03 October 2007

RBC Buys RBTT

  
BMO Capital Markets, 3 October 2007

As expected, on October 2 Royal Bank announced an agreement to acquire 100% of Royal Bank of Trinidad and Tobago (RBTT), in a deal worth US$2.2 billion. We had speculated on a deal in a research comment released in the morning of October 2 and don't intend to repeat that comment verbatim. Everything was largely as advertised: TT$40 per RBTT share (or US$6.33) comprised of TT$24 and stock of RBC (RY share piece is collared). The one variation from our expectations was that we had expected the 46 RBC branches to be rolled in first. Instead, this will be done after the deal closes. The transaction is expected to close by mid-2008 and will be marginally accretive to earnings in 2008.

All in all, we continue to extol the virtues of banking in the Caribbean. This deal will anchor Royal's operations in the region and will be marginally accretive. We believe that the merged entity would become a more powerful player in the region, with a deep pocketed parent and a more diversified banking footprint. For further details on Caribbean banking and a backgrounder on RBTT, please see our research comment, 'Caribbean Opportunity: After One Time Is a Next Time,' dated October 2.

We maintain our Outperform rating on Royal Bank shares. As opposed to Centura and the bank's ongoing attempt to develop critical mass in the U.S., this deal would, in a single transaction, make RBC a meaningful competitor in the region.
__________________________________________________________
Scotia Capital, 3 October 2007

Royal Bank of Canada to Acquire RBTT Financial Group for US$2.2 billion

• Royal Bank announced an agreement to acquire RBTT Financial Group based in Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago for approximately US$2.2 billion or US$6.33 per share. Consideration consists of 60% cash and 40% RBC common shares. The transaction is expected to close mid 2008 and be accretive by the end of fiscal 2008.

Acquisition Price

• The acquisition price is an 18% premium on RBTT's closing price on September 28, 2007 and a 27% premium on RBTT's average share price over the last 12 months.

• The price of the transaction, according to RBC, represents 14.2x LTM earnings, price to book value of 3.05x, price to tangible book value of 3.39x and a deposit premium of 34%.

• Under the agreement the collar mechanism is used. RBTT's shareholders will receive a fixed amount of cash and a number of RBC common shares for their RBTT shares which will be determined by an exchange ratio.

• The number of RBC shares received by RBTT shareholders is subject to a 10% plus/minus collar based on a RBC share price of US$54.42 per share (the average trading price for the five days ending Sept. 28). RBC would issue 16.2 million common shares based on RBC US$54.42 share price, increasing shares outstanding by a very modest 1.3%.

RBTT

• RBTT is a Caribbean-owned banking and financial services group that offers a complete range of banking and financial services to customers in Trinidad and Tobago and the Caribbean.

• RBTT product strengths are in retail/commercial banking, investment banking and asset management.

• RBTT has US$7.5 billion in assets, US$4.5 billion in deposits and US$3.7 billion in loans. RBTT is the second largest bank in Trinidad and Tobago and the third largest bank in Jamaica.

• RBTT branch network has a total of 84 branches, including 25 branches in Trinidad and Tobago (2nd largest, 27 % market share), 21 branches in Jamaica (3rd largest, 14.4% market share), 15 branches in Dutch Caribbean, 11 branches in Eastern Caribbean, 5 branches in Suriname, 4 branches in Barbados, and 3 branches scheduled to open.

RBC/RBTT Acquisition - Scale & Complementary Fit

• The transaction expands RBC's Caribbean presence to the 4th largest bank (previously 11th) with pro forma assets for RBC/RBTT of US$13.6 billion. Scotiabank is the third largest bank with assets of US$16.1 billion and CIBC FirstCaribbean is the fifth largest bank with assets of US$12.3 billion.

• The acquisition increases RBC's Caribbean branch network from 46 branches to 130 branches across 18 countries and territories in the region. The combination broadens the product offering and diversifies the operations across the Caribbean.

• The RBC/RBTT acquisition is expected to have very little cost synergies as there is no overlap in branch networks but will potentially have positive revenue synergies from improved scale and diversified product offering. The transaction will allow the bank to leverage its local market expertise, state of the art retail banking technology platform, diverse products, and geographic reach.

• Headquarters of the combined Caribbean operations are to be established in Port of Spain over a timetable to be determined following the close of the transaction.

• RBTT Financial Group CEO Suresh Sookoo will be appointed CEO of RBC's Caribbean retail banking operations following integration of the businesses.

• RBC will explore the possibility of issuing depository receipts backed by common shares on the Trinidad and Tobago Stock Exchange.

Recommendation

• RBC's acquisition of RBTT is the second international acquisition in the past month and the ninth acquisition outside of Canada in the past 12 months. RBC remains committed to growing its business platform outside of Canada.

• Maintain 1-Sector Outperform based on absence of premium multiple, superior profitability and strong retail and wealth management operation platform with wholesale only representing 27% of earnings in Q3/07, the second lowest of the bank group.
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, Sean B. Pasternak, 3 October 2007

Canada's banks will make more foreign acquisitions to take advantage of the stronger Canadian dollar, analysts and investors said, after the industry spent $10.5 billion yesterday in its biggest-ever shopping spree abroad.

Toronto-Dominion Bank agreed to buy New Jersey's Commerce Bancorp Inc. for $8.3 billion, making it the seventh-largest North American bank by branches. Royal Bank of Canada, the country's biggest bank, will pay $2.2 billion for RBTT Financial Holdings of Trinidad and Tobago, doubling its Caribbean network.

Canada's five largest banks, including Bank of Nova Scotia, Bank of Montreal and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, have been looking to expand abroad because they're blocked by the federal government from merging. With the Canadian dollar at a 31-year high, foreign takeovers are a bargain.

``The dollar recognizes that the country's in a strong position; the financial sector's in a strong position; our customers in Canada are in a strong position,'' Bank of Nova Scotia Chief Executive Officer Richard Waugh told reporters in Toronto today. ``All that comes together, and that gives all of us some great opportunities that you're starting to see.''

Canada's second-biggest bank passed on RBTT because ``it didn't fit for us,'' Waugh said. Scotiabank is already the largest Caribbean bank, he said, with more than 200 branches.

Canada's currency reached equal value with the U.S. dollar for the first time in three decades on Sept. 20. It touched $1.0091 on Oct. 1, the highest since November 1976. Today it traded at $1.0034 at 12:16 p.m. in Toronto.

``Canadian banks are using the dollar at parity to buy assets cheaply,'' said Andrew Martyn, who helps manage the equivalent of about $475 million at Toronto-based Davis-Rea Ltd. ``They're going to continue going south for acquisitions, as there's almost nothing left in Canada.''

In addition, Canadian banks haven't been hurt as much as U.S. banks by rising defaults of subprime loans because they offer fewer high-risk mortgages, analysts said.

``U.S. banks are probably facing another four to eight quarters of pain,'' said Paul Hand, managing director, equity trading at RBC Capital Markets. ``Their willingness to enter into deals has increased.''

Canada's financial companies have disclosed $15.7 billion of acquisitions of foreign-owned financial companies this year, more than double the $7.6 billion reported in all of last year, data compiled by Bloomberg show.

John Aiken, an analyst at Dundee Securities Corp., wrote yesterday in a note to investors that he ``would not be surprised to see other Canadian financial institutions make large acquisitions in the near term.''

``With the dollar being the way that it is, there's no question that Canadian banks can take advantage of this,'' said Jacob Jegher, an analyst at Boston-based research firm Celent. ``There's still some banks there that haven't made a move yet, and they're going to be feeling the competitive pressures.''

Jegher said Bank of Montreal, which has operations in the Chicago area through its Harris Bank unit, is one of the more likely acquirers. Harris Bank was one of several companies approached by Minnesota-based TCF Financial Corp. to make a takeover bid, Crain's Chicago Business reported last month.

Ralph Marranca, a spokesman at the Toronto-based bank, said the bank always looks at potential acquisitions. He declined to be more specific.

Canadian banks have been banned from merging since 1998, when the Finance Minister, Paul Martin, blocked two sets of combinations on concern they would lead to a concentration of ``economic power in the hands of an even smaller number of very large institutions.''

Jim Flaherty, the current Finance Minister, has said that re-examining the issue isn't a priority for the ruling Conservative government.

Canadian bank mergers are ``never going to happen,'' Toronto-Dominion Chief Executive Officer Edmund Clark said yesterday in an interview on Business News Network television. ``I think it's a great thing that the five Canadian banks are stopping talking about mergers, which I think is a distraction.''
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, Duncan Mavin, 3 October 2007

Royal Bank of Canada has made a splashy Caribbean acquisition, muscling in on the territory of Canadian rivals Bank of Nova Scotia and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, and is now set to expand further into Latin and Central America.

The bank said yesterday it has bought Royal Bank of Trinidad and Tobago (RBTT) for $2.2-billion, a move that sees it go head-to-head with Scotiabank and CIBC, which both have growth plans in the region.

Canada's largest bank also says its acquisition is just the first step in a wider Americas strategy, with retail-banking activities in Latin and Central America next on the agenda.

"An Americas strategy for banking is not a bad way to think about our future steps," said Peter Armenio, RBC's head of U.S. and international banking.

Scotiabank, which earns more than 25% of its profit outside of Canada, has long held the unofficial title of Canada's most international bank, thanks to extensive retail-banking operations in Latin and Central America.

But RBC appears to be threatening Scotiabank's title. RBC already earns about 35% of its profit from U.S. and international operations, and aims to increase that figure to almost 50%,Mr. Armenio said.

RBC has investment-and private-banking operations in several countries in Latin America, including Brazil, Uruguay and Venezuela. The bank is opening offices in Mexico, Panama and Chile and another office in Brazil in the next year.

Mr. Armenio said the RBTT acquisition now provides a retail-banking infrastructure in the region that can be expanded into other countries in the Americas where the bank has existing operations.

The deal "marks RBC's renewed focus on growing its international presence," said Blackmont Capital bank analyst Brad Smith.

But although the bank definitely has enough capital to embark on an international-banking spree, it remains to be seen whether RBC can emulate Scotiabank's overseas success, said Dominion Bond Ratings Services banking analyst Brenda Lum.

RBC does not have the same experience as Scotiabank in adding foreign banks to its empire, she said.

For now, the RBTT deal sees RBC become the fourth-largest bank in the Caribbean with US$13.6-billion in assets, behind third-place Scotiabank (US$16.1-billion) and just ahead of CIBC (US$12.3-billion.)

RBC will increase its branch presence in the Caribbean to 130 branches from 46.

Scotiabank has 200 branches in the Caribbean. CIBC subsidiary FirstCaribbean International Bank (FCIB), which had been considered a possible buyer of RBTT before RBC stepped in, has more than 100 branches.

RBC's Mr. Armenio said it will be "kind of fun" to compete with Scotiabank and CIBC in the region "with a little more armour."

RBC is paying an 18% premium on RBTT's closing share price from Friday. The board of directors at the Caribbean bank has unanimously recommended the deal to shareholders, and the acquisition is expected to close in mid-2008.

"We view this acquisition as strategically positive with minimal near-term earnings impact," said Blackmont's Mr. Smith.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Tavia Grant, 3 October 2007

Royal Bank of Canada has returned to the Caribbean, encroaching on turf occupied by Canadian rivals and gaining a springboard for further expansion in the region.

Canada's largest bank will buy Trinidad and Tobago-based bank RBTT Financial Holdings Ltd. for about $2.2-billion in cash and stock, RBC's second international deal in two months as it spreads into faster-growing markets outside Canada.

The bank will combine its 46 Caribbean retail branches with RBTT's 84 branches, and aims to eventually make its new Port of Spain headquarters a hub for further expansion in both the Caribbean and Latin America.

“This deal creates an ideal platform for further growth,” Peter Armenio, RBC's head of U.S. and international banking, said in an interview from Trinidad. “We're going to have much more infrastructure now in the Caribbean to be able to take advantage of these other opportunities.”

RBC will, for the foreseeable future, focus on integrating operations. But buying the Trinidad bank will give it access to new markets in countries such as Aruba, Jamaica and Suriname. RBTT has also done financing deals in Costa Rica and Guatemala in the past year. The combined bank will be the fourth largest in the Caribbean, ranking just below Bank of Nova Scotia and a notch above Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce's FirstCaribbean International Bank.

The Caribbean has become a hot spot for international investment in recent years. In Trinidad and Tobago, the region's largest oil and gas producer, the economy has grown by an average 6 per cent a year since 2002. Canada, China and the U.S. all want to boost trade ties with the region.

The purchase will give RBC more corporate relationships in the region, but also “there's no question that the middle class is definitely moving forward,” Mr. Armenio said. “More people are not only using banking, they're using wealth management and using other things.”

This is a return of sorts for RBC, which had operations in Trinidad and Tobago from 1902 to 1987. RBTT's origins date to when the Union Bank of Halifax opened a Port of Spain branch in 1902. RBC subsequently bought the business amid booming imports of sugar, cocoa and corn to Canada and exports of grain, horses and salted cod to the region.

RBC stuck with the bank for the next 85 years, selling its controlling stake in 1987 as it streamlined operations and began to focus on the U.S.

The deal announced yesterday will expand RBC's Caribbean presence to 18 countries and territories in the region. It stomps squarely on the territory of Scotiabank, which prides itself on being Canada's most international bank.

The best thing about yesterday's deal “is that it's not in Canada,” said Blackmont Capital analyst Brad Smith. “It broadens RBC's opportunities beyond our borders. The growth prospects [in Canada] are rather limited.”

The bank has repeatedly highlighted the region as a growth possibility and in April bought a 50-per-cent stake in Bahamas-based Fidelity Merchant Bank & Trust Ltd.

Suresh Sookoo, the RBTT chief executive who will assume the reins of the new Caribbean operations, said other Canadian banks have been nosing around for the past year, “one in particular.” RBC kicked the tires in 2005, kept in contact and came back on a more serious note in June.

RBTT's board has approved the deal and recommends shareholders back it. The deal is an 18-per-cent premium over RBTT's closing shares on Friday and is expected to add to RBC's earnings by the middle of next year.

RBTT is the second-largest bank in Trinidad and the third largest in Jamaica. Its main challenge of late has been its asset management business, which has seen profits fall due to lower fees associated with a falling local stock market.
__________________________________________________________
BMO Capital Markets, 2 October 2007

Details & Analysis

Royal Bank (RBC) voluntarily exited banking in the twin island republic of Trinidad and Tobago about 20 years ago. As such, there will be some degree of irony if recent speculation of RBC acquiring Royal Bank of Trinidad and Tobago (RBTT) is true. We have speculated in the past (March 22, 2006 - Options in the Sun and January 9, 2007 - Caribbean Opportunity), that either CIBC or Royal Bank would acquire control of RBTT, so this isn't unexpected. Regulatory (or political) risk aside, this does appear to be the final chapter in the ongoing saga of who will get RBTT.

Subject to the specifics of any possible individual transaction, we would broadly view an acquisition of RBTT by RBC as a modest positive for RBC and minor negatives for both CIBC and BNS. We believe that the merged entity would become a more powerful player in the region, with a deep pocketed parent and a more diversified banking footprint. We maintain our Outperform rating on Royal Bank shares. As opposed to Centura and the bank's ongoing attempt to develop critical mass in the U.S., this deal would, in a single transaction, make RBC a meaningful competitor in the region.

Caribbean Banking – A Good Business

First and foremost, banking is a play on the domestic economy. As such, the strength of the economies of the region is a strong underpinning for any financial institution operating in these markets.

Second, banking is largely a regional business so that most banking franchises can compete capably if they have a 'top three' position.

Third, we believe that the Canadian banks have shown themselves to be very capable of operating highly successful, branched-based Personal and Commercial Banking operations. Much of this is because a lack of domestic merger activity has focused them to build, rather than buy, growth

Fourth, we believe that it is possible to operate a Pan-Caribbean banking footprint. This means that while each market is small, it is possible to coble together a reasonablesized operation.

Lastly, the Canadian banks have tremendous history in the region with connections going back to trading links between the Maritimes and the West Indies.

A Bit of Background on RBTT

RBTT is a very strong Trinidad and Tobago (T&T) based bank. It operates approximately 80 branches with top three market positions in T&T, Jamaica and the Dutch Antilles. Its long-term track record is excellent, with consistently high ROE, sound corporate governance and internationally accepted accounting standards.

Having said that, RBTT has produced disappointing earnings for the past several years, particularly when considered in the context that its core market, T&T, is a petrochemical-based economy which has achieved strong GDP growth. Clearly, RBTT's attempts to build outside of T&T have been somewhat unsuccessful.

It is interesting to consider what a RBTT/RBC merger would look like. The new entity would be one of the largest financial groups in the Caribbean with strong market share positions in the four big economies of the English-speaking Caribbean, and pro forma earnings of over C$200 million. Using a 60:40 cash:stock deal, and assuming a full buyout (and more normal loan losses), the deal would be essentially neutral to RBC's earnings.

Timing Seems a Bit “Iffy”

On September 28, Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Patrick Manning dissolved parliament and called a national election for November 5. Historically, there has been sensitivity surrounding the existence of, and potential for additional, foreign ownership of banks in the Caribbean. As such, we consider the timing of a possible deal involving RBC and RBTT to be somewhat questionable.

Whatever the political backlash, there is little doubt that the investors, Board members and senior executives of RBTT are well plugged into at least two of the three parties in the upcoming election.

Conclusion

We are assuming that the speculated deal (sale of RBC branches for 20% of RBTT, followed by a cash and RY stock offer for all of RBTT at TT$40 per share) would be successful. Under these conditions, this would be a slightly positive deal for Royal Bank. We maintain an Outperform rating on RY shares.
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, Sean B. Pasternak and Frederic Tomesco, 2 October 2007

Royal Bank of Canada, the country's largest bank, agreed to buy RBTT Financial Holdings Ltd. in Trinidad and Tobago for about $2.2 billion to more than double its Caribbean branch network.

RBTT shareholders will receive about TT$40 ($6.37) a share, 60 percent of which will be in cash and 40 percent in Royal Bank shares, Toronto-based Royal Bank said today in a statement.

Royal Bank, which has 46 branches in Caribbean countries such as the Bahamas and Cayman Islands, is taking advantage of a soaring Canadian dollar to expand in that region, joining Bank of Nova Scotia and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce. Toronto- Dominion Bank, Canada's third-biggest lender, today agreed to buy New Jersey-based Commerce Bancorp Inc. for $8.5 billion.

"Canadian banks are strong in the Caribbean,'' said Ian Nakamoto, director of research at MacDougall, MacDougall and MacTier Inc. in Toronto, which manages $4.3 billion, including Royal Bank shares. ``They have a good history in that area.''

RBTT has $7.5 billion in assets, employs 5,400 and serves 1.3 million clients. Its acquisition will boost Royal Bank's Caribbean assets to $13.7 billion, spread out across 130 branches and 18 countries. W Holding Company Inc., the owner of Westernbank Puerto Rico, is the biggest bank in the Caribbean, with assets of about $17.5 billion as of March, Royal Bank said.

``The acquisition is advantageous in that it expands Royal Bank's presence in the growing region at a time when there are becoming fewer reasonable targets,'' Dundee Securities Corp. analyst John Aiken said in a note to clients.

Royal Bank is trying to catch up with Canadian rivals in the Caribbean. Scotiabank runs more than 200 branches there, and last year the Toronto-based bank spent $56 million to buy Jamaica's Dehring Bunting & Golding Ltd. CIBC has spent $1.3 billion since last year to increase its stake in Barbados-based FirstCaribbean Bank to 91.4 percent.

Adding RBTT also may allow Royal Bank expand to Latin America, said Peter Armenio, head of U.S. and international banking for the bank.

The transaction ``provides a platform for future expansion beyond the Caribbean, as we start to took at other places around Central and Latin America where we do have other businesses,'' Armenio told analysts on a conference call. He didn't elaborate.

RBTT has Canadian roots. It was incorporated in Halifax, Nova Scotia, in 1856 and was owned by Royal Bank before the lender sold control in 1986, said Brad Smith, an analyst at Blackmont Capital in Toronto.

``We believe this renewed commitment would signal the emergence of a new, capable market competitor,'' Smith wrote in an Oct. 1 note to clients. The proposed transaction was reported by the Trinidad and Tobago Express newspaper on Sept. 30.

The Port of Spain-based bank was ranked first in Trinidad and Tobago for capital adequacy by financial publication The Banker, according to RBTT's Web site. In April, RBTT said it was considering a possible combination or partnership for its business, according to its Web site.

Royal Bank said its offer is 18 percent more than the closing price of RBTT shares on Sept. 28. Royal Bank shares rose 60 cents to C$56.53 by 4 p.m. in Toronto Stock Exchange trading today. RBTT shares rose 99 cents to TT$35.

The transaction will probably close by mid-2008 and bolster per-share earnings next year, Royal Bank said.

Canadian lenders have spent more than $7.5 billion in global takeovers this year after the Canadian dollar climbed to parity with the U.S. currency for the first time since 1976.

For Royal Bank, this would be the biggest purchase since it bought Raleigh, North Carolina-based Centura Banks Inc. for $2.28 billion six years ago. The bank agreed on Sept. 6 to buy Alabama National BanCorp. for $1.6 billion in cash and stock to add 103 branches in Alabama, Florida and Georgia.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins, 1 October 2007

The Royal Bank of Canada is close to buying RBTT for more than $2-billion (U.S.) in a deal that would be among the biggest acquisitions in the Caribbean in recent times, the Trinidad & Tobago Express reported this weekend.

The takeover would be paid for with a mix of cash and shares, and has already won approval from key shareholders, the newspaper reported, citing unnamed sources. RBTT's board of directors is close to giving its approval, the newspaper said.

Royal Bank spokeswoman Beja Rodeck said Monday that, "as a corporate policy we don't comment on market rumour and speculation."

RBTT has been up for sale for some time. In April, its chairman suggested a deal was on the way. The bank then said it had been invited to enter into other strategic discussions, and that it was extending its process in order to properly consider any and all opportunities.

Royal Bank was never counted out, however, recent speculation had focused on Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce and Bank of Nova Scotia, which had both demonstrated interest in expanding their regional Caribbean market presence, Blackmont Capital analyst Brad Smith wrote in a note to clients Monday.

"Although yet to be confirmed, the acquisition would mark a renewed commitment by RBC, which operates 43 branches in the Caribbean, to expand in a region that had been de-emphasized following the 1986 sale of its controlling interest in RBTT," he wrote.

He added that the renewed commitment "would signal the emergence of a new and capable market competitor, making operating conditions more challenging for existing market participants."
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, Sean B. Pasternak, 1 October 2007

Royal Bank of Canada is close to buying RBTT Financial Holdings Ltd., the largest bank in Trinidad & Tobago, for at least $2 billion, the Express newspaper reported on its Web site.

Royal Bank has already won support from several of RBTT's largest shareholders, the newspaper said, without citing anyone. The offer would be 60 percent cash and 40 percent Royal Bank stock, the report yesterday said.

Toronto-based Royal Bank trails Canadian competitors Bank of Nova Scotia and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce in the Caribbean. The bank owned a controlling stake in RBTT until about 20 years ago, said Blackmont Capital analyst Brad Smith. RBTT has assets of $7 billion, the newspaper said.

The purchase ``would mark a renewed commitment by RBC, which operates 43 branches in the Caribbean, to expand in a region that had been de-emphasized following the 1986 sale of its controlling interest in RBTT,'' Smith wrote today in a note to investors.

Royal Bank spokeswoman Beja Rodeck declined to comment. Royal Bank is Canada's largest lender.
__________________________________________________________
Tridinad & Tobago Express, Carmini Marajh, 30 September 2007

In what is likely to be the biggest takeover deal in the Caribbean in recent times, Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) is getting ready to buy out local banking giant, RBTT, in an acquisition priced at well over US$2 billion.

Sources report that an acquisition agreement is close to sign off by the Peter July-led Board of RBTT Directors.

The RBC offer is said to contain a mix of cash and stock in a buyout that sources say has already secured the approval of key shareholders, among them the National Insurance Board (NIB) which has a 22 per cent interest, Guardian Holdings Ltd, a 14 per cent stakeholder and business tycoons Arthur Lok Jack, Richard Azar and Imtiaz Ahamad, who are listed among the largest individual stakeholders.

And while the Peter July board has refused to say anything more than the bank is having "strategic discussions with other parties", the Sunday Express understands that RBC, the latest in a series of Canadian suitors to knock on RBTT's door, is the favoured partner for a takeover deal.

Both have financial incentives to see the deal through, according to financial sources. RBC, Canada's largest bank is flush with acquisition dollars, assets of Can$563 billion and a market capitalisation of Can$69 billion.

It is also trailing behind rivals Bank of Nova Scotia and First Caribbean International Bank (FCIB),a subsidiary of Canadian bank, CIBC in its Caribbean operations.

RBTT, Trinidad's largest bank with assets of US$7 billion, has stumbled in recent years on issues related to management, flat earnings and growth limitation.

The RBC offer, comprising 60 per cent cash and 40 per cent RBC stock, if approved by shareholders, would give RBTT stockholders a much-needed boost with an option of cash and RBC shares - Can$55.26 at the close of trade on the Toronto Stock Exchange on Friday.

The buyout offer of a flat TT$40 per RBTT share plus RBC equity, according to sources, has found favour with a substantial block of RBTT shareholders.

Exploratory talks aimed at securing the requisite foreign ownership licence from the regulatory agencies and the Patrick Manning Government have reportedly gone well, said sources, adding that the RBC buyout of the local bank has been given the green light to go ahead.

And while the acquisition might be close to being a done deal, Central Bank Governor Ewart Williams, on Friday, told the Sunday Express that the Bank was yet to be "formally notified".

A not unusual event, said sources close to the deal, noting that one option being looked at as an initial part of the transaction is the sale of RBC's Caribbean banking interests to RBTT.

This manoeuvre would give RBC an immediate foothold into RBTT as a 20-plus per cent stakeholder.

Still to be worked out, however, is the price of RBC shares which are to be listed on the local Stock Exchange under the depository receipt system used on the Nasdaq and other major Exchanges where a specified number of shares of foreign companies are issued and traded.

Sources say the listing of a big international bank like RBC on the TT Stock Exchange would be a major coup for this country and could well catapult Trinidad centre stage and a step closer to the Prime Minister's dream of making this country the financial capital of the Caribbean.

Financial analysts say if 20 per cent of the cash or $TT1.6 billion from the RBTT sale goes back into the local market, it could help the recovery process of the stock market which has been in the doldrums in recent time.

Speculation of a takeover has seen RBTT stock climb from the start of September by $3 closing at the end of trade on Friday at $34.01.

GHL, a substantial shareholder in RBTT, has also benefitted from the market speculation, closing at $25 on Friday after starting September at $20.02.
;

Scotiabank in Marketing Deal with NHL

  
Globe and Mail, Brian Milner, 3 October 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia is hitching its marketing wagon to the National Hockey League in a costly deal designed to raise its profile and boost its weak share of the Canadian consumer banking market.

The five-year pact that makes Scotiabank the official bank in Canada of both the NHL and its players' association, the NHLPA, will cost an estimated $50-million. The price includes $5-million annually for rights fees and about the same amount each year for advertising, incentives and other marketing costs associated with the deal, say people familiar with the agreement.

Neither the bank nor the NHL would reveal the terms, but it's the richest sponsorship deal signed by the league since before the player lockout that wiped out the 2004-05 season. The league would love to lure similar dollars in the U.S. market, but Canada remains its best source of such revenue.

The high price reflects heavy competition among the major banks for marketing supremacy in the Canadian sports landscape, sports industry watchers say.

Scotiabank is a more recent entrant to the battlefield, as chief executive officer and acknowledged sports nut Rick Waugh has launched a major push into big-time sports and entertainment sponsorships to gain ground on his stronger domestic rivals.

The key, he said, is boosting brand awareness. “It's going to be good for us, it's going to be good for our customers and the community, and that is going to get us more customers, hopefully. And that's market share, and that's good for the shareholders,” Mr. Waugh said Wednesday after a news conference hosted by CBC broadcaster Ron MacLean.

The bank is also sponsoring a new CBC pregame show hosted by Mr. MacLean that will run Saturdays before Hockey Night in Canada.

Scotiabank's marketing data indicated the bank is good at retaining customers, but “we were not high on the radar screen” when it comes to attracting new consumer business, Mr. Waugh said. “We're not the No. 1 or No. 2 bank [of choice]. We're third, fourth or fifth; That's our opportunity.”

The NHL gives the bank a national platform for its brand, which it does not have with its existing hockey sponsorships with the Edmonton Oilers and Calgary Flames. The bank has also held naming rights to the Ottawa Senators' arena, now called Scotiabank Place, since 2006, in a 15-year deal that cost $20-million.

Scotiabank's deal with the NHL sets up a pitched battle with the country's largest financial institution, Royal Bank of Canada, which is a major sponsor of Hockey Canada and the Olympics. RBC has poured money into grassroots community hockey programs as part of its sponsorship of the sport. Scotiabank is eager to get on to the same turf.

“It will definitely give them [Scotiabank] a point of difference in the marketplace,” said Keith McIntyre, president of Mississauga-based K. Mac & Associates Marketing Inc. “It creates a competitive playing field.”

The bank has been exploring a connection with the NHL for the past couple of years, but the league didn't begin looking for a banking sponsor until earlier this year. Scotiabank and the NHL began negotiations in the spring.
;

TD Bank Customers Seek Damages Over FX Rates

  
Bloomberg, Joe Schneider, 3 October 2007

Toronto-Dominion Bank customers who say they were charged improper foreign-exchange fees on credit-card transactions are seeking a windfall by demanding wholesale rates available only to financial institutions, the bank's lawyer said.

Attorney Lyndon Barnes today urged the Ontario Court of Appeal to reject a request for certification of a class-action lawsuit over the fees. Customers were promised a competitive rate and they got it, even though some fees weren't fully disclosed, he said.

The plaintiffs, seeking C$150 million ($150 million) in damages, asked the appeal panel to overturn a lower-court ruling two years ago that denied them the right to sue as a group. The individual amounts are too small to warrant suing the bank on a case-by-case basis, although collectively they amount to a lot of money, the plaintiff's lawyer, Harvey Strosberg, said at a hearing.

``It applies to millions of contracts and millions of transactions,'' Strosberg said in his argument. ``A class-action is the only practicable procedure.''

Until 2001, Toronto-Dominion, Canada's third-biggest bank by assets, didn't disclose that credit-card customers were being charged an ``issuer fee'' of 0.4 percent to 1 percent and a 1 percent conversion fee on all foreign-exchange transactions, Strosberg said. The bank disclosed the fees on some Visa credit cards in 2001 and others in 2003.

``We say a deal is a deal,'' Strosberg said. ``The deal was for only certain, specified, charges, which did not include a conversion fee or an issuer fee.''

The plaintiffs want all undisclosed exchange fees collected by the bank for transactions between 1987 and 2001 on some Visa credit cards, and between 1987 and 2003 on the others, to be returned.

The amounts, although not broken down, were fully disclosed, Barnes said, pointing out each transaction was recorded on a statement received by the card holder. In one case, a $38.90 charge for a U.S. hotel room was clearly shown as a C$58.62 debit, he said

``A person receiving a statement knew exactly what he or she was paying,'' Barnes said.

They would have probably ended up paying more had they used an automated teller machine to withdraw money and paid cash for the hotel in the U.S., he said. A class-action certification isn't warranted because it's not clear if, or how much, each card holder should be compensated, Barnes said.

The court didn't indicate when it will rule in the case.

The case is Paul Cassano v Toronto-Dominion Bank, Ontario Court of Appeal (Toronto). Case No.: C46542.
;

01 October 2007

CIBC & RBC in Bloomberg's Q3 2007 Global Finance M&A Rankings

  
Bloomberg, Wendy Soong, 1 October 2007

The following table shows the rankings of financial advisers for global mergers & acquisitions in the period ended September 30, 2007. The ranks are based on the aggregate dollar amount of deals from each firm and compared with the ranks in the same period of previous year. The total deal volume increased 41 percent to $3.47 trillion, from $2.46 trillion last year.



2007 2006
01/01/07-09/30/07 Market Volume Deal Market Y-O-Y
Firm Rank Share ($mln) Count Rank Share Change
==============================================================================
Goldman Sachs & Co 1 29.2 1,014,112 338 1 29.3 -0.1
Morgan Stanley 2 28.1 975,713 293 2 24.1 4.0
Citi 3 26.9 935,449 350 4 22.3 4.6
JP Morgan 4 24.7 858,102 289 3 23.1 1.6
UBS 5 21.3 740,574 331 5 18.0 3.3
Merrill Lynch & Co 6 20.8 721,631 237 6 17.8 3.0
Lehman Brothers 7 19.7 683,813 204 7 16.0 3.7
Credit Suisse 8 19.2 667,814 245 8 15.6 3.6
Deutsche Bank AG 9 18.5 640,838 185 9 11.6 6.9
Lazard LLC 10 11.9 413,969 169 10 11.5 0.4
Rothschild 11 9.0 311,228 275 11 10.6 -1.6
Greenhill & Co 12 7.7 266,434 27 30 1.7 6.0
ABN AMRO Bank NV 13 7.3 251,947 140 15 6.0 1.3
Bank of America 14 6.6 230,901 84 19 4.4 2.2
BNP Paribas Group 15 5.4 188,809 105 12 8.5 -3.1
RBC Capital Markets 16 4.4 151,535 100 28 1.8 2.6
Royal Bank of Scotland 17 4.1 143,123 4 308 0.0 4.1
CIBC 18 3.8 130,262 92 27 2.2 1.6
Dresdner Kleinwort 19 3.5 122,917 51 23 2.5 1.0
Bear Stearns & Co Inc 20 3.1 108,511 42 25 2.4 0.7

Total* $3,473,018 23,788

* -- Includes mergers, acquisitions, divestitures, self-tenders and spinoffs.
Excludes open market repurchases. Volume in US$ millions.
* -- Total volume represents all announced transactions in US$ millions.
;

29 September 2007

Banks & Wealth Management

  
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins, 29 September 2007

This summer, Bank of Montreal sent a press release to newspapers across the country with the title “Boomers Baffled about what it means to be Executor of a Will.”

In a recent survey, the bank had found “mass confusion” among baby boomers over what the role of an executor entails, it said. It also found that most baby boomers had no idea that being executor of an estate is a job that usually takes more than a year to complete.

Surprise, surprise – just this spring, the Bank of Montreal had been training staff in its branches across the country in the area of bereavement services.

If a customer's mother dies, that customer can now walk into a branch and request that BMO Trust Company do everything from planning her funeral to asking Canada Post to redirect her mail to settling her outstanding debts.

BMO is not alone. Royal Bank of Canada is rolling out a similar service through its massive branch network under which the bank will pick up many of the duties of the executor of an estate.

The banks are going to new lengths to become closer to their customers – and their wealth.

They know that a greying population means now is the time to push the envelope in wealth management, which is why it has become one of the hottest games on Bay Street.

‘The growth rate for this industry is probably twice what the GDP growth rate is,” said Gilles Ouellette, chief executive officer of BMO's private client group and deputy chairman of BMO Nesbitt Burns.

“Because it's attractive, it's attracting more and more competition. The banks are competing in this, the independents, the life insurance companies, everybody's in this space because of its growth prospects. I mean, it's the most attractive part of the finance industry.”

That's why some of Canada's biggest financial institutions, such as Bank of Nova Scotia and CI Financial, are clamouring over the chance to gobble up DundeeWealth Inc., with its 600 full-fledged brokers and 1,200 advisers who can sell mutual funds. CI's $2.36-billion hostile bid for the business is 52 per cent higher than the price DundeeWealth's shares closed at before the bid was made.

“If there was to be an auction process for Dundee, every single Canadian bank would be kicking the tires there,” said Dan Richards, an industry consultant and president of Strategic Imperatives.

Once upon a time, Canadians identified themselves as Royal Bank of Canada or Toronto-Dominion Bank customers the way they identified themselves as a GM owner or a Ford owner, he said. Some bank executives became complacent.

“We've seen a transition away from a relationship-driven world, where people make decisions based on who they've done business with historically, to a value-driven world,” Mr. Richards said. “The banks clearly dropped the ball in the 1990s in terms of aligning what they were offering – advice and performance – with what customers were demanding,” Mr. Richards said.

A research study in the mid-nineties found that when mystery shoppers posed as prospective customers with $100,000 to invest and wandered into bank branches seeking advice about mutual funds, they were generally handed a pamphlet and told to come back after they had decided what they wanted to buy, according to Mr. Richards. Less than one-quarter of the customers were invited to sit down. One in ten were asked what their name was.

In the years since, the banks have made huge inroads in wealth management, becoming the dominant force in the industry. They've once again demonstrated the ground-shaking power they have in Canada when they put their collective minds to something.

They used different strategies and some were slower than others to wake up to the opportunities. But now all of the big banks are forging ahead in the wealth management arena, and working to recapture those customer relationships that breed loyalty.

Bet your mother's banker never asked her whether her kids might fight over her estate, or when her daughter is getting married, or how her divorce is coming along. Depending on their level of wealth, Canadians might be surprised to find out some of the things some banks are willing to do for them these days – for a fee, of course – from guiding boomers on how to get proper health care for their elderly parents, to helping them decide which child to leave the family business to, to connecting them with a good dog-walker.

While many of these services are still only offered to private banking clients – those with a high net worth, who deal with the big banks' private bankers – they are beginning to trickle down into the branches.

“There are a number of things that are driving the focus that the banks have on wealth management,” Mr. Richards said. For one, it's a high-growth area at a time when many of the traditional banking products – mortgages, and GICs and the like – are slowing down. Moreover, “it's a high-margin, high-profit area, at a time when banks are being squeezed on their traditional spread-based businesses.” They're being squeezed because customers are becoming more picky, Mr. Richards said. They are smarter and tougher, and they know that the posted interest rate on, say, a mortgage, is just a starting offer.

“Canadians are very much speaking with their feet when it comes to deciding where they're going to do business,” he said.

At the same time, the banks are aggressively expanding their private banking businesses, one of the key segments of wealth management right now. BMO Harris Private Banking, for example, plans to double the number of offices it has in Canada from 20 to 40 over the next five years, with the accompanying goals of doubling its assets under management and revenues.

While the phrase “wealth management” likely brings to mind mutual funds, it's increasingly much more than that. The goal is to be a one-stop shop for Canadians' financial needs, and to develop a rapport that keeps the customer coming back.

While there are a host of different ways to rank the players – from number of advisers, to client assets under management, to profitability – it's clear that this country's biggest bank, Royal Bank of Canada, is one of the leaders in Canadian wealth management.

It has roughly 15 per cent of the market in what is still a relatively fragmented industry, according to George Lewis, the bank's head of wealth management.

But RBC's head start hasn't stopped it from pouring more resources into the business and tweaking its model to find new ways to grow.

For instance, it now does 25 per cent of its fund sales outside of its branch network. “If you go back to 2000, we didn't even try to market our funds outside of the bank branch network,” Mr. Lewis said.

RBC has come to put such a focus on wealth management that, earlier this year, it rearranged itself into new divisions to carve out a global wealth management division.

“It's a business that we view very attractively, and our shareholders do as well in terms of the valuations that pure wealth management companies trade at,” Mr. Lewis said.

The shift to fee-based revenues makes wealth management a lot less cyclical. And “our business grows with our client assets, and does not rely on the growth of the bank's balance sheet,” he said.

A high-flying wealth management business sucks few resources out of the banking and capital markets businesses, which both rely on the balance sheet.

RBC's Canadian wealth management business saw revenue rise $53-million or 17 per cent in the most recent quarter to $369-million.

Despite advantages, some Canadian bank executives are playing catch-up in the wealth management business now because their predecessors in the early 1990s were fearful of cannibalization – that a push into mutual funds would divert money out of savings accounts, for example.

These days, you would be hard-pressed to find an executive who didn't extol wealth management's virtues. It's not difficult to see the rationale.

As Sun Life Financial's president for Canada, Kevin Dougherty, points out, about 80 per cent of the household assets in this country belong to people aged 45 and older. About half that would be people who haven't retired yet.

“A lot of the money in motion, if you like, is with people age 45 to 60, the boomers really, who are on the home stretch to retirement,” he said. “And then people in retirement, who are increasingly concerned about things like outliving their assets, and estate planning.”

According to Investor Economics, Canadians had $2.39-trillion of financial assets at the end of 2006, and roughly three-quarters of that, or $1.83-trillion, was held by the 853,000 households that have half a million dollars or more in savings. Ten years out, there are expected to be more than 1.78 million households with half a million or more, and the financial assets they hold will have risen to about $4.63-trillion.

It's demographics 101; the first boomers have just turned 60. “It ties in with the aging of the baby boomers, people living longer, people being more affluent,” said Roy Firth, Manulife's head of wealth management in Canada. “As a result, this is a market that's exploding, quite frankly, in terms of size and importance.”

Aside from just managing these assets, the trends open up a whole host of opportunities, from bereavement services to succession planning. About half of this country's privately held companies are expected to change hands in the next decade, says Graham Parsons, executive vice-president of global private banking at BMO.

It's not just that there are a plethora of clients with bundles of money. There's also a school of thought that those bundles will move into the hands of fewer institutions over time.

“One of the things that happens as people age that's a very interesting phenomenon is that they tend to deal with fewer and fewer financial advisers; they consolidate their wealth in one place,” Mr. Firth said.

“People in their 40s have three of four different financial advisers, one being their bank, one being their stockbroker, one being their insurance agent, one being somebody else. And, as they move into their 50s or 60s, they actually consolidate a lot of that. And so [financial institutions] want to be able to provide all the services.”

There's yet another factor at play here. There's been some neglect when it comes to pitching wealth management services to the baby boomers.

“What's happened is, there's a belief that this market has been considerably underserved,” Mr. Firth said. “As a result of that, there are a lot of people trying to move into this space and provide the advice and the counsel and the products that are required by this large demographic group.”

But a strong wealth management business isn't built overnight.

There are plenty of profits to be had once a business is established, but assembling the building blocks, such as a large team of advisers, takes time.

Just ask Bill Hatanaka, the head of wealth management at Toronto-Dominion Bank. While its self-directed online discount brokerage business is the industry leader, TD is still in the early stages of building up some of its advice-based businesses. That's something that Mr. Hatanaka, a former pro football player in the CFL, sees as a significant opportunity for the future.

“We have a huge opportunity, in that we have entire cities with very few investment advisers right now,” he said.

With roughly 600 advisers, the bank lags many of its rivals who have networks of 1,000 or more across the country. But rather than instructing the head of the bank's private investment advice business to flood the market with help-wanted signs, Mr. Hatanaka's instructions have been that the next hire made must enhance the organization, as must the one after that, and so on.

This is a business where people, and the relationships they create with their customers, are invaluable. TD sees one of its key differentiators as its staff's reputation for being highly approachable, Mr. Hatanaka said.

“Demographics mean the wind is at our backs right now,” he said of the industry. He believes those who do a “great job” in the next 10 to 20 years will have “as much business as they can handle.”

So, yes, TD's open to merger possibilities. “Our general view on acquisitions is that it was important to get our own shop into great shape,” Mr. Hatanaka said. “After five years, we believe we have our business humming,” he said, and TD would now look at opportunities that made sense.

Mr. Richards said “TD really marched to its own drummer in saying ‘we think there's a better opportunity by being the first-mover in the discount brokerage business, rather than acquiring a full-service firm.' And they're still benefiting from that today; they're the dominant player with Waterhouse. But what they began doing in the mid-nineties is saying ‘we're going to build our own full-service brokerage firm.' And the reason that TD is behind – in terms of numbers and assets – RBC and CIBC and Bank of Montreal on that is fundamentally their decision to build, rather than acquire,” he said. “Because any time you build rather than acquire, it's going to be a slower process.”

The problem for those who might want to grow through acquisitions is that the opportunities are few and far between.

“One of the challenges today is you say ‘who's left out there that's an interesting candidate that has significant scale?' Well, there's Dundee, there's AGF and there's AIC. And what those three have in common is that they're all controlled by their founders, [and there's] no clear sign that they're up for sale,” Mr. Richards said.

There are some other players scattered across the country. For instance, Winnipeg-based brokerage Wellington West is quietly shopping itself. And National Bank of Canada CEO Louis Vachon said this week that the problems in credit markets might create an opportunity for National to buy up some wealth management businesses.

What Mr. Vachon is seeking is more stockbrokers and money managers, he said in an interview.
“Scale is important in this business, and where companies don't have scale, and aren't growing, there will be acquisition opportunities,” he said.

The need for heft is another factor driving the hunger among some institutions for DundeeWealth.

Scotiabank, which has historically been a bit of a laggard in areas such as mutual funds, is one of the institutions with a strong motivation to snag DundeeWealth, if the chance arises.

Scotiabank's wealth management business has been on a roll this year, earning it kudos from analysts and the investment community, after CEO Rick Waugh made it a top priority.

Executives at rival banks say they respect Mr. Waugh's decision to put more muscle in this area, and that it's a wise move. No one wants to be caught missing the boat.

While Scotiabank's success in the fund business this year might look like it's come overnight, “it's been a lot of heavy lifting for quite a while,” said Glen Gowland, managing director of wealth management.

It required the hiring of some key people in investment management, a broadened product group, and new technology, tools and training for staff in the bank branches.

Lastly, there was “a very big focus on raising the profile of the fund business over all, because we did have some very good investment solutions for customers, and we weren't good at telling everybody about it,” Mr. Gowland said. “So you'll certainly see now everything from television advertising to in-branch posters, etcetera.”

Now that Scotiabank's catching up, it's shifting its focus back to other revenue streams.

“We certainly wanted to ensure that we had the asset management quality and the breadth of product that we need in the mutual fund space,” said Barb Mason, executive vice-president of wealth management.

“I think now we're turning to ensure that the broader team of experts we have – whether it be private banking, charitable foundations, insurance – that we've got great quality service there, so the advisers in our various channels have access to those additional revenue streams, and are able to offer our clients that range of services,” she said.

From will and estate planning to financial planning to charity donations, “we're seeing increasingly, from our research and experience in our businesses, that our clients are looking for more and more of those services,” she said.

And so it comes full circle, with Scotiabank and its rivals looking to expand their grasp on the wealth of Canadians by becoming a more integral part of their lives.

“We're certainly seeing that, as the demands on peoples lives continue to increase, whether it's in the baby boomer segment, the preretirement segment, the concept of one-stop shopping, of being able to get all of your financial needs serviced by one entity, is increasingly popular,” Ms. Mason said.

Some executives are travelling across the country to help coach staff on how to build relationships with their customers. And others are going halfway around the world to scope out opportunities for their clients to give to charity.

Marvi Ricker, BMO Harris Private Banking's vice-president and managing director of philanthropic services, recently took a trip to Africa, because it's a region where many Canadians want to use their money to make a difference and she wanted to be sure she knew the local charitable landscape.

Whether it's creating a foundation or donating to a local hospital, Ms. Ricker sits down with BMO's wealthy private banking clients and their families to help walk them through the process.
As BMO's Mr. Ouellette says: “I think what you're going to be seeing over time is that organizations like ours are going to be expanding the services that we offer in areas that have not traditionally been considered to be banking.”
;

Scotiabank to Buy Dundee Bank, Stake in DundeeWealth

  
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins, 29 September 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia successfully closed its acquisition of 18 per cent of DundeeWealth Inc. yesterday, a deal that was only made possible by happenstance.

DundeeWealth, with its 600 full-fledged brokers and 1,200 advisers who can sell mutual funds, is described by Blackmont Capital analyst Brad Smith as one of Canada's "premier wealth management platforms."

Mr. Smith recently pointed out in a note to clients that DundeeWealth's mutual fund assets have grown at a compound annual rate of 21 per cent over the past two years, compared with a combined rate of 17 per cent for similar assets at the six biggest banks in Canada.

More than half of DundeeWealth is owned by the Goodman family's holding company. Their controlling stake gives them a veto over any transaction, and they've said time and time again that they don't want to part with their wealth management business.

But fate turned against them this summer when turmoil erupted in the credit markets.

About one year ago, they had created Dundee Bank, which attempted to lure customers with high interest rates on its savings accounts. That meant that the bank had to invest its deposit base in something with an even higher return, to profit from the spread. Dundee Bank put much of its money in areas such as non-bank-sponsored asset-backed commercial paper and collateralized loan obligations, which fell into trouble as liquidity dried up in August.

DundeeWealth was forced to buy up some of those assets to keep the bank's balance sheet in shape, and it had to take on extra debt.

The situation created an opening for Bank of Nova Scotia, whose chief executive officer, Rick Waugh, had been coveting DundeeWealth for some time.

Scotiabank agreed to fork over $260-million for the unprofitable Dundee Bank in order to be allowed to buy 18 per cent of DundeeWealth for $348-million.

The agreement also gives Scotiabank a right of first refusal if the Goodman family ever decides to sell its stake.

Scotiabank is not the only one that wants DundeeWealth. Mutual fund giant CI Financial has already tossed in a bid that far exceeds Scotiabank's on a per-share basis. Shortly after the Goodmans rejected it, CI's CEO, Bill Holland, removed some of his offer's conditions in an attempt to make it more palatable. His offer is still on the table, despite the deal with Scotiabank.

Others are also sniffing around.

Some observers speculate that minority shareholders will resort to lawsuits if necessary in order to realize the potential gains from CI's bid.

Manulife's head of wealth management, Roy Firth, describes the saga as a soap opera. "I don't think the story's at an end yet, let's put it that way, but it's an interesting one to watch," he said.

"We obviously have made acquisitions in the past, and while we have nothing on the planning table at this point in time, it's certainly something we monitor and certainly don't exclude the possibility of acquisitions in the future," he added.

If the Goodmans were to open the process to a full-fledged bidding battle, both Manulife and CI are seen as top contenders because of how closely their operations resemble Dundee's.

But if determination counts for anything, then a winning Scotiabank bid cannot be ruled out.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Derek DeCloet, 27 September 2007

Well, this is quite a box he's got himself into now, isn't it? No, not Ned Goodman: We're talking about his new pal, Rick Waugh.

Last week, the Bank of Nova Scotia boss looked like Bay Street's new master of the deal. First, he gave a big loan to help DundeeWealth, the Goodman-controlled financial services group, out of a tight spot. Then he used that position to buy 18 per cent of that business, at a very reasonable price, and negotiated first dibs on the other 82 per cent to boot. Such a clever lad, Rick Waugh. Who says Winnipeg produces nothing but hockey players and frostbite?

But it's all part of the plan. Scotiabank's Achilles heel is money management, a great business opportunity that it has largely squandered. Of the Big Five banks, it's dead last in mutual fund assets, with $18-billion (Bank of Montreal, the next-smallest, has $38-billion). It employs 30 per cent fewer investment advisers than the brokerage arms of either Royal Bank or BMO. Scotiabank is so far behind, it needs binoculars to see the competition's backside.

This is the kind of problem that bankers don't usually like to talk about. On second thought, maybe they do. Here's Mr. Waugh in 2004: "We will find new ways to grow in wealth management." In 2005: "We are making wealth management a top priority." After the annual meeting in 2006: "It's very important for us to grow in wealth management, and particularly here in Canada." The man has staked a lot of his credibility as CEO on solving this.

Trouble is, there's virtually nothing to buy. Of the Canadian fund companies with at least $15-billion in assets, every one is owned by a big bank, a big foreign company, or the employees, with two exceptions: DundeeWealth, and AGF Management, each run and controlled by the founding family, neither willing to sell.

This summer, fate gave Mr. Waugh his chance when Dundee got caught in the credit squeeze. The result was a nice, clubby little deal that gave Scotiabank a toehold in one of the fund industry's fast growers. Over the past five years, while Scotia was adding $5-billion in mutual fund assets, Dundee grew by about $15-billion (more on that in a moment).

Then Bill Holland of CI Financial had to go and ruin everything, lobbing a bid for the whole company at a huge premium to the market and to what Scotiabank paid. There are only two possible outcomes now: (1) the Goodman family refuses to sell at any price or (2) Dundee will start a full-blown auction that will see Mr. Waugh bidding against CI, Manulife Financial and God-only-knows who else. Let's consider these one at a time.

In scenario one, Mr. Waugh gets his 18 per cent, but with little chance of getting the big prize - control - in the future. Ned Goodman will turn 70 in November. If he isn't going to sell the business now, that implies the decision will be left to his son, David Goodman - who, by the way, is 43 years old and has been the CEO of DundeeWealth for exactly 99 days. Do you really think he'll be anxious to sell? The Americans might get a man to Mars first.

In scenario two - the auction - Mr. Waugh has the upper hand. The minority stake, and the right to match any offer, are powerful advantages. But they are offset by a couple of factors. Scotiabank trades at 12 times earnings; CI's bid, $2.36-billion, values DundeeWealth at about 30 times profit. Matching it would require the bank to deplete its excess capital.

Ian de Verteuil, the sharp-eyed bank analyst at BMO, figures that at that price, Scotiabank could still make the deal and not hurt its per-share earnings, if it cut $75-million in costs. It could surely do that, as there's overhead to chop; David and Ned Goodman together received $5-million in salary and bonuses last year. But what then? The big reason Dundee has grown so fast is that it was early to spot some investing trends (real estate, income trusts, natural resources). Part of the credit, surely, belongs to Ned Goodman and his intuition for the market. Removing him would hurt the business. And what about Dundee's star money managers - would they work for a bank?

You can see Mr. Waugh's predicament if this goes to a bidding war. If he wins, he will be paying full price - certainly more than CI's proposed $2.36-billion - for a business that would not be quite the same once he owns it. But if he loses, he's blown a chance to fulfill his promise to get serious about wealth management. Scotiabank has done some of its best deals buying broken or temporarily distressed assets, such as Montreal Trust or Mexico's Inverlat. Mr. Waugh thought he had done it again with Dundee, until Bill Holland got in the way.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Shirley WOn & Tara Perkins, 27 September 2007

CI Financial Income Fund yesterday revised the terms of its $2.36-million hostile bid for DundeeWealth Inc., fuelling speculation about an imminent takeover battle for the financial services company.

The mutual fund giant is still offering $20.25 per share for DundeeWealth, but dropped a condition that it scuttle its $348-million deal to sell its bank unit and an 18-per-cent stake in the firm to Bank of Nova Scotia.

"The CI bid is an opening bid - not the winning bid," said Ron Mayers, a vice-chairman of Desjardins Securities who specializes in arbitrage trading and bought DundeeWealth shares this week. "I wouldn't own it if I thought I was going to lose money," Mr. Mayers said in an interview. "DundeeWealth could go for $25 or $26."

Shares of DundeeWealth, which owns Dynamic Mutual Funds, surged 8 per cent yesterday to close at $18.30 on the Toronto Stock Exchange with 4.8 million shares changing hands. That's on top of a 28-per-cent price jump on Tuesday.

"This is an ongoing soap opera," said Westwind Partners analyst Horst Hueniken. "The market is saying that the odds of a transaction have gone up.... Beyond that, it's all speculation."

Analysts have suggested that other potential bidders could be Scotiabank, which has the right of first refusal through its deal with DundeeWealth, or other financial players like IGM Financial Inc. - which owns Investors Group Inc. and Mackenzie Financial Corp. - or Manulife Financial Corp.

CI chief executive officer Bill Holland said he is "optimistic" about a possible deal with his new offer that would cost $3.2-billion when including the additional shares that Scotiabank will hold in DundeeWealth.

Toronto-based DundeeWealth also has 1,800 advisers in its financial planning and mutual fund dealer arms. "It recognizes the value that they have built over the last 20 years," Mr. Holland said.

Any takeover depends on Ned Goodman and his family - who control a 56-per-cent stake in DundeeWealth through parent company Dundee Corp. - putting the company up for sale. And David Goodman, CEO of DundeeWealth, recently told The Globe and Mail that "we're not sellers."

The unsolicited offer by CI is 52 per cent above the closing price of DundeeWealth on Monday. Under a private placement, Scotiabank is buying its minority stake in DundeeWealth for $12.76 a share. The Scotiabank transaction is set to close this week.

While the Goodman family - who control Dundee through a dual-class voting structure - may have the law on their side in not budging on a sale, "the optics are terrible for them," argued Mr. Mayers.

"At some point, the premium becomes so high that someone could make a case for shareholder oppression."

Toronto-based CI rushed to change the conditions of its offer after Dundee on Tuesday rejected the "terms and conditions" of CI's surprise bid, but did not appear to rebuff the offer outright. The move came after Mr. Holland had a conversation with Ned Goodman. "He did not tell me what the conditions were," he said. "So I looked through the logical conditions and eliminated them."

CI's offer also requires the recommendation of the six-person DundeeWealth board, which includes four independent members. "If the board is supportive, that could place more pressure on the parent company and its willingness to sell," said CIBC World Markets analyst Stephen Boland.

DundeeWealth spokesman Robert Patillio would only say that it was just "business as usual" at DundeeWealth. "The only thing we are focused on at the moment is the completion of the Scotia arrangement," he said.

Scotiabank spokesman Frank Switzer would not comment on CI's new offer.

CI, which is 36 per cent owned by Sun Life Financial Inc., is Canada's third-largest fund company with $64-billion in assets. Like DundeeWealth, it also has financial planning and brokerage arms.
__________________________________________________________
The Globe and Mail, Sinclair Stewart, Tara Perkins, Boyd Erman, 19 September 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia has long coveted Dundee Corp.'s vast network of investment advisers as a way to narrow the gap with its Big Five rivals, but could never find a way to persuade the controlling Goodman family to relinquish a stake in its brokerage.

That is, until credit markets seized up in mid-August.

Dundee's year-old banking business was dealt a blow by the crisis in the asset-backed commercial paper sector, forcing the company's asset management unit, DundeeWealth Inc., to orchestrate a bailout by taking on additional debt. Suddenly, Scotiabank had the catalyst it needed.

A telephone conversation between Scotiabank chief executive officer Rick Waugh and DundeeWealth CEO David Goodman on the last Saturday in August rekindled talks that had gone cool after a year of fruitless back-and-forth.

By Monday night, the companies had nailed down the terms of the deal that they announced yesterday: Scotia would buy Dundee Bank, an unprofitable business that sources said Scotiabank never really wanted, for $260-million as a quid pro quo for being allowed to purchase 18 per cent of DundeeWealth for $348-million or $12.76 a share.

Scotiabank also gets right of first refusal should more of DundeeWealth ever be for sale.

The acquisition is "very attractive from a strategic perspective" for Scotiabank, because the purchase aligns the bank with a highly regarded business in Dundee, analyst Brad Smith of Blackmont Capital said in a note to clients. "With three board seats and a right of first refusal on any future sale of the controlling interest, the acquisition positions [Scotiabank] to substantially expand its domestic wealth business should an opportunity present itself down the road."

Scotiabank's network of about 900 brokers has for years been dwarfed by those of Royal Bank of Canada, Bank of Montreal and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce. Although the bank has identified wealth management as a priority, the brokerages available for sale in Canada tended to be either too small, or a poor cultural fit. A stake in Dundee, with about 600 full-fledged brokers and another 1,200 advisers who can sell mutual funds, provides the bank with a much bigger sales force.

In addition, Dundee's Dynamic mutual fund arm is the 12th-largest fund company in the country.

"The investment in DundeeWealth is a perfect strategic fit with Scotiabank's commitment to grow our wealth management business," Scotiabank spokesman Frank Switzer said.

For Dundee, the plan is now to focus on the wealth management business and potential expansion opportunities in the United States and Europe, without the distraction and expense of trying to right an unprofitable bank.

Dundee Bank was created to offer loans to people through investment advisers, providing an alternative to the big banks. But while its high interest rates attracted deposits quickly - the bank now has over $2-billion - the business lost money because it was difficult to find ways to invest those deposits at even higher returns. And what's more, the country's banking regulator demanded that increasing amounts of capital be set aside to cover the growing depositor base.

In search of those higher returns, the bank invested more than $380-million in asset-backed commercial paper, which tempted investors with better returns than other short-term investments, but which became frozen when the sector was gripped by a liquidity crisis.

The bank's sister company, DundeeWealth, agreed to buy the paper at par to get it off the bank's balance sheet, but that still promised to constrain Mr. Goodman's ability to follow through on plans for expanding the asset management side of the business. To make the purchase, Dundee had to increase its line of credit with long-time banker Scotiabank to $500-million.

The sale to Scotia "represents a very big opportunity for our company to get back to its money management roots and to get back to the business model that we understand," said Mr. Goodman, the son of Dundee founder Ned Goodman.

DundeeWealth shares, which had fallen by almost about a quarter since August, rebounded yesterday, and shares of Dundee Corp. also jumped.

The discussions, in which Dundee was counselled by GMP Securities, were exclusive, cutting out any other potential bidders.

But Mario Mendonca, an analyst with Genuity Capital Markets, said he believes Dundee is now in play, adding that its rising stock price suggests the market believes there are other bidders out there.

The end game for Scotiabank, ideally, would be a full takeover of the DundeeWealth business.

However, the Goodmans have never displayed a public interest in selling the company they built, and David Goodman said that's not about to change.

"We're not sellers," he said.
__________________________________________________________
Financial Post, David Pett, 18 September 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia increased its domestic wealth management platform Tuesday, after agreeing to buy an 18% stake in DundeeWealth with a right to acquire 20% for $348-million. The "big six" bank also agreed to buy Dundee Bank for $260-million.

DundeeWealth stock jumped more than 8% following the news. Scotiabank shares, meanwhile were up only slightly in morning trading.

Blackmont analyst Brad Smith said the acquisition is a positive strategic fit for the bank, telling clients in a note "it aligns Bank of Nova Scotia with a highly regarded domestic wealth platform in Dundee."

He added that with three board seats and right of first refusal on any future sale of the controlling interest in DundeeWealth, Scotiabank is in a great position to expand its wealth interest, should it choose to go down that road in the future.

In the near term, Mr. Smith said he expects limited impact on Scotiabank's earnings per share and left his "buy" rating and $62 price target unchanged.
__________________________________________________________
Bloomberg, Sean B. Pasternak, 18 September 2007

Bank of Nova Scotia, Canada's second-largest bank, will take an 18 percent stake in DundeeWealth Inc. and buy the firm's banking unit for C$608 million ($594.5 million) as it pushes deeper into asset management.

Scotiabank agreed to buy 27.3 million DundeeWealth shares for C$348 million, or C$12.76 a share, and buy Dundee Bank of Canada for C$260 million in cash, the Toronto-based bank said today in a statement.

Bank of Nova Scotia, which owns the smallest mutual-fund business of Canada's five largest banks, has said expanding its money management business is a priority. The bank hired three fund managers from Royal Bank of Canada and boosted sales through its branches, contributing to a 19 percent gain in asset-management revenue last quarter.

Wealth management firms are ``very attractive for their fee income,'' said Stephen Jarislowsky, chief executive officer of Montreal-based Jarislowsky Fraser Ltd., Scotiabank's third- biggest shareholder, according to Bloomberg data.

DundeeWealth manages almost C$63 billion in assets, and its Dynamic Mutual Funds unit is the eighth-biggest non-bank mutual fund seller in the country. Scotiabank will appoint as many as three directors to the DundeeWealth board, and has the right to increase its stake to 20 percent.

The acquisition is ``an important step in our continuing strong focus on wealth management,'' Scotiabank Chief Executive Officer Richard Waugh said in the statement. The transactions are scheduled to close this month, subject to regulatory approval.

Scotiabank's Scotia Securities unit had C$17.9 billion in mutual fund assets at the end of August, compared with C$19.8 billion at Dundee's Dynamic, according to the Investment Funds Institute of Canada.

Buying Dundee Bank of Canada allows Scotiabank to offer high-interest deposit accounts without ``mass cannibalization of its own deposit base,'' John Aiken, an analyst at Dundee Securities, wrote in a note to investors today. The bank may also be able to buy the rest of DundeeWealth if it were put up for sale, he said.

DundeeWealth is selling its bank less than a year after it was formed to offer savings accounts and other bank products through its investment adviser network. DundeeWealth said it will post a loss of about C$70 million from the sale of Dundee Bank because of a decline in some of its investments.

DundeeWealth said last month it reduced its holdings in asset-backed commercial paper by half, or about C$400 million, after the market seized up amid concerns over links to U.S. subprime mortgages.

While reducing the asset-backed commercial paper had ``something to do with'' selling the bank, DundeeWealth wants to focus on increasing its asset-management business, spokesman Robert Pattillo said.

Ned Goodman, chairman of DundeeWealth parent Dundee Corp. has had a ``personal relationship'' with Waugh, and previous Scotiabank CEOs Peter Godsoe and Cedric Ritchie, Patillo said.

GMP Securities advised Dundee on the sale.

Scotiabank shares rose 70 cents to C$52.65 at 4:10 p.m. on the Toronto Stock Exchange. DundeeWealth rose 90 cents, or 7.4 percent, to C$13.
;

28 September 2007

CIBC World Markets Will Have Weaker Q4 2007 Results

  
The Toronto Star, Rita Trichur, 28 September 2007

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce says tough market conditions are weighing on its World Markets business and warned the division's fourth-quarter results will be weaker than levels achieved earlier this year prior to the full-scale meltdown in U.S. subprime residential mortgages.

CIBC World Markets, the bank's wholesale and corporate banking arm, has already taken $290 million in mark-to-market writedowns in securities related to the U.S. residential mortgage market during the third quarter.

Millions more in writedowns are expected in the current quarter as the bank continues its market-value assessment of its collateralized debt obligations and residential mortgage-backed securities, which are investments related to U.S. subprime mortgages.

That mark-to-market process determines the current market price for those securities versus their previously assigned book value.

CEO Gerald McCaughey said at an investor conference in Mont-Tremblant, Que., yesterday that "market and industry conditions are challenging and our fourth-quarter results are not likely to match the strength in the World Markets business that we have seen in the earlier parts of 2007."

CIBC has previously stated that its "target business mix" is to invest 25 to 35 per cent of its capital in its wholesale business. Last March, McCaughey told investors at the bank's annual meeting that CIBC had "room" to provide additional capital to its World Markets division and improve its productivity.

But yesterday, McCaughey cast a more sombre outlook vis-à-vis those previously stated scorecard objectives: "Currently, we are at 24 per cent and, given the more difficult market conditions, we do intend to remain near the low end of our range at this time."

Last month, CIBC revealed its exposure to troubled subprime mortgages though collateralized debt obligations and residential mortgage-backed securities was about $1 billion (U.S.).

Executives also estimated the bank would take another $90 million in markdowns for August based on preliminary data. Those further markdowns for August could reduce the bank's per share fourth-quarter earnings by an estimated 18 cents (Canadian), according to RBC Capital Markets.

Analysts have also warned that more fallout is possible if U.S. subprime securities continue to undergo price erosion. McCaughey gave no further hints yesterday about the expected value of CIBC's investments in subprime-related securities for the fourth quarter. He conceded, however, the securities have ended up being "riskier" than originally thought despite their high credit ratings.

"The volatility that we've experienced and the fact that we ended up with large holdings and a large writedown is not something that we would like to have on an ongoing basis," McCaughey said. "We're trying to dampen volatility and so we are examining how we can look through this type of thing in the future."

CIBC is not the only bank re-evaluating its risk exposure. The Bank of Montreal, too, has learned lessons from its mounting commodity-trading losses, which have already had an impact of $829 million before taxes so far this year.

The losses mostly occurred from natural gas trading involving New York-based brokerage Optionable Inc. and are now being scrutinized by regulators and law enforcement officials.

Karen Maidment, BMO's chief financial and administrative officer, said at the same conference the bank is continuing its enterprise-wide review of risk management practices: "We're changing a lot of monitoring and limits and measures and things like that to ensure that we stay within the risk profile."

BMO's exposure on its commodity book is about $11 billion and it plans to work it down over the next two quarters. And while analysts have warned of more trading losses, Maidment said the bulk of the losses have already been incurred.
;

RBC CM on Manulife

  
RBC Capital Markets, 28 September 2007

F/X drag and low interest rates should not negatively impact Manulife's target of 15% organic EPS growth. Manulife believes that it can reach its target of 15% organic EPS growth in the current environment as long as it achieves 10% year over year growth in Premiums and Deposits, which it views as possible now that Japan variable annuity sales have returned to previous levels. Manulife delivering on its objectives should be a positive for its shares. We are estimating 11% EPS growth in 2008, which is slightly below consensus estimates of 12%.

Credit issues in the US may be a catalyst for US insurance consolidation. If consolidation occurs, we believe Manulife is well positioned to make acquisitions in the US because: (i) Manulife's valuation has improved compared to US lifecos, currently trading at a 22% premium to selected US lifecos versus 6% in June 2007; (ii) Manulife has $3+ billion in excess capital that it can deploy for acquisitions; (iii) the rising Canadian dollar, versus the US dollar, makes potential US acquisitions larger; and (iv) Manulife would be able to generate significant synergies in most lines of business'.

Management was very positive on Q3/07 variable annuity sales results in Japan. We believe that Q3/07 Japanese VA sales results may top Manulife's previous best quarter of US$1.05 billion (Q1/06). Manulife's shares should react positively to an improvement in sales as sales had declined to approximately US$400 million per quarter since July 2006, when a key product was shelved for regulatory reasons.

Manulife is currently trading at 14.0x NTM earnings compared to its 5-year average of 13.1x and the current lifeco median of 13.0x. We believe that Manulife deserves the premium valuation it trades at compared to Canadian financial services companies and life insurers worldwide, based on the company's sales and earnings growth track record, excess capital holdings, growth prospects in Asia, and lower credit risk profile than U.S. lifecos and Canadian banks. Diversity of operations limits downside earnings risk and reserves appear conservative, with large provisions for adverse deviations relative to reserves and a track record of booking experience gains. The company remains well positioned if long-term interest rates increase.

Valuation

Our 12-month price target of $47 is a combination of our P/E, price to book and embedded value methodologies. It implies an approximate forward multiple of 14.5x earnings, compared to the 5-year average forward multiple of 13.1x. Our P/B target of 2.9x in 12 months is at the high end of our target for lifecos given a higher expected ROE than average. Our target P/E multiple of 14.5x 2008E earnings is above the company's 5-year average forward P/E to reflect potential benefits from higher interest rates, rapidly growing value of new business, and potential for upward EPS revisions as our expected earnings growth is below what the company has historically achieved and is targeting, partially offset by deteriorating credit quality, uncertain equity market performance and lack of benefits from transformational acquisitions. Our target multiple on embedded value of 2.0x is higher than for the other two Canadian lifecos, reflecting higher prospects for growth in value of new business, because of the company's positioning in Asia and the U.S.

Price Target Impediment

Risks to our price target include persistently low interest rates, deteriorating equity markets, adequacy of actuarial assumptions, acquisition/execution risk, unfavourable political and/or economic developments in Asia and appreciation in the Canadian dollar. To the extent that the appreciation in the Canadian dollar is due to improved bond yields, Manulife has a natural hedge to help offset its F/X drag due its asset/liability mismatch.

Company Description

Manulife is Canada's largest insurer, with 45% of net income generated in the U.S., 36% in Canada and 19% in Asia. Manulife has delivered 12 consecutive years of record earnings growth, registering a 25% CAGR during that time frame, and is the fourth-largest life insurer globally as measured by market capitalization.
;

27 September 2007

Scotiabank to Buy 3 Banks from Altas Cumbres

  
BN Americas, Maria Alejandra Moreno, 27 September 2007

Scotiabank is about to buy three banks from Chile's Grupo Altas Cumbres for US$200mn, Chilean newspaper Diario Financiero reported.

The three are Banco del Trabajo in Peru, Banco de Antigua in Guatemala and Banco de Ahorro y Crédito Altas Cumbres in the Dominican Republic, according to the report.

All are small players. Banco del Trabajo has a loan market share of 2% and Banco de Antigua around 1%.

The acquisitions would fit Scotiabank's strategy as Latin America has been a key driver of overall earnings growth for the Canadian group, Joseph Scott, senior director at Fitch's Financial Institutions Group, told BNamericas.

With Canadian law currently prohibiting mergers among major banks, Scotiabank is looking to expand in markets offering better growth opportunities and wider spreads than its domestic market, Scott said.

Scotiabank's Mexican unit, with Cnd$21.1bn in earning assets at end-September last year, generated 15% of overall net income. By contrast, the group's US operations, with Cnd$41.9bn in earning assets, generated 9% of total net income.

Executives from Altas Cumbres were unable to comment as they are traveling abroad. A Scotiabank's spokesperson said the bank does not comment on speculation.

Last August, Scotiabank agreed to buy Chile's seventh largest bank Banco del Desarrollo for some US$1.03bn. This month the company said it would pay US$50mn for Spain's BBVA pension and insurance units in the Dominican Republic.
;

'True Yield' of Dividend Paying Stocks

  
Financial Post, David Berman, 27 September 2007

Any investor who chases after dividend-paying stocks knows yield is only part of the attraction. A low payout ratio is also good, not to mention the ability to raise a dividend over time.

George Vasic, strategist at UBS, revisited his regular look at Canadian dividend-paying stocks recently, fine-tuning a stock screen to select the best of the best.

Using his approach, the best dividend-paying stocks have yields above 1.5%, a "true yield" (that is, taking into account share buybacks) above 3%, no share dilution over the past three years and five consecutive dividend increases above 10%. Finally, these stocks should have a payout ratio that is below 50%.

What stocks make the grade? There are just nine of them: Methanex Corp., National Bank, Canadian National Railway Co., Manulife Financial Corp., CIBC, Bank of Montreal, Bank of Nova Scotia, Sun Life Financial Inc. and Royal Bank of Canada.

Yes, the list includes a lot of banks and insurance companies. "The bottom line is that when share count is included, the large cap financials look even better than their already attractive dividend yield would suggest," Mr. Vasic said in a note to clients.
;

Banks Unable to Roll Over All of Their Own ABCPs

  
Bloomberg, Sean B. Pasternak, 27 September 2007

Canadian banks haven't been able to roll over all of their asset-backed commercial paper amid the global credit crunch, Bank of Montreal Chief Financial Officer Karen Maidment said.

``We've seen the rollovers haven't been 100 percent, so there has been some support provided to those,'' said Maidment, speaking at an investor conference today. ``That was particularly a problem in August, and it's much improved into September.''

Bank of Montreal spokesman Paul Deegan said in a telephone interview that Maidment was referring to the banking industry as a whole, and not her bank. Canada's fourth-largest lender continues to roll over commercial paper at ``prevailing market prices,'' Deegan said.

The failure of Canada's biggest banks to refinance all their commercial paper coming due shows the gridlock in the short-term debt market in Canada hasn't been limited to non-bank dealers such as Coventree Inc. Canadian banks are paying record interest-rate premiums to get investors to buy their asset- backed commercial paper amid the U.S. subprime crisis.

``It's been a disruptive market, but I think we can foresee it working through,'' Maidment said at a conference in Mont-Tremblant, Quebec sponsored by CIBC World Markets.

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce Chief Executive Officer Gerry McCaughey said the commercial paper market is ``better'' and has ``a feel of equilibrium right now.''

Canadian lenders such as Bank of Montreal have committed to provide so-called ``back-stop'' liquidity to finance their asset-backed commercial paper if investors refuse to roll over the debt, which have maturities of up to 364 days. The Toronto- based bank had C$42.7 billion ($42.7 billion) set aside for this purpose at the end of 2006, more than any other Canadian bank, according to CIBC World Markets estimates.

The bank-sponsored market for asset-backed paper contrasts with the debt sold by non-bank dealers such as Coventree. That market seized up last month after foreign banks such as Barclays Plc declined to provide emergency funding. A group of investors and banks said today it needs more time to convert some of that commercial paper into notes maturing in five to 10 years.
;

Big 5 Not Increasing Presence in Quebec: National Bank

  
Canadian Press, 27 September 2007

Canada's five largest banks have failed to dramatically increase their physical presence in Quebec or provide a consistent approach in the province, says the head of the National Bank of Canada.

“To have an impact on a mature market like Quebec, you need a consistent approach to that market and I think for our competitors, their approach has been anything but consistent regarding Quebec,” CEO Louis Vachon told analysts Thursday at a CIBC investors conference in Mont-Tremblant.

Mr. Vachon heads Canada's sixth-largest bank. His comments were directed at Bank of Montreal, Bank of Nova Scotia, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, Royal Bank of Canada, and TD Canada Trust.

Mr. Vachon said the impact of the leading banks over the last 18 to 24 months has primarily been to tighten spreads in mortgages and some commercial banking — essentially using competitive pricing to attract customers.

Louis Vachon maintains that the Big Five banks have an inconsistent approach to the Quebec financial services market.

He noted the National Bank has not been as disciplined as it should have been in some of its pricing.

Meanwhile, Mr. Vachon said National Bank will continue to focus part of its growth strategy on expanding its presence outside Quebec, which accounts for 65 to 70 per cent of its business.

Early next year, it plans to disclose its expansion plans. But Mr. Vachon said the bank has preferred to focus on areas where it already has a presence in francophone areas of New Brunswick and Ontario, particularly in the Toronto area and Windsor, Ont.

It is also working on replicating its success in servicing the agricultural community of Quebec by expanding in Western Canada. It has offices in Calgary and Lethbridge.

Mr. Vachon said it has expanded its market share over the past five years in the oil and gas sector based in Calgary, where it has been active for nearly a quarter century.

He said the current crisis in credit markets may also pave the way for it to make acquisitions in the brokerage and wealth management businesses.

On the dividend front, Mr. Vachon said the bank is guided by caution and seeks only to increase the return to shareholders when it “is sustainable in any circumstances.”

As for the future, Mr. Vachon had this warning to those who question the future of the country's sixth-largest bank.

“Do not underestimate the strength of the franchise and the capacity of the franchise to generate earnings growth.”
;

Banks Sell Medium Term Debt at Premium Yields

  
Financial Post, Sean Silcoff, 27 September 2007

Faced with dwindling demand for their short-term debt offerings, Canadian banks have lured investors in the past month by selling massive amounts of medium-term debt securities at bargain prices.

The biggest issuer so far has been Royal Bank of Canada, which has sold $4.4-billion worth of three-to-five-year senior deposit notes in five separate offerings since mid-August, an amount and volume of deals market observers characterized as unusually high.

RBC typically raises such funds outside Canada, but "we tapped the Canadian market this time around because it was the most attractive source of funding," said Katherine Gay, a spokeswoman for the bank's RBC Capital Markets division.

"We're very active in the Canadian debt markets now because it's the most effective source of funding for us and the fact we're getting very strong investor support for the RBC name. We simply did the math, and it's the right thing to do."

But bond investors doing the math have come to their own conclusions: The price for such high-quality debt is a steal. RBC's debt has been sold at spreads as much as 93 basis points (93/100ths of 1%) above comparable government of Canada bonds. Those spreads are double or more what such securities yielded in June, offering a significant premium for bond investors accustomed to earning 5% to 6% per year.

"When you look at where spreads have traded, it's kind of a gift," said Marc-Andre Gaudreau, vice-president of corporate bonds with Mont-real-based Natcan Investment Management, which manages $16-billion in fixed-income assets. "It tells me that the banks from a historical standpoint are cheap relative to the rest of the market. To me it's just a sign investor appetite is not as high as it was before."

Bank of Montreal also last week sold $800-million worth of 10-year subordinated notes at 135 basis points above Canadian bonds. That spread was about 70 three months ago.

Mr. Gaudreau said he expected more large debt offerings from Canadian banks before their fiscal years end next month.

The well-priced issues of high-end bank paper have sold quickly as shrewd bond investors -- who are typically happy to beat the returns of their peers by 2/10th of 1% -- pounce on opportunities created by the global credit crunch.

"This is a very unusual circumstance and an extremely attractive one as long as you do the work to make sure securities you are buying are high quality," said Scott Lamont, head of fixed-income at Phillips, Hager & North, a Vancouver-based fund manager with $45-billion in fixed-income assets. "These are the kinds of opportunities we wait for as active managers."

But Mr. Lamont said he didn't expect the good deals to last for much longer. The banks "have concluded in the last two weeks they can sell as much as they want at [higher yields]," he said. "But they've probably concluded they don't want to continue to have to pay these kinds of yields to attract investment dollars. Rather than issue at those spreads, they'll [keep assets] on their balance sheet. Either spreads will come down or they'll issue less of it."

Some seasoned bond investors speculate the large debt offerings are part of an effort by the banks to free up their balance sheets so they can "repatriate" assets such as car and mortgage payments that were previously rolled into short-term securities called "asset backed commercial paper. " The ABCP was typically rolled from one 30-to 90-day issue into the next. But because of a meltdown in one part of the ABCP market in August, investor appetite for all such securities has dropped in Canada -- even the offerings sponsored by the banks. "It's part of a flight to quality," said Mr. Lamont. "A lot of people will go to the most risk-averse alternatives," such as government bonds.

As a result, banks are expected to wind down these instruments and take the assets back on to their books. This could increase their cost of capital and weigh on their returns, as ABCP has become a convenient way for banks to turn assets into tradeable securities they sell to investors, allowing them to deploy capital more effectively.

"Now they will have to hold them on their balance sheet, and have more assets to fund than they planned to" said Mr. Gaudreau.
;

21 September 2007

Outlook for Capital Markets Business

  
RBC Capital Markets, 21 September 2007

The outlook for Canadian wholesale businesses may not be as bad as feared back in August, but risks related to economic growth have grown

• Three of the four U.S. brokers' Q3/07 results were close to or above street expectations despite major losses and write-downs taken by each in fixed income businesses, alleviating concerns of potentially disastrous results. Goldman Sachs posted the strongest results, and Bear Stearns the weakest.

• These results, combined with the Q3/07 results and disclosures by the Canadian banks on "hot topics", lead us to believe that the outlook for capital markets businesses, although not as good as in the last 12 months, may not be as bad as feared back in August.

• The bigger risk to Canadian bank earnings relates to economic growth; a decline would negatively impact loan growth and credit losses. If there was a recession, which our economists do not envision at this time, the implication for both bank profitability and valuation multiples would be negative and investors would be better off holding lifeco stocks, in our view.

Key themes from the U.S. brokers' results:

1) Diversity of businesses helped weather the credit and liquidity crisis in Q3/07.

2) Managements appeared confident in valuation write-downs and losses taken, and in their capital and liquidity positions.

3) The brokers' outlook is "cautiously optimistic".
;

RBC Fires Bond Salespeople in `Challenging Market'

  
Bloomberg, Caroline Salas, 21 September 2007

RBC Capital Markets, the investment-banking arm of Canada's biggest bank, is firing employees in its U.S. fixed-income division as a slump in credit markets curbs revenue on Wall Street.

The Toronto-based bank reorganized its U.S. fixed income unit "in the face of challenging credit markets," Chuck Powis, head of U.S. fixed-income sales in New York, said in an e-mail to clients this week that was obtained by Bloomberg News. "This reorganization involves changes that we feel are necessary to better align our business to these volatile markets." The e-mail didn't refer to job reductions.

RBC cut 40 fixed-income sales positions and may close its Fort Lauderdale, Florida, office, people with knowledge of the reductions said. Powis confirmed the contents of his e-mail. He wouldn't discuss the job reductions.

Bond traders in the U.S. are losing or leaving their jobs as losses sparked by defaults on subprime mortgage securities spread throughout the credit markets.

Royal Bank of Scotland Plc's RBS Greenwich Capital unit ``resized'' a department that deals with collateralized debt obligations, according to an e-mailed statement last month. Merrill Lynch & Co. said last week that Kenneth Margolis, 53, a managing director who helped oversee its CDO underwriting business, left as sales of the securities tumbled.

Kevin Foster, a spokesman for RBC, wouldn't comment on the firings and declined to say how many salespeople remain employed by the U.S. fixed-income unit.

``We have made some changes to our operations -- this is a strategic response to changing opportunities in the U.S. fixed income market,'' Foster said in an e-mailed statement. ``Our fixed income and currency business is not experiencing a significant change in business performance.''

As investors fled to government debt, more than 50 companies postponed or reworked bond sales in June, July and August, and demand for mortgage securities dried up.

Bear Stearns Cos., the securities firm hit hardest by the collapse of the mortgage market, yesterday reported its third- quarter net income dropped 61 percent, the New York-based firm's biggest profit decline in more than a decade. Morgan Stanley and Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., both based in New York, also posted declines.

As part of the changes, RBC this week named Powis, 44, head of sales after previously serving as head of U.S. structured credit and rates at RBC. Mike Quinn, 42, was also appointed head of U.S. credit trading and remains co-head of structured credit, financial products.

RBC, a unit of Toronto-based Royal Bank of Canada, elevated Powis and Quinn after the departures of sales chief Brian Shapiro, head of high-grade trading Stuart Alper and Robert Lambert, who ran high-yield trading. Lambert quit to join Harbinger Capital Partners.

``We remain committed to building a top tier fixed income business globally with a significant presence in the U.S. market,'' Foster said in the statement.
;

17 September 2007

CIBC to Test Sunday Branch Hours

  
The Globe and Mail, Tara Perkins, 17 September 2007

Any notion that bank machines and the Internet will replace the teller and local bank branch were put further to rest Monday with Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce's announcement that it is going to test Sunday branch hours in select locations.

The big banks are falling back in love with their expensive branch networks as the battle for customers heats up.

While some major banks once offered Sunday hours, they have been phased out and none currently has standalone branches open Sundays.

Some banks have smaller pavilions in grocery stores or malls that are open seven days a week.

CIBC's decision to start opening some of its Toronto- and Vancouver-area locations on Sundays, beginning later this year, comes as Toronto-Dominion Bank is aggressively recruiting staff in preparation for Nov. 1. That's the day TD rolls out its new extended hours.

The change will bring the number of hours the average TD branch is open each week to more than 60 from about 50.

And a Royal Bank of Canada spokeswoman said Monday that all of its main market branches are moving, or have moved, to extended hours.

Rivals who are jumping into the fray with banking products that are only available online, by phone or through independent advisers are part of the reason that the big banks are now trying to make the most of their physical locations.

TD's head of personal banking, Tim Hockey, said "competition continues to increase. It's a good thing for Canadian consumers, they get to reap the benefit of it."

"Those of us that have branch networks realize it's a great strength and tend to want to optimize that, and really make it stand out relative to those that don't," he added.

TD, which has the longest hours of operation of the big bank networks, doesn't currently have any plans for Sunday hours. But it's keeping an eye on CIBC's experiment.

"We know that customers like hours and if it turns out the customers really respond to Sunday hours, then we'll give them Sunday hours," Mr. Hockey said.

While it may seem counterintuitive that the banks are putting more money into their branch hours as Internet banking evolves, Mr. Hockey suggested online banking isn't quite as prevalent as some people might think.

TD has the highest proportion of customers who are actively banking online, but it's still less than one-third, he said.

Stephen Forbes, CIBC's senior vice-president of communications, said "branch banking is foundational to the service we provide. Many of our clients, particularly new Canadians, prefer to visit a branch, and by providing our clients with the ability to bank on Sunday, we are providing more flexibility and choice."

And branches are still the best place for customers to get advice-based products, and to multitask, CIBC said.

"Whether our clients want to sit down and talk about a mortgage, set up an account for their child or get a mortgage or line of credit, the branch is generally the best place for our clients to do multiple things at the same time," said Christina Kramer, senior vice-president of CIBC retail markets.

CIBC will gauge the success of the new Sunday hours in its test markets before deciding whether to bring them to other locations.
;