earnings volatility.

• Bank stock valuations remain attractive although not as compelling as they have been. Banks are trading at a low (based on fundamentals) 13.2 times our 2006 earnings estimates with a bank dividend yields relative to bonds (Exhibit 24), equity markets (Exhibit 25), income trusts (Exhibit 28) and pipes and utilities (Exhibit 26) all in the Buy range although not at the previous extreme discounts.

• Solid earnings growth outlook and double digit dividend growth expected for the next three to five years bodes well for continued appreciation in bank share prices.

• We reiterate our Overweight Banks recommendation based on attractive valuation, strong fundamentals, and low relative low risk.

• Maintain 1-Sector Outperform ratings on TD, RY and LB, and 2-Sector Perform ratings on BNS, CWB, and NA, with 3-Sector Underperform ratings on BMO and CM.

• We continue to expect TD and RY to move to 10% to 15% P/E premiums to the bank group with CM and BMO declining to 10% discounts based on relative fundamentals.
;

17 May 2006

Wall Street's War for China

  
The big investment banks are fighting for a piece of the action in the world's fastest-growing economy. Inside their multibillion-dollar battle.

Fortune, Clay Chandler; Joan L. Levinstein and Zhang Dan, 17 May 2006

On a Friday in March, executives from some of the world's most powerful investment banks gathered at the Beijing headquarters of the Industrial & Commercial Bank of China to compete in one of the richest beauty contests of all time.

One after another, teams from each firm were led to a chilly tenth-floor conference room where they were given 60 minutes to describe their plan for selling the state-owned bank's shares to foreign investors. Contestants battled in pinstripes, not swimwear, and sought to dazzle with the brilliance of their PowerPoints more than their smiles.

But in this master-of-the-universe pageant the prize was well worth turning on the charm. Victors would claim the right to lead ICBC in a $12 billion public offering this fall, the world's largest in seven years. The mandate would mean hundreds of millions of dollars in advisory fees, millions more in follow-on business, and the chance to forge a long-term partnership with China's largest bank--not to mention fat bonus checks at year-end.

Goldman Sachs was the hands-down favorite. Its executives had courted ICBC for years. On his many trips to China, CEO Hank Paulson had called regularly on chairman Jiang Jianqing. Jiang's daughter had worked as a summer intern at Goldman in New York City. Earlier this year Paulson had underscored the firm's commitment by pledging to buy a 7% stake in the bank for $2.6 billion.

ICBC hadn't even invited Goldman's archrival, Morgan Stanley, to submit a proposal, allowing Fred Hu, a polished, Harvard-trained economist, to make Goldman's pitch with confidence.

So it was no small shock when, a few days later, ICBC notified contestants of its decision. The IPO would be shared by five firms: Merrill Lynch, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, China International Capital Corp. (China's only domestic investment bank), and an ICBC subsidiary based in Hong Kong. Goldman's services were not required.

That Goldman could be so abruptly chucked out of such a high-profile deal for reasons that remain unclear hints at the perils faced by Western investment bankers as they jostle for position in the world's fastest-growing economy. When Paulson began making regular forays to China in the early 1990s, China's Communist leaders were struggling to fathom global capital markets. Liu Erhfei, who accompanied Paulson on some of those meetings as a junior Goldman banker (and who now leads the Merrill Lynch team that trumped Goldman on the ICBC deal), recalls Chinese officials' difficulty in grasping what, exactly, investment bankers do: "The response was, 'You're a banker, but you don't take deposits and you can't give me a loan? Why am I talking to you?' "

In the years since, China's leaders have learned a thing or two about firms like Goldman--not least of which is how to play them off against one another. Now, as market forces unleashed more than two decades ago gather momentum and China's rulers seek foreign investors to help bring fiscal discipline to their state-owned dinosaurs, China is emerging as a battleground for the world's largest investment banks.

Over the past three years China has spawned some of the world's largest IPOs, including the $3 billion listing of China Life Insurance on exchanges in New York and Hong Kong in 2003 and China Construction Bank's $9 billion offering on the Hong Kong stock exchange last fall. This month the Bank of China, China's second-largest bank, hopes to raise $9.9 billion from an IPO in Hong Kong. All told, the value of mainland deals in the pipeline this year could top $30 billion, and dozens of other Chinese companies have declared their intention to seek a foreign listing by 2008.

And it's not just IPOs. Increasingly, Chinese firms are players in the world's biggest cross-border mergers and acquisitions. Completed deals involving Chinese firms reached a record $28.5 billion in 2005, according to Thomson Financial, up from $1.9 billion in 1995. That figure is sure to climb as China eases restrictions on foreign investment and more of its own firms venture abroad.

Global financial giants themselves are responsible for a large chunk of China-bound investment. In the past two years Western firms including Goldman, Bank of America, Merrill Lynch, American Express, and HSBC have spent more than $20 billion to acquire stakes in Chinese banks. And Morgan Stanley, Goldman, and Citigroup have all launched ventures to cash in on China's booming property markets.

Never mind that China accounts for only a sliver of worldwide investment banking activity. Dealogic, a financial consultancy, estimates that since January 2005, mainland deals generated $1 billion in investment banking revenue, only a little more than 1% of the $85.1 billion global total. Still, executives at nearly all the major international investment banks hail China as a vital component of their plans for growth. And they have gone to extraordinary lengths to secure a foothold in this new market.

In angling for a piece of last year's China Construction Bank offering, J.P. Morgan turned to Henry Kissinger, while Deutsche Bank enlisted Germany's then-Chancellor Gerhard Schroder to write a letter to Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao. (Neither ploy succeeded.) Paulson, Morgan Stanley's John Mack, and Merrill's Stan O'Neal each made at least half-a-dozen trips to China last year. Several firms, including Merrill, UBS, and Credit Suisse, have put the offspring and in-laws of Communist Party heavyweights on their payrolls, and others have spent millions poaching star dealmakers.

In February, days after Morgan Stanley's top China banker, Jonathan Zhu, left for a private equity firm, the bank snatched away Citigroup's top China rainmaker, Wei Christianson. Citi retaliated by stealing Morgan Stanley's co-head of investment banking for China, Zhao Jing, prompting Morgan Stanley to raid Citi for another member of its China team. Merrill's Liu has worked for Rothschild, Goldman, Morgan Stanley, and Smith Barney. Goldman's star China dealmaker, Fang Fenglei, who has access to China's top financial officials, was once the prime mover at Morgan Stanley's joint venture, China International Capital Corp.

Goldman and Morgan Stanley own stakes in Chinese brokerages, and other foreign firms are wooing local partners. Everyone says they are preparing for the day when Western investment banks are allowed to manage the pension funds of Chinese companies, peddle financial services to China's prodigious savers, and trade debt and equity on China's exchanges as freely as they do in Japan or South Korea. "We know the opportunities will be big," says Michael Berchtold, Morgan Stanley's Asia Pacific president, "and we want to make sure that as they continue to arise, we're ready with the right capabilities."

In the race to become China's investment bank of choice, Morgan Stanley took an early lead. In 1992--the year Brilliance Auto floated shares on the New York Stock Exchange in China's first foreign IPO--Jack Wadsworth, then Morgan Stanley's Asia Pacific chairman, approached China Construction Bank with a proposal to establish the country's first domestic investment bank. The idea won support from China's reform-minded vice premier, Zhu Rongji, and in 1995 the two banks formed China International Capital Corp. (CICC). Morgan Stanley bankrolled the venture with $35 million in exchange for a 35% stake, and it offered personnel and financial know-how.

But it was a troubled marriage. Mainland staffers chafed at Morgan Stanley bankers' oversized salaries and egos. Morgan Stanley staffers griped that local colleagues were holding out on them on deals. The larger problem was that Wadsworth envisioned CICC as an onshore platform for his investment banking operations in Hong Kong, while his counterpart, China Construction Bank president Wang Qishan, saw the venture as an independent entity free to do deals with anyone. The rift broke into the open in 1997, when Fang, a rough-hewn former People's Liberation Army soldier who was CICC's savviest dealmaker, helped steer an advisory role in the foreign listing of state-owned telecommunications giant China Mobile to Goldman, not Morgan Stanley.

Fang says he tried to pitch the deal to Morgan Stanley first but got the brushoff from bankers in New York (a claim the firm disputes). In any event, Wadsworth's failure to land China's first megadeal undermined his credibility at headquarters, and relations between the two sides deteriorated. Fang was eventually forced out, and in 2000, Morgan Stanley pulled its executives from CICC and relinquished control. The venture is now run by Zhu Rongji's son, Levin Zhu.

Morgan has since made its peace with China Construction Bank and, though now a passive investor in CICC, has collaborated with it on a number of big deals. Last year Morgan Stanley served as lead underwriter for China Construction Bank's Hong Kong listing, making it the top investment bank in China in 2005. CICC's ability to dictate which foreign firms get a piece of the action is waning, though. And Christianson, an Amherst-educated Beijing native married to an American lawyer, will face stiff competition as she tries to keep her new employer out in front.

At 7:20 on a recent Friday morning, Peter MacDonald, chief operating officer of Goldman Sachs Gaohua Securities, convenes a group of nine salespeople and analysts in a cramped conference room in Beijing. Counterparts at Goldman offices in New York, London, Hong Kong, and Taipei join in by speakerphone. As cranes twirl over construction sites outside, questions fly around the table. "Chris, you spent the day on the road with management at Sinochem. Any surprises?" Someone else weighs in with a view on Shanghai Raw Water: "We're incrementally more positive."

What's remarkable about this meeting is that it's happening in Beijing. Goldman, which got a foothold in China in the early 1990s, is the only foreign securities firm with a trading platform on the mainland. But securing it has required some clever footwork. As a show of good faith to China's regulators, Goldman agreed to pay $68 million to bail out clients of Hainan Securities, a scandal-plagued brokerage it had no connection to that collapsed in 2001. Next it advanced Fang and five co-investors $100 million to launch Gaohua Securities, a new brokerage.

The final step was the creation of Goldman Sachs Gaohua, a joint venture in which Gaohua holds 67% and Goldman owns 33%, the maximum allowed. Goldman won't discuss the terms of its loan to the Fang group, other than to say it gives Fang, who serves as chairman of both Gaohua and the joint venture, ample incentive to remain a part of the Goldman team. The aim of all this was to create a legal framework granting Goldman effective control over a mainland investment bank, even if, on paper, it's owned by someone else.

How much control is a matter of debate. "What's to stop Fang from dumping Goldman the way he dumped Morgan Stanley at CICC?" asks the regional head of one large Western firm. J. Michael Evans, chairman of Goldman Sachs Asia, isn't fazed: "That's not something I worry about. Fang thinks of himself as a Goldman person. I trust him 100%."

A more interesting question is what the partnership is worth. Trading shares on China's exchanges isn't exactly a lucrative proposition. Fees are low, and well-run companies are in short supply. From an investment banking standpoint, many Goldman competitors do just fine chasing mainland deals from lightly taxed regional offices in Hong Kong. But Evans says Gaohua "gives us on-the-ground insight into the challenges of China's capital markets and puts us in the best possible position to work with regulators on how to tackle them."

Evans takes a similarly broad view of Goldman's failure to win the ICBC deal. Losing a deal here or there, he shrugs, won't distract Goldman from its long-term China strategy. Such equanimity is remarkable, given the intensity of Goldman's pursuit. But it's true that Goldman has won its share of big China deals. In addition to China Mobile, it led PetroChina's $2.9 billion listing in 2000 and co-managed Ping An Insurance's listing in 2004 and the $2.2 billion listing of the Bank of Communications in 2005. It is also leading the Bank of China IPO.

Some believe Goldman's role as advisor to the Bank of China doomed its bid for ICBC. Acting as book runner for both banks in the same year would have required separate teams of salesmen, lawyers, accountants, and compliance experts. Sources close to ICBC say the final decision was made not by Jiang but by the State Council, Beijing's highest policy authority. But the reasons for Goldman's 11th-hour rejection remain murky. The State Council's information office declined Fortune's request for an interview, as did other banking and regulatory officials and executives at ICBC.

Evans says the outcome highlights Beijing's determination to spread the deals around. "Decisions were taken to maintain a sense of balance," he says. "China needs to preserve the ability to work with multiple overseas service providers. We understand that, and we're not overly surprised at the outcome."

China's effort to find balance can throw foreign bankers for a loop, as Merrill's Liu was reminded on a dusty April morning that found him pacing Beijing's Avenue of Eternal Peace, mobile phone pressed to one ear, trying to explain to a reporter how Merrill lost a $2 billion deal. Liu was among the first wave of Chinese students granted permission to further their education in the U.S. after the Cultural Revolution. He earned degrees from Brandeis and Harvard Business School and found himself besieged by offers from American banks.

Liu, who has been with Merrill since 1999, jokes that now, at 48, he's getting too old to be an investment banker. But for the past two years his China team has notched a series of key deals, enabling Damian Chunilal, head of Merrill's Asia operations, to boast that Merrill is "the house with greatest momentum" in China. The ICBC deal is a trophy fish for Merrill, but to land it, Liu has had to let a smaller catch swim free. ICBC executives demanded that Merrill forfeit its role underwriting the IPO of China Merchants Bank, the country's sixth-largest. Merrill's place was quickly filled by J.P. Morgan, until now a minor player on China's investment banking scene.

No firm has had more difficulty finding its footing in China than Citigroup. In 1999 its underwriting team misread global demand for shares of China National Offshore Oil Corp. so badly that the offering had to be withdrawn, earning Citi the dubious distinction of having managed China's only botched IPO. In 2001, desperate to get back in the game, Citi lured Margaret Ren, daughter-in-law of former Chinese Premier Zhao Ziyang, away from Bear Stearns with a salary reported to exceed $8 million.

Ren brought Citi a slew of deals, including China Netcom, Mingsheng Bank, and China Life. To keep Citi from getting pushed out of the $3.5 billion China Life IPO, she went head-to-head with CICC's Zhu. Ren prevailed with help from senior Citigroup executives, including Robert Rubin, chairman of the bank's executive committee, and the following year China Construction Bank hired Citi to assist with a $5 billion listing.

Then things unraveled. Citi fired Ren, alleging she had submitted false documents to U.S. regulators in connection with an investigation into the China Life listing. (Ren could not be reached for comment.) Last May, China Construction Bank kicked Citi off its underwriting team after executives reneged on a promise to take an equity stake. Earlier this year Christianson, hired as Ren's replacement, decamped for Morgan Stanley after only 18 months on the job.

Now Citi is trying to rebuild. Its strategy, says regional investment banking head Mark Renton, is to create a broad team of China experts rather than chase after the next hot rainmaker and to capitalize on Citi's extensive corporate banking network. But how to get the corporate and investment banking functions to work together?

"At Citi, the corporate banking culture dominates," grouses one former Citigroup investment banker. "If you're on the corporate side, why mess with your nice, dependable lending franchise to help some cowboy on the investment side cut a deal?"

To replace Citi on its underwriting team, China Construction Bank turned to Credit Suisse--much to the consternation of John Mack, CEO of lead manager Morgan Stanley, who had been forced out of Credit Suisse. In a meeting with China Construction Bank officials in Beijing after Citi's ouster, Mack argued that Morgan Stanley and CICC didn't need help from a third firm to manage the Chinese bank's IPO. But his objection was rebuffed.

Though it may lack the swagger of its Wall Street rivals, Credit Suisse has proved remarkably effective in China. Between 2003 and 2005 it raised more money for mainland companies than any other foreign investment bank. And it has done so without Chinese partners, compensating in part by luring top Asian executives and institutional investors to Hong Kong for the region's biggest financial conference.

Stoking the frenzy of China stock offerings are two forces: Beijing's belief that selling foreigners minority stakes in China's state-owned behemoths will improve corporate governance without sacrificing government control, and global investors' belief that owning shares of Chinese companies is a sensible way to profit from the economy's torrid growth.

Neither proposition is self-evident, but both are finding accommodation in Hong Kong. Five years ago investment banks steered their Chinese clients to the New York Stock Exchange or Nasdaq. But Hong Kong has loosened listing requirements while Sarbanes-Oxley has made them more costly in the U.S. Mainland enterprises now account for a third of all companies listed on the Hong Kong exchange and half its market value.

The affinity between Chinese firms and foreign investors is also evident in Beijing, along Finance Street, the proud new corporate corridor west of Tiananmen Square, where a score of China's corporate giants are erecting gleaming new headquarters. At one end of Finance Street sits the Bank of China building, designed by I.M. Pei, with a bamboo grove and a reflecting pool in its soaring lobby. Upstairs, Zhu Min, executive assistant to the president, describes how foreign investors are helping to make the bank more transparent. Non-Chinese citizens now hold four seats on the governing board. Experts from the Royal Bank of Scotland, which paid $3 billion for a 10% stake, offer advice on risk management, technology, and customer service. The bank's chief credit officer is a Briton from HSBC.

But problems run deep. A recent study by accounting firm Ernst & Young estimates bad loans at China's four largest state-owned banks at $358 billion--more than twice what officials acknowledge and nearly half of China's foreign currency reserves. From the window of his office near Beijing's Forbidden City, Ernst & Young partner Jack Rodman, an expert in distressed debt, gazes out at the frenzy of construction. Chinese banks, he marvels, continue to dole out credit to money-losing enterprises, harebrained infrastructure schemes, and speculative property developments. Why are global investors so keen to share in such excess? "The level of foreign interest in Chinese banks," he says, "defies all logic."

The campaign to sell China's banks to foreign investors gathered momentum in 2003, as Chinese planners feared the nation's financial system was hurtling out of control. An earlier effort to cleanse bank balance sheets by transferring $170 billion in dud loans from state banks to government-backed asset-management companies had proved too timid. A more rigorous accounting revealed an additional $450 billion in bad loans. And analysts estimate that China's banks racked up another $225 billion in a speculative lending binge between 2002 and 2004. The newly appointed administration of Hu Jintao concluded that selling bank shares to foreigners--who would insist on global standards--was the last best hope. But Beijing has limited foreign ownership of Chinese banks to 25%, and even that has left Hu vulnerable to criticism at home that he is giving away the family silver.

How will the experiment end? Will China's new IPO darlings hold up in the face of more bad loans, or rising interest rates, or a dip in Chinese growth? China Inc.'s new foreign partners can only hope that today's investment banking beauty pageants don't turn ugly tomorrow.
;

Principal Financial Gets Subpoena

  
BMO Nesbitt Burns, 17 May 2006

Last night, Principal Financial Group announced that it had received a subpoena from the Attorney General of New York regarding the sale of retirement products and services. While we have no more details on the nature of the subpoenas, we assume that this applies to the sale of corporate and individual retirement plans (401(k)s, IRAs, and 403(b)s) and perhaps annuities and mutual funds. PFG is among the leaders in providing these services and plans in the U.S. These segments account for roughly 65% of PFG’s total operating earnings. From a Canadian perspective, Manulife generates roughly 13% of net earnings from these segments in the U.S., Sun Life at 20%, and Great West at 18%.

We do not believe that any of the Canadian companies are involved with this investigation. While this development is clearly a concern, we would make the following observations. First, the U.S. annuities industry has been under investigation for over two years and we do not know if this subpoena is related to that investigation. Second, the “Spitzer impact” has diminished significantly over the last four years. If true to form, PFG will have to pay some fine and the event should have no long term impact on its franchise. Nonetheless, in our view any investigation into the insurance industry is likely to weigh on the share prices in the short term.
;

Power Corp's Newspaper Assets

  
The Globe and Mail, Konrad Yakabuski, 17 May 2006

Yves Michaud calls Paul Desmarais his "friend of almost 50 years." In truth, the two feisty septuagenarians have been on opposite sides of Quebec's political divide since the beginning of the Quiet Revolution. Mr. Michaud is as sovereigntist as the pope is Catholic and once founded a newspaper to counter a perceived federalist slant in the Quebec media, led by Mr. Desmarais' La Presse.

Now, as Quebec's most determined and entertaining activist investor, Mr. Michaud is taking on his old "friend" on behalf of minority shareholders in Power Corp. of Canada. And once again, the centre of their dispute revolves around Power's media assets, about which its financial statements disclose, well, almost nothing.

Through its 100-per-cent held Gesca Ltée subsidiary, Power owns six French-language dailies, including La Presse, the main Montreal broadsheet, and Quebec City's Le Soleil. Its newspapers have weekly circulations of more than three million copies, making it the biggest publisher in French Canada. For Quebeckers, Gesca remains the principal symbol of the Desmarais family's influence.

Mr. Desmarais' newspaper ownership has always been a touchy subject in Quebec. The National Assembly, of which Mr. Michaud was then a member, held parliamentary hearings before allowing him to buy La Presse in 1967. Premier Robert Bourassa blocked Power's first attempt to buy Le Soleil, preferring Conrad Black, who ended up selling the paper, along with two other dailies, to Power in 2000. Then Parti Québécois premier Lucien Bouchard, a Desmarais family friend, took a lot of flak from within his own party for allowing the transaction.

Why exactly has Mr. Desmarais been so keen to own print media assets in Quebec? After all, Power has always been the first to get out of so-called declining industries, from forest products to trust companies. Is Mr. Desmarais in newspapers strictly for business reasons, or has he gained control of them, regardless of the drain on or marginal contribution to Power's finances, to promote his political views? And if so, why should Power's minority shareholders have to bear the burden of the media unit's losses or, at best, its below-average returns? If the Desmarais family insists on owning the newspapers, which are a non-core component of Power's largely financial services business, why doesn't it just buy them from Power?

These questions are implicitly at the heart of Mr. Michaud's attempt to force Power to disclose Gesca's financial results. Invoking a never-before-used clause of the Canada Business Corporations Act that allows any shareholder to examine the financial statements of a subsidiary, Mr. Michaud, a colourful orator, woke the audience from its slumber at the Power annual meeting last week.

Prior to the meeting, Mr. Michaud had contacted Power to advise them of his request. Power's general counsel, Ted Johnson, did not dispute Mr. Michaud's right to view the Gesca statements, but he asked Mr. Michaud to provide a written request outlining "in what quality and to what ends" he was making the inquiry.

"I retorted on the spot that it was none of his business and that the law does not require a shareholder to specify the motives of his request," Mr. Michaud told the public meeting, comparing Mr. Johnson to Torquemada, the leader of the Spanish Inquisition.

Under the law, Power has 15 days to respond to Mr. Michaud. If it opposes his request, it must prove to a judge that opening Gesca's books would be "detrimental" to Power or its media subsidiary. Expect a legal challenge; Mr. Michaud has struck a nerve.

"If Gesca is losing money, [Power] has a duty to protect minority shareholders," Mr. Michaud said. "They say it's profitable; others say not. But one can't assume anything without seeing Gesca's statements."

Power's minority shareholders are not usually the type to complain. Partly, with reason. Although the stock has moved sideways in recent months, it has posted a 10-year annual return of 22.6 per cent.

A note to Power's financial statements breaks out the contribution to net earnings from Great-West Lifeco, IGM Financial and Parjointco, Power's European affiliate. They are all highly profitable. Everything else, which is lumped under the "other" heading is not. Power's "other" holdings, which include Gesca, its stakes in CITIC Pacific, Neurochem and other companies, contributed a loss of $103-million in 2005, a modest improvement from a loss of $123-million in 2004. But the numbers are too incomplete for shareholders to draw any conclusion about Gesca.

Power contends that, for competitive reasons, it keeps Gesca's results private. But rival Quebecor breaks out the operating results of its various media divisions, including its newspapers.

Le Soleil became a tabloid last month after years of faltering circulation.

La Presse has made gains at the expense of Quebecor's Journal de Montréal since 2001. But at what price? Power invested huge sums in a 2003 redesign. Some doubt the paper is profitable.

Mr. Michaud knows first hand how tough it is to make a buck in the newspaper business. Le Jour, the Montreal-based sovereigntist daily he co-founded in 1974, crumbled after barely two years.

After all, not every money-losing paper can count on a deep-pocketed owner who supports its cause.
;

16 May 2006

Manulife Owns 31.3% of Seamark

  
Dow Jones, 16 May 2006

Seamark Asset Management Ltd.'s president and chief executive, Stuart R. Raftus, has purchased 130,000 shares of Seamark from Seamark's chairman and chief investment officer, G. Peter Marshall, and 320,000 shares from a unit of Manulife Financial Corp., at C$8.40 a share.

Seamark, a Halifax, N.S. investment management company, said that, following these transactions Marshall will continue to own 1,370,000 shares and Manulife will continue to own 3,355,900 shares of Seamark, representing 12.8% and 31.3%, respectively, of the total shares outstanding.
;

UBS Analyst Upgrades RBC, Scotiabank, TD

  
The Globe and Mail, Angela Barnes, 16 May 2006

UBS Securities Canada Inc. has upgraded its ratings on three of the big banks, increasing Royal Bank of Canada, Bank of Nova Scotia and Toronto-Dominion Bank to "buy" from "neutral." UBS left its "neutral" recommendations on Bank of Montreal, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce and National Bank of Canada unchanged.

RBC "has finally pulled back ... offering a slightly more attractive entry point on a platform with considerable near-term operating momentum, and a very solid outlook," analyst Jason Bilodeau said in a report written early yesterday.

Scotiabank is one of the cheapest names in the group, he said. Its first-quarter results lacked some of the momentum seen elsewhere, "but a series of incremental deals, a viable international growth strategy, strong management and exceptional capital levels support an attractive medium-term outlook," he said.

Mr. Bilodeau said TD continues to be affected by challenges with its TD Banknorth Inc. subsidiary and, more recently, a conservative outlook from management at TD Ameritrade Holding Corp. "However, we continue to believe in the medium-term strategy at BNK [Banknorth] and see the TWE/AMTD [TD Waterhouse-Ameritrade] combination as a driver of significant operating upside through year-end and into '07," the analyst said. "Meanwhile, the domestic operations continue to perform well," he added.

Bank stocks have been under pressure of late and as of last Friday had dropped nearly 6 per cent in the past two months. Valuations have as a result pulled back materially, Mr. Bilodeau said. He sees upside for the group as it heads into what he expects will be a generally positive second quarter.

Mr. Bilodeau also boosted the 12-month price targets for five of the bank stocks. He increased the target for Scotiabank to $54 a share from $53, for CIBC to $94 from $93 and for RBC to $55 from $54. Meanwhile, the target for TD rose to $75 from $74 and for National Bank to $69 from $68. BMO's target was left unchanged at $71.
__________________________________________________________
Investment Executive, James Langton, 15 May 2006

UBS Securities Canada Inc. is bumping up its ratings on Royal Bank, TD Bank and Bank of Nova Scotia, and is generally speaking positively about the group ahead of the banks reporting their second quarter earnings.

The firm notes that its fundamental outlook on the bank sector hasn’t changed, and it still sees some fundamental challenges on the horizon, but recent weakness merits an upgrade. “Canadian banks have been weak, off nearly 6% on two months and have underperformed year-to-date amid rate/inflation concerns and recently a weak equity market,” UBS says in a new report. “However, our fundamental outlook is largely unchanged, we continue to see some operating headwinds as we move through [the second half], while valuations have pulled backed materially. Heading into what should be generally positive [second quarter] news flow, we see room for upside.”

UBS says that the current quarter should be generally positive news. “Some moderation in loan growth and continued gradual uptick in credit costs are expected. However, we see some opportunity for better [net interest margins] in a higher rate environment and strong capital markets and trading activity, along with good wealth management growth, should provide lift again this quarter.”

The firm says that Royal Bank has the best near-term operating momentum and solid outlook, and is finally trading at more reasonable valuation. Scotiabank is one of its favoured platforms for the medium-term, with room for a healthy dividend hike this quarter. And, adds that TD Bank’s near-term challenges are distracting from its attractive medium-term growth prospects.

It also still sees operating upside at CIBC. “Results at CIBC could impress again this quarter on the back of continued productivity enhancements, but the stock has held in relatively well as one of the best recent performers in the group,” it notes.
__________________________________________________________
Credit Suisse, 15 May 2006

• Credit Suisse downgraded Scotiabank to Neutral
• Credit Suisse upgraded RBC to Outperform
;

14 May 2006

Banks Lose Out to Red Hot Commodities

  
Reuters, 14 May 2006

In a market hooked on red-hot commodities, Canada's financial stocks are flat this year, and even predictions of positive earnings from the sector aren't pulling investors away from their thirst for oil and lust for gold.

"Insurance company earnings will probably be higher than the banks', if the banks are high single digits (earnings growth), the insurance companies might be low double digits," said John Kinsey, a portfolio manager with Caldwell Securities Ltd.

He forecast dividend increases, share buy-backs and stock splits when the banks report second-quarter earnings in the coming weeks, announcements that would be enough to boost the sector under normal market conditions.

But the likelihood of good news in the sector is not inspiring investors this time, as soaring commodity markets grab everyone's attention and suck in capital from bigger and more liquid sectors like insurance and banks.

"There is a situation of group rotation that takes place from time to time and, in part, that's what's happening," said Michael Goldberg at Desjardins Securities. "Bank stocks are being used as a source of funds to buy other stuff."

Lifted by record crude prices, Canada's oil and gas sector is up 10 percent so far this year, while the mining-focused materials sector is ahead 26 percent. The gold sector, a component of the materials group, is up a staggering 35 percent.

The rise in commodity-focused stocks also reflects gold prices at 25-year highs, and firm prices for other metals.

Goldberg said financial stocks are often seen as a safe place to position money because they offer good returns from growth and steady dividend increases. But parking money is not the most exciting motivation to own stocks.

The Toronto Stock Exchange S&P/TSX composite index is up 6.9 percent this year. In contrast, the financial sector is up a lackluster 0.7 percent.

Adding to the financial sector's worries is the specter of rising interest rates, which increase the cost of borrowing for the banks.

The U.S. Federal Reserve raised rates a quarter of a percentage point to 5 percent on Wednesday and left the door open to further interest rate hikes.

The Bank of Canada is expected to raise its overnight interest rate to 4.25 percent on May 24, and some analysts expect it to signal its monetary tightening campaign will end, due in part to the Canadian dollar's strength.

But analysts say higher interest rates are not damaging banks as they once did, as banks look to other sources of income such as underwriting and fees.

They say it may not yet be time for investors to return to the sector. Financial stocks are still 76 percent above the levels seen at the start of 2003 -- a performance that compares unfavorably with an 82 percent rise in the overall index.

"There is so much volatility in this market that they tend to go too far on the upside and they tend to go too far on the downside," said Kinsey.
;

12 May 2006

Manulife CEO to Diversify Holdings

  
The Globe and Mail, Sinclair Stewart,12 May 2006

All good investors understand the importance of diversification, and Dominic D'Alessandro is no exception.

Now that he's accumulated nearly a third of a billion dollars worth of equity in a single company, he's making a move to juggle the portfolio.

The chief executive officer of Manulife Financial Corp. announced plans yesterday to exercise as many as 500,000 stock options this year and sell them in the markets: The first time in his 13 years at the helm that he's actually reduced his holdings in the company.

The value of this stock is almost $36-million, based on the financial services giant's closing share price of $71.79 on the Toronto Stock Exchange yesterday.

But it represents just 12 per cent of the common shares Mr. D'Alessandro owns either directly, or expects to obtain through options or other share awards.

"There's a few things I want to do," he said in an interview yesterday. "You know, some things I might want to buy."

By his own admission, Mr. D'Alessandro is not much of a big spender -- "I live a modest life," he says -- although he did recently purchase a vacation home in Naples, Fla. He said he wanted to free up some liquidity for personal reasons, without elaborating, but insisted that Manulife would continue to represent his largest single investment by a wide margin.

Today, the market value of his equity would stand at almost $300-million, but that's not all his gain, as the bulk of his investment is in options that must be exercised at various strike prices. When you factor out the cost of exercising these options, he's up about $170-million.

Mr. D'Alessandro, 59, has 2.45 million exercisable stock options worth about $88-million and 719,332 unexercisable options valued at $10.2-million, according to Manulife's most recent proxy circular. He also has more than 690,000 share units worth about $50.2-million and 281,250 common shares worth more than $20-million.

"It's a very, very, very, very, very, large [stake]," he said. "I've been here almost 13 years, and I've constantly reinvested my bonuses and my long-term incentives and so forth. And this is the first sale or exercise of its kind since I've been here."

Mr. D'Alessandro said his decision to unload some options after having held them for almost seven years is "not untypical" for a CEO, and added that he wanted to alert the market so investors would understand why he was selling.

In his announcement, Mr. D'Alessandro said that given the size of his current stake in Manulife, his financial advisers encouraged him to diversify his investments.
;

11 May 2006

BMO NB on Power Financial's Q1 2006 Earnings

  
BMO Nesbitt Burns, 11 May 2006

Power Financial reported fully diluted EPS of $0.55 versus $0.52 in Q1/05, our estimate of $0.57 and consensus of $0.59. Results were not surprising given the lower than expected results at Great-West combined with in-line earnings at IGM Financial last week. Pargesa reported another strong quarter in local currency, but these were somewhat offset by the negative impact of the rising Canadian dollar. As expected, the company announced a 7.5% increase in its quarterly dividend to $0.25 per share from $0.2325 per share. We expect another 4–7% increase in the dividend in Q3/06.

Power Financial remains Market Perform rated. Great-West contributes roughly 70% to the earnings of Power Financial, and we believe that 2006 is a transition year for GWO due to foreign exchange and uncertainty surrounding the future growth plans in the U.S. While growth expectations are more modest in 2006, Power Financial and its subsidiaries have a strong record of acquisitions and new strategic initiatives. Over the next 12 months, we expect dividend growth to outpace earnings growth in 2006, but that beyond 2006 earnings and dividend growth rates should be more similar. Given the lower earnings estimates for Great-West, slightly offset by higher earnings estimates at IGM Financial, as well as the results in the quarter, we reduced our 2006E and 2007E EPS to $2.50 and $2.85 from $2.55 and $2.90, respectively.

Power Financial’s share of its subsidiary earnings is presented in Table 1. The company’s share of GWO’s operating earnings rose 7% to $313 million in Q1/06 from $292 million in Q1/05. Overall, the results of GWO were shy of our expectations, as solid earnings in Canada were offset by lower earnings in the U.S. The company faces relatively modest earnings growth in 2006 given modest membership growth in the U.S., some additional expenditure on new systems as well as a strong Canadian dollar.

Power Financial’s share of IGM Financial’s earnings rose 11% to $103 million in Q1/06 from $93 million in Q1/05. Overall, results in the quarter were slightly ahead of expectations and the company continues to execute well. IGM is extremely well positioned from a strategic perspective in the Canadian mutual fund industry with multiple distribution capabilities, significant scale and a broad product offering that should generate reasonable net flows in most market environments. The company’s financial condition is exceptional and it is a prolific generator of free cash flow.

The contribution of Pargesa’s earnings declined 10% to $10 million in Q1/06 from $11 million in Q1/05. The decline is attributable to lower earnings at Bertelsmann and the negative impact of the strong Canadian dollar, which were somewhat offset by better results at Imerys. The better results at Imerys were attributable to strong sales results, slightly lower expenses, a lower effective tax rate and the positive impact of acquisitions.

Operating earnings at Power Financial available to common shareholders were $392 million, or $0.55 per share, compared with $365 million, or $0.52 per share, in the same quarter last year. Net dividend income to the holding company (i.e., dividends received from subsidiaries less dividends paid to common and preferred shareholders) is estimated to be roughly $12 million in the quarter.

Recommendation & Valuation

Power Financial remains Market Perform rated. Great-West contributes roughly 70% to the earnings of Power Financial, and we believe that 2006 is a transition year for GWO due to foreign exchange and challenges in U.S. health care. While growth expectations are more modest in 2006, Power Financial and its subsidiaries have a strong record of acquisitions and new strategic initiatives, and we expect dividend growth to outpace earnings growth in 2006. Given the lower earnings estimates for Great-West, slightly offset by higher earnings estimates at IGM Financial, as well as the results in the quarter, we reduced our 2006E and 2007E EPS to $2.50 and $2.85 from $2.55 and $2.90, respectively.

On a discount to current net asset value analysis, Power Financial shares trade at a 15% discount to net asset value, and our $36 target price represents a 16% discount to target net asset value
;

10 May 2006

RBC CM Preview of Cdn Banks Q2 2006 Earnings

  
RBC Capital Markets, 10 May 2006

Cash EPS Growth Estimated Up 11% YoY The banks start reporting Q2 earnings during the 4th week of May. Our estimated growth is indicated highest at RY (expected to lead revenue growth and operating leverage), followed by TD (partially acquisition assisted, but now more adversely impacted by currency) and BNS (International divisional growth, but also negatively impacted by currency). We are not factoring for any unusual gains/losses/items this quarter.

Moderate Revenue Growth. We estimate 8% YoY revenue growth (5% excl. TD’s Banknorth acquisition), roughly in line with 7% growth recorded in Q1/06 (5% excluding Banknorth). We are not anticipating retail spread improvement, though higher business loan volumes should augment already-solid wealth and wholesale activity. Adverse currency translation is expected to play a bigger role in dampening revenue growth this quarter.

Credit Solid…But Watching More Closely Now. Our normalized loan loss provision estimates for the group are indicated up 20% QoQ and 35% YoY, purely on a return to more normal, run-rate levels rather than as a result of impaired loan developments that we expect to remain very low. We are looking for an increase in LLP/L&A to 0.29% versus 0.23% in Q1/06. In our view, 0.30-0.35% should be the cycle-neutral average. This level of credit provision remains very manageable with only moderate EPS impact at the current low levels. Two banks (RY and TD) had modest impaired loan increases last quarter – if this broadened to a trend, we believe the banks would be quite weak as investors have been lulled into a rather complacent attitude.

Overall, we recommend investors remain cautious on bank this earnings cycle – the sudden and we think sustained interest rate rise in quarter may alter the banks’ outlook/guidance on loan volume & spread.
;