24 August 2007

Banks' Exposure to Asset-Backed Commerical Papers

  
The Globe and Mail, Tavia Grant, 24 August 2007

Ewen Mackenzie has been trading securities for nearly three decades, half of that as head of his Thornhill, Ont., investment firm. And he's always been able to buy short-term government treasury bills — until Friday.

Like scores of other fixed-income investors, Mr. Mackenzie was looking to park money in one of the safest spots in Canada — government-backed bills. But when he called one of the Big Five banks Friday to place about $250,000 in 30-day and 90-day T-bills, he was told they weren't available.

The experience illustrates just how rattled investors are. Their aversion to the perceived risk of anything connected with non-bank asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) means many are fleeing money market funds altogether for the haven of government-backed securities.

"I've been in this business for 28 years and I've never heard of anything like that before," said Mr. Mackenzie, who runs Ewen Mackenzie Investment Advisors Ltd. "I can only surmise that individual investors are bailing out of money market funds and buying Treasury bills and maybe they've bought them all up."

Treasury bills are sold at an auction every second Tuesday through the Bank of Canada. They're bought by investment dealers, who then typically resell them to retail investors.

Mr. Mackenzie wants the central bank to help soothe the liquidity problems by issuing more bills.

"If I'm getting a better rate than in the money market fund and it's got the guarantees of the government of Canada, it's a prudent thing to do. And now it would appear that that's been taken away from me," he said.

Fresh evidence of that came Friday when the Finance Department said the budget surplus for fiscal 2007-08 will be much higher than the $3-billion it had projected.

Canadian Treasury bill prices rose for a 14th-straight day, pushing the yield on a 90-day Government of Canada bill down 11 basis points Friday to a scant 3.80 per cent from 3.91 per cent Thursday. (A basis point is 1/100th of a percentage point.) Three weeks ago, the yield was 4.58 per cent, with the sudden drop indicative of the premium investors are willing to pay for debt backed by the Canadian government as they move into only the safest paper amid concerns about the safety of asset-backed commercial paper, which has been for years a substitute for scarce T-bills.

In the U.S., Treasury bill demand is easing after a surge last week and investors are showing confidence in asset backed commercial paper, signified by a shrinking spread between the yields on the two types of investments.

Appetite for T-bills surged in recent days after Coventree Inc. said it has been unable to find buyers for millions worth of ABCP. Fear that troubles in that segment could contaminate Canada's commercial paper market caused widening in spreads between commercial paper and one-month T-bills.

"To say that [T-bills] are scarce relative to what's out there is definitely true," said Mark Chandler, a fixed-income strategist at RBC Dominion Securities Inc.

That poses challenges for larger investors with a mandate to put their money into safe, low-risk vehicles.

Now, "concern about credit generally ... has the regular investors scrambling," he said.

"There's still a lot of confusion and until that confusion eases up a bit, I just don't see that part of the market improving that much," said Sheldon Dong, vice-president of fixed-income strategy at TD Waterhouse Group Inc.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, John Partridge, 24 August 2007

National Bank of Canada has fulfilled more than half of its pledge to buy back $1.85-billion in troubled short-term debt at the heart of a credit crunch in Canadian markets, a move that will make it the largest declared holder of the paper.

Bank spokesman Denis Dubé said Friday it has bought $999-million in so-called third-party, or non-bank, asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) from eight of its mutual funds and an additional $88.6-million from six funds operated by its Altamira Investment Services Inc. unit.

National, the smallest of Canada's Big Six banks but the one with the largest exposure to this beleaguered and once obscure segment of the corporate debt market, said in a statement that this means it now has acquired all the ABCP from both its and Altamira's mutual funds.

This adds up to $1.08-billion in all, apparently leaving about $770-million of the $1.85-billion still to be dealt with.

In announcing its repurchase plan Monday – designed to protect its reputation and save its clients from losses – the bank said it also planned to buy ABCP bought by individual investors through it, its investment dealer and its discount brokerage arms on the same terms as the fund repurchases – 100 per cent of the clients' acquisition cost plus accrued interest.

It also pledged to buy back holdings of $2-million or less from corporate clients.

Meanwhile, Northwest Mutual Funds of Toronto joined National and a small list of other financial institutions that have decided to rescue their clients. The firm said in a statement that it will “assume” all the third-party ABCP held in its money-market fund. However, it provided no details and officials could not be reached for comment.

In other ABCP developments, the Ontario government has emerged as one of the largest holders of the paper yet known, but says the exposure is not material and will not impair its ability to meet its cash-flow needs.

The province currently owns a little over $700-million of ABCP, Ontario Ministry of Finance spokesman Scott Blodgett said Friday.

It also owns “less than $100-million” in ABCP sponsored by banks, Mr. Blodgett said.

In all, this adds up to less than 10 per cent of the province's $9-billion cash reserves, and as such, the government does not consider it material from a fiscal, financial or liquidity perspective.

“It won't have any impact on our surplus or our liquidity or ability to meet our cash flow needs,” Mr. Blodgett said.

By way of illustration, he said the province was able to sell out a $600-million issue of 10-year domestic bonds “within minutes” Thursday morning.

“We've certainly informed our bond underwriting syndicate. . .that out [ABCP] exposure is less than 10 per cent of our cash reserves and they have no further questions or concerns,” Mr. Blodgett added.

The government holds the ABCP investments through the Ontario Financing Authority, which manages provincial finances, he said.

By contrast, representatives for the New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Newfoundland and Labrador and Manitoba governments, for example, said Friday morning that their treasuries have no exposure to ABCP.

ABPC is debt in the form of such things as mortgages, car loans and credit card receivables that banks or other third-party structured finance companies buy, repackage and sell to investors as short-term instruments for parking their cash at a profit.

However, in the fallout from the global credit crunch triggered by the U.S. sub-prime mortgage debacle, skittish investors have in the past two weeks largely stopped buying the third-party variety, and major banks have used a legal loophole to avoid having to honour agreements under which they are supposed to provide back-stop financing for the paper.

This has left several third-party finance companies in dire straits, most visibly Coventree Inc., a Toronto structured finance company. Its shares have plunged more than 80 per cent since it announced it could not find new buyers for hundreds of millions of dollars in asset-backed loans that had come due.

More small holders of the tarnished third-party paper disclosed their exposure Friday. They included Western Canadian Coal Corp. of Vancouver, which says it has $5-million tied up in the stuff, about 12 per cent of its current cash holdings, and Acceleware Corp. of Calgary, which said third-party ABCP accounts for $1.45-million of its $7.2-million in cash and cash equivalents.

Although it has refused to divulge its exposure, Quebec's massive pension fund, Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec, is thought to be the largest holder of third-party paper in Canada, where the market for the stuff is currently estimated at about $35-billion.

The Caisse was the driving force behind a plan to salvage the market launched by a group of 10 financial institutions, the main plank of which is to convert the ABCP into longer-term notes. As of Thursday afternoon, the group had signed up companies that, it said, in total hold a little more than 77 per cent of the outstanding $35-billion.

Among the other larger holders of the paper that have ‘fessed up so far are, Dundee Bank of Canada, at $400-million, air-traffic control system operator Nav Canada, with $368-million, the Greater Toronto Airports Authority, with $249-million and tour operator Transat A.T. Inc., with $154.5-million.
__________________________________________________________
Reuters, Nicole Mordant, 23 August 2007

As the blame game starts after a credit crunch in a corner of Canada's asset-backed commercial paper market, it is emerging that several red flags were raised in the past year about these unique short-term debt investments.

In a June 2006 report, rating agency Standard & Poor's pointed out that Canada's ABCP market was one of a kind in its acceptance of products with "extremely limited-use liquidity support."

The phrase is prophetic, in hindsight. The market for ABCP issued by groups other than Canada's big banks froze up last week when issuers of the instruments turned to financial backers for emergency funding when they were unable to find takers for maturing paper as buyers took fright.

Those backers, mostly international banks operating in Canada, refused to throw issuers a lifeline, citing clauses in the ABCP agreements requiring them to step up only in the event of a "general market disruption" -- a loosely defined term and a situation that the banks said had not taken place.

"Conduits with this type of liquidity backup likely would not receive an investment-grade rating from Standard & Poor's," Toronto-based S&P primary credit analyst Maria Rabiasz and two other S&P analysts wrote in the 2006 report.

At the time, and still today, Toronto-based DBRS is the only rating group to rate Canadian non-bank ABCP, which are short-term debt instruments invested in assets such as mortgages and corporate credit.

DBRS handed most of this paper its top R-1 rating, a lure to investors who now want to know how many of these seemingly safe investments went sour. Players in the sector would have ended up in default, but for a bail-out drawn up late last week by 10 large market participants.

Rabiasz and her colleagues urged investors to request multiple rating opinions on the paper.

But S&P rival Moody's has also been concerned for some time about the lack of iron-clad funding backstops in non-bank ABCP contracts, Charles Gamm, vice-president and senior credit officer at ratings agency Moody's said.

"Moody's has always stated that this type of liquidity facility is not consistent with our highest short-term rating, which we call Prime-1," Gamm told Reuters.

The market for this specialized commercial paper is worth about C$35 billion ($33 billion). It grew rapidly in recent years as companies and money market funds looking for liquid investments with good returns for their cash piled in.

DBRS itself became concerned late last year, albeit not with the contract's liquidity clauses, but with the types of investments that some of the non-bank ABCP issuers were making, according to Canada's Globe and Mail newspaper.

That led the rating agency to firm up its ABCP investment criteria in January. DBRS also told the newspaper it has launched a review of the way it rates ABCP. The rating agency was not available for comment.

In May, Edward Devlin, Canadian portfolio manager at Pacific Investment Management Co. (Pimco), the world's largest bond manager, warned in an article of imprudent risk-taking in the ABCP market.

"In hindsight, this was not DBRS's finest hour," Devlin told Reuters.

But he is wary of blaming DBRS for the market freeze, which has resulted in several companies being unable to access their working capital because of a 60-day standstill clause in the bail-out plan.

"We at Pimco took the rating agencies' rating as just one opinion that we factor into our investment process... As an investor it is our fiduciary responsibility to do those things," he said.

But others said they depend heavily on agencies.

"It is not our core business, so we have to rely on some credible indicators and outside expertise," said Terence Chandler, president of the small mining company Redcorp Ventures Ltd. , which has C$90 million of its cash frozen in non-bank ABCP.

DBRS is not alone among rating agencies in drawing fire in recent weeks as cracks appear in credit markets around the world, sparked originally by rising defaults in the U.S. subprime mortgage market.

S&P, Moody's and Fitch have all come in for criticism and a U.S. senator has called for a review of rating agencies' role in giving strong ratings to risky subprime mortgage securities.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins & John Partridge, 23 August 2007

HSBC Bank Canada has become the second bank to say it was telling clients to buy non-bank commercial paper based on the ratings it had received from DBRS Ltd.

"Like other financial institutions and intermediaries, HSBC Bank Canada and our subsidiaries have supplied bank and non-bank ABCP [asset-backed commercial paper] to customers based on ratings," spokeswoman Sharon Wilks said yesterday.

DBRS is the only credit rating agency that has been active in the Canadian non-bank ABCP market. Earlier this week, National Bank of Canada chief executive officer Louis Vachon said he believed his bank probably "focused a lot" on the solid ratings that DBRS had given these securities.

As a growing number of small resource firms disclose that they bought non-bank ABCP based on advice from HSBC Bank Canada, the Vancouver-based arm of Europe's biggest bank issued a statement yesterday saying that it recognizes the concern of its customers and will work with them during this "difficult time."

"This is a complex situation and it's going to take some time to work through," Ms. Wilks said.

The list of resource companies that say they bought non-bank ABCP based on advice from HSBC Bank Canada grew yesterday to include names such as Superior Mining International Corp., Silver Standard Resources Inc., Canada Energy Partners Inc., and Southern Arc Minerals Inc. Redcorp Ventures and First Quantum Minerals Ltd. are among the firms that have already said the same thing. All together, these small companies have more than $173-million invested in this area.

Vacation operator Transat A.T. Inc. also revealed yesterday that nearly half its cash is parked in this market. It says it made those investments based on advice from National Bank of Canada.

Executives at Montreal-based Transat sought to assure clients and investors that they still have sufficient funds on hand to keep the business operating.

The company said $154.5-million of its $340-million cash holdings are invested in 10 different ABCP trusts. But less than half of Transat's ABCP investments are in trusts managed by Coventree Inc.

"We would like to emphasize that we have enough cash to operate and that customer deposits are not at stake," Transat chief financial officer François Laurin said on a conference call.

The company will work hard to recover its money, but it's too soon to tell whether it will incur losses, executives said.

It will be some time before the Canadian companies who are holding non-bank ABCP find out what their investments are worth.

While some financial institutions are buying back the troubled paper from mutual funds and retail investors, corporate clients are largely being left to fend for themselves, people in the industry said.

"Nobody's having luck getting their money back," said the chairman of one Canadian firm that holds non-bank ABCP.

To protect its reputation, National is spending $1.85-billion to buy back non-bank ABCP, but the majority of that money will be used to buy it back from mutual funds that National Bank runs and from some individual investors.

As for corporate clients, National said it would buy non-bank ABCP from those who hold $2-million or less, and who are not accredited investors.

That means only very small companies qualify.

Transat's Mr. Laurin said yesterday that the tour operator is "in discussions with [National] about a lot of things."

Meanwhile, HSBC has not decided whether it will buy back non-bank ABCP from its corporate customers, Ms. Wilks said.

"We are working through, individually with customers, and just generally as an organization, how we're going to handle various situations."

While HSBC was recommending these products to its clients, it did not put them in its own mutual funds.

ABCP is debt in the form of such things as mortgages, car loans and credit card receivables that banks or other "third party" structured finance companies buy, repackage and sell to investors as short-term instruments for parking their cash at a profit.

In the fallout from the global credit crunch triggered by the U.S. subprime mortgage debacle, skittish investors largely stopped buying the third-party variety last week, and major banks have taken the position that conditions under which they contracted to provide backstop financing for the paper have not been met.

This has left several third-party finance companies in dire straits, most visibly Coventree, which announced it could not find new buyers for hundreds of millions of dollars in asset-backed loans that had come due.

Earlier yesterday, Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial Services Inc. of Quebec City said it will buy back all $70-million in third-party ABCP held in its money market mutual funds at 100 per cent of the purchase price plus accrued interest, the same terms National is offering.

Meanwhile, NAV Canada and Dundee Bank of Canada each disclosed yesterday that they hold close to $400-million of non-bank ABCP.
__________________________________________________________
Scotia Capital, 21 August 2007

National Bank Moves Rapidly to Protect Franchise

• National Bank announced that it plans to acquire $2.0 billion in asset-back commercial paper (ABCP), including about $150 million in bank administered conduits, held in mutual funds as well as held by retail clients.

• This very quick action reflects NA's active participation in the "Framework Agreement" and is very supportive to their customers and investors. The $2 billion will be going on NA's balance sheet and if underlying credit remains solid and interest rates do not increase we would expect the bank to suffer no material financial loss on this transaction. The $2 billion figure includes money market funds, fixed income funds and other pooled funds of its subsidiaries.

National Bank to Make Funds Whole

• NA has agreed to purchase the asset-backed commercial paper at cost thus keeping the holders whole. The $2 billion in assets represents $2 billion in risk-weighted assets which will reduce the bank's Tier 1 capital ratio by 36 bp.

• NA stated it will take the following measures in its press release on August 20, 2007:

o "Holders of Mutual and Pooled Funds: National Bank will agree to acquire all ABCP currently held in the National Bank and Altamira public mutual funds and in the pooled funds used by Natcan in its discretionary management (except for two alternative funds) and by National Bank Trust in its private investment management at 100% of the acquisition cost of such ABCP to these funds plus accrued interest. Payment to the funds will be made in cash and used to purchase securities such as Canadian treasury bills or other similar high quality liquid government bonds.

o Individual Investors: National Bank will agree to acquire ABCP purchased through the Bank, National Bank Financial or National Bank Direct Brokerage and held in their accounts by individual retail clients of such entities at 100% of their acquisition cost plus accrued interest. Payment will be made in Bearer Deposit Notes or in National Bank Banker's Acceptances.

o Corporations: National Bank will also agree to acquire ABCP purchased through the Bank, National Bank Financial or National Bank Direct Brokerage by other clients who have total holdings of Cdn. $2 million or less in ABCP in their accounts at such entities and who do not qualify as accredited investors under securities regulations, at 100% of the acquisition cost of such ABCP plus accrued interest. Payment will be made in Bearer Deposit Notes or in National Bank Banker's Acceptances."

Market Heavily Discounting NA ABCP Exposure

• NA will have to make a decision in Q4 whether there is any impairment on the $2 billion of ABCP and whether or not to take a provision although assets are currently rated R-1 by DBRS with DBRS stating that asset quality remains solid.

• NA's exposure of $1.85 billion to non-bank administered conduits includes securitization sponsors Coventree, Quantos and Newshore with conduits including Rocket, Comet, Aurora, Gemini, Planet, Slate, Apollo, Apsley, Whitehall and Devonshire.

• In terms of potential write-downs or provisions, a 10% provision on the $1.85 billion of non-bank administered ABCP would represent $185 million pre-tax ($120 million after-tax or $0.75 per share). We believe the market is currently discounting approximately $1 billion, which, in our opinion is excessive.

Major Banks - No Exposure to Non-Bank ABCP

• The remaining 5 major Canadian banks issued press releases (RY and TD on August 16, 2007, followed by BMO, BNS and CM on August 20, 2007) stating that their Canadian money market funds have no exposure to asset-backed commercial paper administered by non-bank sponsored conduits. The commercial paper held in money market funds is sponsored by the major Canadian banks. In addition, the banks stated that money market funds do not have any exposure to U.S. sub-prime, collateralized debt obligations or derivatives markets. BMO also stated that it has not experienced above average redemption activity in its funds.

Banker's Acceptances Spreads Blow Out

• The nervousness in the market about liquidity and the ABCP crisis is reflected in the Banker's Acceptance - T-Bill spread that has moved out 68 bp in the past 8 days to 72 bp, the highest level since the Asia Crisis in Sept/Oct 1998.

Recommendation

• We recently upgraded NA to a 2-Sector Perform from a 3-Sector Underperform based on share price weakness and substantial P/E discount of 19%.
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, Doug Alexander and Frederic Tomesco, 21 August 2007

Bank of Montreal, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce and Canada's four other biggest banks agreed to work together to ensure that the C$120 billion ($113 billion) market for asset-backed commercial paper continues to ``perform satisfactorily.''

The banks' chief executive officers held discussions today, and reiterated their commitment to provide ``liquidity'' for their commercial paper when it comes due, according to a joint statement. The Bank of Canada said the move was a ``positive step.''

``This might very well be to placate their mutual-fund holders,'' Genuity Capital Markets analyst Mario Mendonca said in an interview.

The statement may indicate the banks are facing redemptions from their commercial paper funds, and are trying to reassure investors that they'll prop up money markets, he said. National Bank of Canada yesterday offered to buy back C$2 billion in commercial paper from clients.

The market for commercial paper used to buy assets from mortgages to car loans has seized up as fallout from the subprime mortgage crisis in the U.S. spreads. In Canada, a group of 10 banks and pension funds last week agreed to convert about C$35 billion in commercial paper into longer-term notes after non-bank firms such as Coventree Inc. failed to roll over debt.

``Ultimately the objective is stability in the market, so the banks needed to address the concerns investors have,'' said Huston Loke, head of global structured finance at DBRS, a Toronto-based rating company.

Some Canadian lenders including Royal Bank of Canada and National Bank have said they haven't had problems rolling over their own asset-backed commercial paper. National Bank said yesterday it had redemptions of about 5 percent from its money- market funds.

``The paper is definitely rolling over,'' Loke said. ``Obviously the spreads are wider than everyone would like.''

Banks manage about two-thirds of the C$120 billion market for asset-backed commercial paper in Canada, with the rest run by firms like Coventree.

``The commitment by Canada's major bank CEOs to work together to support the performance and liquidity of the market for bank-sponsored asset-backed commercial paper is a further positive step to help re-establish well functioning money markets,'' the Ottawa-based central bank said in statement today on its Web site.

The bank CEOs held a conference call this morning, Royal Bank spokeswoman Beja Rodeck said in an interview.

In a separate statement, CIBC said it will support its own commercial paper trusts: Crisp Trust, Franchise Trusts I and II, Macro Trust, Safe Trust, Smart Trust and Sound Trust. And Industrial Alliance Insurance and Financial Services Inc., a Quebec City-based insurer, said today it offered to buy back C$77 million in non-bank commercial paper.

Royal Bank shares rose 92 cents, or 1.7 percent, to C$54.32 at 4:16 p.m. on the Toronto Stock Exchange, leading the gains among Canada's six-biggest banks. The S&P/TSX Banks Index rose 1.5 percent.

Asset-backed commercial paper is corporate debt that matures within a year and is backed by assets such as mortgages or commercial loans.
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, John Greenwood, 21 August 2007

Hit by a wave of redemptions by spooked investors, National Bank Financial took evasive action yesterday, announcing it will buy back $2-billion of troubled asset-backed commercial paper held by its mutual funds and clients.

The market for asset-backed commercial paper, a widely held form of commercial debt, ran aground last week as investors grew concerned about exposure to U.S. subprime mortgages. So far, most of the worry is focused on asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) issued by nonbank firms, a $35-billion sector owned by entities ranging from mutual funds to mining companies. That market is now all but dried up, with issuers unable to sell at any price.

National Bank said most of its exposure to ABCP is through funds such as its Altamira subsidiary. Denis Dube, a spokesman for the bank, said the board of directors made the decision to take the hit on Sunday after a chaotic week during which frightened investors withdrew $100-million from National's money-market mutual funds, or about 5% of the total.

"We view this as very much a move to preserve the bank's reputation with investors," said Mario Mendonca, an analyst at Genuity Capital Markets. "They did this to cover themselves."

Louis Vachon, National's chief executive, said buying back the investment was "the right thing to do, for all stakeholders."

Commercial paper is a popular investment with companies and individuals looking to park their money for short periods of time. In recent days a string of companies have disclosed exposure to ABCP. National Bank and the Caisse de depot et placement du Quebec, Canada's largest pension fund manager, are believed to be the biggest holders.

National's announcement comes four days after a group of 10 major financial institutions unveiled a plan to calm the troubled market. The group, which includes National and the Caisse de depot, said they will convert the ABCP that can't find buyers into longer-term debt, thereby removing or at least postponing the threat of default by some issuers.

The plan's backers are hoping that by transferring the troubled investments to another market and extending payment deadlines, the value may be restored. But critics charge that the bail-out still leaves investors on the hook for risk that they never agreed to accept in the first place. The troubles in the commercial-paper market first emerged early last week after Coventree Inc., a leading independent player in asset-backed paper, was unable to roll over some of its debt.

Coventree and other issuers typically have deals with big banks that require them to come to the rescue with additional financing in the event of a market collapse. But when Coventree called on its bankers for emergency funding last week, its pleas were declined. That prompted DBRS, the only rating agency that covers the sector in Canada, to issue a series of default warnings. Since then the market for has been all but dry.

Asset-backed commercial paper is backed by bundles of credit obligations ranging from car loans to credit-card debt to, in some cases, U.S. subprime mortgages. Much of it is packaged with "enhancements," including guarantees by financial players to kick in funding if something goes wrong with the market or with underlying cash flows. Partly on the strength of those arrangements, DBRS gave many Canadian ABCP issues top ratings.

The troubles are exacerbated by the lack of clarity as to exactly what kind of debt investors are exposed to with top-rated issues not requiring a prospectus. That means investors have limited knowledge of what they are buying.

The market crisis now unfolding "is something nobody ever thought would happen," said one industry insider. He said it was always assumed that a default was considered a highly remote possibility.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins & Sinclair Stewart, 21 August 2007

National Bank of Canada says it relied on Dominion Bond Rating Service's stamp of approval when it put substantial mutual fund assets into a now-troubled corner of the commercial paper market, and it's not the only investor holding these securities.

Canada's sixth-biggest bank is buying nearly $2-billion worth of so-called non-bank asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) from its money market funds, individual investors and corporations in a move designed to protect its reputation.

Money market funds are typically perceived as bastions of safety by average investors. But National Bank's money market funds had up to 40 per cent of their assets invested in non-bank-administered ABCP that is now experiencing a liquidity crisis.

Asset-backed commercial paper is short-term debt that's backed up by packages of loans, ranging from credit card receivables to car loans to mortgages. It generally rolls over every day.

Last week, the Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec led a group of major financial institutions in the creation of an agreement, dubbed the "Montreal proposal," to shore up the market for non-bank ABCP.

But it's too early to know what these securities will eventually be worth.

"Whatever our decisions were, the consequences should not be borne by our clients," National Bank chief executive officer Louis Vachon said on a conference call yesterday.

Having assumed the role of CEO earlier this summer, he found himself defending National Bank's reputation, as it was the only big Canadian bank to put money market fund assets into these securities.

Mr. Vachon said he believes National probably "focused a lot" on the solid ratings that the securities received from DBRS.

"Given that we were still within the investment management policies that we had, we ended up with a fair amount of weighting of these securities in our funds," Mr. Vachon said.

DBRS did not comment yesterday.

Last week, DBRS managing director Jerry Marriott said that "any rating agency should be able to stand up for itself and give its rationale for why it took a particular rating decision." He said DBRS has been "very responsible in terms of not only giving ratings on this paper initially, but also confirming that rating and being clear about the basis of our confirmation of that rating throughout this time of uncertainty."

While lessons will be learned, Mr. Vachon said to "keep in mind the market is obviously a lot more aware of the risk of these securities over the last few weeks, but you just go back three or four weeks ago, the market was still functioning properly."

He also noted that National is holding about $2-billion of the estimated $35-billion market in Canada, and said he would like to know where the other $33-billion is being held.

A flurry of mining companies have stated that they are holding millions of dollars in third-party ABCP. Some of them have said they got into the market on the advice of HSBC Bank Canada, which has declined to comment.

Ernst & Young, which is working with the financial institutions that signed the Montreal proposal, is trying to find out who owns the rest, Mr. Vachon said.

The five biggest Canadian banks issued statements yesterday to say their mutual funds do not hold non-bank ABCP. The non-bank market is a small part of the Canadian ABCP market that includes companies such as Coventree Inc. A larger part of the market is administered by the banks.

Desjardins Group said it will buy non-bank ABCP out of its money market funds. Its exposure is about $100-million, a spokesman said.

Some big banks said they kept largely away from the non-bank ABCP market because the underlying assets are opaque, and it's hard to determine what they are worth.

All of the big five banks are providing liquidity to their own sponsored conduits - vehicles set up to package and sell ABCPs - and that market is functioning smoothly, a source said.

"I think non-bank conduits are done. It's over. And it will never happen again," said the source, who is a senior executive at one of the big banks. They added that it was large international banks that helped it to flourish.

Mr. Vachon said National's board and senior management decided to buy back the $2-billion in commercial paper because they were concerned that clients would be worried about the quality of their investments.

"There were two scenarios that we absolutely wanted to avoid," he said. "One was to suspend redemptions of any of our money market products. And, second, facing a hypothetical situation whereby we would have to inform our money market investors that they were taking losses on an investment they'd make on money markets with National Bank."

Redemptions in the funds had hit 5 per cent in the past week or so, Mr. Vachon said.

This weekend, The Globe and Mail and a number of Quebec newspapers reported that National's money market funds had assets invested in the non-bank ABCP market.

About 90 per cent of the $2-billion worth of paper it's buying back was in mutual funds and other vehicles where National had discretionary investment responsibility for the assets, he said.

The bank is also buying $150-million in bank-sponsored ABCP.

National's decision to buy back ABCP from some individual and corporate clients who bought it from the bank is causing a headache for the other large banks, who are now getting calls from clients asking whether they will do the same, said sources at two of the banks.

National executives said that up to 10 per cent of the non-bank ABCP market is invested in U.S. subprime mortgages.

Exposure to non-bank, or third-party, asset-backed commercial paper:

National Bank $1.85-billion
New Gold $152-million
Desjardins Group $100-million
Barrick Gold U$65-million
Baffinland Iron $43.8-million
Petrolifera $37.7-million
Miramar Mining $37-million
Westaim $19.7-million
Jura Energy $14.9-million
Ivanhoe Mines $13.8-million
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, 20 August 2007

National Bank of Canada is defending its dramatic decision to protect retail, mutual fund and some other clients from losses by repurchasing about $2-billion in troubled asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP), and warning investors not to rush to judgment about the size of its presence in this market.

“The amounts are large, I'll grant you that,” chief executive officer Louis Vachon said of National's exposure during a conference call with analysts Monday after it pledged to buy all the ABCP held by these clients for 100 per cent of the clients' original purchase price plus accrued interest, in a move that also is designed to protect the bank's reputation. “However, before reaching any conclusions on our relative weight in these things versus some of our other competitors on the street, we should probably wait and see where the rest [is].

“We've accounted today for $2-billion of the $35-billion. . . I think it would be fair to find out where the other $33-billion is being held.”

The short-term paper, sold as a good place to park cash at a premium return, has run into a major liquidity crisis in the current global credit squeeze, especially a variety sold by so-called third-party, or non-bank issuers, which currently accounts for about $35-billion of the approximately $120-billion Canadian ABCP market.

National Bank is moving to protect its retail and mutual fund clients, and its reputation, from potential losses on so-called third-party asset-backed commercial paper.

As well, challenged by one analyst about the potentially costly precedent National is setting by bailing out its clients this way, Mr. Vachon said the bank decided the alternative would be worse – even though it had no legal obligation to take action.

“We were much more worried about the other precedent we would have created in the event that we would have had to suspend redemptions on our money market funds and/or there may have been losses [for retail investors] associated with our money market funds,” he said.

“So, we are taking pretty drastic measures, [but] our sense is that it's the right thing to do to protect the franchise – and well see.”

Mr. Vachon said it is too soon to tell what financial impact the measures will have on National's financial results and that selling third-party ABCP was not a major business for the bank.

“Now, with the benefit of hindsight, clearly we'll take the next few months to find out what we could or should have done a little differently in terms of managing these assets,” he added.

The Globe and Mail reported Saturday that National, the smallest of Canada's Big Six domestic banks, is the only one of them to have loaded up its money market funds with the third-party variety.

Analyst Ohad Lederer at Veritas Investment Research in Toronto warned in a report to clients Friday that there is a “significant risk” that the National money market funds in question “will incur losses unwinding their holdings” and, in the worst case, might have to suspend redemptions.

“Should this happen, National's reputation will be seriously damaged,” Mr. Lederer wrote, who has a “sell” recommendation on the bank's shares.

In an interview following the conference call Monday, he said National had no choice but to take action. “It's kind of like they were forced into doing the right thing,” he said. “It's good for the retail investor.”

However, the bank is taking the $2-billion in ABCP on to its own balance sheet, and this means it will have to set aside capital to cover the additional assets. “That's capital that can't be used for other things, such as [share] buy-backs,” Mr. Lederer said.

Desjardins Group, which also has some ABCP in several funds, also issued a statement Monday saying that it “will take charge of” all this paper “in order to protect its members against the current uncertainty prevailing in the. . . market.”

Meanwhile, Bank of Montreal, Bank of Nova Scotia and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce all issued nearly identical statements saying that their money market mutual funds do not contain any third-party asset-backed paper in money market funds and do not have any exposure to U.S. subprime, collateralized debt obligations and derivatives markets.

National's action Monday comes four days after it and nine other financial institutions — none of them other Big Six banks — announced a rescue plan for the battered third-party ABCP market involving the conversion of this short-term debt into longer-term instruments and other measures, including a standstill agreement.

The group issued another statement Monday saying investors who want to participate in the plan should contact accounting firm Ernst & Young, which the group has hired to co-ordinate the effort, to confirm that they support the standstill. “By doing so, [they] are simply committing to continue to roll their paper during the 60 day standstill period and not to take any action that would precipitate a default in any of these trusts,” the group said.

National said it will buy all the ABCP currently held in its and Altamira's public mutual funds, pooled funds used by subsidiaries Natcan (excluding two hedge funds) and National Bank Trust in their discretionary and private investment management activities. Payment will be in cash that will be used to buy “high-quality liquid government bonds,” including treasury bills, it said.

“As a result, our clients can be reassured that the funds will not hold any ABCP until we are convinced of the quality and liquidity of the paper, whether or not it is issued by a major bank,” National said.

Meanwhile, individual investors who bought ABCP through the bank or its brokerage arms, will be paid in bearer deposit notes or banker's acceptances, the bank said.

National added that it also will buy back holdings of up to $2-million in ABCP from corporate clients which “do not qualify as accredited investors under securities regulations,” also paying bearer deposit notes or banker's acceptances.

“Thanks to the bank's good financial position, we have the opportunity to voluntarily take these extraordinary measures to maintain the relationship of confidence that we have with our clients,” Mr. Vachon said in a statement.

National said that as a result of these actions it expects to buy a total of about $2-billion in asset-backed paper from its clients, including about $150-million issued by bank-sponsored conduits.

Asset-backed commercial paper is created when banks or other companies take long-term assets such as mortgages, auto leases and credit card receivables, repackage them as short-term debt and sell them to investors, through special purpose trusts, or conduits.

Third-party ABCP is created by non-bank financial companies, the largest in Canada being Coventree Inc. in Toronto.

Coventree became the epicentre of the crisis in the market last week — and saw its stock market value shredded — when it disclosed it could not find buyers for large chunks of this paper when it came due and that banks that had committed to providing it with loans to back-stop its operations were refusing to do so.

It said it plans to assess the value of the acquired paper, as well as other contingencies related to its exposure to the current quarter.

National Bank's shares gyrated up and down and up again on news of the rescue plan. At about 2.20 p.m. EDT, they were back in the black at $54.87, up 7 cents, on the Toronto Stock Exchange, having fallen as $53.75.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins, 18 August 2007

A number of National Bank of Canada's money market mutual funds contain a troubled type of commercial paper that could expose them to potential losses.

National, the country's sixth-largest bank, is the only big bank to have holdings of this type in its money market funds, said Christian Charest, associate editor of Morningstar Canada, which rates mutual funds.

Groupe Desjardins has two money market funds with minimal amounts of exposure, he added.

National Bank declined to comment yesterday. Desjardins could not be reached for comment.

The $40-billion third-party asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) market fell into disarray recently after liquidity dried up.

On Thursday, a group of 10 financial institutions, including National Bank, announced a preliminary bailout plan for the market. It would see the short-term paper converted into longer-term instruments, with maturities of up to 10 years.

Some fund industry players have complained that money market funds can only hold debt that matures within a year, meaning they might be forced to sell and take a loss.

Five of National Bank's funds are loaded with third-party ABCP issued by conduits that are experiencing a problems with liquidity, Veritas Investment Research analyst Ohad Lederer wrote in a note to clients yesterday. He questioned whether National is the next BNP Paribas.

Paribas, France's biggest bank, sent markets tumbling last week after it said it was freezing three mutual funds, halting withdrawals on billions of dollars of assets.

Mr. Lederer said National Bank told him it believes that if the bailout goes through, National's money market funds will be able to hold the notes and not be forced to sell at a potential loss.

Mr. Lederer estimates that, as of March 31, the five National Bank funds with exposure held between 16.9 and 46.2 per cent of their net assets in commercial paper issued by conduits having liquidity problems.

Mr. Charest said, as of July 31, the five funds had between 8.44 and 42.34 per cent of their holdings exposed to trusts that were on a list of more than 20 trusts and issuers placed under review by Dominion Bond Rating Services this week.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, 17 August 2007

Last week, French bank BNP Paribas SA suspended three asset-backed securities funds, saying it could not value them accurately as the liquidity crisis was in full swing around the globe.

Now, Veritas Investment Research is asking if National Bank of Canada is the next Paribas?

Analyst Ohad Lederer points out that National has loaded five of its money market mutual funds with asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP) issued by non-bank conduits that are currently experiencing a lack of liquidity.

“We believe there is a significant risk that these funds will incur losses unwinding their holdings and, in a worst case scenario, the funds may have to suspend redemptions. Should this happen, National’s reputation will be seriously damaged,” he warns, advising investors to “sell” shares of National.

The stock is trading at $53.87, down 43 cents, on the TSX Friday and down from a recent high of $63.64 on July 24.

Mr. Lederer figures National’s Corporate Cash Management Fund, which is benchmarked against 91-day T-bills, holds an estimated $350-million of commercial paper issued by non-bank conduits that are now on Dominion Bond Rating Services’ watch list. That represents an “astonishing” 46 per cent of the fund’s net assets, he adds.
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, Barry Critchley, 17 August 2007

Seasoned pros have seen it before. Novices in the business now have a new relationship -- one that explains the recent flurry of releases from the chartered banks providing further details of their exposure to the asset-backed commercial-paper sector -- to work on.

"It's all to do with the stock price. They will give more disclosure when they see the stocks melting down," said one observer, adding that after being beaten up for the past few days, most of them rallied yesterday when the banks told the world more about their exposure to the sector.

"It was in their best interests to give some information," said a market participant who contends the rest of the banks learned from the experience of Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, which earlier this week detailed its exposure to the U.S. subprime market. Even though the exposure was more than what many expected, the stock rallied. "The banks got a nice lesson in disclosure," added the participant, who says that without the disclosure [from the banks yesterday] the banks would have continued to trade lower. "If investors weren't taking their stocks down, we wouldn't have heard anything more."

Indeed, prior the flurry of information, the market was in the dark. The banks didn't provide this information in their annual reports. Instead, they referred to overall numbers --numbers that included exposure to their own conduits and to third-party conduits. "Their disclosure [until yesterday] was bad until they realized they were going to get hit," said one observer, who still believes the banks haven't told the full story. "They still don't want to provide the nitty-gritty but it's better than nothing."

Among individual banks that commented yesterday, Bank of Nova Scotia said it has $10.9-billion of exposure, of which 73% represents committed liquidity for Scotiabank Canadian sponsored conduits. It has a 3% exposure (or about $300-million) to non-Scotiabank sponsored Canadian conduits. For its part, Bank of Montreal said it "is an insignificant provider of liquidity backup lines to third party administered asset-backed commercial paper issuers in Canada." Toronto-Dominion Bank, which didn't provide any overall numbers, said it didn't have any exposure to non-bank issuers of ABCP. CIBC, which also didn't provide numbers on exposure, said its "direct holdings in the third-party asset backed commercial paper market are not significant." Earlier in the week, Royal Bank of Canada said "over 90%" of its $34.3-billion in backstop liquidity facilities "was committed for RBC-administered commercial paper conduits."

And what's more, a number of the banks reported that their own conduits -- where they are aware of the individual assets that are included -- are preforming satisfactorily.
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, Paul Vieira, 17 August 2007

Finance Minister Jim Flaherty's statement Thursday to calm investors about Canada's economy amid plunging markets was more a "subtle hint" to the major chartered banks to do their part to ensure the turmoil over a credit crunch does not snowball into a full-blown crisis.

If it was designed as such, the banks got the message. Hours after the Minister's statement was made public, the five major chartered banks -- Royal Bank of Canada, Bank of Montreal, Toronto-Dominion Bank, Bank of Nova Scotia and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce -- said in notices they would do their part to make funds available to market participants who find themselves in a liquidity squeeze.

Mr. Flaherty, in his statement, tried to reassure investors about the global credit crunch -- perhaps exacerbated in Canada by concerns in the market dealing with asset-backed commercial paper.

The Minister said he was pleased with an accord struck yesterday, involving a consortium of lenders and investors, to convert asset-backed commercial paper into longer-term notes in an effort to ease liquidity concerns. But he urged players on Bay Street to go further in bringing calm to markets.

"Clearly, there are stresses in some corners of the Canadian money markets. ? [And] I know that there are distinct pressures in the market for the non-bank-sponsored asset-based commercial paper vehicles," Mr. Flaherty said.

"It is in the best interest of all involved that sponsors, liquidity providers (including large international banks) and investors (including large pension funds) engage constructively to pursue orderly market solutions to this liquidity situation," he said in the statement, released after lunchtime when the Toronto benchmark stock index was at its biggest loss of the day.

One market watcher said he believes Mr. Flaherty's words were aimed directly at the big Canadian banks.

"He's basically telling them that everyone ought to co-operate. And I would say it is a subtle hint," said Laurence Booth, a professor at the University of Toronto's Rotman School of Management and an expert in structured finance. "He's suggesting to the banks that they can't operate in their own narrow interests and refuse to honour their commitments."

A string of issuers of securitized debt have sought added funds from chartered banks after failing to find buyers for new paper. But some banks, most notably CIBC, had declined to provide backstop financing -- even though financing agreements between lenders and debt issuers generally provide for emergency funds in times of liquidity shortages, Mr. Booth said.

Later yesterday afternoon, though, the banks appeared to heed Mr. Flaherty's call for credit. Four banks issued statements, in which they pledged their support to find an "orderly solution" in the non-bank commercial paper market

Curiously, stocks on Bay Street recovered in the hours after Mr. Flaherty's statement. Between roughly 12:45 p.m., when the statement was released, and 4 p.m., the Toronto benchmark index went from a 560-point loss to a drop of 200 points.

Mr. Flaherty's statement also went to great lengths to assure Canadians that the fundamentals underlying the domestic economy remained "strong," and that the financial system was "well capitalized."

Nevertheless, he said he was in "close contact" with the Bank of Canada regarding global cash crunches -- stoked largely by a meltdown in the U.S. subprimemortgage market -- and Finance department officials would continue to closely monitor developments.

As part of efforts to stabilize markets, the Bank of Canada yesterday injected an additional $370-million into the financial system through agreements to purchase and resale securities. The central bank this week took the unusual step of extending the list of securities it would accept as collateral on short-term financing arrangements.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, John Partridge & Tara Perkins, 16 August 2007

The funding crisis in a key part of Canada's debt market may be over.

A group of 10 major financial players, including Quebec's giant provincial pension fund, said Thursday that, at a meeting in Montreal, they have reached an agreement to bail out the battered $40-billion market for so-called third-party asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP).

In a statement issued at 8.40 a.m. (EDT), the group said its members hold at least two-thirds of this ABCP, and that they are “confident” other market participants will sign on to the agreement.

The key elements of the rescue plan are to convert this short-term debt, which is sold through special-purpose trusts, into longer-term instruments, while also slapping a temporary moratorium on both investors trying to get their money out of the trusts and on issuers seeking financial injections from their lenders to keep the paper afloat.

The third-party ABCP market has been hammered by a sudden, rapid exodus of investors and a refusal by many banks and other lenders to honour agreements to provide such injections.

The third-party segment accounts for about one-third of the total ABCP market, while the other two-thirds is dominated by bank-sponsored trusts.

“Obviously the objective here is to bring some stability to the market, and we're encouraging every holder of this type of commercial paper to roll it over and take part in the standstill period so we can restructure the trusts,” Mark Boutet, a spokesman for the group, said when reached in Montreal.

Besides the Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec, which is believed to have spearheaded the push for a solution, the 10-member group includes: ABN Amro, Barclays Capital, Desjardins Group, Deutsche Bank, Merrill Lynch, National Bank of Canada and UBS, along with PSP Investments, the investment arm of the federal Public Service Pension Investment Board, the pension plan for the federal public service, the armed forces and the RCMP.

The federal Finance Department was heavily involved in brokering the deal, sources in Ottawa said.

Finance Minister Jim Flaherty applauded both the rescue plan and the “positive actions” of Canadian banks in support of the ABCP vehicles they sponsor and exhorting all market players to pull together to try to stabilize the market.

“I know that there are distinct pressures in the market for the non-bank sponsored asset-based commercial paper vehicles,” Mr. Flaherty said in a statement issued at midday.

“It is in the best interest of all involved that sponsors, liquidity providers (including large international banks) and investors (including large pension funds) engage constructively to pursue orderly market solutions to this liquidity situation.”

Later in the afternoon, the Bank of Canada also voiced support.

“The agreement announced this morning by major investors and liquidity providers to pursue an orderly restructuring of the Canadian market for structured finance asset-backed commercial paper (third party ABCp) provides an opportunity for parties to work through the many complex issues related to the market for asset-backed commercial paper,” the central bank said in a statement.

“The Bank also welcomes the confirmation by Canada's major chartered banks that they are supporting their own bank-sponsored asset-backed commercial paper programs.”

The commercial paper crunch is part of the worldwide fallout from the implosion of the U.S. subprime (read “high risk”) residential mortgage market.

The group's statement came as the Bank of Canada injected another $370-million in temporary short-term credit into the financial system in its latest bid to help loosen the credit squeeze.

Among the most important terms of the pact announced Thursday morning are that all outstanding third-party ABCP will be converted into term, floating-rate notes that will mature no earlier than the underlying assets and on which interest will be payable monthly or quarterly to match the fixed payment dates on those underlying assets.

“Existing liquidity facilities will therefore not be necessary and will be cancelled and all outstanding liquidity calls will be revoked,” the group said.

As well, margin agreements on the ABCP will be “revised to create renewed stability, thereby reducing the likelihood of near-term margin calls.”

In the short term, meanwhile, the group's members have agreed to continue to roll over the paper they hold for the next 60 days and will “encourage” other holders who have not yet signed up to do the same.

As well, they will not pursue any margin calls during this standstill period against any of the so-called conduits, which have repackaged the ABCP into special-purpose trusts they have then sold to investors. The conduits, in turn, will drop requests for liquidity they have already made and not make additional calls for 150 days after the standstill expires.

The conversion of the trusts to notes is designed to turn short-term instruments into longer term instruments, Mr. Boutet said, while the standstill will provide time for investors to approve the conversion, he said.

However, persuading investors to do this could be a tough proposition, judging by complaints about the rescue package levelled by Ken Anderson, who manages both the Canadian and U.S. money market funds for Fidelity Investments.

"What is really disheartening is that there was a meeting just yesterday with some of the largest underwriters of these securities and they've come to in their minds a great solution, they're going to take these extendible securities and turn them out into three- and five-year portion of the curve," Mr. Anderson said during a conference call Thursday. "We have one-year guidelines. We cannot invest out past one year. So, I'm not sure what type of solution this is.

“I think the holders of these securities will be forced to sell and most likely take some losses in their funds."

By contrast, one of the trusts affected by the crisis welcomed the news of the rescue package, calling it “important.”

The trustee for Global Diversified Investment Grade Income Trust II, which holds credit default swap agreements against various mortgage- and asset-backed securities and other instruments, said that the deal “could resolve the current inability” of its counterparty Silverstone Trust to renew or replace maturing short-term debt.

News of the rescue plan did nothing to stop another stock market plunge, which saw the S&P/TSX composite index drop dramatically.

Dominion Bond Rating Service said the agreement “reduces the liquidity risk, while exposing the investor to the same amount of credit risk that the investor held prior to the exchange.”

It added in a statement that it has placed about 90 individual asset-backed commercial paper trusts “under review” following the announcement.

News of the rescue plan could be especially sweet for structured finance firm Coventree Inc. of Toronto, the largest player in this market, whose troubles have become the epicentre of the crisis and whose stock market value has been shredded since the crisis began.

Coventree has been most visibly hurt by the commercial paper crunch and, despite news of the rescue package, its shares fell again Wednesday, as markets plunged.

Coventree operates nine conduits, special-purpose trusts that hold such long-term assets as mortgages, auto leases and credit card receivables that the firm buys from their originators, and then repackages and sells to investors as short-term debt.

Before the lenders group made its announcement Thursday, Coventree issued a statement saying it had been unable to find buyers for any ABCP that came due Wednesday, and has now requested a total of $1.6-billion in liquidity from its lenders, but that most are balking at providing funds.

The rescue plan also could benefit CFI Leasing Ltd. of Toronto, the latest player in the ABCP market to disclose it has run into trouble. It said Thursday morning that CFI Trust, which it manages, has been unable to roll over $82-million in asset-backed commercial paper and has therefore extended the term.

Quebec's Caisse is the biggest buyer of the asset-backed paper in which entities like Coventree and CFI Trust operate. The Globe and Mail reported Thursday that the giant Quebec pension fund has been pushing Canadian and international banks to provide liquidity to bail out the seized-up ABCP market.

In a report issued Wednesday, Merrill Lynch Canada Inc. economist and strategist David Wolf hypothesized that confidence could quickly return to the ABCP market if there were an agreement among participants or banks demonstrated they were broadly willing to provide backstop financing.

“Crisis over, Canadian ABCP starts rolling again at higher market-clearing spreads, and we wait for the credit crunch mole to pop back up in another market and another country.”

Without such a development, Mr. Wolf said, Coventree and other third-party sponsors' trusts could quickly begin defaulting.

Given the deteriorating global credit backdrop, he said, creditors would likely have an incentive to act quickly, likely leading to the forced sale of underlying assets. “This could end up being the tug on the Canadian string that further unravels the global credit ball of yarn, as these assets are both pressured and marked for the world to see,” Mr. Wolf warned.
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, Doug Alexander and Frederic Tomesco, 16 August 2007

ABN Amro Holding NV, Deutsche Bank AG and eight other banks and money managers agreed to convert asset- backed commercial paper in Canada into longer-term notes to ease a credit crunch in the C$40 billion ($37 billion) market.

The group of lenders and investors, which also includes the Caisse de Depot et Placement du Quebec and Merrill Lynch & Co., signed an agreement in Montreal today, according to a statement.

The accord may lift a money-market freeze in Canada sparked by the meltdown in the U.S. subprime mortgage market. Commercial paper trusts in Canada have been unable to sell debt coming due this week, and banks such as Deutsche and Barclays Plc have declined to provide emergency funding.

``This is a bad precedent, it's a form of bailout,'' said Hans Black, chairman and chief investment officer at Interinvest Consulting Corp. in Montreal, which manages about $2.8 billion and doesn't own commercial paper. ``This is going to calm the markets down, but only temporarily.''

Under the agreement, the commercial paper funds will be converted to floating-rate notes with maturities linked to the underlying assets, such as mortgages and corporate loans. Commercial paper in Canada typically matures in one to three months.

``It creates bigger problems down the road,'' Black said. ``This is floating-rate paper that is being issued, so somebody is going to have to get paid at some point.''

The pension funds, which include the Caisse de Depot et Placement du Quebec, also agreed to roll over maturing commercial paper for 60 days while the restructuring is carried out. These funds will also encourage other investors to roll over debt as it matures. The agreement is supported by two-thirds of the holders of this type of commercial paper, the group said.

Caisse, the largest pension fund manager in Canada, is among the largest holders of asset-backed commercial paper and called the group together to reach an agreement. The Montreal-based fund manager owned about C$1.69 billion of the debt at year end. The Caisse declined to say how much it still owns.

As part of the agreement, the banks won't seize assets as collateral during the period, and commercial paper issuers won't seek emergency financing from banks for 210 days, the statement said. The banks have refused funding for some trusts this week, arguing the freeze wasn't a ``market disruption'' that would force them to provide financing.

The agreement was also signed by Desjardins Group, HSBC Holdings Plc, The Public Sector Pension Investment Board, National Bank of Canada, Barclays Plc and UBS AG. DBRS, a Toronto-based rating company, was present for the discussions.

``It will resolve the liquidity crisis facing these conduits and the risk that they will default,'' Desjardins Securities analyst Michael Goldberg said in a note. ``We view this as a positive development overall for capital markets because it should reduce concerns about this issue spreading.''

Canadian Finance Minister Jim Flaherty said he welcomed the agreement and encouraged banks to pursue further ``market solutions,'' according to a statement today.

Royal Bank of Canada, the country's largest bank, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, Toronto-Dominion Bank and Bank of Montreal said in separate statements that they support the agreement.

``We are supportive of attempts to resolve issues, even if we are not directly involved, and would encourage other financial institutions to do the same,'' said Toronto-Dominion Chief Executive Officer Ed Clark in a statement.

About 23 commercial paper trusts will be supported, with assets of C$35 billion. These include at least seven run by Coventree Inc., Canada's biggest issuer of non-bank asset-backed commercial paper, and three run by Metcalfe & Mansfield Capital Corp., whose owners include Deutsche Bank and National Bank. Other trusts include Selkirk Funding Trust, Devonshire Trust, Foundation Trust and Skeena Capital Trust.

Coventree's units have been struggling to refinance debt as the subprime crisis spills over into Canada's C$120 billion asset-backed commercial paper market, about a third of which is run by non-commercial bank firms such as Coventree.

Coventree is ``supportive'' of the proposal to ``stabilize'' the market and hasn't issued funding requests on its paper that matured today, the Toronto-based company said in a statement. Earlier today Coventree said it was seeking an additional C$790 million of emergency funds from banks after failing to sell any notes yesterday.

Its shares rose 10 cents, or 2.6 percent, to C$4 at 3:26 p.m. trading on the Toronto Stock Exchange, and have declined 69 percent in five days. Canadian banks shares also rose, led by Bank of Montreal and Toronto-Dominion.

The agreement could offer relief for firms such as Redcorp Ventures Ltd., a Vancouver-based mining company whose repayments of C$102.2 million from investments in Coventree funds have been delayed.

``It's still a little murky right now, but obviously there's a lot of people working on this issue to resolve it,'' Redcorp President Terence Chandler said in an interview. ``We're hopeful that that means we'll have a resolution in our particular case as soon as possible.''

Redcorp told investors today it didn't receive repayments from Coventree, driving the stock down as much as 64 percent in Toronto.

``It's sheer worry and panic,'' said Denis Durand, a senior partner at Montreal fund manager Jarislowsky Fraser Ltd., which oversees the equivalent of $58.7 billion. ``Everyone in Canada thought a few weeks ago that the subprime mortgage problem was something limited to the U.S.''

Canadian banks account for about two-thirds of the asset- backed commercial paper market, led by Bank of Montreal and CIBC, according to DBRS. These banks have said this week they haven't had trouble rolling over their commercial paper, and that they aren't ``significant'' suppliers of emergency funds for these non-bank trusts. Foreign banks such as Barclays are the most active in that area.

``We believe this is good news for the Canadian banks, as it reduces the likelihood that they will have provided back-stop liquidity support'' to these trusts, CIBC World Markets analyst Darko Mihelic said in a note.
__________________________________________________________
;

23 August 2007

BMO Capital Markets on Bank Dividends

  
BMO Capital Markets, 22 August 2007

We aren't in the camp that is encouraging banks to boost dividends and buybacks aggressively. Maybe we are just showing our age, but we continue to believe that the short-term fixed income market volatility warrants some caution.

We believe that CIBC will boost its dividend this quarter (it has meaningfully lagged its peers on this front over the past year); we think there is a chance of RY and/or BMO moving, and we expect all other banks to stand pat.

In many ways, the dramatic volatility over the past couple of weeks should cause Bank Directors to pause. We believe there will be lots of opportunities in the future for banks to commit to return more annual earnings to shareholders (which dividend increases effectively do) and to reduce their permanent capital (which buybacks do). Given the current environment, discretion is the better part of valour.

We continue to recommend bank shares, with a preference for TD, CM and RY (all rated Outperform). All three have above-average exposure to the domestic Canadian economy, and we believe that the news on this front remains good. The risks appear to be quite manageable given the strength of the core franchises and the high degree of capital in the banking system.

Volatility Is High

It is clear that what started as a problem in the U.S. sub-prime mortgage market has spread. Risk has again become a four letter word, as evidenced by the recent problems in the non-bank asset backed commercial paper (ABCP) market in Canada. Conduits, which according to all reports continue to hold performing assets, have been unable to roll commercial paper, at any price. In this case, the perceived risks have more than outweighed the current cash flows of these vehicles It is the issues beyond Canada's borders, however, that have caused us the most concern. The rate on 90-day US T-Bills varied from 2.9% to 3.6% inter-day yesterday (see chart). If this isn't a sign that there are liquidity problems in short-term markets, we don't know what is. We expect Canadian banks to weather these problems, but we highlight that fourth-quarter trading revenues for Canadian banks tend to be seasonally weak, and this will likely be exaggerated by the current environment.

Banks have Already done a lot

Investors view (rightly) bank dividends as sacred, and the increases in dividends have put long-term commitments on all banks (in our opinion). Canadian banks have boosted their annual common dividends to shareholders from under $3 billion in 2000 to over $8 billion currently (see chart below). In a period of unprecedented volatility, a breather on increases seems justified.

Buybacks seem far less permanent, and investors seem to pay far more for dividends (again rightly so). Over the past couple months, banks have already begun to ratchet up their share repurchases. In July, banks bought back about three times their monthly average. We try not to be swayed by monthly purchases, and rather consider six rolling averages. Even on this front, banks have already moved to take the opportunities of weaker share prices (see chart below).

Conclusion

It is possible that investors will be disappointed by a more cautious view on the dividend and buyback front. If the earnings outlook is so solid, they may well ask, why not continue to boost dividends aggressively? We remain comfortable on the earnings outlook (although continued market volatility could spill over into the broader economy, which would reduce earnings expectations somewhat). We are confident that the Canadian economy will continue to perform well relative to its peers. Having said that, we believe that some caution is warranted, and not just for defensive reasons. Many cynics of Canadian banks suggest that they missed an opportunity in the early 1990s to build a larger non-Canadian presence following the debacle of commercial real estate in North America. At that stage, however, they were facing their own problems. The situation is different today. We believe that given their relatively strong balance sheets, the strength of the Canadian dollar and the relatively robust Canadian economy (which still drives the core of bank profitability) there could well be an excellent opportunity to expand at a fortuitous time.

We continue to recommend Canadian banks, with a preference for TD, CM and RY which have above-average exposure to the domestic Canadian economy. We think that TD is particularly well positioned to expand if the U.S. economy deteriorates. We just aren't sure that the time is right to reduce permanent capital (through buybacks) or to commit to increased annuity payments to shareholders (through dividend increase).
;

TD Ameritrade in Merger Talks with E*Trade

  
The Globe and Mail, Sinclair Stewart, 23 August 2007

If the U.S. discount brokerage industry is indeed poised to undergo another round of consolidation, few people can match the kind of cards that Ed Clark is holding.

There is a significant wrinkle, though: The head of Toronto-Dominion Bank is playing a pair of hands at the same time.

Speculation about online brokerage mergers was revived yesterday after a report suggested TD Ameritrade Holding Corp., of which Mr. Clark's bank owns just under 40 per cent, has been in secretive talks about combining with archrival E*Trade Group Inc.

On paper, at least, a deal between the second- and third-largest players in this industry would seem to make a great deal of sense: Because of the excess capacity of their technology platforms, the two could slash overlapping trading costs and potentially deliver huge savings to shareholders.

Both companies confirmed yesterday they are always willing to discuss a deal that would create value. Privately, however, sources close to TD Ameritrade and E*Trade said nothing has happened in the past several weeks to suggest a deal is imminent.

This shouldn't come as a complete surprise.

For Mr. Clark, TD Ameritrade represents just one leg of his U.S. expansion strategy. An issue he must weigh is whether it's better to invest further in the discount brokerage business, or look at bulking up his underperforming U.S. retail bank, TD Banknorth Inc., amid a climate of declining regional bank values.

The discount brokerage option would seem to yield much higher returns for shareholders, but it's not an easy solution - especially if TD wants to remain a dominant minority owner. For one thing, TD would likely have to contribute about $2.4-billion (U.S.) if it expects to maintain a 40-per-cent stake in a merged TD Ameritrade-E*Trade. Because discount brokerage acquisitions bring with them a substantial amount of goodwill, that could hurt TD's balance sheet at a time when the credit markets are already causing banks serious consternation.

TD has about $9-billion worth of goodwill on its books - almost as much as the rest of the Canadian banking industry combined. Goodwill essentially measures intangible assets, such as the worth of a company's brand: It is the difference between a company's book value, and the overall price it can fetch from an acquirer.

Adding more goodwill would put serious pressure on TD's Tier One capital ratios, a key measure of capital strength that regulators use to assess a bank's financial health.

A regional bank purchase, by contrast, would not likely have the same goodwill problem. Although the credit crunch has made some of these banks sketchy targets, tumbling stock prices in the sector could yield some bargains. The KBX regional bank index is down almost 10 per cent so far this year, and had fallen more than 20 per cent earlier this month.

Even if Mr. Clark shies away from any deal making in the retail sector, where TD has struggled, there are other reasons to be skeptical about a TD Ameritrade merger with E*Trade.

One significant obstacle is culture. Mr. Clark worked on a possible merger of TD Waterhouse Group Inc. and E*Trade a few years ago, but the deal fell apart after the two sides could not agree on who would take key executive roles in the new company.

Sources close to TD said the bank has a more positive view of E*Trade chief executive officer Mitch Caplan than it did at the time of the merger talks, though it's still not clear whether E*Trade and TD Ameritrade would be able to agree on who would run the show.

Michael Hecht, an analyst at Bank of America, flagged this as one of a handful of issues that he predicted will "ultimately prevent a deal." He also said in a report that credit quality concerns in E*Trade's loan book (the company has a small banking operation) could pose a stumbling block, and suggested that E*Trade's commission-driven model would not help TD Ameritrade's strategy of shifting more of its business toward fee revenues. While Mr. Hecht predicted a merger could produce cost savings of 45 per cent, he noted that these sorts of synergies haven't produced the kind of earnings growth that investors were anticipating when TD Waterhouse and Ameritrade struck their agreement. Indeed, since mid-2005, when the deal was announced, earnings per share have remained flat, he said.

News of merger talks, reported in the Wall Street Journal yesterday, come just months after two hedge funds raised concerns about TD's influence at TD Ameritrade, and lobbied the company to remove TD executives from its merger committee.
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, Duncan Mavin, 23 August 2007

A merger involving TD Ameritrade appeared more likely yesterday after revelations in U.S. media the firm has held weeks of talks with rival online brokerage E*Trade Financial.

However, the nature of a possible deal and what it could mean for Toronto-Dominion Bank, a part owner of TD Ameritrade, remain far from certain.

TD owns 39% of Ameritrade. A deal with another U.S. broker, if it happens, could see a range of outcomes, including TD taking a smaller share in a bigger entity or exiting the sector altogether.

"I think a deal will happen and I think E*Trade will be the surviving brand," said Robert Ellis, an analyst with Celent LLC.

TD's executives could be interested in selling out during "a bull market that is at or near the top," Mr. Ellis said. "If you were interested in cashing out, now would be a good time to do it."

However, TD's executives may be more interested in extending their investment in a combined firm that would likely benefit from synergies of scale.

"TD's ownership in a combined entity would be approximately 25%, giving it more flexibility to increase its stake," said Blackmont Capital analyst Brad Smith.

The recent deal rumours were sparked by a report in yesterday's Wall Street Journal that said E*Trade and TD Ameritrade have held talks over several weeks.

The report, which also said the two sides are not close to a deal, follows months of speculation about consolidation in the U.S. online-brokerage sector, where TD Ameritrade and E*Trade are dominant players alongside Charles Schwab.

Chatter intensified in June when two hedge funds -- S.A.C. Capital Advisors LLC and JANA Partners LLC -- with an 8.4% stake in TD Ameritrade demanded "a value maximizing transaction." In July, TD Ameritrade removed TD's seat on a board committee mandated to look at the brokerage's M&A options.

TD Ameritrade has acknowledged that it "has had and expects to continue to have discussion with its peers in the industry regarding mergers and acquisitions." Joe Moglia, chief executive, has also recently confirmed the broker is talking to other parties about a possible deal.

But some observers question whether a deal is even on the cards at all.

"While we have long understood the synergies of a potential deal, the number of hurdles to overcome continues to mount," said UBS Investment Research analyst Michael Carrier.

The obstacles include a possible clash of strong management teams at the two brokerages.
__________________________________________________________
The Wall Street Journal, Susanne Craig & Dennis K. Berman, 22 August 2007

The online brokerage industry, which underwent a wave of consolidation after the bursting of the dot-com bubble, may be headed for another shakeout, with giants TD Ameritrade Holding Corp. and E*Trade Financial Corp. holding merger discussions.

A merger of the two online brokers would create a dominant player in what has been a highly fragmented industry, with dozens of smaller companies battling for market share. As a result, it could reduce some of the fierce competition that has benefited consumers by driving down the cost of online trading but has squeezed the industry by chipping away at its profit margins.

As of the end of June, E*Trade had 4.7 million brokerage and banking accounts, TD Ameritrade had 6.3 million such accounts, and Charles Schwab Corp., now the largest online broker, had about 6.9 million. Merrill Lynch & Co., in contrast, has more than 7 million customer accounts.

A spokeswoman for E*Trade said the firm's management team has consistently stated it believes there is "tremendous value in consolidation that aligns business strategy and operational synergies and will do what is in the best interest of its customers." A TD Ameritrade spokeswoman said, "We have talked and continue to talk to peers in the industry."

E*Trade and TD Ameritrade have been in serious discussions for weeks but aren't yet close to a deal, according to people familiar with the matter. They have discussed an alliance several times in previous years but have never managed to make it to the altar. This time, however, they may feel more pressure to reach a deal. Two hedge funds with big stakes in TD Ameritrade have publicly urged the two companies to talk.

The two funds -- Jana Partners LLC and S.A.C. Capital -- have argued that Toronto-Dominion Bank, which owns 39% of TD Ameritrade, opposes a merger of the company because its interests aren't fully aligned with other shareholders. The funds, which own a combined 8.4% of TD Ameritrade, contend that the Canadian bank wants to use the online broker, which is based in Omaha, Neb., to grow in the U.S. and isn't necessarily focused solely on maximizing shareholder value. TD Bank has publicly disagreed with that characterization of its position.

Even so, Jana and S.A.C. successfully pressured TD Ameritrade to remove TD Bank's chief executive from the online broker's mergers and acquisitions committee in early July.

It isn't clear what a merger deal between E*Trade and TD Ameritrade would be worth or how it might be structured. One person familiar with the talks estimated a deal could create a company valued at as much as $20 billion, given the cost saving that could result from uniting both company's accounts on a single computer system. The consolidation would make the cost of adding new clients minimal.

Yesterday, E*Trade shares rose 93 cents to close at $15.57 in 4 p.m. composite trading on the Nasdaq Stock Market. TD Ameritrade, which also trades on Nasdaq, closed at $16.35, up 17 cents. TD Ameritrade currently carries a market capitalization of $9.74 billion while E*Trade's stock value is $6.6 billion.

A person familiar with the merger talks said the discussions currently are focused on making sure both online brokers agree on strategy. Ameritrade historically has been known as king of the low-cost trade while E*Trade has pursued a more diversified strategy and even owns a bank. In recent years, though, both firms have become more focused on offering customers an array of products.

"Both companies are looking to add client assets and diversify their operations away from trading commissions, so on many levels a merger makes sense," says Rich Repetto, an analyst at boutique brokerage firm Sandler O'Neill + Partners LP.

Since the Internet bubble burst, the sector has been beset by falling commissions. New York-based E*Trade, for instance, now charges between $6.99 and $9.99 a trade. In 1997, by contrast, Schwab Corp. made headlines by offering the then-bargain price of $29.95 for online trades of up to 1,000 shares. At the time, Schwab insiders worried that such a price cut -- trades had cost roughly three times that amount before -- would eat up profits.

Today, the competition for low-cost trades is even fiercer. Some banks, including Bank of America Corp. now offer free online trades for customers who meet certain minimum-balance requirements. In Bank of America's case, customers must have at least $25,000 in deposits to qualify.

With private-equity firms shrinking from the acquisition scene amid the current credit crunch, traditional mergers among industry rivals like TD Ameritrade and E*Trade may be the surest path for such companies to reach a deal. Such a deal might also be subjected to less antitrust scrutiny now under the business-friendly Bush administration than if it came up for review under President Bush's eventual successor.

In recent years, a number of deals between major competitors have passed antitrust muster, including appliance maker Whirlpool Corp.'s acquisition of Maytag Corp. and the merger of the nation's largest and second-largest hog producers, Smithfield Foods Inc. and Premium Standard Farms Inc.

The credit crunch, however, has added a new wrinkle to the TD Ameritrade-E*Trade talks: Last week E*Trade was hit with rumors that the quality of its mortgage portfolio, a growth engine for the company in recent years, was weak. The company's stock's dropped 28% last Thursday before rebounding the same day after E*Trade assured the market that despite some volatility, "the financial health of the company is sound."

Still, sources close to the negotiations say the quality of E*Trade's mortgage portfolio is an issue TD Ameritrade is watching closely.

Eventually, those involved in the talks say they expect the sticking points to be familiar ones: The two sides will need to agree on a management team to run the combined company and, on a related note, what degree of control Ameritrade shareholder TD Bank would have once the two brokerage firms were combined.

Picking a management team won't be easy. Both companies are run by forceful chief executives: Mitch Caplan at E*Trade and Joe Moglia at TD Ameritrade. Control was a point of contention during Ameritrade's 2005 talks with TD Bank. Eventually Mr. Moglia got the CEO post and TD Bank acquired five of the company's 12 board seats.

A person familiar with the matter said the two companies were talking before hedge funds Jana and S.A.C. went public with their call for talks between the pair. This person said the move actually slowed down negotiations because TD Ameritrade has been working to address some of the concerns raised by the funds, such as removing the TD Bank CEO from its merger and acquisition committee.

A deal between E*Trade and TD Bank would put added competitive pressure on Schwab. During a conference call with analysts in July, Schwab Chief Executive Charles Schwab threw cold water on speculation his firm might merge, suggesting that its internal growth opportunities were superior to acquisition-related ones. Yesterday, a Schwab spokeswoman declined to comment.

Schwab, long criticized by analysts for its high expenses, has sought in recent years to cut costs. It also recently named Walt Bettinger as president and chief operating officer to help assuage some concerns that had been brewing on Wall Street about the depth of Schwab's management bench. In another move aimed at getting its house in order, Schwab last year sold U.S. Trust to Bank of America. Schwab initially bought U.S. Trust in hopes of retaining more wealthy clients, but the marriage never worked, in part because of culture clashes between the two companies.
;

22 August 2007

Preview of Banks' Q3 2007 Earnings

  
Financial Post, Jonathan Ratner, 22 August 2007

Appreciation of the Canadian dollar has slowed, which helps banks with operations outside of Canada and the domestic economy.

Investor rotation into short term treasuries has driven down yields, which should boost bank margins since they borrow short term and lend long term.

With prices having dipped 15% since January, valuations for Canada’s financial stocks have become more attractive. The Big Six banks are trading at 10.98 times forward earnings per shares estimates, compared to 12.55x in 2006 and 12.86x in January 2007.

These are some of the reasons Canadian banks present an attractive investment opportunity, Citigroup analyst Shannon Cowherd said in a report previewing their third quarter results.

However, she is predicting an increase in the range of 50% for credit loss provisions compared to the third quarter last year.

As a result, Ms. Cowherd’s estimates average 4% below consensus (excluding Bank of Montreal).

She thinks BMO and CIBC could show upside earnings surprises, while Royal Bank and Toronto-Dominion may disappoint given their debt securities exposure.

Ms. Cowherd rates BMO a “buy” with a $85 price target, saying very little is expected given its earlier losses related to commodities trading.

Bank of Nova Scotia is also a “buy” with a $64 target, while its geographic diversification is considered a source of stability.

CIBC is the last of her “buy-rated” names in the group, with a price target of $121. It pre-announced third quarter results and is most exposed to the U.S. subprime market, Ms. Cowherd said. “Given the bank will likely report strong results it is best to buy ahead of the quarter’s results,” she added.

National Bank is rated “hold” with a $67 price target, while the analyst noted its dependency on its capital markets businesses.

Royal Bank is also rated “hold” with a $59 price target, given the lack of any clear catalyst that would boost the stock and less expected benefit than its rivals from the yield situation.

Finally, TD is rated “hold” with a $73 price target, both of which will be re-evaluated when more information surfaces about its asset-backed commercial paper exposure.
__________________________________________________________
Scotia Capital, 16 August 2007

Overview

• Banks begin reporting third quarter earnings August 23. There is tremendous nervousness in the equity markets, particularly with respect to bank stocks, given the current liquidity and credit crisis. Our forecast of earnings growth of 13% year over year (YOY) and 2% sequentially is unchanged with some potential for weaker earnings due to losses in the banks’ trading books. However, we believe bank trading revenue, although weak, will not have the impact on overall earnings the market is implying.

Banks Begin Reporting August 23

• Banks begin reporting third quarter earnings with Toronto-Dominion Bank (TD) on August 23, followed by Royal Bank (RY) August 24, Bank of Montreal (BMO) and Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS) August 28, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CM) and National Bank (NA) August 30, and Laurentian Bank (LB) and Canadian Western (CWB) closing out reporting September 6. Scotia Capital’s earnings estimates are highlighted in Exhibit 1, consensus earnings estimates/target prices in Exhibit 2, conference call information in Exhibit 3, and dividend increases and trends in Exhibit 6.

Q3 Earnings – Relief Rally?

• Canadian banks’ shares continue under selling pressure due to the liquidity crisis and credit concerns. Bank stocks have declined 8% year-to-date and 13% from their all-time highs. The bulk of bank share price weakness has occurred since the end of June. Canadian bank share price declines have been similar to Bank of America, Wells Fargo, Wachovia, and JP Morgan. We expect third quarter earnings to give the market some comfort about the sustainability of earnings, although follow-through into 2008 is likely needed.

• Our earnings forecast for Q3/07 is unchanged although the risk of weaker earnings than expected due to capital market volatility and significant widening of credit spreads has increased.

• Market concerns have moved from sub-prime mortgage loans to CDOs/CDOs squared to commercial paper and LBO financings.

• The banks’ loan exposure to major problem loan areas, highlighted in Exhibit 9, reflects the banks’ high capital and earnings levels relative to asset risk especially compared to previous cycles. Exhibit 7 also highlights the relatively benign Canadian sub-prime market compared with the United States. Pricing of sub-prime mortgages (ABX-BBB) and LBO loans (LCDX) have shown declines, as highlighted in Exhibits 10 and 11. The Canadian market is being hit by liquidity concerns with credit thus far remaining relatively solid.

• Bank stocks typically absorb the bulk of the market sell-off early given their liquidity, inherent financial risk, and the fact that their share prices have been trading at all-time highs.

• Bank market capitalization has declined $34 billion from its high. Bank valuation, we believe, is discounting a 31% decline in bank earnings, or a $9 billion decline pre-tax, which we believe is excessive. Bank trailing P/E multiples retraced early in the year based mainly on earnings strength as bank earnings increased nearly 20% in the first half of 2007. The recent sell-off has caused bank P/E multiples to decline further to 12.4x trailing earnings, the lowest since October 2002 and below the 2006 trough of 13.0x.

• Upon surviving the 2002 Telco-Cable, Power, Power Generation loan fears with earnings relatively intact (ROE 15%), the market expanded the banks’ P/E from 11x to 15x trailing earnings over the subsequent two years. Bank P/E multiples have been consolidating in the 13x-15x range over the past several years.

• We expect the banks to weather the most recent storm with earnings relatively intact and a trough ROE of 18%. Upon scaling yet another wall of worry we would expect P/E multiples to expand to the 15x-16x range. However, prior to these events unfolding we expect volatility and worry to persist in the near term.

• Bank valuation has become extremely compelling with the bank dividend yield relative to the TSX at its highest level in history (except for the Nortel impact), and the bank dividend yield relative to 10-year bonds moving back to 3.2 standard deviations above the mean. Bank dividend yields against pipes and utilities have also moved to all-time highs.

• Bank P/E multiples relative to Insurance companies are now 1.9x lower, the lowest relative P/E multiple in six years.

• We remain overweight the bank group despite the liquidity crisis and credit concerns based on strong underlying capital position, earnings power, and compelling valuation.

• RY and TD remain rated 1-Sector Outperform with LB, CWB, and CM rated 2-Sector Perform. We upgraded NA to 2-Sector Perform from 3-Sector Underperform based on a 16% decline in the share price year-to-date 2007 and the fact that the P/E discount has widened to 15%, at the higher end of our expected range. We maintain a 3-Sector Underperform rating on BMO based on weaker expected earnings and lower profitability with no meaningful P/E discount.

Dividend Increase expected from BMO, CM, RY, and TD

• Dividend increase candidates this quarter are BMO, CM, RY, and TD, with dividend increases expected in the range of 5% to 9% (Exhibit 6). This follows dividend increases by

BNS and NA last quarter of 7% and 11%, respectively.

• The bank group’s dividend payout ratios on our 2007 and 2008 earnings estimates are 46% and 41%, respectively. BMO dividend payout ratio on our 2008 earnings estimate is a high of 51%, and CM is at the low end at 37%. We continue to expect bank dividend payout ratios to drift towards 50%.

Wealth Management Earnings Expected to Be Solid

• Wealth Management earnings are expected to remain strong this quarter driven by solid mutual fund sales and continued AUM growth. Bank average mutual fund assets are up 16% from a year earlier and 3% sequentially. The banks continue to dominate mutual fund sales, particularly RY and TD, with market share of net long-term asset sales at 19% and 9%, respectively, during the quarter. NA experienced relatively low levels of net long-term asset sales due to continued weakness at Altamira.

Retail Bank Earnings Expected to Be Strong

• We expect retail bank earnings to be solid, driven by strong volume growth, stabilizing net interest margin, and stable loan loss provisions and cost management. RY and TD continue to have the strongest earnings momentum in this segment.

Wholesale Banking Earnings to Remain Solid

• The Canadian banks stand to benefit this quarter from the continuing high levels of capital market activity. The number of M&A deals closing this quarter increased 11% YOY and 29% sequentially, while the value of completed transactions increased 40% from a year earlier. TSX trading volume was also up a significant 34% YOY although remained flat quarter over quarter (QOQ). IPO dollar value increased sequentially by 10% but declined 29% from a year earlier. Secondary financing dollar value increased 79% from a year ago but declined 31% sequentially.

• In the third quarter, the Canadian dollar appreciated an astonishing 8%, a magnitude that compares with yearly appreciations in 2002, 2003, and 2004. The rapid increase in the Canadian dollar is expected to negatively impact the bank group’s international earnings, with the largest impact on BNS and a negligible impact on NA, which does not have any foreign subsidiaries.

Third Quarter Highlights

• Bank of Montreal is expected to report earnings of $1.32 per share versus $1.30 per share a year earlier, an increase of 2% YOY and 1% sequentially. We expect the bulk of BMO’s earnings growth to come from wholesale banking and wealth management as the bank continues to reinvest in its Canadian and U.S. retail businesses. We are concerned about the bank’s structured investment vehicles (SIV) business in the United States, which it started in January 2006.

• Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce is expected to report $1.99 per share, an increase of 17% YOY and 2% sequentially. On August 13, 2007, CIBC announced it expects Q3/07 reported earnings to be approximately $2.30 per share including unusual items such as gains on securities and credit derivative hedges, reversal of litigation, and income tax accruals. Expected Q3/07 operating earnings (excluding unusual items) were not disclosed; however, CIBC expects they will be above analyst consensus of $1.90 per share. Expected earnings include a $290 million ($190 million after tax or $0.56 per share) write-down on assets with U.S. sub-prime exposure. Revenue growth excluding FirstCaribbean is expected to remain challenging.

• National Bank is expected to report $1.40 per share in the third quarter, an increase of 12% YOY and flat from the previous quarter. We expect solid earnings growth from all segments and very little negative impact from recent currency appreciation. However, we remain concerned about NA’s high reliance on market-sensitive revenue.

• Royal Bank is expected to report $1.07 per share, an increase of 18% YOY and 8% QOQ. Strong earnings growth is expected from RY’s retail and wealth management businesses, with potential weakness from U.S. & International Banking driven by appreciation in the Canadian dollar.

• Toronto-Dominion Bank is expected to report $1.35 per share, an increase of 12% YOY and a decline of 1% QOQ. Retail and Wealth Management earnings are expected to continue to drive earnings, with wholesale banking contributing increasingly to earnings growth. We continue to believe that downside risk from TD Banknorth is limited going forward as management has shifted its focus from acquisitional growth to improving operating inefficiencies. TD Ameritrade earnings contributions for Q3/07 are estimated at $0.08 per share versus $0.09 per share in the previous quarter and $0.08 per share a year earlier.

BMO – Two Small Wisconsin Acquisitions

• On July 10, 2007, BMO announced two small acquisitions in Wisconsin for a combined US$372.2 million, of which US$137.2 million will be paid in cash and US$190 million will be paid in stock. The purchase price represents 25.4x LTM earnings, 2.2x combined book value, 3.0x tangible book value, and a combined deposit premium of 19%. We view these acquisitions as mildly negative given price, low market share, difficult operating environment, execution risk, and low expected shareholder return.

BMO – Renews Normal Course Issuer Bid

• On July 24, 2007, BMO announced the renewal of its normal course issuer bid commencing September 6, 2007, and ending September 5, 2008. BMO will have the ability to purchase up to 25 million shares or 5% of the public float for cancellation. BMO’s current normal course issuer bid expires on September 5, 2007.

BNS – Scotiabank Mexico Earnings and Contribution Disappointing

• Scotiabank Mexico reported Q2/07 consolidated net income of C$91 million (P$927 million), a decrease of 21% from last quarter and a decrease of 13% from a year earlier. Negative earnings momentum was due to a more normal tax charge and the absence of loan loss reversals.

CM – Announces Write-Down on CDO Exposure

• On August 13, 2007, CIBC announced it expects Q3/07 reported earnings to be approximately $2.30 per share including unusual items such as gains on securities and credit derivative hedges, reversal of litigation, and income tax accruals. Expected Q3/07 operating earnings (excluding unusual items) were not disclosed; however, CIBC expects they will be above analyst consensus of $1.90 per share.

• Expected results also include a mark-to-market write-down of approximately $290 million ($190 million after tax or $0.56 per share) of CDOs and residential mortgage-backed securities related to the U.S. residential mortgage market.

TD – TD Ameritrade Earnings

• TD Ameritrade reported Q3/07 cash earnings of US$0.28 per share versus US$0.24 per share in the previous year, above IBES estimates of US$0.25 per share. At its current ownership level of 39.8%, the estimated contribution to TD would be C$59 million or C$0.08 per share, versus C$0.09 in the previous quarter and C$0.08 per share a year earlier. TD Bank’s contribution declined QOQ due to the appreciation of the Canadian dollar.
__________________________________________________________
RBC Capital Markets, 14 August 2007

• The Big 6 Canadian banks report Q3/07 results between August 23rd and August 30th.

• We estimate EPS growth of 11% on average versus Q3/06. We forecast five banks in the 10-13% range, with BMO trailing at 6%, on weaker expected growth in domestic retail earnings.

• Our estimates are below consensus for all the banks except for NA, probably because of a more cautious outlook on wholesale earnings.

• If wholesale earnings are ahead of expectations, we would caution against assuming that Canadian banks are unaffected by worldwide capital markets jitters. Canadian banks' Q3/07 include the months of May and June, which were good months for capital markets businesses in general. We believe that future revenue shortfalls are possible not only in U.S. sub-prime securities, but also in debt underwriting, M&A and trading. A spillover of debt market issues into equity markets would also have negative implications.

• Retail businesses should show continued strong growth in earnings on continued strong loan growth, stable margins and higher equity markets. We believe that higher loan losses due to growth in credit card portfolios and lower commercial recoveries will partly offset these positives.

• Bank valuations are currently below their 5-year average (11.2x NTM P/E versus 12.2x) and stock prices are well below our 12-month target prices. We do believe, however, that bank stocks may see share price weakness in the near term because:

a) we do not believe that the street's estimates reflect much deterioration in wholesale earnings;

b) News flow out of world financials is likely to be negative with the potential for negative surprises outside of U.S. sub-prime housing;

c) We do not believe that banks are trading at valuations that are low enough to attract incremental money. Banks are trading above their trough valuations of the last 5 years (10.5x NTM P/E) and banks in the U.S. and Europe are trading at lower valuations. Canadian banks may indeed face less potential issues related to U.S. housing, but we believe foreign money flows are easier to attract when valuations are distinctively cheap.

• Within the bank space, we favour the stronger retail banks (TD and RY and/or those with lower exposure to wholesale income (TD and CIBC). CIBC clearly has the most direct exposure to U.S. sub-prime housing, but we believe that its stock price reflects that risk.
__________________________________________________________
BMO Capital Markets, 3 August 2007

Loan Growth – Outstanding

It is difficult to describe Canadian loan growth as anything other than outstanding. We now have volumes for both May and June (two of the three months in the quarter). Both months saw loan balances across the banking system grow by over 10%, with both the business and consumer books contributing strongly.

We continue to forecast a slowdown in loan growth in the coming months. This view is predicated on the strength of the dollar, and a simple statement of fact: every period of 10%+ loan growth in Canada has been followed by a decline to about 5% within the next year or two. We believe that dollar strength has negative implications for Central Canada (the core of the Canadian bank loan book) as business becomes less competitive vis-à-vis U.S. competitors. This should slow demand for commercial credit, and ultimately job growth in Ontario and Quebec. We are assuming loan growth in 2008 of slightly less than 5%, so we are clearly forecasting a fairly rapid decline from current levels.

Spreads Should Remain Stable

We expect spreads to remain stable in the third quarter. Dramatic shifts in loan mix in the period 2002 until the end of 2006 resulted in sharp declines in domestic P&C spreads. Most importantly, we saw rapid growth in residential mortgages and a decline in demand for business credit. Effectively, we were replacing 300 basis point loans with 70-basis-point loans. Furthermore, the non-residential mortgage book experienced a material shift from unsecured to secured credit. Both of these shifts caused tighter spreads, but bode well for the next credit cycle (discussed later).

Of course, there are several other factors that impact spreads, including Prime-BA spreads, slope of the yield curve, absolute levels of interest rates and competitive pressures. On the first, the anticipation of a rise in Prime (analogous to the situation in 2006) resulted in wholesale rates squeezing in on Prime. This caused some compression in the Prime-BA spread—back to the lower levels of 2006. Overall, we believe that this impact will be modest. If anything, BNS would be marginally more impacted than the rest.

The second factor, the slope of the yield curve, has become more positive this quarter, particularly when compared to the past four quarters. A perception of rising inflation fuelled an intra-quarter rally in longer-dated bonds. However, with less pressure at the short-end, we saw the yield curve move from inverted to slightly sloping during the quarter. As in the case of Prime-BA spreads, we believe BNS is the most exposed. In reality, these two counter trends will likely offset.

The last two variables don’t appear to have changed much. The prime rate moved modestly higher in June and this should continue to help deposit spreads. We see little significant change on the competitive front. ING, long the price leader, has moved away from its Everyday Low Price strategy and hasn’t actually moved the rate on its ISA account for over six months. It has relied on “limited time offers” which we believe are far less compelling to the consumer. This isn’t to say that price competition has gone away (ICICI and Manulife appear to be picking up the slack), but with ING’s retreat, the situation isn’t getting any worse. To date, Royal’s high interest account has been relatively low key, and we expect it to stay that way.

Dividends, Buybacks and Balance Sheets

We believe that at least one, likely two, and possibly three, Canadian banks will raise dividends this quarter. CIBC should institute its long-telegraphed dividend increase with the third quarter release—probably by more than 10%. We also expect BMO, which has been quite intent on returning excess money to shareholders, to increase its quarterly dividend by a modest $0.02. There is some chance that RY boosts its dividend as well this quarter.

The news on balance sheets should remain very good. High ROE, and more modest RWA growth, should ensure that Tier 1 ratios don’t change much in the current quarter. Buybacks have become noticeably more active in the third quarter, and we would expect to see more of the same in the fourth. Specifically, BNS and CM have significant room to boost buybacks.

Better Disclosure Would Be Helpful

Consistent with greater scrutiny, we expect to see Canadian banks again improve their disclosure. It goes without saying that additional disclosure would be welcome. It seems to us that Canadian banks remain their own worst enemies in disclosure. More information will highlight the modest levels of risk, while lack of information causes the market to jump to extreme conclusions. There are several suggestions that we would make that we believe would provide investors with some comfort. The following list is not exhaustive: CDO exposure (including ratings and tranches), subprime exposure, bridge lending commitments, loan exposure to hedge funds, etc.

Specific Company Comments

• TD Bank – High Expectations

It is clear that the market has begun to reward TD for its strategic changes over the past couple of years. Banknorth and Ameritrade seem to have found a base of earnings, while the Canadian businesses (both wholesale and retail) have solid momentum.

We are forecasting Cash EPS of $1.34 compared to $1.21 in the same quarter of a year ago. With Basel II a couple quarters away, and the potential for more M&A activity in the U.S., TD will probably be reluctant to boost its dividend—even though it has the lowest payout ratio among the big banks.

We expect strong performance in the domestic retail businesses. In the case of TD Canada Trust, we continue to believe that earnings growth will slow. Having said that, with the great volume growth industry-wide and the outlook for stable spreads, this could easily be another excellent quarter. We have continued to be surprised by the strength of the Wealth Management business. It is clear that the build-out of the full-service business has been better than we expected, and on the mutual fund and discount brokerage businesses, the results have gone from strength to strength.

• Royal Bank – More Moderation in Wholesale, More Strength in Retail

We expect the retail business of Royal to continue to power earnings growth. Overall Cash EPS growth of 12% looks reasonable, as long as trading revenues don’t decline too much. The market reacted poorly towards the results in the second quarter, as the wholesale business underperformed its peers. We believe that the market will be far more discerning this time, and will focus on how the retail businesses perform.

We aren’t forecasting a dividend increase this quarter, but there is some chance that one could occur. If there is an increase, it would be minor, $0.02 quarterly.

• BMO – Back to a More Normal Pattern

After the commodity trading loss, this should be an uneventful quarter. Year-over-year earnings growth should be driven by good investment banking and private client results. We are forecasting Cash EPS of $1.41 compared to $1.30 a year ago. BMO moved on its dividend two quarters ago, and we are expecting a modest $0.02 increase. This would maintain the payout at the mid-point of the bank’s 45–55% range.

There is little reason to be optimistic on either Harris or the domestic P&C Bank. In Canada, the year-ago results include the MasterCard gain and a tax recovery, so the lack of growth is misleading. Excluding unusuals, the growth should be about 10%. Harris is more difficult to call. Continued pressure on margins and the potential to see some rise in loan losses could result in even weaker performance than we are forecasting. The strength of the Canadian dollar is also a headwind.

We are forecasting a more robust result from the Private Client business, after what we would describe as a disappointing earnings result in the second quarter. We expect to see better cost control and the benefit of good volumes both in mutual funds and brokerage.

• Scotiabank – Domestic Strength to Bolster International

This should be another workman-like quarter from the Scotiabank. Investors will likely be impressed with the bank’s ability to earn through headwinds both from currency and from a more normal result from Mexico. We forecast Cash EPS of $1.00 compared with $1.03 in the second quarter and $0.88 a year ago.

The bank raised its dividend at the second quarter’s release so there will be no news here. The balance sheet remains very robust and with the pullback in share price, we believe that buyback activity should begin to accelerate. There will likely be some update on the ongoing opportunities in international. The Puerto Rican deal has been delayed, and there is now additional speculation on a deal in Chile. Let’s hope, for Scotia’s sake, that the Toronto Police Force isn’t involved in the negotiations (memories of the U20 World Cup earlier this summer remain).

• CIBC – No News Is Good News, I Guess

We have cut our earnings estimate for CIBC to $1.75 from $1.97. This compares with $1.95 in the second quarter and $1.70 in the third quarter of 2006. We have articulated in the past that CIBC could take a $100–150 million hit from its CDO exposure. Given the lack of a pre-announcement, we are maintaining this estimate.

That’s the bad news. The good news is that we believe the bank will move meaningfully on dividend (to $0.86 from $0.77), and to reaffirm its commitment to complete its buyback by yearend. Given the run rate of re-purchases (1.5 million shares a month), this looks very achievable. We note that CIBC’s balance sheet remains stable with a Tier 1 ratio of about 9.5%. For the third quarter in a row, we again expect a stock split—maybe this time we will be right.

• National Bank – More Help from Retail, Less from Wholesale

We expect somewhat slower growth this quarter from National Bank. Our EPS estimate of $1.39 compared to $1.25 in the year-ago quarter reflects modest retail growth, a flat wholesale result and lower loan loss recoveries. After the robust dividend increase last quarter, there likely won’t be any change to the quarterly dividend.
;